Breaker Morant Blu-ray Review

Umbrella Entertainment’s Blu-ray release of "Breaker Morant" features a 1080p transfer, encoded with MPEG-4 AVC in a 1.84:1 aspect ratio, diverging notably from Criterion's 2015 version. Unlike the Criterion release, which likely utilized a 4K scan of the original negative, Umbrella's edition seems to derive from a different master. This is evident through the presence of minor visual imperfections, such as flecks and black marks, which suggest a secondary source may have been used, perhaps an interpositive.

The film’s presentation on this Blu-ray is somewhat softer in image density and sharpness compared to Criterion’s. Although image stability remains commendable, there's noticeable room for improvement in terms of grain exposure, attributable to minor shortcomings in encoding optimizations. Despite these discrepancies, the release avoids problematic digital manipulation, preserving the film's essence.

Color reproduction varies between editions as well. The Umbrella release showcases more pronounced yellows and yellowish nuances, while blue hues exhibit distinct variations. These differences lead to an overall altered color temperature and aesthetic when compared to previous releases. Flesh tones appear natural, with pleasing contrast despite the softer visuals. While not achieving the pristine clarity of the Criterion edition, Umbrella Entertainment’s release still delivers a solid visual experience for fans and newcomers alike. This Blu-ray is region-free, ensuring accessibility to audiences worldwide without compatibility concerns.

The Blu-ray release of "Breaker Morant" presents its audio with two robust options: the English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and the original English mono in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, complemented by optional English SDH subtitles for accessibility. The default setting is the 5.1 track, though switching to the 2.0 requires manual navigation using a remote control. The preference for the original track might appeal to purists due to its authentic sound.

Both audio tracks maintain a high quality, exhibiting clear dialogues and commendable dynamics without significant age-induced imperfections. The 5.1 track distinguishes itself by introducing a subtle reverberation, adding a sense of spaciousness and fullness to the audio experience, yet it still primarily functions as a mono track with enhanced depth. This approach ensures the audio remains clean and well-defined across both versions.

In conclusion, audiophiles and cinematic purists will appreciate the meticulous preservation of the film's original sound identity, while still benefiting from the option to experience a slightly more immersive soundstage with the 5.1 track.

The Blu-ray extras for "Breaker Morant" offer a compelling and thorough exploration into the film’s historical context and production nuances. The newly recorded audio commentary is a rich, engaging discussion with director Bruce Beresford, actor Bryan Brown, and producer Matt Carroll, detailing the film's conception, casting decisions, and cinematography. "Breaker Morant: The Retrial" documentary provides an in-depth retrospective of Harry Morant's controversial historical legacy with insights from historians and descendants, while interviews offer candid reflections on both the character and the movie's reception. Archival pieces like "The Breaker" uncover fascinating anecdotes about Morant's life, underscoring his complex persona. Each piece contributes meaningfully to understanding the layers of historical and cinematic storytelling inherent in the film.

Extras included in this disc:

• Australian Trailer: Remastered trailer for the local audience.
• U.S. Trailer: Vintage trailer for the U.S. market.
• Commentary: Audio discussion featuring insights on various aspects of the film’s production.
• Breaker Morant: The Retrial: Documentary examining Morant's legacy.
• Edward Woodward: Archival interview with insights on the character and film success.
• The Breaker (1973): Documentary detailing Morant's life and the Boer War.
• The Myth Exposed: Reflection by Frank Shields on omitted evidence from "The Breaker."
• Photo Gallery: A collection of production stills.

Bruce Beresford's 1980 film "Breaker Morant" emerges as a compelling exploration of military morality and justice during the Second Boer War. Set in 1902, the narrative revolves around Australian soldiers Harry 'Breaker' Morant, Peter Handcock, and George Witton, played by exceptional talents Edward Woodward, Bryan Brown, and Lewis Fitz-Gerald respectively. These men, operating under British command, face court-martial by the British for executing Boer prisoners and a German missionary. Through dynamic courtroom scenes, Major J.F. Thomas, portrayed by an outstanding Jack Thompson, valiantly defends their actions as adherence to wartime orders amidst a predetermined trial outcome. The film intelligently questions the hypocrisy and political motivations underpinning military decisions, reminiscent of the nuanced reflections presented in Stanley Kubrick's "Paths of Glory."

Technically, the film excels with its crisp cinematography and authentic portrayal of South African landscapes, although shot entirely in South Australia. It intricately uses lighting and camera movement, notably in the gripping execution scene. Despite being shot within a mere thirty-five days, the film's production quality stands strong with superb chemistry among the cast which balances the intensity of the narrative without descending into melodrama. Minimalist in its soundtrack, Beresford opts for moments of authentic brass band music to punctuate scenes effectively.

"Breaker Morant" not only holds significance for its storytelling but also marked a milestone in Australian cinema by winning Best Supporting Actor (Jack Thompson) at the Cannes Film Festival. This success helped set the stage for future cinematic explorations of Australian soldiers' experiences under British command, akin to Peter Weir’s "Gallipoli." The film remains a critical examination of wartime ethics and the complex layer of political interests that govern military trials.

Bruce Beresford's "Breaker Morant" serves as a penetrating examination of military injustice and power abuse, much akin to the critical narratives portrayed in Stanley Kubrick's "Paths of Glory." Set against the backdrop of the Boer War in South Africa, the film intricately depicts the tumultuous series of true events involving British and Boer struggles over regions rich with gold and diamonds. Despite its modest reception outside Australia at its initial 1980 release, "Breaker Morant" cemented Beresford's international reputation, spotlighting his deft storytelling and directorial finesse.

The Blu-ray presentation of "Breaker Morant" is distinguished by a technical quality that diverges from Criterion's 2015 release, offering audiences a fresh visual and auditory experience. This new edition is complemented by an impressive array of exclusive new and archived bonus features, enriching the viewer's understanding of the film's historical context and production nuances. This release, therefore, not only rejuvenates the film itself but also provides depth through its added content.

In conclusion, "Breaker Morant" is a testament to Bruce Beresford's narrative craft and continues to resonate with contemporary audiences through its unflinching portrayal of historical military conflicts and moral ambiguities. The Blu-ray edition, with its unique presentation and comprehensive supplemental materials, makes a persuasive case for its addition to any film enthusiast's collection. Highly recommended for those seeking a powerful cinematic exploration of the complexities of war and justice.