Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer Blu-ray Review
Score: 72
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Fun, lighthearted 'Fantastic Four' film with great Blu-ray features; note on PC playback issues.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
The Fantastic Four sequel shines on Blu-ray with a pristine 1080p transfer, boasting vivid colors, superb detail without grain or softness, and excellent CGI, making it potentially the best video transfer seen.
Audio: 69
Rise of the Silver Surfer's Blu Ray release boasts a superior DTS HD 5.1 audio track with clear dialogue and robust effects, alongside versatile audio options, enhancing any home theater experience.
Extra: 76
Fox's Blu-ray release of FF: Rise of the Silver Surfer enhances the viewing experience with high-quality audio-visuals, comprehensive extras including BD-Java games and commentaries, appealing to fans and newcomers alike.
Movie: 66
The Fantastic Four face the mysterious Silver Surfer, whose arrival on Earth signals global disaster, amidst Reed and Sue's wedding chaos and team challenges, in a sequel filled with humor, action, and camaraderie.
Video: 74
"Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer" shines on Blu-ray with its presentation in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio widescreen High Definition 1080p picture quality, providing an exemplary viewing experience that truly does justice to the grand visuals of the film. The transfer showcases incredible detail, free of any softness, edge enhancement, or grain, resulting in a lifelike picture quality that almost surpasses reality—an effect so vivid it appears as though Jessica Alba has been painted directly into the scene. The integration of seamless CGI, especially with the shiny effects surrounding the Silver Surfer and the explosive set pieces, benefits markedly from this clarity. Moreover, the deep and rich color palette highlights the vibrant blues of the Fantastic Four’s attire against the contrasting fiery reds and oranges, while maintaining solid blacks to enhance nighttime scenes and shadow details.
Encoded in MPEG4 AVC with a video bitrate averaging around 27Mbps, this Blu-ray edition excels in delivering a near-perfect transfer, marred only by minimal noise that likely stems from the original sources rather than the encoding process. The richness and depth of colors set a new standard for how comic book movies should be visualized in High Definition. Scenes are rendered with an outstanding texture that brings every detail to life, from Susan Storm’s hair to Ben Grimm’s rocky exterior, offering viewers a chance to appreciate the meticulous attention to detail throughout. A highlight is Chapter 7: The Silver Surfer sequence, which showcases an exceptional range from bright daylight to the darkness of space without losing clarity or becoming washed out—except in certain deliberately darkened scenes. This presentation not only serves as a testament to Blu-ray's capabilities but also ensures that this film will be a visual showcase for enthusiasts and newcomers alike.
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of "Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer" on Blu Ray is a notable highlight, equipped with a DTS HD 5.1 lossless audio track that stands out for its clarity and dynamic range, even if most systems will primarily utilize its 'core' DTS element. This maintains a superior quality over its DVD counterpart's DTS mix, featuring clear and coherent dialogue that is expertly balanced across the fronts and center channels. The real audio spectacle, however, lies in the film's soundtrack and effects, from the iconic patriotic theme song to the dramatic, high-stakes scenes filled with rich, immersive soundscapes that make full use of a six-speaker setup. The surround and LFE channels are particularly engaged, elevating action sequences, military encounters, and grand planetary moments to an auditory experience that is arguably among the best available.
Moreover, the main audio track's encoding with 5.1 DTS-MA Master Audio ensures a very active and dynamic soundtrack, ideal for showcasing the capabilities of any home theater system. The balance between dialogue, sound effects, and music is meticulously maintained, ensuring that spoken words are never overshadowed. This results in an environment that feels genuinely immersive, with clever use of audio panning and a richness that contributes to a more engaging film experience without overpowering the viewer. Additionally, the inclusion of alternative English Dolby Digital 5.1 @ 448kbps track, alongside French and Spanish DD 5.1 options, reflects a commendable effort to accommodate a wide array of home audio systems. This versatility enables viewers to enjoy high-quality sound regardless of their setup, from simple stereo to advanced DTS lossless configurations, making it a prominent feature for both enthusiasts and casual viewers alike.
Extras: 76
The Blu-ray release of "Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer" stands out for its inclusion of innovative BD-Java extras alongside a broad selection of high-definition content that enriches the viewing experience. Notably, it introduces two BD-Java games, marking a significant advancement in Blu-ray technology that previously echoed features found in HD DVDs. Although these games, "Saving the World One Question at a Time" and "Who Dares Defy Galactus?," offer engaging, albeit basic entertainment, their inclusion alongside standard extras—presented in varying video resolutions and Dolby Digital audio—demonstrates a commendable effort to leverage the format's interactive potential. This release also features comprehensive documentaries and featurettes, like the behind-the-scenes exploration in "Family Bonds: The Making of FF:RoSS" and the detailed look at the iconic "Fantasticar," providing an immersive deep dive into the production and legacy of both the film and its characters. Audio commentaries offer invaluable insights into the creative process, though they vary in engagement levels. While some extras mirror those from the 2-disc DVD edition, the Blu-ray exclusive java games and high-definition presentations set this edition apart as a significant addition to any fan's collection.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentaries: In-depth discussions with the director, producers, and film editors.
- Deleted/Extended Scenes: Additional scenes with optional director commentary.
- Family Bonds: The Making of FF:RoSS: A comprehensive documentary split into pre- and post-production insights.
- The Fantasticar: State of the Art: A featurette detailing the creation of the Fantastic Four's iconic vehicle.
- The Power Cosmic: Focuses on bringing the Silver Surfer character to life on screen.
- Sentinel of the Spaceways: Comic Book Origins of The Silver Surfer: Explores the comic book history of the Silver Surfer.
- Scoring the Fantastic: A glimpse into the film’s musical score with composer John Ottman.
- Character Design with Spectral Motion: A look at the effects technique behind The Thing's appearance.
- Saving the World One Question at a Time: A BD-Java trivia game challenging Marvel comic knowledge.
- Who Dares Defy Galactus?: A BD-Java strategy game for one or two players featuring Galactus and the Silver Surfer.
- Stills Gallery: Divided into sections showcasing behind-the-scenes images and more.
- Trailers: Promotional content for this film, its prequel, and other Fox Blu-ray releases.
Movie: 66
In "Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer," audiences are whisked into an engaging whirlwind of global anomalies, galactic threats, and personal milestones for the beloved superhero team. As the Earth experiences bizarre weather complications and frightening energy disruptions, the cause dashes across the cosmos – a silvery entity known as the Silver Surfer. The narrative adeptly combines these grandiose challenges with the intimate affair of Reed Richards and Sue Storm's wedding, creating a compelling juxtaposition that adds depth to the storyline. The introduction of General Hager and the uneasy alliance with Dr. Victor von Doom weave complex layers of intrigue and tension, setting a dynamic stage for the heroes’ quest.
The movie excels in its execution of action and adventure, appealing to a broad demographic without compromising on intensity despite its PG rating. Humor and camaraderie among the Fantastic Four, particularly between Chris Evans’ Johnny Storm and Michael Chiklis’ Ben Grimm, inject warmth and relatability into the narrative, distinguishing it from darker comic book adaptations. This sequel stands out for its swift pacing and lighter tone, confidently moving beyond origin storytelling to explore new territories. The global locales add a refreshing scope to the film, enhancing the visual and emotional stakes.
Technically, the film is a marvel of visual effects that brings the Silver Surfer to life with stunning clarity, thanks in part to Laurence Fishbourne's voice work. The special effects marry well with the film's action sequences, especially during the high-stakes pursuit of the Silver Surfer, demonstrating a marked improvement from its predecessor. The character dynamics, coupled with an intriguing plot line about interstellar doom, ensure that "Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer" is an entertaining watch that improves upon repeated viewings, striking a fine balance between humor, heart, and heroics.
Total: 72
"Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer" shines as a standout in the bustling realm of comic book cinema, presenting itself as a lighthearted and entertaining journey suitable for viewers of all ages. Director Tim Story has skillfully crafted a film that counters the prevailing trend of its more serious contemporaries, infusing a wholesome mix of humor and adventure that sets it apart. The Blu-ray edition elevates this experience to greater heights, boasting exemplary picture and sound quality that immerses viewers in the Fantastic Four's world. Additionally, the disc is packed with a wealth of extra features and interactive options, ensuring enthusiasts have ample content to delve into.
However, it's noteworthy to mention some technical hiccups encountered during playback on PC systems, specifically when using Windows Vista Ultimate with PowerDVD Ultra 7.3. Initial attempts to play the disc were met with failure, and even after downloading a necessary update, only a blank screen was presented. This issue points to a compatibility conflict between BD+ security technology and PC media playback software, which could frustrate users preferring to view on their computers rather than standard Blu-ray players.
In conclusion, "Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer" on Blu-ray is highly recommended for its positive deviation into a fun-filled cinematic adventure, enhanced by superb audio-visual quality and an abundance of engaging supplementary content. While it scores high on entertainment and technical excellence for traditional Blu-ray player audiences, PC users should be wary of potential playback challenges. Despite these minor technical obstacles, the overall package remains an attractive addition for fans and newcomers alike, promising hours of enjoyable exploration into the Fantastic Four saga.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 100
The bigger, more explosive set-pieces and shiny Silver Surfer effects look tremendous in High Definition and this is a fantastically glossy number to come glistening to the superior Blu Ray format....
Audio: 90
Dialogue comes presented clearly and coherently, predominantly across the fronts and centre channels but, again just like the first movie, the standout aspects are really the suitably patriotic theme-song...
Extras: 80
Thankfully there clearly isn't enough here to warrant an extended FF2.1, but there could also be more footage (particularly from the latter half of the movie) that they are holding back from this edition...
Movie: 70
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by PeteRRead review here
Video: 90
As seen in the film's theatrical trailer, the chase of Surfer by Johnny Storm down the eastern seaboard is an amazing sequence that goes from the bright outdoors to the blackness of space....
Audio: 90
Note: the main audio track of this disc is encoded with 5.1 DTS-MA Master Audio, since I am using the Sony PlayStation 3 as my playback unit only the lossy core 1.5Mbps DTS is currently available to me....
Extras: 80
Particularly interesting is the conversation between editors Eliot and Hoy: they show how much of the film was molded and changed from the script in post production....
Movie: 70
What sets these films apart from other comic book adaptations is the humor and fun, without descending into the camp that plagued the original Batman franchise....
Total: 90
With all the other comic book film franchises starting to crowd the marketplace, the approach by Tim Story and his team to have a fun, funny, lighthearted adventure is welcome....
Director: Tim Story
Actors: Ioan Gruffudd, Jessica Alba, Chris Evans
PlotIn the film, the Fantastic Four—Reed Richards (Mr. Fantastic), Sue Storm (Invisible Woman), Johnny Storm (Human Torch), and Ben Grimm (The Thing)—face a new challenge when a mysterious interstellar visitor, the Silver Surfer, arrives on Earth. The Silver Surfer heralds the arrival of Galactus, a cosmic entity that consumes planets to sustain its life force. The arrival of the Silver Surfer creates global panic as he travels across Earth, leaving destruction in his wake. The Fantastic Four must unravel the enigma of the Silver Surfer and confront this threat to Earth's existence. Their mission becomes personal as they deal with their own struggles, particularly Reed and Sue, who are attempting to balance their superhero responsibilities with their upcoming wedding.
As they pursue the Silver Surfer, the Fantastic Four discovers that there's more to their adversary than meets the eye, revealing a complex character with deep motivations. Their investigation leads them into conflict not only with the Silver Surfer but also with the U.S. military and their old nemesis, Victor Von Doom, who has his own agenda regarding the cosmic visitor and the impending doom. The team must overcome internal strife and external challenges to understand the true nature of the threat they face, setting the stage for a confrontation that will require them to unite and tap into strengths they never knew they had.
Writers: Don Payne, Mark Frost, John Turman
Release Date: 15 Jun 2007
Runtime: 92 min
Rating: PG
Country: United Kingdom, Germany, United States
Language: English, Japanese, Chinese, Arabic