Cameraman: The Life and Work of Jack Cardiff Blu-ray Review
Score: 47
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Cameraman is a sublime education on Jack Cardiff's masterful work, showcasing his humor, craftsmanship, and the enduring beauty of his cinematography despite the digital era.
Disc Release Date
Video: 47
The Blu-ray of 'Cameraman: The Life and Work of Jack Cardiff' offers a 1080p/AVC MPEG-2 (1.78:1 aspect ratio) presentation with a mix of film and video sources. The color reproduction is lush, especially during Technicolor clips, yet the image quality varies with minor print damage, crush issues, and some upscaled artifacts. Despite inconsistencies, it remains engaging and highlights Cardiff's excellence.
Audio: 37
With an English Dolby Digital 5.1 and 2.0 mix, the audio presentation of 'Cameraman' maintains clear dialogue and clean interview audio but suffers from minimal surround effects and occasional distortion in archival footage. Despite its front-heavy and basic design, the soundtrack handles balance well with delicate background scoring.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray extras for 'Cameraman: The Life and Work of Jack Cardiff' offer a rich and informative assortment of interviews, behind-the-scenes footage, and technical insights, highlighting Cardiff's contributions to cinema with high-definition clarity and Dolby Digital 2.0 sound, underscoring the documentary's extensive production journey and Cardiff's innovative mastery.
Movie: 81
A thoroughly engaging documentary that paints an illuminating portrait of Jack Cardiff’s contributions to cinema, tracing his pioneering Technicolor work and fascinating collaborations with legendary directors and actors, yet occasionally missing deeper insights into the man behind the camera.
Video: 47
The Blu-ray presentation of "Cameraman: The Life and Work of Jack Cardiff" offers an engaging visual experience in 1080p with an MPEG-2 encoding. Presented in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio, this documentary is a blend of various film and video sources, capturing the nuances of Cardiff's illustrious career. While the primary documentary footage displays minor print damage and some visible banding, the lush and vibrant color palette remains a highlight, with stable hues showcasing the power of Technicolor. Skintones during interviews appear natural, enhancing the realism and intimacy of these moments. Meanwhile, the video footage occasionally exhibits jagged edges, but these interludes are brief and do not detract significantly from the overall visual experience.
The image quality varies throughout the documentary due to the diverse range of source materials. Interview footage, which appears to come from both film and digital mediums, maintains clarity despite some fine grain and occasional specks on the film material. Professional studio setups for several interviews feature impressive lighting, adding production value and visual appeal. Clips from Cardiff's movies are mixed, with some standard definition masters displaying noticeable artifacts like edge enhancement, while others such as 'The African Queen,' 'The Red Shoes,' and 'Black Narcissus' are sourced from high-definition masters, boasting excellent saturation and clarity. This inconsistency in visual quality is expected given the variety of mediums used, yet it manages to be consistently watchable and frequently enjoyable. Despite some upconverted footage not meeting high standards, Cardiff's remarkable work shines through in every condition.
Overall, colors, contrast, and black levels are largely dependent on source material and shooting conditions, resulting in variations from good to slightly washed out or overexposed. While not perfect, the HD presentation faithfully illuminates Jack Cardiff's contributions to cinema, making it a compelling watch for enthusiasts of his work.
Audio: 37
The Blu-ray audio presentation for "Cameraman: The Life and Work of Jack Cardiff" employs a 5.1 Dolby Digital sound mix, which aligns with the standard expectations for documentaries. The mix operates with a strong frontal presence, ensuring dialogue from interviews is consistently clear and intelligible, effectively accommodating a range of accents and speech patterns. Although the design is straightforward, it successfully balances interviews with musical scoring that subtly utilizes the surround channels without disrupting the viewer's focus on the conversations. Low-frequency effects are minimal, fitting the documentary's nature.
Archive film and television clips present the primary audio challenge, as they often exhibit a slightly distorted quality in contrast to the relative clarity of the interview segments. The English Dolby Digital 5.1 track remains front-heavy and direct but maintains balance across all audio elements. Music enjoys good separation, though directional effects are generally sparse, aside from occasional audience reactions which briefly activate the rear channels.
Dynamic range is decent, maintaining clear frequencies with no significant distortion. While the bass remains subdued, this is appropriate for the content. The audio quality varies somewhat based on source material but is handled competently overall. Despite not being immersive or offering lossless fidelity, the score maintains pleasant fidelity, and interview audio is notably pristine. The overall balance ensures a well-coordinated blend of interviews, film clips, and archival content.
Extras: 46
The Extras on the Blu-ray for "Cameraman: The Life and Work of Jack Cardiff" offer a well-rounded and insightful extension to the documentary, providing a deeper dive into various facets of Cardiff's illustrious career. Each featurette is presented in 1080p with Dolby Digital 2.0 sound, ensuring a high-quality viewing experience. The highlights include a comprehensive interview with director Craig McCall, explaining the arduous 13-year production journey and his deep admiration for Cardiff. Other notable inclusions are Cardiff’s personal behind-the-scenes footage from classic films like "The African Queen" and insightful interviews with industry titans discussing the cinematographer-director relationship. Technically detailed segments such as “Working with Three-Strip Technicolor” offer a fascinating look at the technical challenges Cardiff faced.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interview with Craig McCall by Ian Christie: In-depth discussion on the documentary's origins and production.
- Jack's Actress Portraits: Extended insights into Cardiff's private collection of leading lady portraits.
- Jack's Behind-the Scenes Movies: Commentary on Cardiff's private on-location footage.
- Cinematographer and Director Relationship: Industry interviews exploring key professional dynamics.
- Working with Three-Strip Technicolor: Recollections on technical challenges and creative exploits.
- Photo Galleries: Collections of actress portraits and behind-the-scenes stills.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer of the documentary.
Movie: 81
“Cameraman: The Life & Work of Jack Cardiff” delves into the illustrious career of a legend whose artistry behind the camera transformed cinema. The documentary, directed by Craig McCall, offers a meticulous exploration of Cardiff’s expansive filmography, which spans over six decades. Beginning his career as a child actor before transitioning to cinematography, Cardiff’s work with Technicolor and on classics such as “A Matter of Life and Death,” “Black Narcissus,” and “The Red Shoes” is highlighted with extensive clips and detailed analysis. His collaborations with iconic directors like Alfred Hitchcock and John Huston are also showcased, illustrating his invaluable contributions to their cinematic masterpieces.
Cardiff’s personal reflections are the heart of the documentary, as he shares anecdotes and behind-the-scenes stories about working with legendary figures like John Wayne, Marilyn Monroe, and Orson Welles. His deep understanding of lighting and color composition not only advanced Technicolor photography but also immortalized countless scenes in film history. The inclusion of interviews with prominent industry figures such as Martin Scorsese and Lauren Bacall further enriches the narrative, exhibiting an affection and respect for Cardiff’s enduring influence and genial persona.
While “Cameraman” provides an enriching overview of Cardiff’s professional life, it occasionally diverges too deeply into the achievements of his collaborators, slightly detracting from Cardiff’s own narrative. Despite this, the documentary excels in presenting a vibrant, albeit surface-level, examination of his legacy. The extensive use of film excerpts, coupled with Cardiff's insightful commentary and rare behind-the-scenes footage, offers an engaging tribute to a cinematographer whose work forever shaped the visual landscape of cinema.
Total: 47
"Cameraman: The Life and Work of Jack Cardiff" is an engaging and insightful documentary that captures the essence of one of cinema's most talented cinematographers. The Blu-ray release does justice to Cardiff’s illustrious career, offering an array of interviews and archival footage that provide a comprehensive look into his significant contributions to film. This documentary effectively highlights Cardiff’s humor and unwavering dedication to blending fine arts with cinematic visuals, resulting in some of the most iconic images in movie history. Despite occasional variations in audio and video quality due to the diverse sources of the footage, the overall presentation remains compelling.
Jack Cardiff's involvement in films ranging from "Ghost Story" to "Rambo: First Blood Part II" showcases his versatility and continuous innovation throughout his career. The documentary not only celebrates Cardiff’s achievements but also thoughtfully addresses the shift from practical techniques to digital methods in filmmaking. This narrative subtly expresses a melancholy for the lost artistry of traditional film methods while acknowledging Cardiff's openness to new cinematic frontiers. Although the supplementary material on this Blu-ray is somewhat brief, it adds value by providing additional context and insight, making it a worthwhile inclusion for enthusiasts of classic cinema.
In conclusion, Jack Cardiff continued to work almost to the year of his death, shooting such varied pictures as "Ghost Story" and "Rambo: First Blood Part II" along the way. Cameraman presents Cardiff as a man who never abandoned his sense of humor or his faith in beauty, mixing love for the fine arts into his cinematic achievements, creating iconic images as he carried on. While a celebration of the man and his silver screen miracles, Cameraman ends on a slightly solemn note, expressing sadness that these practical techniques have been lost to the digital revolution, losing the handcrafted appeal of film to point-and-click post-production math. It's a harsh reality, but one Cardiff takes in stride, refusing to give in to nostalgia, eager to explore the new frontier of moviemaking. His story ends in 2009, but his achievements live on, with Cameraman a sublime education on the masterful work of Jack Cardiff.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 70
Color is key here, and the HD presentation doesn't hold back when it comes to providing a lush, stable range of hues, highlighting nuclear red and blues to reinforce the power of Technicolor....
Audio: 50
The 5.1 Dolby Digital sound mix holds to the documentary standard, with a sturdy frontal presence for interviews and reflections, delivering clarity on a wide range of accents and speech impediments....
Extras: 80
Interview with Craig McCall by Ian Christie (12:52, HD): This conversation between the director of "Cameraman" and film scholar Christie covers the origin of the documentary and how various interview participants...
Movie: 90
Growing from a camera operator (on pictures such as 1937's "Wings of the Morning") to a cinematographer, Cardiff rapidly found his footing as a master of light and color, working his way through the industry...
Total: 70
While a celebration of the man and his silver screen miracles, "Cameraman" ends on a slightly solemn note, expressing sadness that these practical techniques have been lost to the digital revolution, losing...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Overall colors, contrast, and black levels are all dependent on the source of the footage and shooting conditions of the interviews being showcased, varying from good to a little washed out or overexposed....
Audio: 60
While front heavy, lossy, and not terribly immersive, there is some nice fidelity in the score and all of the interview material comes through cleanly....
Extras: 20
Photo Galleries - Separate photo galleries are included for Actress Photos and Production Stills, featuring Cardiff's actress portraits and some behind-the-scenes stills from the making of the doc and...
Movie: 80
The documentary starts off with archive footage of actor Dustin Hoffman bestowing Cardiff with an honorary Academy Award, and from here the film cuts between various talking head interviews, stills, film...
Total: 60
Video and audio quality varies depending on the source of the footage and recordings, but the majority of the material looks and sounds just fine....
Director: Craig McCall
Actors: Jack Cardiff, Martin Scorsese, Kirk Douglas
PlotThe film meticulously explores the illustrious career of a celebrated cinematographer, detailing his influence on classic cinema through personal anecdotes and interviews with industry icons. From his early beginnings in British cinema to groundbreaking work with directors like Michael Powell, the narrative highlights his innovative use of Technicolor and his profound impact on visual storytelling. Through rare behind-the-scenes footage, viewers gain insight into his artistic process and the creative decisions that shaped such iconic films as "The Red Shoes" and "Black Narcissus."
The documentary also delves into the relationships he built with legendary actors and directors, showcasing the mutual respect and admiration that defined these collaborations. Significant segments of the film are dedicated to his work with Hollywood legends and his ability to bring out their best performances through his mastery of light and color. The exploration of his later years and the legacy he leaves behind in cinema provides a touching conclusion, celebrating a life dedicated to the art of filmmaking.
Writers: N/A
Release Date: 13 May 2011
Runtime: 86 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English