Grace Stirs Up Success Blu-ray Review
Score: 48
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Solid audio and video presentation can't save 'Grace Stirs Up Success' from a lackluster plot; best for die-hard 'American Girl' fans only.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 51
An American Girl: Grace Stirs Up Success offers a largely satisfying 1080p transfer, with crisply defined details and bold, though occasionally overly saturated, colors. While the digital nature can render wider shots somewhat flat and introduce moderate noise and minor banding, overall image quality impresses in its detailing.
Audio: 61
An American Girl: Grace Stirs Up Success delivers a high quality DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track with crisp, well-defined clarity, strong low-end support, and effective ambient sound detailing key locations. Despite deplorable song content, the track ensures clear dialogue and a lively auditory experience.
Extra: 26
The Blu-ray extras of 'Grace Stirs Up Success' feature brief, high-definition segments like 'Girls About Town', 'Meet Bonbon', and 'MasterChef Junior', alongside standard inclusions such as trailers and a digital copy voucher, providing a snapshot into the making of the film and its charming atmosphere.
Movie: 36
"Grace Stirs Up Success" is a sugary, unrealistic fairy tale that prioritizes feel-good messages and vibrant visuals over genuine authenticity, making it enjoyable for young audiences but disconnected from real-life challenges, despite solid themes of determination and personal touch.
Video: 51
The Blu Ray presentation of "An American Girl: Grace Stirs Up Success" features a largely satisfying 1080p transfer, though not without its flaws. The image provides crisply defined details that highlight elements like baked treats, fabric textures, and the architectural charm of Parisian streets. The strong digital sharpness allows viewers to notice everything from minor imperfections in the baked goods to makeup blemishes on the actors' faces. However, the picture occasionally lacks depth in wider shots, appearing somewhat flat due to its digital nature.
The color palette is bold and vivid, often to an overpowering extent. Reds, along with greens, blues, and lavenders, stand out the most and are sometimes excessively saturated. The attempt to make the film more engaging for younger audiences through heightened color saturation is apparent, though it compromises the realism of the visuals. Skin tones skew slightly warm, and while black levels are predominantly deep and inky, they can appear lighter in some scenes. The video does exhibit moderately heavy noise, along with some minor banding and aliasing, detracting from the overall clarity.
Overall, while "Grace Stirs Up Success" offers a visually engaging experience with detailed textures and vibrant colors, the overly digital look, coupled with noticeable video noise and occasional flatness in depth, may leave some viewers wishing for a more polished transfer. Nonetheless, the presentation serves its purpose well for younger audiences and casual viewing.
Audio: 61
Universal's Blu-ray release of "An American Girl: Grace Stirs Up Success" features a top-notch DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless track, reflecting the studio's commitment to high-quality audio presentation. The soundtrack stands out with crisp and well-defined music, integrating both airy scores and high-energy Pop-Rock anthems seamlessly. It features excellent clarity, natural aggression, and a robust low-end support that enhances the overall audio experience. This mix includes well-pronounced effects and ambient sounds, particularly highlighted by the cacophony of appliances in the grandparents' bakery and external auditory cues that transport viewers to key locations like New England, Paris, and a reality TV show stage. However, it should be noted that a few dialogue lines towards the end tend to go soft, albeit without significantly disrupting the overall audibility.
Sound effects in this release are lively and dynamic, effectively utilizing all channels to produce an immersive audio environment. Cooking and kitchen sounds, along with city ambience, are articulated with precision and make full use of the rear speakers. Despite personal opinions about the musical choices within the film, these songs are reproduced with a full, well-balanced sound that is both engaging and satisfying to listeners. Bass frequencies deliver a solid rumble, contributing to the mix's depth. Crucially, dialogue remains crystal clear and easy to follow throughout the film, even when layered with thick French accents. There are no undesirable audio artifacts such as pops, cracks, hiss, or shrill tones, ensuring a smooth auditory experience despite the often high-pitched dialogue and sound effects. Universal has indeed crafted a commendable audio mix for this release.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray release of "Grace Stirs Up Success" offers an array of charming and light-hearted extras that provide viewers with a delightful behind-the-scenes glimpse into the production. These supplementary materials add value to the viewing experience, especially for fans of the "American Girl" series. Each segment is presented in high definition, ensuring clarity and quality. Highlights include a tour of Budapest in "Girls About Town," an introduction to the film's furry star in "Meet Bonbon," and insights into on-set baking activities in "Masterchef Junior." The collection also includes previews for other titles in the franchise. Overall, these extras, while brief, add an enjoyable touch to the disc.
Extras included in this disc:
- Girls About Town: The girls visit Budapest and share trivia about the city.
- Meet Bonbon: A look at the film's star dog.
- Masterchef Junior: Behind the scenes of baking on set.
- Doggie Day Spa: Girls bathe dogs for a day.
- Playing Dress Up: Girls appearing in various costumes.
- Previews: Trailers for other American Girl movies.
Movie: 36
"Grace Stirs Up Success," the latest installment from the American Girl series, aims to inspire young girls with themes of determination, hard work, and selflessness. However, the film's saccharine delivery and overly idealistic depiction of life's challenges somewhat diminish the impact of its positive messaging. The narrative focuses on Grace (Olivia Rodrigo), an enthusiastic young baker who initially spends her time in her grandparents’ quaint New England bakery, before a family trip to Paris introduces her to a whole new realm of culinary adventures. The vibrant colors and sugary Pop songs do little to mask the unrealistic escapism that permeates the movie, which often feels more like a modern storybook fantasy than a reflection of real-world challenges.
Grace's journey, filled with conveniently resolved conflicts and unwavering familial support, pushes the boundaries of believability. When she opens her bake shop to earn money for a new bike, her initial entrepreneurial success is overshadowed by an even grander adventure in Paris. There, she endeavors to help her uncle's struggling bakery, leveraging her newfound skills to transform his business. Despite its attempt to teach valuable life lessons, the film's predictable plot and excessively cheerful resolution present an overly simplified perspective. Reality TV show segments, meant to add excitement, only further detach the narrative from any semblance of authenticity.
The central theme, encapsulated by the phrase "je ne sais quoi," metaphorically aligns life with baking—suggesting that a personal touch and a bit of risk are essential ingredients for success. Though this is solid advice, it feels forced within the movie's polished veneer. While young audiences may find enjoyment in the film’s cheerful atmosphere and catchy songs, older viewers might notice its disingenuous tone. "Grace Stirs Up Success" ultimately provides feel-good entertainment but fails to encapsulate the complexities of achieving success outside its rose-colored lens. The film maintains its charm with delightful visuals and delectable treats, yet leaves a taste of unreality lingering.
Total: 48
"Grace Stirs Up Success," a charming entry in the American Girl series, aims to delight its target audience—young girls who are fans of the cherished doll line. The film centers on Grace, a relatable and spirited protagonist, navigating her adventures with optimism and determination. While the narrative doesn't offer a nuanced depiction of reality, its heartwarming message about perseverance and creativity is clear, if somewhat idealized.
The Blu-ray release by Universal provides a competent audiovisual experience. The video presentation captures the colorful and vibrant world through which Grace navigates, albeit without reaching the highest levels of visual fidelity. On the other hand, the audio quality stands out, delivering a well-balanced soundscape that enhances the overall viewing experience. The included extras—though brief—add some additional appeal for the younger audience, fitting seamlessly with the main feature's tone and theme.
In conclusion, "An American Girl: Grace Stirs Up Success" may not resonate with an older or broader audience, but it succeeds in delivering a pleasant and uplifting experience for its intended viewers. Its idyllic representation of challenges and their resolutions offers a comforting escape. For families with young enthusiasts of the American Girl franchise, this Blu-ray release is worth a look. Otherwise, it may be best to pass on this one.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
Whether baked treats, intimate facial features, fine fabric textures, or good-looking bits of charmingly rough brick and concrete accents around Paris, the transfer impresses across the board when it comes...
Audio: 70
anthems, Universal's lossless soundtrack enjoys a crisp, well defined edge, excellent clarity, natural aggression, fine spacing, and a quality low end support....
Extras: 30
Girls About Town (1080p, 3:19): The girls visit Budapest and the piece offers a few trivia morsels about the European city....
Movie: 40
While that unrealistic perfection that defines the entire movie -- where various crises are solved, personal problems are averted, lessons are learned, and everything is made right by only a trip to Paris,...
Total: 50
The target audience probably won't care or notice, but it might be good to follow the movie up with a discussion that life isn't a perfect walk in the park, that its obstacles aren't always barely noticeable...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Skin tones are somewhat natural, but look hindered, and the black levels are mostly deep an inky, if not on the light side of things....
Audio: 80
The songs featured in the film might be down right deplorable and make you question these musicians lot in life, but they sound very good over the speakers, delivering a very full and well-balanced sound....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 0
Instead, it's a fairy tale type of situation, where nothing bad ever happens, and these young girls who are watching these movies would believe that everything will come true and be as easy as following...
Total: 40
If you have someone who is a die hard fan of the 'American Girl' doll line, then they'll probably enjoy this, otherwise, feel free to skip this one all together....
Director: Vince Marcello
Actors: Olivia Rodrigo, Virginia Madsen, Eloise Webb
PlotGrace is a young girl with a passion for baking, inspired by her grandparents who own a bakery. When her mother announces that the family will be traveling to Paris for the summer to help Grace's aunt, who recently had a baby, Grace is initially upset about leaving her friends and the bakery behind. However, her interest is piqued when she learns her aunt runs a French pastry shop. In Paris, Grace becomes captivated by the culinary world and spends her time learning new baking techniques. Her confidence grows as she masters French recipes and discovers a newfound love for the craft.
Upon returning home, Grace is faced with the news that her grandparents' bakery is struggling financially. Determined to save it, she teams up with her friends to combine what she's learned in Paris with their own creativity. They come up with innovative ideas to revamp the bakery, drawing in new customers and reigniting the local community’s interest. Through hard work, collaboration, and a sprinkle of entrepreneurial spirit, Grace and her friends strive to save the bakery and make their culinary dreams come true.
Writers: Jessica O'Toole, Amy Rardin
Release Date: 09 Jun 2015
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United States
Language: English