Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" impresses with its UHD release, marrying technical brilliance and deep storytelling.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
DTS-HD MA
Video: 69
Current HDR lacks standards, making UHD reviews subjective. 'Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon' on UHD shows significant visual improvements over Blu-ray, while its enhancements remain subtly respectful, offering a premium yet authentic experience.
Audio: 78
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon's Dolby Atmos soundtrack elevates immersion with precise, vibrant effects and music, enhancing action and ambiance while keeping dialogue crisp.
Extra: 80
Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon's Ultra HD Blu-ray offers a rich array of extras including new and vintage interviews, deleted scenes with HDR, and commentaries, though HDR issues mar some features.
Movie: 93
'Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon' re-released on 4K Blu-ray, combines wuxia with deep emotional narrative, stunning martial arts, and technical enhancements.
Video: 69
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" serves as a pertinent case study in the nuanced world of home video enhancement, demonstrating a transition from the Blu-ray's already commendable 1080p remaster to an even more impressive 2160p/HDR presentation. Despite the inherent challenges in standardizing the implementation of high dynamic range (HDR), which currently lacks exact calibration tools, this release manages to elevate the visual experience substantially. The 4K remaster, built from the original filmed elements, lays out a rich tapestry of detail that was previously unachieved, highlighting the textured intricacies of clothing, facial features, and architectural nuances with a newfound clarity. The grain structure is meticulously balanced, contributing to an enriched filmic quality that rivals, if not surpasses, its previous iterations in home video formats.
Color handling in this UHD version is executed with finesse, as the HDR enhancement subtly amplifies the vibrancy of the film's palette without overtaking the director's original vision. Leafy greens and earth tones pop with a subdued vibrancy, and flesh tones receive a fuller representation, maintaining a commendable equilibrium between enhancement and fidelity to source material. Despite some narrative moments captured with intentional soft focus leading to occasional blurriness, this decision seldom detracts from the overall appreciation of the upgraded visuals. The aspect ratio preservation at 2.35:1, coupled with improved specular highlights and marginally deeper black levels, elevate metal objects and other textures to a more lifelike appearance, though some shadows still lose detail due to murkiness.
While the leap to UHD may not represent a colossal shift in quality—with some sequences showing minimal enhancement—the combined marginal gains across sharpness, detail reproduction, and color grading coalesce into a significant overall improvement. This presentation showcases how UHD technology, when applied thoughtfully, can breathe new life into classic cinema without distorting its essence. It stands as a testament to the potential of 4K mastering in rejuvenating beloved films like "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon," offering a version that, while not without its subtleties in improvement, provides a tangible uptick in visual fidelity that will be appreciated by cinephiles and newcomers alike.
Audio: 78
The Dolby Atmos mix of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" on 4K UHD Blu-Ray is a resplendent upgrade that masterfully expands the film’s audio landscape. Engaging the entire platform, this mix not only broadens the soundstage but brings a new depth and dimensionality to the cinematic experience with sounds emanating from overhead and at ear level. The addition of atmospheric sounds, such as the rustle of leaves in the bamboo forest and the echo of rain in a cave, alongside the carefully positioned movements of characters and objects, creates a deeply immersive experience. The score spills over the sound field, enriching the story's thematic layers with an impressive blend of depth and orchestration.
Audio clarity is paramount in this mix, offering stellar instrumental fidelity and a dynamic mid-range that breathes life into each scene. Ambient effects discreetly enhance the ceiling speakers, providing an appreciable improvement over the original sound design. Instrumental sounds pulse through the action sequences with grandeur, while swordplay is rendered with meticulous clarity, ranging from the lightest pings to heavy gongs. The fluidity of movement and precision placement of audio elements align seamlessly with the on-screen and off-screen action, crafting an auditory experience that is as engaging as it is precise.
Dialogue remains firmly anchored in the center channel, crisp and full of warmth throughout the film, ensuring that character interactions are always at the forefront of the auditory experience. Although the low end isn't overtly pronounced, it supports Tan Dun’s haunting score with adequate weight and presence, making it feel responsive and accurate. As the film transitions into its more action-packed sequences in the latter half, ambient effects and directional audio cues shine, creating a sonically rich environment that does not stray too far from the original design but introduces new dimensions and surprises, particularly in the use of overhead channels for creating an encompassing dome-like soundfield.
Extras: 80
The 4K UHD Blu-ray extra presentation of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" marks a significant improvement over previous editions by incorporating a unique blend of newly restored deleted scenes and expansive retrospective interviews, alongside standard extras. Noteworthy are the six deleted scenes presented in breathtaking 4K, offering fans a deeper glimpse into the film's majestic world. The in-depth retrospective interviews with key figures like Ang Lee, James Schamus, and Tim Squyres enrich the viewing experience by providing valuable insights into the film’s creation and its enduring impact. However, the technical execution of some extras is marred by the absence of HDR coloring, leading to visual inconsistencies that detract from the overall quality. Despite these technical setbacks, the inclusion of dual audio commentary tracks, a making-of documentary, and a conversation with Michelle Yeoh offers a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look that fans will appreciate. This release also includes digital HD copy, rounding off a compelling package for enthusiasts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deleted Scenes: Six scenes restored in Ultra HD.
- Retrospective Interviews: In-depth conversations with Ang Lee, James Schamus, and Tim Squyres.
- Exclusive Introduction: By Ang Lee, discussing the film and deleted scenes.
- Audio Commentary: With cinematographer Peter Pau.
- Commentary by Ang Lee and James Schamus: Insights into the film's production.
- A Conversation with Michelle Yeoh: A 13-minute featurette.
- The Making of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon: 20-minute documentary.
- Photo Gallery: Collection of stills from the film.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional material.
- Digital HD Copy: For convenient digital access.
Movie: 93
"Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon," a film that serves not only as a cinematic rendition of the wuxia genre but also as a bridge that brought Eastern martial arts drama to Western mainstream audiences, finds new life in Sony Pictures Home Entertainment’s 4K UHD Blu-ray release. This modern classic, helmed by the versatile Taiwanese director Ang Lee, combines the epic storytelling of historical narratives with the fantasy elements of martial arts, creating a film that is both a visual and emotional spectacle. Notably, the movie's 2160p video is meticulously remastered from a 4K master, paired with a Dolby Atmos soundtrack, enhancing its already stunning cinematography and dynamic sound landscape, offering an unparalleled viewing experience.
At the heart of this tale are master warriors navigating life's intricacies, embodied by characters such as the venerable Li Mu Bai and the formidable Shu Lien, portrayed by Chow Yun-Fat and Michelle Yeoh, respectively. Their quest to retrieve the stolen Green Destiny sword evolves into a multi-faceted narrative exploring themes of honor, love, and unfulfilled desires. The film, while action-packed, privileges character depth and emotional resonance, aligning more with art cinema than traditional action sequences. Its success in the Western box office, juxtaposed with its mixed reception in Asia, underscores its unique approach to storytelling and genre fusion.
The release not only celebrates this cinematic masterpiece through technical refinements but also enriches it with several new supplements on top of existing extras. This offering ensures that aficionados and newcomers alike can delve deeper into the wuxia genre and appreciate the meticulous craft involved in bringing such a layered narrative to life. "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" stands as an exemplar of the boundless potential of cinema to merge disparate genres and traditions, creating a universally appealing and evocative work of art.
Total: 77
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon," a film that has captivated audiences with its unique blend of drama, martial arts action, and deeply emotional storytelling, receives a formidable upgrade from Sony Pictures Home Entertainment. This release showcases a meticulous restoration that bridges the film's original artistry with cutting-edge Ultra HD and Blu-ray video quality, alongside a marvelous Dolby Atmos immersive sound mix that elevates every scene. Additionally, this combo pack is enriched with all-new supplements, including filmmaker insights and restored deleted scenes, alongside the cherished legacy features. Fans of the genre and this seminal film will find the Ultra HD presentation a compelling reason to revisit this classic.
Despite being a long-anticipated re-release, the transition to UHD reveals a dual-edged sword. On one hand, the 4K/HDR video and Atmos sound configuration rank among the best available, offering a renewing experience that honors the film's visual and auditory legacy. On the other hand, the upgrade from its Blu-ray predecessor might not be as pronounced for some viewers, with the primary allure being the enriched sound quality and the convenience of new supplements rather than a significant leap in video quality. Moreover, while minor detractors such as a cumbersome menu system and the necessity to toggle HDR settings for different content may slightly mar the experience, they do not significantly detract from the overall impressive presentation of this cult classic.
In conclusion, "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" on 4K UHD Blu-ray stands as a testament to the enduring appeal and innovative craftsmanship of Ang Lee's masterpiece. Despite some limitations in the leap from Blu-ray to UHD in terms of video enhancement and some navigational quirks, the superior Dolby Atmos audio and the inclusion of valuable new extras make this release a worthwhile addition for both long-time fans and newcomers to this epic tale of love, loyalty, and conflict. The meticulous care in presenting this film ensures that its transcendent story and breathtaking action sequences can be experienced like never before, reaffirming its status as a groundbreaking film that continues to resonate across cultural boundaries.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Grain structure is attractively balanced as well, accentuating the richness of texture that abounds both near and wide to the point that it's safe to say that few, if any, home video releases have found...
Audio: 100
The film's elements play in expert harmony, with the added middle-back and top layer sound emplacements adding a greater sense of depth and immersion to the proceedings....
Extras: 100
The Making of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (2160p upscaled, 19:02): A vintage piece that explores the key elements behind the making of the film, including the shooting locations, challenges of the shoot,...
Movie: 100
Sony has re-released the acclaimed modern classic 'Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon' with newly remastered 2160p video from a 4K master....
Total: 80
With the debut of UHD only months ago, there was never going to be a better timeframe for a re-release, and Sony has hit it out of the park....
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 60
But primaries remain nicely saturated with secondary hues benefitting the most from the jump to 4K. Various earth tones and yellows are rich and glowing, giving the video a nice glow during many of the...
Audio: 80
Granted, there isn't a whole lot going on action wise since much of the focus remains on the conversations and character interactions, but ambient effects occasionally bleed into the ceiling speakers with...
Extras: 70
Audio Commentaries — The first track is the same from the previous Blu-ray release where director Ang Lee and producer/writer James Schamus analyze their own film, touching on various aspects of the production....
Movie: 90
The story focuses first on its character dynamics, allowing the action to evolve naturally from that, rather than the other way around, as is usually the case....
Total: 80
On the plus side, the Dolby Atmos soundtrack is excellent, accompanied by a small collection of supplements and one lone exclusive to the new format, making the overall package worth checking out for fans...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 82
With that in mind, my approach to reviewing Ultra HD Blu-ray will be to assess the elements observed which I find to generate the most significant visual impact when compared to standard high definition...
Audio: 90
This includes effects such as, a horse galloping left to right out of the frame and over your shoulder to the rear of the room, falling rain, air born poisonous darts traveling from off camera and striking...
Extras: 80
Ultra HD Disc 2: Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon Blu-ray (HD) *NEW* 6 Deleted Scenes, Restored (HD) *NEW*...
Movie: 100
As each warrior battles for justice, they come face to face with their worst enemy - and the inescapable, enduring power of love....
Total: 88
As a bonus all new supplements that include insights from the filmmakers and restored deleted scenes are included with legacy features....
Director: Ang Lee
Actors: Chow Yun-Fat, Michelle Yeoh, Ziyi Zhang
PlotIn Qing Dynasty China, legendary swordsman Li Mu Bai decides to retire from his warrior life and bequeath his fabled sword, Green Destiny, to a benefactor. He entrusts this precious weapon to his old friend Yu Shu Lien, who runs a security company in Beijing. Before Shu Lien can deliver the sword to Beijing, it is stolen by a masked thief. As Shu Lien pursues the culprit, it becomes clear that the thief possesses skills only known to students of the Wudang martial arts sect.
The search for the stolen sword leads to the affluent Governor Yu's household and his daughter, Jen Yu, who is soon to marry into an arranged relationship. Beneath her aristocratic façade, Jen harbors the restless heart of a warrior and a secret life connected to the criminal underworld. As mysteries unfold, the paths of the characters intertwine in complex relationships ridden with unfulfilled love, honor, and betrayal. The quest to retrieve Green Destiny casts a spotlight on personal desires and the struggles between following one's heart and adhering to societal expectations.
Writers: Hui-Ling Wang, James Schamus, Kuo Jung Tsai
Release Date: 12 Jan 2001
Runtime: 120 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Taiwan, Hong Kong, United States, China
Language: Mandarin, Chinese