Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta offers a captivating performance with excellent 1080i picture quality, strong audio, and a substantial bonus documentary, perfect for fans.
Disc Release Date
Video: 55
Despite being presented in 1080i MPEG-2 instead of the standard 1080p, 'Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta' offers vibrant colors, impressive detail, and a dynamic presentation from the stage to the audience, though minor issues like shadow delineation and occasional jaggies are noted.
Audio: 58
Featuring uncompressed PCM 5.1 and Dolby Digital 5.1, this Blu-ray excels in delivering vibrant, beat-driven performances with clear, solid bass. While the PCM tracks, particularly the 5.1 mix, offer a more immersive crowd experience, some may find the vocals occasionally overpowered by music and crowd effects.
Extra: 50
Extras provide a decent overview for fans, with 'Destiny's Child: A Family Affair' delivering a substantial 46-minute documentary on the group's history and individual paths, fan testimonials highlighting concert experiences, and three bonus audio tracks offered in PCM 2.0 stereo and Dolby Digital 5.1 surround.
Movie: 70
Capturing their final tour in 2005, 'Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta' is a must-own Blu-ray showcasing breathtaking stage effects, impressive choreography, top-notch vocals, and exceptional audience engagement, culminating in a theatrical, unforgettable concert experience for fans.
Video: 55
"Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta" arrives on Blu-ray delivered in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio, utilizing MPEG-2 encoding and offering a 1080i transfer. While this may seem unconventional compared to the now-standard 1080p, the video quality remains impressive, provided your playback chain handles interlacing adeptly. The transfer exudes a remarkable three-dimensional depth typical of high-definition content, producing a vibrant, you-are-there experience. Colors stand out vividly, with even challenging primaries like reds and blues rendered cleanly during live performances. Nonetheless, areas such as shadow delineation in low-light scenes may not meet the highest standards, though they align with typical live performance recordings.
The disc shines through in capturing the concert's glitz and glamour. The crispness of the image ensures that every detail, from Beyoncé, Kelly, and Michelle’s textured outfits to the individual faces in the crowd, is sharply defined. Skin tones occasionally appear oversaturated, likely a byproduct of heavy stage makeup. However, the overall picture quality exceeds expectations, presenting visually stunning, vivid colors and excellent detail resolution in each frame. Audience shots reveal an immense depth and intricate patterns on clothing, further enhancing the immersive experience. Despite minor issues like occasional jaggies during high-contrast tracking shots, the visual presentation remains rock-solid throughout.
In summary, "Live in Atlanta" on Blu-ray offers an eye-catching and colorful video presentation with a solid 1080i transfer. The concert's enchanting visuals and intricate details are well-preserved, contributing to an overall commendable viewing experience. Despite non-optimal aspects like the handling of shadow detail and minor jaggies, the vibrant color scheme and crisp image quality are bound to thrill fans of Destiny's Child.
Audio: 58
The Audio presentation of the "Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta" Blu-ray offers several high-quality options, primarily featuring uncompressed PCM tracks in both 5.1 surround and stereo formats, as well as a Dolby Digital 5.1 track. For the optimal audio experience, the PCM tracks are highly recommended. The PCM 5.1 mix notably enriches the listening atmosphere by dispersing crowd noise around the listener, delivering an immersive concert experience that makes you feel as if you are part of the Atlanta crowd. However, both PCM tracks are heavily center-focused, which benefits the clarity of the front-laden dance tracks, allowing them to resonate clearly in your living room.
The Dolby Digital 5.1 option, while serviceable, falls short compared to the depth and richness offered by the PCM tracks. The stereo PCM mix achieves a balanced sound profile that may appeal more to listeners seeking clarity. While the 5.1 mix offers some incremental benefits in audience immersion, it's primarily through boosted crowd noise rather than substantive improvements in music quality. The music itself impresses with a strong and solid bass line, but the occasional overpowering background elements can cause the singers' voices to get slightly lost amidst the dynamic instrumental layers.
Overall, the audio quality is high, capturing the liveliness of a studio recording with a live performance’s unique ambiance. Fans might notice some artificial volume enhancements during crowd interactions, but generally, all audio elements — from vocals to pre-recorded overdubs — are harmoniously mixed. This release offers an engaging audio experience that any Destiny's Child fan will likely find satisfying.
Extras: 50
The Blu Ray extras for "Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta" offer a mix of engaging content and behind-the-scenes insights. Destiny's Child: A Family Affair is the standout element, providing a substantial 46-minute documentary produced for British television. This semi-chronological piece presents personal reflections from the band members on their journey and success, featuring appearances by industry heavyweights like Missy Elliott, Wyclef Jean, and Patti LaBelle. Fan Testimonials compile enthusiastic post-concert reactions, focusing on favorite moments and songs from the show. Finally, the Bonus Audio Tracks section comprises three audio-only songs: "Flashback," "Let's Stay Together," and a remix of "Check On It," available in both PCM 2.0 stereo and Dolby Digital 5.1 surround formats, each set to static images.
Extras included in this disc:
- Destiny's Child: A Family Affair: Semi-chronological documentary featuring band member reflections and guest appearances.
- Fan Testimonials: Short interviews with fans post-concert.
- Bonus Audio Tracks: Three songs with audio-only options accompanied by still images.
Movie: 70
Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta captures an unforgettable live performance of the iconic group at the Philips Arena on July 15, 2005. The concert, part of their Destiny Fulfilled... and Lovin' It farewell tour, showcases an impressive setlist featuring hits like "Say My Name," "Survivor," and "Bootylicious." The show is meticulously crafted with elaborate stage setups, vibrant special effects, urban ballet dancing, and guest appearances by T.I. and Lil' Wayne. Each element contributes to a highly stylized production that not only underscores the trio’s vocal prowess but also their dynamic stage presence.
Technically, the Blu-ray delivers exceptional clarity and vibrant audio, ensuring that every choreographed move and vocal harmony is captured with stunning fidelity. The large neon screens and multiple smaller floaters provide excellent visibility, making sure even those seated far from the stage feel part of the action. The filming crew adeptly captures both the performers and the ecstatic audience, further amplifying the concert's electric atmosphere. The disc features all 22 songs performed, interspersed with captivating intros, interludes, and costume changes that add to the theatrical prowess of the show.
What sets this concert apart is not just its technical execution but the palpable chemistry between Beyoncé, Kelly Rowland, and Michelle Williams. Their camaraderie is evident as they tease, provoke, and entertain the crowd with effortless charm and sincerity. Highlights include a PG-13-rated audience interaction during "Cater 2 U," showcasing their playful side and enhancing audience engagement. Overall, Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta is a spectacular audiovisual experience that brilliantly captures the essence of one of the best-selling female groups of all time.
Total: 57
"Destiny's Child: Live in Atlanta" on Blu-ray delivers a visually stunning and richly detailed concert experience. The 1080i picture quality offers a feast for the eyes, with vibrant colors and fine gradients in blue and orange hues that stretch deep into the background. The performance captures Destiny's Child at their best, showcasing their dedication and passion for their fans. Technically, the Blu-ray excels in presenting the concert with high-definition clarity, offering an immersive viewing experience that feels almost as electrifying as attending the live show.
In terms of audio, this Blu-ray stands out with top-notch sound quality that elevates the live concert vibe. It's remarkable how Blu-ray has revolutionized home entertainment standards, making it possible to enjoy high-quality recordings of live pop, rock shows, operas, and ballets from the comfort of your home. The sound mixing is expertly done, ensuring each lyric and note is captured beautifully, contributing to an overall engaging experience. Another highlight is the bonus documentary included, which offers more substance than typical concert fillers, adding value to this release.
I can't comment if the video has improved from its DVD incarnation as I've never seen that original offering but what I can say is even at 1080i, the picture offers up a wonderful feast for the eye. The girls come across well and obviously put their heart and soul into this performance, and it's always good to see a band making an effort for their fans. It is the fans themselves though that this will really only appeal to, and if you are one of them then I would have to say that you're probably going to enjoy it. If not, then I'm sure there are other video concerts available for your own tastes.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 70
Skin tones are a little oversaturated, and I wondered if that was a little too much make up, but the definition of the girls clothes, sparkly costumes and even sweat on their cheeks is all there now for...
Audio: 70
Of the two PCM tracks, both are very front heavy and really the 5.1 system only wins out a tad because it places crowd noise and adulation around your listening position, allowing the viewer really to...
Extras: 50
It would perhaps have been interesting to have more detail on the individual band members and what they have been working on since that final tour, since this is after all part swansong, part advert for...
Movie: 50
Unfortunately not all of their fans would have been able to see them, never mind on their final tour, so for these people this would be a worthwhile addition to their Destiny's Child collection....
Total: 60
I can't comment if the video has improved from it's DVD incarnation as I've never seen that original offering but what I can say is even at 1080i the picture offers up a wonderful feast for the eye, colours...
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
As the camera zooms over the audience and captures every little move Beyonc�, Kelly, and Michelle make you will notice the tiny little sweat drops on their faces, their heavy breathing....
Audio: 90
The 5.1 mix only slightly betters the overall listening experience by adding a bit more of the expansive audience-effect, it is certainly more prominently featured....
Extras: 70
Fan Testimonials � A collage of interviews where fans of the band share their thoughts as they depart the Atlanta venue....
Movie: 90
From the impressive intro where the three divas entered the stage in chic, utterly sexy, outfits to the farewell performance of Lose My Breath there is one word that describes this show best - perfection....
Total: 90
Yet, as the studios slowly begin to introduce more and more music on BD I find myself more and more enthusiastic about the format....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Unfortunately, the disc does lack shadow delineation in low-light moments, though this is not out of character with most live performances shot on HD that I've seen....
Audio: 80
The only really fake moments are the sudden volume bursts of the crowd -- whenever a sing-along is required, the audience suddenly seems to get louder....
Extras: 40
Destiny's disciples are predictably breathless and over-enthusiastic, gushing about topics ranging from a review of the show to the best costumes to the favorite song of the evening....
Movie: 80
By the time they launch into their mega-hit "Survivor" near the show's end, it's like watching Dreamgirls with a happy ending....
Total: 80
Bidding a fond farewell after a solid decade of success, the ladies put on a very lively show, and it's nicely captured on this Blu-ray release....
Director: Julia Knowles
Actors: Beyoncé, Aisha Jamila Francis, Kelly Rowland, Michelle Williams
PlotThe film captures the powerhouse performances of a celebrated music group during their sold-out concert in Atlanta. The show opens with a dramatic entrance, featuring dazzling lights and elaborate choreography that immediately captivates the audience. With infectious energy, the group goes through an impressive setlist that spans their greatest hits, including fan favorites and chart-topping singles. Each song is presented with meticulous attention to detail, showcasing not just vocal prowess but also intricate dance routines that highlight their versatility as entertainers.
In addition to the electrifying musical numbers, the film offers glimpses of the camaraderie and mutual support among the performers, providing an intimate look into their dynamics both on and off the stage. Throughout the concert, spontaneous interactions with the audience amplify the palpable sense of celebration and connection. Behind-the-scenes footage interspersed with on-stage action provides a richer context to the emotion and hard work driving each performance, creating an engaging narrative that is as much about the journey and teamwork as it is about the music. The film concludes with a spectacular finale that leaves the audience both in the arena and at home exhilarated and inspired.
Writers: N/A
Release Date: 27 Mar 2006
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: USA
Language: English