Father Goose Blu-ray Review
Signature Edition
Score: 78
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Father Goose, a charming and unique Cary Grant comedy, arrives in a high-quality 4K remaster from Olive Films, offering continuous laughs and a refreshing role for Grant.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
The Blu-ray release of "Father Goose," presented in 1080p with MPEG-4 AVC from a 4K remaster, offers dramatic improvements in depth, shadow definition, and color reproduction compared to the old master. Minor flaws and occasional tiny flecks are present, but overall, the quality upgrade is substantial and impressive.
Audio: 79
Father Goose's Blu-ray audio presentation, featuring an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track and optional English SDH subtitles, delivers clear, clean dialogue with no distortions. Despite its period context, dynamics and low-frequency extensions provide engaging depth, especially during action sequences.
Extra: 86
Extras on the Blu-ray of "Father Goose" are meticulously curated, featuring in-depth commentary by historian David Del Valle, engaging featurettes including Marc Eliot's insightful analysis of Cary Grant, and a personal interview with director Ralph Nelson's son, Ted Nelson. Augmented by archival newsreel footage and a profound essay by Bilge Ebiri, these extras provide substantive context and enriching details.
Movie: 76
Father Goose's Blu-ray release by Olive Films enhances its charm with engaging chemistry between Cary Grant and Leslie Caron, delightful supplementary features, and commendable technical quality. Grant's portrayal of an unkempt, alcoholic drifter is surprisingly endearing, elevating this war-time comedy into an irresistible classic.
Video: 74
Presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, the 1080p transfer of Ralph Nelson's "Father Goose" on Blu-ray from Olive Films is sourced from a recent 4K remaster, offering a significant visual upgrade. The new restoration dramatically enhances delineation and depth, especially noticeable on larger screens. Daylight footage, including close-ups and panoramic shots, boasts excellent density and depth, while darker indoor scenes feature improved shadow definition that removes the previous flatness. Grain structure is also notably better exposed, lending greater detail and nuance to various sequences.
This transfer greatly benefits from lusher colors and a broader range of nuances, enhancing the overall visual experience. Black levels remain deep and dark with no evidence of crushing, enriching shadows, shades, and nighttime sequences. Colors are vivid and lifelike, contributing to the realism of the lush island setting. Skin tones consistently appear natural, with facial features becoming strikingly apparent in close-ups, showcasing the authentic details of the cast.
Although minor density fluctuations are present and occasional tiny flecks appear, these are source-related limitations rather than flaws in the transfer process. There are no traces of problematic sharpening adjustments, maintaining the film's original integrity. Despite minor encoding optimizations that could be improved, the overall presentation is clean with minimal noise artifacts. Kudos to Olive Films for promptly addressing initial encoding glitches and delivering a flawless second pressing. This release of "Father Goose" stands as a solid enhancement over earlier versions, providing a visually rich and detailed viewing experience.
Audio: 79
The audio presentation of "Father Goose" on Blu-ray is delivered through an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, with optional English SDH subtitles available for the main feature. This lossless track provides impressive depth and the dynamic intensity necessary for a film of its era, particularly in action sequences. Dialogue clarity is exceptional, with clear, clean, and stable reproduction that ensures the narrative is easy to follow throughout. Additionally, there are no reported audio dropouts or distortions, which speaks to the high quality of this release.
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 format, despite its limitations compared to modern multi-channel formats, delivers a surprisingly robust auditory experience. The low-frequency extension stands out, especially given the film's war setting. Subwoofer use is notably prominent, with deep shots and explosions producing a satisfactory dynamic range that enhances the viewing experience. Although there is no surround sound presentation to speak of, the overall audio quality remains excellent for this period piece.
Extras: 86
The Blu-ray release of "Father Goose" by Olive Films is a treasure trove of insightful extras that immerse viewers into the rich history surrounding the film and its iconic stars. The exclusive audio commentary by film historian David Del Valle meticulously explores the film's conception, production challenges in Jamaica, and the dynamics involving Cary Grant. Featurettes like "Unfinished Business" by Marc Eliot delve into Cary Grant's personal quest for fatherhood and career aspirations, while Ted Nelson's interview in "My Father" provides a heartfelt look at the familial and professional influences of director Ralph Nelson. The disc also includes valuable archival materials such as a Universal Newsreel and a text essay by Village Voice critic Bilge Ebiri, enhancing the contextual understanding of the film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: In-depth commentary by film historian David Del Valle.
- Unfinished Business: Marc Eliot on Cary Grant’s personal and professional life.
- My Father: Ted Nelson reflects on his father, Ralph Nelson.
- Universal Newsreel Footage: Historical footage featuring Leslie Caron.
- Essay: Text essay by critic Bilge Ebiri.
- Booklet: Printed essay by Bilge Ebiri with archival stills.
- Sleeve: Double-sided sleeve.
Movie: 76
Ralph Nelson's Father Goose (1964) arrives on Blu-ray from Olive Films featuring a range of supplemental content, including exclusive interviews and a new audio commentary. The movie highlights Cary Grant in an uncharacteristic role as Walter Eckland, an unkempt and unshaven beach bum, which starkly contrasts with his refined personas in films like North by Northwest. Set during WWII in the South Pacific, the plot follows the drunken drifter forced into a makeshift surveillance role by his navy pal, Commander Frank Houghton (Trevor Howard). The unconventional reward system—Walter receives whiskey for confirmed enemy reports—highlights the comedic quirks embedded in the storyline.
Grant's portrayal is both refreshing and surprising, demonstrating his versatility as he uncannily embodies a character far removed from his usual suave image. The film's charm is elevated by Leslie Caron's role as Catherine Freneau, a prudish French schoolteacher who arrives unexpectedly with seven schoolgirls. Their interactions, laced with witty banter and escalating to a memorable slapping contest, add layers of humor and heart to the narrative. The chemistry between Grant and Caron is particularly notable, infusing the film with an irresistible allure that transcends its otherwise whimsical premise.
While the film may not delve deeply into war themes, it excels as a family comedy. The children’s distinct personalities—from tomboy Harriet to the reticent Jenny—further enrich the story. As Walter transitions from a gruff sailor to a paternal figure, viewers are treated to a blend of slapstick humor and endearing moments. The radio-wedding scene epitomizes the film's comedic and romantic synergy. Ultimately, Father Goose stands out for its spirited performances, engaging dynamics, and the delightful transformation of Grant's character.
Total: 78
Olive Films' Signature Edition of "Father Goose" delivers an impressive upgrade, sourced from a recent 4K remaster. This restoration significantly enhances the visual and audio quality, outshining the previous 2013 release. The 1964 film, featuring a delightfully atypical Cary Grant, offers a charming deviation from his usual suave roles. His character is endearingly rumpled and comical, making for an engaging departure that showcases Grant's versatility.
The chemistry among the cast is palpable, with Grant's understated humor lighting up scenes and rendering the ensemble cast thoroughly enjoyable. The film is replete with memorable one-liners and whimsical situations that ensure continuous amusement. It's an appealing concoction of romance, comedy, and adventure, encapsulating the spirit of classic cinema with a fresh twist.
Conclusively, "Father Goose" stands as a testament to Cary Grant's range as an actor, embodying an all-new personality that is both believable and charming under Alfred Hitchcock's indirect influence. The Olive Films' Signature Edition is a definitive viewing experience due to its superior technical presentation. Despite its flaws, "Father Goose" remains a film with a unique charm comparable to classics like Lina Wertmüller's "Swept Away" and Marco Ferreri's "Liza." HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
Indeed, especially in terms of delineation and depth the improvements can be quite dramatic, and the larger your screen is, the more obvious they will become to you....
Audio: 100
The lossless track has very good depth and action sequences dynamic intensity is as good as one can expect for a period film of this caliber....
Extras: 80
Commentary - in this brand new audio commentary, film historian David Del Valle discusses in great detail the conception of Father Goose and the production process (with specific comments about the shooting...
Movie: 80
Shortly after Walter begins reporting under the alias Mother Goose, however, he makes a very strange discovery -- also hiding on the tiny island is the beautiful but almost unbearably prudish French teacher...
Total: 90
The great Alfred Hitchcock is almost certainly the main reason why Father Goose exists because he apparently managed to convince Cary Grant that he would get a chance to win an Academy Award only if he...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 80
Depth: During the darker indoor footage there is great shadow definition that removes the flatness from the old master and aids the quality of depth in this film....
Audio: 80
Audio Format: English: DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0Subtitles: English SDHDynamics: Low-frequency dynamics....
Extras: 100
• Audio commentary by film historian David Del Valle• “Unfinished Business: Cary Grant’s Search for Fatherhood and His Oscar” – with Marc Eliot, author of Cary Grant: A Biography• “My Father” – internet...
Movie: 80
Reminiscing over all the tuxedos and smoking jackets and loafers makes one question why Grant would take such a role, but after watching such a sweet and naive story I understand that Grant stays true...
Total: 100
The film is full of great one-liners and will continuously have you laughing at both the characters and their circumstances....
Director: Ralph Nelson
Actors: Cary Grant, Leslie Caron, Trevor Howard
PlotWalter Eckland, a reclusive and reluctant drifter, is persuaded by the British Navy during World War II to serve as a coast watcher on a deserted island in the South Pacific. His task is to spot and report enemy ship and aircraft movements. Initially, Eckland wants nothing to do with the war effort and is more interested in his alcohol stash. However, he is coerced into compliance due to his connection with his old friend Commander Frank Houghton. While on the island, Eckland's solitude is disrupted by the unexpected arrival of French schoolteacher Catherine Freneau and her seven young female students, who have been stranded after their ship was attacked.
Despite their vastly different backgrounds and initial mutual disdain, Eckland and Freneau must work together to survive. As they experience challenges such as enemy threats, limited resources, and the struggles of managing the children, they begin to develop a grudging respect for each other. The dynamics shift from conflict to camaraderie, fostering unexpected moments of humor and warmth amidst perilous circumstances. From this point, the story delves into their evolving relationship and the challenges they face as the war continues to encroach on their precarious sanctuary.
Writers: Peter Stone, Frank Tarloff, S.H. Barnett
Release Date: 24 Dec 1964
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English, French, Japanese