High School Musical 3: Senior Year Blu-ray Review
Extended Edition
Score: 53
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
High School Musical 3 divides: a treat for fans, a trial for others, with a solid Blu-ray release.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 55
Disney's Blu-ray of 'High School Musical 3' wows with vibrant colors and detailed textures, though it occasionally struggles with color balance and black levels, not fully meeting the high expectations set by previous releases.
Audio: 60
Surprised by High School Musical 3's excellent 5.1 DTS-HD audio, with great fidelity and dynamics but lighter bass and consistent volume across songs, eliciting mixed reactions.
Extra: 36
Special 'HSM3' edition delights with sing-along, bloopers, and featurettes but deleted scenes frustrate. Extras add value, though not all hit the mark.
Movie: 51
Despite personal reservations, reviewers find 'High School Musical 3' a charming yet unrealistic portrayal of youth, elevated by enthusiastic performances and catchy songs, appealing to its fervent young fanbase.
Video: 55
Disney's Blu-ray release of "High School Musical 3: Senior Year" showcases a dedicated effort to maintain the high standard of video quality the studio is known for, especially given the larger budget and more elaborate production design compared to its earlier counterparts. The 1080p/MPEG-4 AVC transfer, presented in the film's original aspect ratio of 1.78:1, offers a testament to this commitment. Viewers will find themselves captivated by the vibrant and saturated color palette that brings the high school world to life with stunning clarity. Details are finely presented, enabling textures in fabrics and skin to pop in a way that adds a tactile sense to the viewing experience. However, it's noted that the execution of colors, while ambitious, sometimes leans towards over-saturation. Reds, in particular, show a tendency to bleed, especially in scenes with rapid movement, hinting at Disney's effort to mimic the vividness of classic Technicolor films, albeit slightly overshooting the mark.
Despite the strong color representation and detailed imagery, the video transfer occasionally betrays expectations in terms of dimensional depth and crispness. The image, while spotless and clearly defined, sometimes lacks the visual pop and three-dimensional window effect that can immerse the viewer into the film’s musical extravaganzas. This results in a presentation that, while aesthetically pleasing, can feel somewhat flat at moments. Black levels are commendably deep, providing a solid foundation for contrast and shadow delineation that adds to the overall picture quality. Yet, even with these strengths, some may find the overall video quality not quite living up to the high standards Disney has set in previous Blu-ray releases. This minor shortfall does little to detract from the overall enjoyment of the film, assured by its bright, lively presentation that largely captures the energetic spirit and visual allure of "High School Musical 3: Senior Year."
Audio: 60
High School Musical 3's Blu Ray edition boasts a 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track that pleasantly surprises with its quality and dynamism, especially given the movie's emphasis on musical numbers. The track excels in delivering the film's array of songs with admirable fidelity, utilizing the full spectrum of the 5.1 setup to create an immersive listening experience. While the bass could be described as somewhat subdued, this slight deficiency is effectively countered by an exemplary sharpness in dialogue and overall dynamic audio reproduction. It's noteworthy that the sound design ensures clarity and balance without overwhelming the viewer, preserving a natural flow from scene to scene.
On the technical side, the audio presentation offers a good dynamic range and decent bass accents during musical sequences, ensuring that songs are more than just audible—they're engaging. However, some may find that the track maintains a consistent audio level even as it transitions into these sequences, lacking the anticipated punch that might elevate the musical numbers to a more exhilarating climax. The surround effects contribute nicely by adding depth and atmosphere without becoming intrusive, enveloping the listener in High School Musical 3’s vibrant world. The front channels deliver directional sound that enhances the on-screen action, further supplemented by background scores that complement without competing for dominance.
Despite these strengths, the 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track does leave room for desire amongst audiophiles seeking a more pronounced sonic boom to match the energy of a high school musical. While it delivers clear dialogue and well-balanced soundscapes, it stops short of reaching the auditory peaks some might expect from a film so rooted in its musical elements. However, it remains a significantly satisfying auditory experience that captures the essence of Disney's high-energy finale to the High School Musical trilogy.
Extras: 36
The "High School Musical 3: Senior Year" Blu-ray special features offer a deep dive into what made the film such a memorable phenomenon, targeting aficionados and newbies alike. The deleted scenes, while a point of contention for some, offer fascinating glimpses of what might have been, with introductions from Kenny Ortega adding context. Noteworthy is the yearbook-themed menu, making navigation a nostalgic trip, alongside the practical song index for easy sing-along sessions. The behind-the-scenes featurettes, particularly "Night of Nights" and "It's All in the Dress," reveal the meticulous craftsmanship that went into the prom scenes and costumes, enriching fans' appreciation. The blooper reel maintains the film's wholesome aura without crossing into edgier territory, while the cast goodbyes add an emotional coda to the trilogy's conclusion. Extras, including sneak peeks and a digital copy, ensure fans can enjoy the magic across various platforms, making it a comprehensive addition to any collection.
Extras included in this disc:
- Profiles: New Cast Members
- Deleted Scenes with Introductions from Director Kenny Ortega: 8 scenes giving insight into the editing process
- Blooper Reel: A compilation of on-set gaffs
- Night of Nights: Cast shares insights on prom scene choreography
- It's All in the Dress: Discusses how each prom dress represents its character
- Senior Awards: A lighthearted presentation by the cast and crew
- Cast Goodbyes: Reflective interviews with the main cast
- High School Musical 3 Sing-along Mode: For fans to sing along with their favorite tunes
Movie: 51
The latest installment of Disney's "High School Musical 3: Senior Year" ventures beyond its TV roots, making a grand leap onto the big screen with an array of splashier sets, more elaborate costumes, and a slightly meatier narrative. Despite the skepticism and potential franchise fatigue that often accompanies third chapters, this film manages not only to captivate its target tween audience but also offers a sprinkle of charm for the uninitiated viewer. While not groundbreaking in its musical or storytelling ambitions, it delivers a commendable mix of catchy tunes, earnest performances, and vibrant energy that aligns with its predecessors yet benefits from the enhanced budget and production values a theatrical release commands.
Centering on the senior year dilemmas of Troy, Gabriella, and their East High companions, the film navigates themes of dreams, love, and the future with a wholesome fervor. Despite the fairyland depiction of high school life that strays far from reality, the film’s escapist charm and positive messages shine through. The depiction of Troy’s internal struggle with choosing between a basketball scholarship and following his passion for theater reflects universal coming-of-age anxieties, offering audience members a mirror to their own experiences. However, one can't help but notice the overly sanitized portrayal of high school life, devoid of the socio-economic and racial diversity present in real-life scenarios.
The movie excels in its musical and dance sequences, accomplishing feats such as integrating a basketball game into a full-blown musical number without compromising the masculinity of its male characters, a testament to Kenny Ortega's capable direction. Though the runtime may feel extended with a 117-minute cut for the theatrical release, the film never fully loses its pace, thanks to engaging performances and dynamic production numbers. While it might not rival classic musicals in depth or complexity, "High School Musical 3" stands as a glossy, feel-good spectacle that successfully completes its trilogy arc, catering to its ardent fans while offering family-friendly entertainment that even skeptics of the genre can appreciate momentarily.
Total: 53
"High School Musical 3: Senior Year" on Blu-ray presents a mixed bag that varies significantly depending on who you ask. With its transition from the small screen to the cinemas, this franchise closer brings all the dazzle and spectacle expected, aiming squarely at its young and energetically engaged fan base. For fans, this Blu-ray release is akin to attending the ultimate farewell concert, offering decent video and audio quality that, while not topping Disney's finest efforts, certainly meets the mark for an enjoyable home viewing experience. Extras are plentiful, providing a deeper dive into the world of East High with what could be described as an all-access backstage pass.
However, for those not already charmed by the franchise's song and dance routine, this might feel more like an endurance test peppered with eye-rolls than a cinematic delight. The complaint isn't so much about the quality of the Blu-ray presentation—which faithfully captures the vivid colors and dynamic energy of the dances and songs—but more about the content it delivers. Parents might find themselves reaching for metaphorical Tylenol as they navigate through the teenage melodrama, but at the same time, seeing their children's joyous reactions could offer a different form of entertainment altogether.
In conclusion, "High School Musical 3: Senior Year" on Blu-ray serves as a fitting tribute to fans who have grown up with Troy, Gabriella, and company, encapsulating the high energy and emotional highs of adolescence. While it may test the patience of uninitiated adults with its exuberant teen spirit, it ultimately succeeds in providing a celebratory capstone to a beloved series. The presentation quality, though not groundbreaking, supports the film's vibrant productions effectively. For fans, this release is indispensable; for everyone else, it's an opportunity to either discover the charm that captivated a generation or reaffirm their status as passable observers from the sidelines.
Blu-ray.com review by Ben WilliamsRead review here
Video: 90
Black levels occasionally suffer from a slight amount of crush during the presentation, but it's nothing worth getting into a twist over....
Audio: 80
After calming her down a bit by threatening to make her watch the movie with the Spanish language track turned on, Stephanie resumed trash- talking the various "villains" in the film....
Extras: 40
Much like the extras from the first film, she enjoyed Sing-along mode and several of the short featurettes, however, the deleted scenes seemed to annoy her....
Movie: 50
Even though High School Musical 3 is slightly more enjoyable than the first film, I still feel that this is entertainment intended for Stephanie and her peers; parents need only sit back and ignore what...
Total: 50
As I put the High School Musical experience behind me, I'll never forget Stephanie's joy and exhilaration in viewing the films, the range of emotions she experienced, the picture she knocked off the wall...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The spotless source material renders a crisp and clean high-def picture with properly tuned contrast, but lacks the visual pop one expects from this material....
Audio: 80
The musical numbers enjoy good dynamic range, with some nice bass accents, but they never provided the sonic pow I kept craving....
Extras: 40
Featurette: "Cast Goodbyes" (HD, 6 minutes) – Efron, Hudgens, and the rest of the gang reflect on their "graduation" from 'HSM' films, what the trilogy has meant to them, the friendships they've formed,...
Movie: 60
Say what you will about its bubble gum blend of music, puppy love, and friends forever attitude; it's hard to knock such a well-intended film that telegraphs a positive, relatable message....
Total: 60
Video and audio don't quite hang with Disney's best, but they're far from inferior, and a healthy line-up of extras provides fans with a coveted backstage pass....
Director: Kenny Ortega
Actors: Zac Efron, Vanessa Hudgens, Ashley Tisdale
PlotAs high school seniors, Troy Bolton, Gabriella Montez, and their friends face the prospect of separation as they prepare to go their respective ways after graduation. Faced with the challenge of leaving their comfort zones and each other, they decide to channel their emotions and experiences into a final musical. This musical is meant to capture the essence of their high school journey, fears about the future, and hopes for what lies ahead. Troy grapples with his passion for basketball versus his newfound love for theater, while Gabriella faces the dilemma of staying close to Troy or pursuing her academic dreams at Stanford.
The preparation for the musical brings out underlying tensions, aspirations, and the strong bonds among the group. Sharpay Evans, aspiring to leave her mark in the school’s theatrical legacy, battles for the spotlight, adding to the dynamic interplay of friendships and rivalries. Amidst the backdrop of songs, dances, and rehearsals, each student confronts personal dilemmas about identity, relationships, and their futures. The journey to the final performance is fraught with challenges that test their resolve, friendships, and commitments to their dreams, setting the stage for a climax that encapsulates their high school experience.
Writers: Peter Barsocchini
Release Date: 24 Oct 2008
Runtime: 112 min
Rating: G
Country: United States
Language: English