In the French Style Blu-ray Review
Limited Edition to 3000
Score: 73
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Though 'In the French Style' can be pretentious and unbalanced, Seberg's performance and superb A/V quality on Blu-ray make it a recommended viewing.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
In the French Style presents a remarkable 1.66:1 1080p transfer, showcasing a well-preserved print with no significant age-related wear. The consistent contrast and sharpness, occasional softness in opticals, and organic grain field provide a film-like experience while maintaining excellent detail in facial features and textures.
Audio: 79
In the French Style's DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track excels in delivering clear dialogue and a balanced, immersive sense of space, despite occasional unnatural sounding dubbed voices and the film's generally quiet nature. The mix supports the romantic score subtly without overpowering scenes, ensuring authenticity.
Extra: 48
The Blu-ray extras for 'In the French Style' include a crisp Original Theatrical Trailer (1080p; 2:11), an Isolated Score Track in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 with some effects, and a technically rich audio commentary by historians Lem Dobbs, Julie Kirgo, and Nick Redman, though the commentary sometimes struggles with positivity in the film’s final act.
Movie: 67
"In the French Style" on Blu-ray offers an ambitious yet disjointed adaptation of Irwin Shaw's works, delivered through director Robert Parrish's idiosyncratic lens. Jean Seberg's performance as an American artist navigating Parisian romance and career is compelling, but the film's bifurcated structure and uneven tone hinder emotional and intellectual connection, making it an intriguing but ultimately unfulfilled cinematic experiment.
Video: 83
"In the French Style" is presented on Blu-ray in a stunning AVC encoded 1080p transfer with a 1.66:1 aspect ratio. The transfer, sourced from the Sony-Columbia catalog, showcases an exceptional level of clarity and sharpness, maintaining a consistent and healthy grain structure that enhances the organic visual quality. Contrast is robust and stable throughout, although there are minor fluctuations, predominantly in sequences set in various Parisian locations early in the film. Scenes featuring Seberg and Forquet navigating Paris by scooter or relaxing in a park may exhibit slight variances in sharpness and grain, particularly during longer optical shots. Close-up scenes are especially commendable, with minute details such as the texture of a faux leather transistor radio cover being rendered with remarkable precision.
For a film that is over five decades old, the 1.66:1 1080p transfer performed remarkably well, with the print used for the transfer appearing almost pristine. Only minimal instances of speckling around the opening credits and a couple of faint scratches are noticeable, giving the impression of a nearly brand-new release. The grain structure is present yet non-intrusive, providing an extraordinary level of detail across facial features, costumes, and production design elements, such as Christina's art studio. Black levels and grey scaling are finely tuned, delivering deep, inky visuals without any issues of crush or bloom. Additionally, the transfer is devoid of any compression artifacts, further solidifying its position as an excellent release for classic cinema enthusiasts.
Audio: 79
"In the French Style" features an exceptionally well-handled DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track, displaying a high level of fidelity and excellent prioritization of dialogue, which is a critical element given the film’s dialogue-driven nature. The clarity of every spoken word is maintained throughout with no noticeable breaks or dropouts, offering a seamless listening experience. While some voices may sound slightly unnatural due to being dubbed by different actors, this stems from the original recording mix rather than the quality of the audio presentation.
The immersive quality of the track is notable, with a well-balanced sound that provides a robust sense of spatiality and dimensionality, ensuring that scenes feel as if they are set in real rooms rather than on artificial sets. The score by Joseph Kosma complements this beautifully, delivering a romantic and subtle background presence that enhances the ambiance without overwhelming the dialogue. This mix is not just technically proficient but also articulate in preserving the intended emotional and atmospheric nuances of the film. Overall, this DTS-HD MA 1.0 mono track is free of any age-related issues, offering a pristine and engaging audio experience for its audience.
Extras: 48
The extras included in the Blu Ray release of "In the French Style" offer a valuable and insightful addition to the main feature, providing both historical context and deeper appreciation for the film. The Original Theatrical Trailer, presented in HD at 1080p for 2:11 minutes, sets the nostalgic tone. A robust Isolated Score Track in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 enhances the auditory experience, immersing viewers in the film’s atmospheric soundscapes punctuated by occasional effects. The Audio Commentary by historians Lem Dobbs, Julie Kirgo, and Nick Redman is intellectually stimulating, though occasionally subdued, offering technical insights and focusing on Jean Seberg's impressive performance.
Extras included in this disc:
- Original Theatrical Trailer: Brief description.
- Isolated Score Track: Presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 with some effects.
- Audio Commentary: Historians Lem Dobbs, Julie Kirgo, and Nick Redman offer insights into the film and actress Jean Seberg.
Movie: 67
Robert Parrish's "In the French Style" presents a fascinating, yet flawed narrative revolving around the life of Christina James, portrayed by the iconic Jean Seberg. Based on two short stories by Irwin Shaw, the film unfortunately struggles to synthesize these disparate elements into a cohesive whole, resulting in a segmented storyline that lacks emotional and intellectual resonance. Seberg, known for her role in Jean-Luc Godard's "Breathless," brings an undeniable screen presence to the film. However, her world-weary portrayal of a free-spirited American art student in Paris often feels disjointed, perhaps mirroring the film's own narrative fragmentation. The initial segment, which follows Christina's relationship with the miscast Philippe Forquet, promises romantic intrigue but is abruptly deserted, leaving viewers with a jarring temporal leap and a new, albeit underdeveloped, character arc.
The episodic nature of the film continues with Christina navigating love and art in a bohemian Paris. Encounters with characters such as the hard-drinking reporter Walter Beddoes (Stanley Baker) and her wealthy, disapproving father (Addison Powell) add layers but also dilute the primary narrative thrust. The artistic ambitions hinted at within Christina's painting career are curiously handled; although elements of genuine aesthetic potential are present, they are overshadowed by overarching themes of disillusionment and unmet expectations. This further contributes to the film's bifurcated aura, caught between mimicking the stylistic flourishes of the French New Wave and adhering to more conventional Hollywood storytelling.
Despite its ambitious undertakings and moments of poignant performance, "In the French Style" is ultimately hobbled by its inability to unify Shaw's literary ambition with Parrish's cinematic vision. The film's uneven pacing and fragmented structure lead to an experience that intermittently engages but often leaves the audience unfulfilled. While it provides an insightful glimpse into Seberg's diverse career and offers some aesthetically intriguing moments, it remains an experiment in style and substance that falls short of its potential.
Total: 73
"In the French Style" navigates a complex intersection of life, love, art, and female sexuality through the lens of the 1960s Parisian scene. Despite some pretentious elements and mannered performances, Jeannie Seberg’s portrayal remains captivating, particularly in the film's powerful culminating monologue. The second half of the film significantly improves upon the somewhat awkward first half, warranting multiple viewings for its depth and emotional resonance. The Twilight Time Blu-ray release enhances this experience with excellent technical merits.
A standout feature of this release is the comprehensive audio commentary by film historians Lem Dobbs, Julie Kirgo, and Nick Redman. Their in-depth analysis provides substantial context and insight, enriching the viewing experience even if it critically dissects the film's flaws. The commentary is engaging and intellectually stimulating, encouraging viewers to wrestle with different perspectives about the film’s intentions and execution. Additionally, the disc includes an isolated score track and a theatrical trailer, adding value for collectors and aficionados of classic cinema.
Despite its occasional narrative clunkiness, "In the French Style" successfully maintains its charm and poignancy. The Blu-ray's strikingly beautiful A/V presentation makes it a worthwhile addition to any film enthusiast's collection. While not revolutionary like Godard's works, this film is a vivid slice of its era with robust performances and thought-provoking themes. The engaging extras further elevate this release, making it a recommended purchase for seasoned fans and newcomers alike.
There's a pretentious quality to "In the French Style" that is pretty unmistakable, but that doesn't mean the film is pure drivel. There is a certain style to this piece, albeit not the shattering approach of a Godard. Seberg is as lovely as ever, even if she, like the material, can come off as too mannered at times. Technical merits are strong, and with caveats noted, "In the French Style" comes Recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Contrast is generally consistent and strong, as are sharpness and clarity, though there are occasional variances, most notably in some location work, especially in some early going with Seberg and Forquet...
Audio: 80
Some of the urban environments occasionally offer a busier sound design, but this is a fairly quiet film overall, and while there's not a lot to "write home about" here, fidelity is fine, and prioritization...
Extras: 40
Audio Commentary features Lem Dobbs hosted by Twilight Time's Julie Kirgo and Nick Redman....
Movie: 60
One gets the feeling that Shaw and Parrish might have hoped that that segmented approach would in and of itself provide a kind of disjunctive quality that was at least somewhat similar to Breathless, but...
Total: 60
There's a pretentious quality to In the French Style that is pretty unmistakable, but that doesn't mean the film is pure drivel....
The Digital Bits review by Jim HemphillRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 95
Extras: 95
Movie: 90
There’s not much plot to speak of, and the movie is oddly bifurcated thanks to Shaw’s decision to jam two of his (unrelated) stories together: the first half mostly focuses on Seberg’s romance with a teenage...
Total: 94
It and every other facet of the film is expertly analyzed by film historians Lem Dobbs, Julie Kirgo, and Nick Redman on a superb audio commentary featured on this Twilight Time disc; as usual, the label’s...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
The film's black levels and grey scale are in great shape giving the film a deep and inky appearance without any crush or contrast bloom issues....
Audio: 100
The track is very well balanced even for a mono presentation as scenes have a notable sense of space and dimensionality to them ensuring the characters sound as though they're occupying real rooms and...
Extras: 20
They have an appreciation for the film, but they often struggle with finding positive things to say about it as the final act kicks in....
Movie: 60
But when the possibility of a relationship is suddenly cut short, Christina is left to chart her own course in a city that is new to her with few people to call friends....
Total: 80
Considering this film was made in the 1960s, its frankness towards the affairs of a young woman in Paris is appreciable but its clunky second and third acts don't help to make a cohesive and dramatic story....
Director: Robert Parrish
Actors: Jean Seberg, Stanley Baker, Philippe Forquet
PlotAn American artist named Christina James moves to Paris aspiring to immerse herself in the bohemian lifestyle and pursue her painting career. Enthralled by the city's allure, she finds herself engaged in a series of romantic entanglements. Each relationship reflects different facets of her desires and identity, from the suave and enigmatic journalist, Guy, to the youthful and passionate French student, Vincent. These experiences offer her not just love but also an education in the complexities of independence and self-discovery.
As Christina navigates through her love affairs, friendships, and artistic challenges in Paris, she continuously grapples with the contrasting expectations of her free-spirited ambitions and the societal norms imposed upon her. Her journey is both a pursuit of artistic fulfillment and an exploration of personal freedom, leading her to confront the realities of her choices and their implications. With each passing day, Christina's experiences shape her understanding of love, art, and identity in a city that promises both inspiration and disillusionment.
Writers: Irwin Shaw
Release Date: 25 Mar 1964
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: N/A
Country: France, United States
Language: English, French