Excision Blu-ray Review
Score: 60
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Excision delivers a unique, disturbingly graphic cinema experience, with stunning HD and excellent audio, despite minimal supplements—ideal for horror genre enthusiasts.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 71
Excision's 1080p Blu-ray boasts impressive 3D-like depth, razor-sharp details, and minimal compression artifacts. The color palette is bold with vivid greens, blues, and striking reds. Exceptional contrast and deep blacks enhance the visual experience, complemented by a soundstage with well-placed dialogue and dynamic bass.
Audio: 71
Excision’s Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack excels in creating a genuine atmosphere with superb channel separation, precise dynamics, and clear dialogue. While not dazzling, it offers well-defined ambient sounds and realistic effects, delivering a stable sense of presence and excellent fidelity.
Extra: 21
The only supplement is the audio commentary featuring Writer/Director Richard Bates, Jr. and Actor AnnaLynne McCord. Despite their pleasant rapport and occasional insights about production, casting, and plot, the track remains an average, straightforward, scene-specific discussion.
Movie: 63
"Excision" delivers a unique cinematic experience that melds grotesque imagery with dark humor, chronicling the disturbing journey of Pauline, a socially awkward teen aspiring to be a surgeon, amidst a troubled home life. Blu-ray highlights impeccable visual and emotional depth but might leave viewers divided in reaction.
Video: 71
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Excision" is nothing short of remarkable, showcasing impressive 3D-like depth and exceptional fine details throughout each frame. Filmed in HD and encoded in 1080p/AVC MPEG-4, the transfer offers a clean and sterile appearance that enhances both the real-world and dream sequences. Viewers will appreciate the stunning clarity and robust color reproduction, particularly in scenes with dynamic contrasts such as white garments against red blood in a blue backdrop. The presentation maintains excellent black levels, evidenced by deep and rich scenes with minimal banding issues.
Fine details are exceptionally presented, with crystal-clear textures evident in facial lines, makeup, clothing, and various environmental elements. Flesh tones are generally natural, though occasional shifts from pale to golden occur within the film's visual context. The color palette is notably bold and vibrant, with lifelike, vivid greens and brilliant blues. Reds have a realistic luster that adds intensity to the visuals. Despite slightly blown-out contrasts in some scenes, the overall balance is well-maintained, ensuring an immersive viewing experience. This stellar image quality from Anchor Bay successfully delivers the director's vision with fidelity and precision.
Audio: 71
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack on the Blu-ray of "Excision" is a compelling and meticulously crafted audio presentation that excels in clarity and precision. The mix is largely front-heavy, which serves the character-driven narrative well, with superb channel separation and a wide, spacious soundstage. Ambient elements, such as classroom sounds and hallway chatter, are delivered with remarkable accuracy, creating a genuine atmosphere that immerses the viewer. Subtle but impactful effects, like the muffled bass from car stereos or the distinct clang of slamming lockers, are rendered with realistic presence and clarity.
While the soundtrack may not be the most dynamic or immersive compared to other high-action audio experiences, it perfectly complements the film's mood and tone. Dialogue is a standout feature, consistently crisp and well-defined across all environments, ensuring every peculiar comment from Pauline is heard with perfect clarity. Atmospheric nuances, including the distant barking of dogs or chatty off-screen students, further enhance the listening experience. Low bass elements, though sparse, are deep and strong when present, adding depth to specific scenes without overpowering the overall track. The surround channels are occasionally employed for minor discrete effects and musical enhancements, contributing to a well-rounded and engaging audio experience.
In conclusion, while "Excision" may not utilize its full surround potential throughout, it compensates with an exceptionally clear and finely tuned front-heavy mix that brings the film's dialogue and environmental subtleties to life. This Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack may not dazzle in terms of sheer dynamism, but its adept handling of fidelity, presence, and clarity ensures it will meet audience expectations soundly.
Extras: 21
The Blu-ray release of "Excision" includes an engaging yet straightforward audio commentary by Writer/Director Richard Bates, Jr. and Actor AnnaLynne McCord. This feature provides a scene-specific discussion, covering aspects such as casting, performances, plot details, and production insights. While the tone is pleasant and filled with laughter and anecdotes, it doesn't delve deeply into unique behind-the-scenes revelations. Notably, the short film that inspired "Excision" is absent from this Blu-ray edition.
Extras included in this disc:
Audio Commentary with Writer/Director Richard Bates, Jr.: A scene-specific discussion covering casting, performances, plot details, and production insights.
Movie: 63
In "Excision," writer/director Richard Bates, Jr. dives deep into the morbid and bizarre, presenting the unraveling mind of Pauline (AnnaLynne McCord), a high school senior grappling with a turbulent home life and socially awkward existence. The narrative captures her struggle within a hostile environment: a distant father, an overbearing mother (Traci Lords), and a sister (Ariel Winter) suffering from cystic fibrosis. Pauline’s delusions of surgical grandeur manifest in increasingly grotesque fantasies involving blood and gore, which disturbingly juxtapose moments of dark humor and poignant familial tension. Bates masterfully balances these elements, painting a chilling portrait of an aspiring surgeon drifting further into madness.
From a technical perspective, "Excision" combines striking visual aesthetics with unsettling content. McCord delivers a transformative performance that shatters her typical glamorous roles, fully embracing Pauline's unkempt, pimple-ridden appearance and socially abrasive demeanor. Supporting cast members, including John Waters, Ray Wise, and Malcolm McDowell, interject timely humor and horror, enhancing the film’s surreal tone. Bates’s directorial debut boasts commendable cinematographic expertise, especially in Pauline’s fantastical sequences that delve into necrophilia and surgical mutilation, drawing viewers into her deranged psyche.
The film's narrative structure explores complex themes such as isolation, the quest for identity, and the impact of parental influence on mental health, but it sometimes grapples with pacing issues and sporadic self-assurance in its storytelling. Despite this, "Excision" ensures a visceral experience that is both graphically shocking and emotionally jarring. Whether it achieves cult status or incites revulsion is subjective; however, it undeniably stands out in modern horror cinema for its audacious exploration of psychologically disturbed adolescence and body horror. Suitable for open-minded viewers with robust constitutions, "Excision" is a cinematic endeavor that’s as intriguing as it is unsettling.
Total: 60
"Excision," directed by first-time filmmaker Richard Bates, Jr., is an audacious and unsettling venture into the psychological horror genre. The narrative follows a troubled teenage girl, portrayed by AnnaLynne McCord, whose delusions of grandeur lead to grotesque fantasies, culminating in a shocking and repulsive climax that, while deeply unsettling, is narratively fitting. This film blends stylization with hardcore graphic gore, occasionally contrasting a cheery facade with grotesque visuals in imaginative ways, producing an intriguing and challenging cinematic experience.
Anchor Bay's Blu-ray release delivers in terms of audiovisual presentation. The HD video quality dazzles with sharpness and vivid imagery, essential in enhancing the film's disturbing visual style. The lossless audio track is equally impressive, providing a rich and immersive soundscape crucial for the atmospheric horror. However, the Blu-ray falls short in terms of supplementary content, offering only a single extra feature that leaves much to be desired for those looking for deeper insights into the film's production or thematic exploration.
In conclusion, "Excision" is undeniably unique but polarizing—it's not for everyone. Its blend of disturbing imagery, strong performances, particularly by McCord, and its thought-provoking narrative make it a memorable experience for fans of psychological horror. While the Blu-ray release boasts exceptional picture and sound quality, its lack of comprehensive extras might deter some. Nonetheless, it's worth renting for the curious viewer, and fans will find it a worthy addition to their collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Colors are perhaps a hair warm in these scenes, but balance is exceptional and, generally, the various shades take on a bright and real appearance....
Audio: 90
Light-to-heavy effects such as a car's seatbelt warning alarm or Pauline's mother's honking of the car horn come through with realistic presence and clarity....
Extras: 20
The only supplement included with this Blu-ray release of Excision is an audio commentary track with Writer/Director Richard Bates, Jr. and Actor AnnaLynne McCord....
Movie: 60
That's not a bad thing, considering how much of the movie is built on the workings of the imagination in the process, but some might leave Excision more frustrated than satisfied, even if they've embraced...
Total: 60
It's a unique cinema experience about a troubled life and morbid fantasies that manifest themselves in an unbelievable conclusion that's repulsive but that fits the narrative beautifully....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
With pitch-perfect contrast levels and dazzling whites, the freshly-minted transfer comes with exceptional clarity of the tiniest details inside the family home and around the school....
Audio: 80
Low bass is fairly deep and strong when given the chance, and dialogue reproduction is outstanding, delivering every one of Pauline's weird, offbeat comments excellent clarity....
Extras: 0
There's not much to glean from their conversation, except the usual info about casting, the performances, the plot and the overall look of the film....
Movie: 80
Here, she does a complete 180 playing the antithesis of her usual vixen bombshells, allowing herself to be made believably ugly beyond recognition....
Total: 60
Aside from an amazing performance by AnnaLynne McCord, the film features an array of grisly and stunning imagery of gory horror that slowly develops to a shocking, speechless conclusion....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 92
Dynamics and bass are top notch when called upon, however, this is generally a dialogue heavy movie....
Audio: 92
CinemaScope Screen Onkyo PR-SC5509 Pre/Pro Sunfire Theater Grand 7201 Amplifier Sony BDP-S790 Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Extras: 30
...
Movie: 60
He has been having increasingly weird dreams of blood and guts, showing her as a worshiped beauty, giving us a sense to how demented Pauline is really becoming....
Total: 69
CinemaScope Screen Onkyo PR-SC5509 Pre/Pro Sunfire Theater Grand 7201 Amplifier Sony BDP-S790 Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Richard Bates Jr.
Actors: AnnaLynne McCord, Roger Bart, Ariel Winter
PlotPauline, a disturbed and antisocial high school student with a deeply rooted obsession with surgery and bodily functions, lives under the oppressive rule of her controlling mother, Phyllis, while her meek father, Bob, offers little support. Pauline's younger sister, Grace, suffers from cystic fibrosis, and their gender-conforming household only adds to Pauline's mounting frustrations. She often retreats into violent and vivid fantasies involving blood and medical procedures, which she perceives as a way to gain control over her surroundings and assert her complex desires and perversions. Her morbid interests cause severe social isolation and label her as an outcast among her peers, further driving her to rebellious and often shocking behavior as she seeks validation and a twisted sense of purpose.
As her fascination with surgery intensifies, Pauline's mental state deteriorates, marked by increasingly disturbing hallucinations and dreams. Her strained relationship with her family exacerbates the tension, particularly with her mother, who is intent on maintaining appearances and normalcy. Pauline's fixation on performing a groundbreaking surgical procedure on Grace reaches a fever pitch, leading her down a dangerous path. She refines her knowledge and skills through increasingly extreme methods, building towards a climactic and unsettling endeavor. The escalating conflict within her home, alongside her unraveling sanity, creates a harrowing narrative that explores the depths of her psyche and the dark consequences of obsession.
Writers: Richard Bates Jr.
Release Date: 02 Nov 2012
Runtime: 81 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United States
Language: English