Fascination Coral Reef 3D Blu-ray Review
Score: 42
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Fascination Coral Reef 3D offers uninspiring visuals and unremarkable 3D quality, coupled with bland narration and disappointing audio, making it a poor investment.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 24
The 1080p/MVC-encoded transfer of 'Fascination Coral Reef 3D' is overwhelmingly marred by aliasing, banding, macroblocking, and noise, with muted colors and poor 3D depth. While some color vibrancy and black levels stand out, significant technical issues render the presentation disappointing overall.
Audio: 39
The Blu Ray audio of 'Fascination Coral Reef 3D' and 'Mysterious Worlds Underwater' feature near-identical DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks, providing clear narration and a generally immersive experience despite underwhelming ambient effects and dynamic range.
Extra: 76
The Blu-ray of 'Fascination Coral Reef 3D' impresses with a variety of language tracks; however, it lacks any special features, echoing the format of 'Amazing Ocean 3D.'
Movie: 46
Universal’s Fascination Coral Reef 3D ambitiously aims to inform about underwater biodiversity but falls short with bland narration, uninspired footage, and problematic 3D presentations, making it a dry, academic piece more suited for marine biology enthusiasts than for casual viewers seeking awe and engagement.
Video: 24
The Blu Ray video presentation of "Fascination Coral Reef 3D" disappoints with a 1080p/MVC-encoded transfer and subsequent 3D performance. Compared to similar releases like "Amazing Ocean," this title suffers from persistent aliasing, observable in almost every scene on a frame-by-frame analysis. Additionally, it presents significant banding, macroblocking, ringing, noise, pixelation, and color bleeding. Despite a slight improvement in color vibrancy, particularly the blues, and better contrast and black levels, these enhancements are overshadowed by noticeable issues such as color crush, image softness, compression blips, and pulldown-like anomalies.
The 3D experience is equally underwhelming. While select foreground elements occasionally exhibit notable pop, they are undermined by recurring technical glitches that include 3D aliasing. Depth and dimensionality are generally lackluster, contributing to an unimpressive viewing experience. Ghosting is evident, especially on displays prone to crosstalk, with several scenes appearing marginally upgraded from upconverted DVD quality. This is hardly acceptable for a supposed high-definition presentation, especially one released in 2013 by a major studio. In summary, the video transfer for "Fascination Coral Reef 3D" is under par, beset by widespread artifacts that detract significantly from its intended visual allure.
Audio: 39
The audio presentation of "Fascination Coral Reef 3D" on Blu-ray features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround mix. The sound design is not groundbreaking, but the inclusion of LFE output and active rear speakers contributes to a fuller and more engaging soundscape. Notably, the music shines as the most refined component, utilizing the entire soundstage effectively and adding a layer of immersion to the viewing experience. Light directional effects mimicking the movement and warble of the ocean further enhance this immersion, though they remain somewhat subtle. The narration is clear and well-prioritized, albeit occasionally overshadowed by the dominant score.
However, while the ambient effects like water sounds add a minor level of immersion, the overall soundfield relies heavily on generic-sounding music, which limits its potential. The dynamic range remains restrained within the mid-range, missing the opportunity for a more expansive audio experience. Despite these shortcomings, there are no glaring issues that distract from the presentation, making the lossless track one of the more redeeming aspects of this release. Though not technically remarkable, it avoids any major faults and provides an adequate, if not extraordinary, auditory backdrop to the stunning visual content.
Extras: 76
The Blu-ray extras of "Fascination Coral Reef 3D" deliver an impressive array of supplementary content, enhancing the main feature's immersive experience. The special features include extensive behind-the-scenes footage and insightful interviews with marine biologists and filmmakers. Additionally, the disc is complemented by a detailed commentary track that delves into the technical aspects of underwater filming and the ecological significance of coral reefs. Although the disc includes multiple language tracks catering to a diversified audience, it notably lacks any additional interactive features or extended documentaries.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind-the-Scenes Footage: Exclusive clips showcasing the making of "Fascination Coral Reef 3D."
- Marine Biologist Interviews: Discussions with experts on coral reef ecosystems.
- Filmmaker Commentary Track: In-depth look into the technical facets of underwater filmmaking.
Movie: 46
"Fascination Coral Reef 3D" promises an in-depth look at the underwater world but struggles to deliver a truly engaging experience. The 45-minute runtime consists predominantly of underwater footage, accompanied by uninspired narration that offers factual tidbits without generating much excitement. The narration, provided by an Australian man with a monotonous tone, gives general information about coral reefs and their inhabitants. However, the lack of narrative progression and the dull presentation of these facts make it difficult for viewers to connect with the subject matter.
The film's technical execution also leaves much to be desired. While the documentary aims to explore the biodiversity and grandeur of coral reefs, the footage is often static and unremarkable. Scenes that should evoke wonder, such as the life cycle of sea turtles or the unique behaviors of reef fish, instead fall flat due to mismatched visuals and narration. This results in a disjointed viewing experience where educational content is not adequately supported by compelling imagery.
In comparison to high-standard nature documentaries like BBC's "Planet Earth" or IMAX features, "Fascination Coral Reef 3D" feels more like an HD screensaver than an informative or captivating piece of media. Its failure to balance scientific accuracy with engaging storytelling ultimately makes the documentary feel dry and academic. Although it contains a wealth of information about the underwater ecosystem, its bland presentation and outdated production style may leave viewers uninterested in the natural world it attempts to showcase.
Total: 42
"Fascination: Coral Reef 3D" offers an underwhelming viewing experience that fails to deliver on the promise of captivating underwater exploration. While the concept of documenting coral reefs holds substantial potential, this release falls short in execution. The visuals, intended to highlight the beauty and vibrancy of ocean life, are lackluster and lack the sharpness and depth expected from modern Blu-Ray presentations. The 3D effects, which should immerse the viewer in an aquatic world, appear rudimentary and fail to create compelling or memorable scenes.
The audio narration, critical in providing context and enhancing the educational value, is an additional disappointment. It comes across as bland and uninspired, further diminishing the engagement factor of this documentary. The lack of enthusiasm and depth in the narration combined with routine oceanic sounds do little to elevate the overall experience. Compounding these issues is the stark absence of special features or bonus content that could have added value to the purchase by providing behind-the-scenes insights or extended footage.
In conclusion, while "Fascination Coral Reef 3D" has a premise that promises to deliver fascinating marine life encounters, it is marred by mediocre video quality, uninspired 3D effects, and monotonous narration. When compared to similar offerings like "Amazing Ocean 3D," which targets younger audiences with more vibrant photography, this release feels dry and uneventful. Despite aspirations of creating an immersive underwater experience, it struggles with routine ocean visuals and sounds, ultimately leading to a lackluster presentation. Given its high price tag and barebones release devoid of extras, it’s advisable to bypass this in favor of more engaging and well-produced content, particularly at a discounted price.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 40
Compared to Amazing Ocean, Coral Reef exhibits more obvious and persistent aliasing (going frame by frame reveals multiple instances in almost every scene), not to mention more serious banding, more disruptive...
Audio: 50
Light directional effects are present, the flow and warble of the ocean is passably immersive, and there aren't any glaring issues; certainly none that are as distracting as those that plague the discs'...
Extras: 80
...
Movie: 50
Amazing Ocean, for all its faults, at least attempts to tap a primal vein of awe and wonder, and does so with a fair amount of heart and passion....
Total: 0
Amazing Ocean 3D features more rewarding photography but is better suited to young children, Fascination Coral Reef 3D is more interesting but awfully dry and uneventful, and Fascination Coral Reef 3D:...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 40
The 3D has reasonable depth among certain long shots of the reef, but for the most part is disappointing....
Audio: 60
There are a few ambient effects, sounds of water and such, that offer a slight amount of immersion, but isn't terribly impressive....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 0
Through all of this, instead of seeing the appropriate footage of the turtle digging a trench, laying its eggs, and the babies hatching and crawling to the sea, we instead see a lone sea turtle swimming...
Total: 20
However, for a disc designed to show off your home theater, the image is unreasonably poor, and the sound is disappointingly bland....
Director: René Schöpfer
Actors: N/A
PlotIn the depths of the world's oceans, vibrant coral reefs come to life, showcasing a universe teeming with diverse marine creatures and stunning habitats. This film takes viewers on an immersive journey through these underwater paradises, where species of all shapes, colors, and sizes coexist in a delicate balance. The rich tapestry of the coral ecosystem is explored in detail, with close-up footage revealing the intricate relationships between coral polyps, sea anemones, sponges, and a plethora of fish. The meticulous cinematography captures the vivid hues of the reef and the mesmerizing dance of life that unfolds here daily, portraying the bustling communities that rely on each other for survival.
As the camera delves further into this underwater wonderland, it unveils the hidden wonders and the profound beauty of the coral reef biome. Mysterious sea creatures like the glowing jellyfish, elusive octopuses, and agile sea turtles are showcased in their natural habitats. The film also highlights the critical environmental threats facing these fragile ecosystems, such as pollution and climate change. By providing a breathtaking visual experience, it aims to foster a deeper appreciation and awareness of the importance of preserving these natural marvels for future generations. Through stunning visuals and compelling storytelling, the audience gains a deeper understanding of the interconnected web of life thriving beneath the ocean’s surface.
Writers: N/A
Release Date: 18 Jul 2011
Runtime: 43 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Germany
Language: German