Dead Ringers Blu-ray Review

Dead Ringers Video Presentation Review for Blu-ray

The Blu-ray presentation of "Dead Ringers" from Scream Factory features AVC encoded 1080p transfers available in two aspect ratios: 1.78:1 and 1.67:1 (as measured in-house). Notably, while Shout! Factory promotes the 1.67:1 version as the preferred aspect ratio of director David Cronenberg, this new 2K scan diverges from the advertised 1.66:1. The provenance of the 1.78:1 master remains unspecified, but it exhibits indications of an older source through its occasionally harsh digital look and coarser grain, suggestive of possible sharpening. Color temperature disparities are evident between the versions, with the 1.78:1 version cast in bluish tones and the 1.67:1 version presenting a warmer and more natural palette.

Despite the warmer color space and appealing aesthetics of the 1.67:1 version, it appears softer compared to the possibly artificially sharpened 1.78:1 version. Additionally, observable framing differences between the two aspect ratios and occasional vertical wobble are noted in both versions, typical of older masters. Efforts were made to mitigate this in the 1.67:1 version. Framing inconsistencies are present, cautioning against using older DVDs, including the Criterion release, as definitive references. Personally, I found the 1.67:1 version to offer better color temperature and grain resolution, despite its softness compared to the 1.78:1 version. Consequently, I'd rate the 1.78:1 version at 3.25 and the 1.67:1 version at 3.75.

For clearer visualization, individual screenshots from both transfers emphasize these differences, assisting reviewers in their comparative analysis. Screenshots 1-9 feature the 1.78:1 transfer, while screenshots 10-18 highlight the 1.67:1 transfer. The overall visual presentation showcases distinct strengths and shortcomings within each version, providing an appreciable variety for discerning viewers and fans of Cronenberg's work.

The audio presentation of the "Dead Ringers" Blu-ray offers DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and 2.0 mixes. The 5.1 tracks on both versions are identical, delivering an immersive and spacious sound environment that greatly benefits Howard Shore's elegant and elegiac score. Dialogue is consistently clean and clear across both tracks, with no noticeable dropouts or damage, ensuring a high fidelity experience throughout.

Interestingly, there is a notable difference in the 2.0 stereo mixes regarding channel placement, as observed in subtle nuances like footstep positioning in certain scenes. This discrepancy, while minor and not hugely impactful due to the limited directionality of the stereo track, might be relevant to audiophiles or those who prefer meticulous sound staging. That said, the surround track is preferred for its enhanced envelopment and more aggressive spacing of sound effects and music.

Furthermore, for accessibility, English SDH subtitles are available, catering to a wider audience. Overall, the 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix is recommended for a more comprehensive auditory experience, providing superior soundstage and immersion compared to its 2.0 counterpart.

The extras included in the Blu-ray edition of "Dead Ringers" provide an impressive and comprehensive in-depth examination of the film’s creation and nuances. The new audio commentary by William Beard offers an insightful analysis of Cronenberg's oeuvre while delving into the thematic intricacies of the movie. Jeremy Irons’ commentary adds a personal touch from the lead actor’s perspective, enriching the viewing experience. Heidi Von Palleske’s interview intriguingly contrasts the film’s dark narrative with the unexpectedly light mood on set. Stephen Lack delivers a uniquely bizarre yet engaging performance in his segment, while Gordon Smith discusses his significant contributions to the film's makeup effects. Peter Suschitsky’s interview sheds light on the creative challenges faced during production. The vintage interviews and behind-the-scenes featurette provide additional layers of context and retrospection, making this package invaluable for any Cronenberg enthusiast.

Extras included in this disc:

Audio Commentary with Writer William Beard: A thematic and filmography exploration.

Audio Commentary with Actor Jeremy Irons: Insight from the lead actor.

Cary's Story with Actress Heidi Von Palleske: Recollections of the set’s atmosphere.

Working Artist with Actor Stephen Lack: An unconventional yet fascinating interview.

Connecting Tissues with Make Up Effects Artist Gordon Smith: Prosthetics and effects history.

Double Vision with Director of Photography Peter Suschitsky: Production challenges and career insights.

Vintage Interviews: Includes Jeremy Irons, David Cronenberg, and others.

Vintage Behind the Scenes Featurette: Behind-the-scenes footage.

Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional material.

David Cronenberg’s Dead Ringers is a deeply unsettling and uniquely memorable film that showcases Jeremy Irons in an exceptional dual role as twin gynecologists Elliot and Beverly Mantle. Drawing upon real-life events involving Manhattan-based brothers Stewart and Cyril Marcus, the film weaves a tale that is both chilling and profoundly psychological. The twins share everything, including their success with an invented gynecological tool and their intimate relationships, culminating in a relationship with the actress Claire Niveau (Genevieve Bujold). The narrative plunges into darker territories as Beverly becomes romantically involved with Claire and succumbs to drug dependence, altering the dynamic between the twins in unforeseen ways.

The screenplay, co-written by Cronenberg and Norman Snider, artfully combines macabre concepts with intricate character studies. Through cryptic, often disjointed storytelling, the film delves into themes of identity, dependency, and sexual repression. A particularly haunting aspect of the plot explores the twins’ psychic connection, epitomized in moments such as Elliot attending a banquet solo while Beverly cryptically claims, “I was.” This bond is further complicated by their duplicitous interactions with Claire, who remains initially oblivious to their game of identity swaps. The film heightens the sense of discomfort with disturbing imagery and unsettling devices related to their profession.

While some plot elements might challenge suspension of disbelief, Cronenberg’s atmospheric direction and Irons’ masterful performances more than compensate for any narrative ambiguity. Bujold’s portrayal of Claire—a character oscillating between empowerment and psychological fragility—adds an additional layer of complexity. The film’s blend of horror, psychological drama, and nearly surreal storytelling ensures that Dead Ringers remains an engrossing if disquieting watch. Ultimately, it’s difficult to discern whether Elliot or Beverly is truly the malevolent twin or if they both embody this darkness in different ways. This ambiguity contributes significantly to the film's lingering impact.

Scream Factory’s Blu-ray release of "Dead Ringers" is a compelling package for fans of David Cronenberg and psychological thrillers. The film, renowned for its slow burn narrative and poignant performances, especially by Jeremy Irons in dual roles, retains its psychological intensity and haunting imagery. This release presents the movie in two aspect ratios: 1.66:1 and 1.78:1, offering viewers a choice in how they experience this classic. The 1.67:1 version is generally perceived as the better looking of the two, although it has its own set of issues.

The technical quality of the Blu-ray is commendable, marked by a solid transfer that upholds the film’s atmosphere with good detail and color fidelity. The audio performance is equally strong, providing clear dialogue and an immersive soundtrack that enhances the mood of the film. While some may debate over the preferred aspect ratio, the supplementary features included are quite robust and add significant value to the package. These extras showcase behind-the-scenes insights and augment the appreciation of the film’s creation and thematic depth.

Overall, despite a few minor imperfections in the transfers, Scream Factory delivers a solid release with "Dead Ringers." The package is comprehensive and well-curated, making it a worthy addition to any cinephile’s collection. Whether you are drawn to Cronenberg's distinctive style or simply appreciate well-crafted psychological thrillers, this Blu-ray is recommended for its thorough presentation and engaging supplemental content.

My hunch is Dead Ringers is going to be yet another hotly debated release, but my personal opinion is the 1.67:1 version is the better looking of the pair presented in this set, even if it has its own issues. As is usual with Scream Factory releases, the supplementary package is quite appealing and may help concerned consumers overcome qualms about the actual transfers. With caveats duly noted, Dead Ringers comes Recommended.