Poltergeist II: The Other Side Blu-ray Review

The Collector's Edition of "Poltergeist II: The Other Side" on Blu-ray, presented by Shout! Factory, offers a substantial improvement over previous releases. The transfer emanates from a new 2K scan of the interpositive and is presented in its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio on this AVC-encoded BD-50 with an average bitrate of 43.91 Mbps. This edition eliminates the amber-like tint found on the earlier Fox Blu-ray, instead offering richer and more vibrant colors. The natural skin tones and deep blacks, along with the added picture information on all four sides, contribute to a more authentic visual experience. The frame is divided into a dozen scene selections.

The new 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer from Shout! Factory enhances clarity and detail, rendering fine textures and depth more pronounced than the previous MGM release. A consistent light layer of grain is visible, contributing to a cinematic feel without obscuring detail. The redefined color timing, shifting from the previous warmer cast to a cooler one, brings a more accurate portrayal of the cinematography, particularly noticeable in the film’s climactic scenes. Contrast has been honed to deliver deeper blacks and natural brightness, further establishing an immersive visual presentation.

With the new 2K interpositive transfer, the image is more lively, full, and bold compared to prior editions. Improved depth makes the film’s visuals appear more three-dimensional, with smooth cinematic movements and backgrounds that feel distant yet defined. Black levels are deep and rich, although some details can occasionally be obscured in very dark scenes. Color reproduction is rustic and natural, with greens and other hues standing out effectively. Skin tones remain consistent throughout, revealing finer details like freckles and makeup in medium and close shots. Overall, this release is marked by significant visual enhancements, providing a solid video upgrade for fans of "Poltergeist II."

The Blu-ray release of Poltergeist II: The Other Side features two audio options: a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix and a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track. The 5.1 track, encoded at 4046 kbps, is particularly noteworthy for its immersive soundscape. The surround channels are actively engaged during the film's fantastical scenes, effectively complementing Jerry Goldsmith's rich, thematic score. However, the dialogue could benefit from improved amplification, as certain conversations are at times difficult to discern. The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix, encoded at 2004 kbps, provides a reliable stereo experience, albeit without the expanded spatial awareness of the 5.1 track.

The 5.1 track's dynamic range is commendable, offering robust sound effects and a clear representation of both quiet and explosive moments. The mix’s active use of low-frequency extensions bolsters the auditory excitement, particularly during action sequences that feature thunder, explosions, and intense pulsing sounds. Meanwhile, the audio elements are well-balanced, effectively placing emphasis on dialogue, effects, and music as required. Despite some minor crackles in high frequencies, the dialogue remains clean and crisp overall. The track is more front-focused but delivers periodic immersive experiences with sounds traveling around the room.

Overall, this audio presentation preserves the film's original auditory intent while enhancing certain aspects to modern standards. The English SDH subtitles are included, ensuring accessibility. Whether one opts for the more immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track or the robust stereo experience of the DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, both offer distinct advantages that cater to various audiophile preferences.

The Blu-ray release of "Poltergeist II: The Other Side" offers a comprehensive suite of extras that will delight fans and film enthusiasts. The supplementary content is presented in full HD with DTS-HD MA 2.0 sound, ensuring high-quality viewing and listening experiences. It features insightful audio commentaries, with writer/producer Michael Grais sharing behind-the-scenes anecdotes and industry insights, and Poltergeist II fan site editor David Furtney offering a detailed analysis of script revisions and production trivia. The extensive collection includes interviews, retrospectives, featurettes on special effects, and vintage promotional materials. These extras provide an in-depth look at the making of the film, the special effects work, and the legacy of artist H.R. Giger, making this Blu-ray a must-have for collectors.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary with Writer/Producer Michael Grais: Q&A-style session providing insights into the production.
• Audio Commentary with Poltergeist II Webmaster David Furtney: Detailed analysis and trivia about the film.
• Robbie’s Return: Interview with Oliver Robins reflecting on his experiences.
• The Spirit World: Interviews with special effects designers.
• Ghosts of Giger: Tribute to H.R. Giger's contributions.
• They’re Back: The Making of Poltergeist II: Vintage behind-the-scenes featurette.
• Monster Shop: Short piece focusing on creature effects.
• Ghost Makers: Featurette on special effects.
• Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional trailer.
• TV Spots: Four promotional TV spots.
• Still Gallery: Collection of production stills and posters.
• Poltergeist II Script: Slideshow of the shooting script's pages.

"Poltergeist II: The Other Side" picks up a year after the original, with the Freelings seeking refuge at Diane’s mother’s home. Steve Freeling, now a vacuum cleaner salesman, grapples with their insurance company over the missing house. The plot unfolds with the re-emergence of supernatural disturbances targeted at Carol Anne by Rev. Henry Kane, played chillingly by Julian Beck. Beck’s portrayal as the sinister preacher is truly captivating, drawing comparisons to Robert Mitchum’s iconic Harry Powell from "The Night of the Hunter." Additionally, Will Sampson's portrayal of the shaman Taylor offers earthy wisdom as he aids the family against Kane’s malevolent plans.

Despite these strong performances, "Poltergeist II" struggles with a narrative that feels thin and predictable. The backstory involving Kane and his cult is underdeveloped, serving primarily as a vehicle for scares rather than contributing a substantial plot depth. Director Brian Gibson often telegraphs scenes in advance, leading to a lack of suspense. Key moments like swirling clouds and Diane’s dream sequences become too foreseeable. Furthermore, the attempts at expanding the original’s themes result in convoluted explanations that seem more forced than compelling. The screenplay balances Spielberg-esque family dynamics with horror elements but fails to invigorate either aspect sufficiently.

Visually, the film excels with special effects sequences that remain memorable. The effects team, led by Steve Johnson, delivers notable moments such as the braces attack and the Tequila Vomit Creature, enhancing the movie's grotesque appeal. Despite occasional bursts of excitement, the film’s climax feels disjointed with subpar effects and a resolution that lacks impact. However, the cast’s dedication, especially JoBeth Williams and Craig T. Nelson’s performances, adds emotional depth. While "Poltergeist II" cannot match the original's groundbreaking thrill, it offers enough spectacle and continuity to be a worthy, albeit imperfect, sequel.

"Poltergeist II: The Other Side" stands out as a commendable sequel to its renowned predecessor. Despite initial box office performance and critical reception, this film has gained appreciation over time, particularly through the enhanced visual and auditory experience provided by Shout! Factory’s Collector's Edition. The significant improvement in transfer quality from the film's interpositive, coupled with the sheer volume of supplementary content, particularly effects-focused extras, adds substantial value for fans and collectors alike. They have successfully uplifted the film’s presentation, giving it a modern polish while retaining its original charm.

The film itself, while not reaching the same heights as the original "Poltergeist," has moments of genuine suspense and spectacle, especially in its special effects. These elements are notably celebrated within the Blu-ray extras, which include both historical and new content that offers deeper insights into the production and effects work. The addition of a 2.0 audio mix and other bonus features enrich the viewing experience, making it a definitive version for enthusiasts.

In conclusion, "Poltergeist II: The Other Side" deserves a solid recommendation despite its narrative shortcomings. The Blu-ray release elevates its status through superior technical execution and a plethora of supplemental materials. Fans of the original film and those interested in '80s sci-fi/horror will find this version to be an indispensable upgrade to their collection. This release undeniably stands as the closest approximation of a definitive package for this cult classic.