The Silent Partner Blu-ray Review
Score: 72
from 1 reviewers
Review Date:
The Silent Partner, underappreciated with superb Gould & script, gets a Kino Lorber nod. Must-see.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 60
Daryl Duke's The Silent Partner on Blu-ray from Kino Lorber features a 1.85:1, 1080p MPEG-4 AVC transfer with dated visuals, decent depth, and clarity, yet room for improvement in saturation and nuances. Region-A locked, rated 3.25/5.
Audio: 80
This Blu-ray features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track with optional English SDH subtitles, offering clear, deep sound quality free from age-related distortions, though light 'thinning' suggests potential for minor rebalancing.
Extra: 76
Elliott Gould reflects on 'The Silent Partner,' discussing its creation, unique aspects, and Oscar Peterson's soundtrack in an insightful interview. Plus, a commentary explores the film's context and Gould's image, alongside vintage trailers and a radio spot. All for Kino Lorber releases.
Movie: 76
Daryl Duke's The Silent Partner, featuring a versatile Elliott Gould, shines in a new Blu-ray release from Kino Lorber with special features and a gripping tale of a heist that turns life around, underscored by Oscar Peterson's jazz.
Video: 60
In a meticulous 1080p transfer, "The Silent Partner" is presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1, utilizing an MPEG-4 AVC encode, thanks to Kino Lorber's diligent efforts. The onset reveals a transfer that, while respectful of its source material, exhibits marks of age or perhaps the method in which the master was prepared, leading to some early fluctuations in quality. This suggests possible reconstructive efforts or simply the utilization of less-than-optimal original elements. Despite these minor setbacks, the transfer achieves a commendable level of depth and clarity, avoiding the pitfalls of aggressive digital enhancements often seen in other studios' releases.
The visuals, though presenting a consistent density across scenes, occasionally succumb to a mild flatness—a hallmark of mastering with older equipment. In darker sequences, this manifests as a noise in the grain structure, although this does not detract significantly from the overall viewing experience. The color representation, while good, hints at potential areas for improvement in saturation and balance, betraying limitations particularly noticeable in highlights that appear somewhat dated. Nevertheless, image stability remains solid throughout, free from major damage or disruptions aside from the occasional speck.
Technical drawbacks notwithstanding, Kino Lorber's release ensures that "The Silent Partner" is seen with decent to good depth and pleasing clarity. While certain aspects of the transfer hint at the age or methodology behind the master used, the absence of severe digital alterations allows for an authentic viewing experience. The color scheme, despite its constraints, contributes to the film's period charm. This Region-A locked Blu-ray may have its imperfections, yet it serves as a testament to the care taken in bringing this cinematic piece to home audiences with fidelity to its original presentation.
Audio: 80
The audio presentation for "The Silent Partner" on Blu-ray is served through an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track. This choice reflects a balance between preserving the original sound design and offering clarity that meets contemporary expectations. Accompanying the audio track, the release includes optional English SDH subtitles, ensuring accessibility for all viewers seeking to immerse themselves in the cinematic experience without barriers.
Upon evaluation, the audio's clarity and depth shine, particularly in their adherence to expected standards for a release of this nature. The preservation effort is commendable, with the mid to upper registers maintaining a crispness and freedom from age-related imperfections, such as distortions or background hums, indicative of careful remastering. However, it’s worth noting a slight 'thinning' in some portions of the audio, hinting at potential areas where rebalancing could further refine the listening experience. This minor critique aside, it's apparent that any such nuances remain largely faithful to the film’s original sound design ethos.
While the overall presentation does not show signs of significant aural deterioration or neglect, the narrow scope for improvement in sound rebalancing should not go unmentioned. These spots of 'thinning'—albeit infrequent and modest—suggest that there might be untapped potential in further elevating the audio's dynamic range and immersion factor. Despite this, the track admirably serves its purpose, ensuring that "The Silent Partner" continues to be experienced with an audio quality that both honors its historical context and meets modern standards of sound presentation.
Extras: 76
The Blu Ray extras for "The Silent Partner" offer a rich array of content that enhances the viewer's understanding and appreciation of the film. The standout is undoubtedly the exclusive interview with Elliott Gould, where he shares fascinating insights into the making of the film, its casting alternatives, and its musical score, among other topics. This interview alone makes the disc a valuable addition to any cinephile's collection. Complementing this are an insightful new audio commentary by critics Howard S. Berger, Steve Mitchell, and Nathaniel Thompson, who dive deep into the film's context, Gould's star power during the '70s, and the script's exceptional quality. Additionally, the vintage trailer and radio spot offer a nostalgic look back at the film's original promotional efforts, while the inclusion of trailers for other Kino Lorber releases rounds off the package beautifully, providing viewers with a glimpse into further cinematic treasures. The technical presentation of these extras, from the clarity of the 1080p interview to the vintage charm of the 480/60i trailer, ensures a satisfying viewing experience that respects both the source material and the audience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interview with Elliott Gould: Gould discusses the creation of The Silent Partner, casting choices, filming in Canada, his character's uniqueness, Oscar Peterson's soundtrack, and reflects on his career.
- Commentary: Critics Howard S. Berger, Steve Mitchell, and Nathaniel Thompson provide a nuanced analysis of The Silent Partner's place in cinema history and its script's craftsmanship.
- Trailer: A vintage trailer for The Silent Partner.
- Radio Spot: A vintage radio spot for The Silent Partner.
- Trailers: Collection of trailers for other Kino Lorber catalog releases.
Movie: 76
Daryl Duke's 1978 cinematic jewel, "The Silent Partner," has been meticulously remastered and presented on Blu-ray by Kino Lorber, offering a remarkable glimpse into the film's technical and thematic intricacies, alongside a sterling performance by Elliott Gould. This release is imbued with an array of supplementary features, including an enlightening new interview with Gould, an insightful audio commentary from esteemed critics, and the original vintage trailer. The film itself, encoded with optional English SDH subtitles and region-A locked, maintains its visual and auditory fidelity, ensuring a pristine viewing experience.
"The Silent Partner" is underpinned by Gould’s versatile portrayal of Miles Cullen, a bank teller ensnared in the drudgery of his everyday life until a foiled robbery attempt offers him an avenue to reshuffle his destiny. Gould, who shifts between a meek bank employee and a cunning strategist with ease, navigates through this metamorphosis with such authenticity that it elevates the film's premise beyond its scriptural demands. The narrative unfolds with Cullen outsmarting a bank robber dressed as Santa Claus (Christopher Plummer), igniting a cat-and-mouse game filled with psychological intrigue and moral ambiguity. This engaging plot is further enhanced by the film's ability to juxtapose 'logical' solutions against the backdrop of everyday frustrations, offering viewers a mirror to reexamine their own choices and aspirations.
Musically accentuated by Oscar Peterson’s jazz compositions, and helmed by Duke's directorial finesse – a role Curtis Hanson had initially sought – the film's ambiance is one of its standout features. Its soundtrack, released on LP, further immortalizes the film's mood and tone. "The Silent Partner" not only showcases Gould’s arguably finest performance, as lauded by Spielberg, but also serves as a testament to the creative prowess of its cast and crew. Through Kino Lorber's Blu-ray presentation, the blend of superb acting, astute direction, and compelling narrative intricacies are given new life, engaging contemporary audiences with its undiminished charm and suspense.
Total: 72
"The Silent Partner," reissued on Blu Ray by Kino Lorber, stands as a stark underappreciated gem within Elliott Gould's rich filmography. Boasting a performance that arguably surpasses his acclaimed role in "The Long Goodbye," Gould shines brightly in this tight, intriguing script penned by Curtis Hanson. The film delves deep into the psychological cat-and-mouse dynamics between a crafty bank teller and a menacing robber, expertly weaving complex themes of risk, morality, and the lengths to which ordinary people might go when tempted with life-altering opportunities. This solid foundation is further enhanced by the Blu Ray's adept handling of the source material, presenting a commendable master that does justice to the film's nuanced storytelling and crisp cinematography.
Kino Lorber's release not only breathes new life into this overlooked classic through its technical merits but also adds invaluable context with an exclusive new interview with Elliott Gould. This special feature alone is worth the price of admission, offering deep insights into Gould's method and mindset during filming, alongside retrospective appreciations that fans and new viewers alike will find enriching. It's a thoughtful addition that elevates the total package, ensuring that this Blu Ray isn't just a mere release but a comprehensive celebration of the film's legacy.
In conclusion, "The Silent Partner" Blu Ray release is a must-have for aficionados of cinema and collectors alike. Its compelling story, spearheaded by Gould's standout performance and enriched by Hanson's script, makes for an arresting watch. Meanwhile, the quality of the transfer and the inclusion of engaging extras like Gould's interview solidify its status as a highly recommended purchase. Whether you're revisiting this classic or discovering it for the first time, this edition serves as a definitive version that respects its source material while offering fresh insights into its production and enduring appeal.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 70
The color scheme is good, but I think that saturation, balance, and especially the current ranges of nuances can be improved rather substantially....
Audio: 90
I think that there is some room for rebalancing work that could potentially eliminate some very light 'thinning' that pops up, but the majority of it this is likely part of the original sound design....
Extras: 80
Interview with Elliott Gould - in this new video interview, Elliott Gould recalls how The Silent Partner came to exist and some of the alternative options that were considered for key characters, and discusses...
Movie: 80
There is an old rumor that Curtis Hanson, who delivered the script, was interested in directing as well, but after a quick round of negotiations the producers apparently turned down his offer....
Total: 80
Kino Lorber's release is sourced from a decent master and has an outstanding exclusive new interview with Gould that I think makes it unmissable....
Director: Daryl Duke, Curtis Hanson
Actors: Elliott Gould, Christopher Plummer, Susannah York
PlotIn the bustling atmosphere of a Toronto bank just before Christmas, mild-mannered teller Miles Cullen discovers a robbery plan through a forgotten note left by the would-be thief. Observing the peculiar behavior and disguise of the potential robber, who frequents the mall where the bank is located, Cullen cleverly devises a scheme to outwit the criminal. He decides to use the impending robbery as an opportunity to skim a substantial amount of money for himself, believing his perfect crime will go unnoticed amidst the chaos of the actual heist. However, Cullen's life takes a sharp turn as his actions inadvertently place him on a collision path with the criminal, a dangerous and unpredictable man.
As the day of the robbery unfolds, Cullen executes his plan with precision, securing the stolen funds under the guise of being another victim of the heist. Initially, he revels in his success, envisioning a life far removed from his mundane existence. Yet, the aftermath of the crime propels both men into a deadly game of cat and mouse. The robber, realizing he's been outsmarted and robbed of his take, embarks on a relentless quest for retribution. The initially quiet and unassuming Cullen is forced to navigate the perilous consequences of his actions, as the boundaries between the hunter and the hunted blur, leading him into a world of violence and deception far beyond his mundane bank teller existence.
Writers: Curtis Hanson, Anders Bodelsen
Release Date: 16 Mar 1979
Runtime: 106 min
Rating: R
Country: Canada
Language: English, Latin