Election 2 Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Election 2" is showcased in its original aspect ratio of 2.35:1 with an MPEG-4 AVC 1080p transfer. This meticulous encoding offers a crisp and clean image throughout, with impressive depth and clarity noticeable in both close-ups and background elements. The detail level is exceptional, vividly defining intricate textures such as the outline of a vest through dense fabric and the individual tassels on Chinese lanterns. The color fidelity is praiseworthy, with strong primary colors enriching the visual experience. A notable example is a shot of red wine that beautifully captures subtle gradations from deep red to pink-tinged clear liquid. Contrast is robust, delivering bold blacks which are effectively employed in the dark suits of gangsters and the inky darkness of Jimmy’s hair. Shadow detail is skillfully managed, enhancing the film's stylistic atmosphere, especially in scenes where shadows are used to heighten the mystery.

While the transfer retains a cinematic quality suited to high-definition scrutiny, it is not without minor imperfections. Grain is organically present, fitting for the film's gritty aesthetic, though it occasionally borders on excessive. Observations of light edge enhancements and digital noise intermittently surface but do not significantly detract from the overall experience. Importantly, macroblocking and notable debris like scratches or dirt are absent, ensuring a clean presentation. Despite these minor technical hitches, the Blu-ray of "Election 2" successfully capitalizes on Cheng Siu-keung’s cinematography and stands as a recommended viewing, adeptly translating the film's visual intricacies to home screens.

The audio presentation of "Election 2" on Blu-ray is anchored by an outstanding DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track. This uncompressed track opens with an impactful score, exhibiting excellent front separation and vibrant ambient effects, including birds, crickets, dogs barking, and wind murmuring through the various channels. The city scenes leverage the surround sound capabilities effectively, with realistic environmental sounds such as the hustle of crowds and traffic rumbles. While the subwoofer's activity might not be as pronounced as desired, it still contributes with enough low-end effects to enhance the overall auditory experience. Dialogue delivery is crystal clear, ensuring every conversation is easily comprehensible.

Moreover, the score by Robert Ellis-Geiger plays a significant role in this audio presentation, seamlessly blending with the dialogue. The high frequencies are well-balanced against convincing bass and intelligently utilized rear channels. Particularly during violent scenes, the music score dominates the soundstage, showcasing the power and emotion it injects into the narrative. The Cantonese DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track outshines its Dolby Digital counterparts by achieving a more dynamic and immersive sound experience. This meticulously mixed track offers no signs of audio artifacts such as pops, cracks, or dropouts, thereby reinforcing its technical excellence.

In comparison tests, the Dolby Digital tracks—both Cantonese and Mandarin—do not match the dynamic intensity of the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track. This difference is most evident during moments when the soundtrack takes center stage. Although the Dolby Digital tracks are solid in their own right, they lack the depth and breadth that the lossless DTS-HD track provides. The inclusion of various subtitle options within the image frame further extends accessibility to a broader audience, ensuring all viewers can appreciate this expertly crafted auditory experience.

The "Election 2" Blu-ray extras consist primarily of features ported from the previous DVD Special Edition. Each comes with English subtitles, though it’s worth noting there is no exclusive HD content or commentary track available. Key features include in-depth interviews where Director Johnnie To and actors Lam Suet and Lam Ka Tung discuss various aspects of the film, from character development to behind-the-scenes anecdotes. These interviews provide valuable insights into the film’s production and its contextual place within Hong Kong cinema. Additional content includes a brief making-of featurette, promotional trailers, and TV spots, all contributing to a comprehensive understanding of the "Election 2" universe.

Extras included in this disc:

• Interview with Johnnie To: Insights into his productions, character development, and the series' impact.
• Interview with Lam Suet: Details on his scenes, inspiration behind key moments, and his acting journey.
• Interview with Lam Ka Tung: Discussion of his character, action segment experiences, and working with To.
• Making Of: Overview of production with insights from To and the cast.
• Trailers: Promotional material for the feature.
• TV Spots: Three short promotional segments.
• Photo Gallery: Collection of on-set still images set to music.

'Election 2,' directed by the acclaimed Johnnie To, presents a compelling continuation of the intricate power struggle within the Wo Shing Society. The narrative revolves around Jimmy (Louis Koo), a property developer torn between his legitimate aspirations and the intoxicating allure of ultimate power as Chairman. On the other side stands Lok (Simon Yam), the current chairman unwilling to relinquish his command. To's dynamic and unyielding camera work immerses the audience in the thick of the escalating conflict, delivering a kinetic and thrilling experience that builds upon the foundation laid by its predecessor. The juxtaposition of fast-paced "high noon" face-offs with deep character exploration makes 'Election 2' a captivating study of ambition and power.

Johnnie To's sequel delves into darker themes, shifting focus from personal drama to a broader examination of the convergence between global crime and politics. This thematic expansion is deftly handled through the meticulous use of lighting and locations by cinematographer Cheng Siu-keung, which amplifies the film's minimalistic yet impactful storytelling. Silence is strategically employed throughout, replacing action at critical junctures to underscore the tension and gravity of the narrative. The film’s critique on the inevitable merger of triad business interests with China's communist government adds a layer of visionary commentary well-suited for connoisseurs of political thrillers.

What truly sets 'Election 2' apart is its superior character development, with even minor characters leaving indelible marks due to their significant roles within the unfolding power dynamics. The editing team, comprising Cheung Ka-kit and Law Wing-cheong, achieve seamless narrative flow, while Robert Ellis-Geiger's score complements the film’s atmospherics admirably. Collectively, these elements render 'Election 2' not only a formidable standalone piece but also a profound enhancement of Johnnie To's original 'Election,' offering an insightful and engrossing experience deserving of its critical acclaim.

Johnnie To's "Election 2" delivers an engaging and sophisticated crime drama that outshines its predecessor in both narrative complexity and stylistic execution. The film's dark and gritty tone is matched by its intricate plot, offering a compelling experience for fans of intelligent crime cinema. Blu-ray release fans will appreciate the crisp and clear video presentation with a bold contrast ratio and impressive detail that elevates the beautiful cinematography.

The audio presentation on this Blu-ray is solid, with a well-engineered surround mix providing ample engagement. Front separation is spot on, delivering clear and precise dialogue. While the bass may not reach the deepest levels Blu-ray is capable of, the overall sound quality remains high, with haunting violins and intense skin drums contributing to an atmospheric and emotionally resonant score. The extras package, lifted from the Special Edition DVD, offers valuable insights into the film, despite being in standard definition.

With its strong technical presentation and engaging narrative, "Election 2" is a must-own for fans of Asian cinema. Panorama's Blu-ray release ensures that both the visual and auditory elements are finely tuned to provide an immersive viewing experience. Highly recommended for those who appreciate a well-balanced blend of style and substance in crime films.