The Golden Lotus Blu-ray Review
Jin ping shuang yan Gam ping seung yim 金瓶雙艷
Score: 61
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Though not a masterpiece, The Golden Lotus offers sumptuous visuals and historical value with an early Jackie Chan appearance; recommended for the curious.
Disc Release Date
Video: 81
The Golden Lotus on Blu-ray by 88 Films impresses with a vibrant 1080p AVC encoded transfer in 2.41:1, sourced from the original negatives. The presentation boasts excellent detail and striking primaries, despite occasional anamorphic squeezing and grain variation. This is one of the finest Shaw Brothers transfers to date.
Audio: 76
The Blu Ray of 'The Golden Lotus' offers a 2.0 LPCM Mono track in original Mandarin, delivering clear dialogue and ambient sounds despite some high-end thinness during music. While musical fidelity is slightly uneven, it remains largely effective. Optional English subtitles enhance accessibility.
Extra: 2
The Blu-ray release of "The Golden Lotus" is light on extras, focusing on its salacious trailer and brief stills gallery, complemented by a limited edition slipcover, reversible sleeve with original artwork, and four art cards that enhance the packaging.
Movie: 61
The Golden Lotus, a Shaw Brothers production diverging from their martial arts norm, delivers an engaging yet explicit adaptation of a 16th-century Chinese novel, weaving a tale of infidelity, murder, and power dynamics, with Jackie Chan contributing minor comedic relief in this period drama marked by its nuanced storytelling and authentic performances.
Video: 81
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Golden Lotus" by 88 Films offers an impressively robust HD transfer from the original camera negative, encoded in AVC 1080p with a 2.41:1 aspect ratio. This edition stands out within the Shaw Brothers catalogue, showcasing a vibrant palette that remains consistent even during optical transitions like dissolves. Primaries are notably striking, contributing to the overall lively and healthy color portrayal throughout the film. Detail levels maintain a high standard, offering precise textures on costumes and set designs. While there are occasional issues with anamorphic squeezing near the frame edges, the video maintains its organic look without compression artifacts.
The 2.35:1 presentation delivers sharp definition with excellent clarity, offering a strong film-like experience for viewers. Flesh tones appear warm and natural, complemented by a lovely contrast that emphasizes the rich costume designs. The transfer exhibits superb detail preservation, supported by an effective AVC encode that captures complex textures and unfiltered detail across the film’s 116-minute runtime on a BD-50 disc. The meticulous care in processing is evident as film elements appear flawless, with no noticeable damage throughout the viewing experience.
This Blu-ray release is exemplary of 88 Films’ expertise and dedication to preserving Asian cinema in high quality, providing a vivid and immersive viewing experience. The combination of sharp definition, rich colors, and admirable attention to detail ensures that "The Golden Lotus" is presented with exceptional visual integrity, making it a standout entry among Shaw Brothers' releases on Blu-ray.
Audio: 76
"The Golden Lotus" Blu-ray presents an LPCM 2.0 Mono audio track in the original Mandarin, offering an audio experience that holds true to its era while maintaining a professional execution. The monaural sound exhibits a somewhat thin quality on the high end, most prominently during musical segments such as the recognizable Shaw Brothers masthead theme. Despite these minor limitations, the audio track ensures a secure and robust reproduction of ambient environmental sounds and dialogue, effectively engaging the listener with its vintage charm.
The sound design showcases commendable fidelity, particularly considering the film's age. Dialogue is rendered with precision and clarity, supporting the narrative without distraction. Subtle signs of wear appear occasionally in the musical score, though these instances hardly detract from the overall auditory experience. Moments of musical fidelity are slightly uneven, yet the track manages to remain largely cohesive and immersive. Furthermore, optional English subtitles in a white font enhance accessibility without imposing on the visual presentation.
In summary, while "The Golden Lotus" may exhibit some expected limitations inherent to its monaural origins, it delivers a satisfying auditory experience. The balance between dialogue and environmental sounds is handled with care, providing listeners an authentic and engaging glimpse into its cinematic atmosphere.
Extras: 2
The Blu Ray release of "The Golden Lotus" provides a modest selection of extras with a focus on visual content rather than in-depth analytical features. Notably absent is an expected commentary by familiar experts such as Frank Djeng, which might have enriched the viewing experience with context and insights. The trailer included with this release stands out for its bold and provocative presentation, showcasing the film as a prestigious production, albeit with more emphasis on sensational elements than the film itself. The packaging is collectible-friendly, featuring a slipcover with new artwork by Thomas Walker, a reversible sleeve with original Hong Kong poster art, and four art cards.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: Highlights the film’s visual and thematic elements with an emphasis on sensationalism.
- Stills Gallery: A collection of images exploring the film's aesthetic and scene composition.
Movie: 61
"The Golden Lotus," directed by Li Han Hsiang and produced by the famed Shaw Brothers studio, presents an intriguing yet controversial adaptation of a 16th-century Chinese novel, "The Plum in the Golden Vase." Positioned as a period drama with erotic undertones, the film diverges from Shaw Brothers' renowned martial arts legacy, offering instead a vignette-driven narrative steeped in infidelity and intrigue. Jackie Chan, in a minor yet entertaining role, lends comedic flair amidst a landscape that oscillates between opulent debauchery and dramatic tension. His participation, albeit non-action-oriented, adds a unique facet to this ensemble piece. The film's depiction of unbridled lust and its destructive consequences resonates as a cautionary tale, supported by impressive framing, editing, and musical scoring techniques.
Despite its thematic divergence, "The Golden Lotus" retains the studio's hallmark quality in its production values. The narrative’s fidelity to the source material ensures a bawdy yet nuanced portrayal of its themes. It intriguingly juxtaposes explicit sexuality with the intricacies of societal norms from its period setting. The film tactfully omits some scenes advertised in vintage trailers, choosing instead to focus on character development and interpersonal dynamics. This stylistic choice solidifies "The Golden Lotus" as more than an erotic thriller—it is a profound commentary on human nature and the perils of unchecked desires.
The meticulous attention to costumes and set design not only captures the historical essence of the tale but also enhances its visual appeal. As Hsi-Men Ching, portrayed by Peter Yang, navigates his reckless pursuits, the film transitions into an ensemble drama underscored by marital strife. The adept performances and polished screenplay further elevate the narrative, transforming "The Golden Lotus" into a testament to Shaw Brothers' versatility beyond their martial arts prowess.
Total: 61
"The Golden Lotus" Blu-Ray release is a captivating exploration of the Shaw Brothers' approach to erotic period dramas, a genre they portrayed with their distinctive flair. This film, featuring a young Jackie Chan, holds historical significance as both a provocative piece and a glimpse into the nascent stages of Chan's illustrious career. The Blu-Ray's visual presentation is notably rich and visually engaging, showcasing meticulous restoration work that highlights the vivid colors and intricate set designs characteristic of Shaw Brothers' productions. However, while the audio quality achieves a reasonable level of clarity and fidelity, it does fall short of matching the visual excellence, leaving a marginal gap in the full audio-visual experience.
Moreover, the release lacks standout supplemental materials which could have enhanced its overall value. The film's narrative structure, although dated by contemporary standards, delivers an amusing and intriguing storyline that might appeal to viewers interested in the historical context or fans of classic Asian cinema. The ambitious narrative blends elements of melodrama and eroticism with a unique cultural lens, standing as a testament to the studio's pioneering storytelling.
In conclusion, "The Golden Lotus" may not fulfill the hyperbolic claims of a masterpiece, but it undeniably holds a place in cinematic history as a fascinating oddity. This Blu-Ray release is recommended for collectors and enthusiasts interested in the Shaw Brothers' era and Jackie Chan completists. The film is an engaging watch for those seeking insight into the evolution of Asian cinema’s narrative styles and thematic explorations. While its technical offerings could benefit from enhancements, its core charm and historical significance make it a worthy addition to any classic film collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
The palette is very healthy virtually the entire time, and even manages to weather opticals like dissolves with surprising vibrancy....
Audio: 80
This has a somewhat thin sound on the high end which tends to be especially noticeable during music, as in the opening Shaw Brothers masthead theme or some of the higher washes of percussion in the opening...
Extras: 10
Trailer (HD; 2:29) emphasizes bare breasts and the fact that this is a "prestigious" production....
Movie: 70
Continuing with the above moments of hilarity, it turns out that the operatic ( soap operatic?) tendencies of the source novel led to it being adapted fairly recently as a stage musical....
Total: 70
The film may not be the "masterpiece" the back cover hypes it to be, and some may feel my overall score of 3.5 is overly generous, but at least as a real curio in the history of Shaw Brothers, it probably...
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 80
This is some of 88 Films’ best work yet on Blu-ray, and the same goes for whoever is processing their Asian releases....
Audio: 80
...
Extras: 2
The limited edition slipcover offers brand-new artwork by Thomas Walker and four art cards are included inside the case....
Movie: 60
The Golden Lotus becomes more of an ensemble during its final act as Hsi-Men Ching’s many wives fight for their place in his household....
Total: 56
Dated but amusing erotic period drama from Shaw Brothers, which features a young Jackie Chan in a supporting role...
Director: Han Hsiang Li
Actors: Chun Yang, Chin Hu, Ni Tien
PlotSet in the Song Dynasty, the film follows the ambitious and wealthy Ximen Qing, a man notorious for his hedonistic lifestyle and pursuit of carnal desires. Ximen uses his power and wealth to manipulate those around him, indulging in a series of illicit affairs and deceptions. His life takes a dramatic turn when he becomes infatuated with Pan Jinlian, a mesmerizing and beautiful woman trapped in an unhappy marriage to the much older Wu Da. Pan, yearning for affection and material comforts beyond her dull existence, is drawn to Ximen and his promises of luxury and passion. Their forbidden relationship quickly spirals into a tangled web of deceit, betrayal, and manipulation as they both seek to fulfill their own selfish desires.
Meanwhile, other characters become embroiled in the chaos unleashed by Ximen's reckless behavior. Wu Song, Wu Da's righteous brother and a skilled martial artist, becomes suspicious of the swirling rumors surrounding Pan and Ximen. He starts probing into their illicit affair, setting off a chain of events fueled by vengeance and justice. The intricate societal dynamics and moral corruption are laid bare as various individuals are pulled into the turbulent wake of Ximen's unchecked lust and ambition. Hidden secrets, personal vendettas, and shifting alliances all come to a head, setting the stage for the ultimate reckoning and exposing the fragile threads holding their lives together.
Writers: Han Hsiang Li
Release Date: 17 Jan 1974
Runtime: 112 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin