Populaire Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Populaire, charming on Blu-ray (1.85:1), awaits info on framing; still, it's a must-see. RECOMMENDED.
Disc Release Date
Video: 60
Populaire's Blu-ray features a 1.85:1 transfer, diverging from its original 2.39:1, yet offers outstanding depth, clarity, and vibrant colors without digital flaws, indicating an intentional reframe for the UK market.
Audio: 70
This Blu-ray features French DTS-HD 5.1 and LPCM 2.0 audio, English LPCM 2.0 descriptive audio, and optional English subtitles. The 5.1 option offers superior depth and dynamics, with clear dialogue and a good English translation.
Extra: 41
In behind-the-scenes features of 'Populaire', Regis Roinsard and cast delve into its creation, love story, '50s style, and the era's typing contests, highlighting period typewriters. All in French with English subtitles. (14 min total).
Movie: 71
Populaire dazzles with romance, vibrant '50s charm, and a spirited typing competition, featuring a stellar cast and earning critical acclaim, including Cesar nods.
Video: 60
The 4K UHD Blu Ray presentation of Regis Roinsard's "Populaire", courtesy of Entertainment One/Momentum Pictures, showcases a meticulous transfer that respects the film’s visual flair, albeit with a curious alteration in aspect ratio. Originally designed to be seen in a wider 2.39:1 format, this home video version has been modified to a 1.85:1 aspect. Despite this significant change, the composition's integrity remains intact, leading to speculation that this decision, presumably endorsed by the film's creators, was tailored for the UK audience. The intent behind this reframing warrants further inquiry for a deeper understanding of its implications on the viewing experience.
The video quality itself is nothing short of impeccable, thanks to encoding with MPEG-4 AVC at 1080p resolution which brings out a vivid and dynamic range of colors. The spectrum of hues displayed — from the deepest reds to the most vibrant yellows — feels exceptionally warm and natural, enhancing the period aesthetic of the film without succumbing to artificial digital enhancements. Sharpness and detail are particularly noteworthy; whether in the intimacy of close-ups or the scope of panoramic views, the image's clarity and depth are consistently impressive. This level of detail contributes to an image stability that is remarkably solid throughout.
Furthermore, this release is commendably free from common digital artifacts or compression issues, ensuring a smooth and immersive viewing journey. It's important to note that this Region-B locked Blu-ray demands specific hardware for playback — either a native Region-B or Region-Free player is necessary to enjoy this exemplary video presentation. The care taken in transferring "Populaire" to Blu-ray format underlines a dedication to preserving the film’s artistry while navigating the technical limitations and considerations of the home video market.
Audio: 70
In assessing the audio presentation of the 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Populaire," it's apparent that careful consideration has been given to offering a versatile auditory experience. The disc features two primary French audio tracks: a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 selection and an LPCM 2.0 option. Additionally, there is an English Descriptive Audio LPCM 2.0 track to cater to a wider audience. Subtitles are provided in both English and English SDH, with different size options available, ensuring accessibility and a more customized viewing experience.
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track clearly stands out for its superior sound quality. Its depth and nuanced dynamic range are commendable, offering an auditory experience that, while it may not rival the surround movement found in blockbuster Blu-ray releases, possesses a certain charm that could pleasantly surprise the more casual viewer. The clarity of dialogue is another highlight of this audio track—being crisp, clean, and remarkably stable, making it easy for viewers to follow along without any strain.
Moreover, the translation quality into English is noteworthy for its excellence, ensuring that non-French speaking audiences can fully enjoy the movie without losing nuance. Although the LPCM 2.0 track might not boast the same level of auditory depth as the 5.1, it still provides a solid option for those without a surround sound setup. The availability of different audio tracks and subtitle options clearly demonstrates a commitment to accessibility and user preference, making this release of "Populaire" on 4K UHD Blu-ray a commendable effort in terms of its audio presentation.
Extras: 41
The extra presentation on the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Populaire" offers a succinct yet comprehensive dive into the whirlwind world behind its production and thematic essence. Starting with "To Begin With," viewers are introduced to the film's genesis by director Regis Roinsard, setting a foundation for a deeper understanding of this cinematic piece. Subsequent features such as "The Love Story," "The 50s," and "A Romantic and Sports Comedy" artfully combine interviews with the main cast and production team to dissect the romantic dynamics, period authenticity, and the peculiar allure of typing competitions that define the film. "Typists Rule" rounds out the extras by spotlighting the vintage typewriters that play an unsung yet vital role, each segment enriched with insights from those who brought "Populaire" to life, all presented in French with optional English subtitles, ensuring an engaging experience for both French-speaking audiences and international fans alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- To Begin With: Director Regis Roinsard explains the origins of Populaire.
- The Love Story: Discussion of the film's romantic elements by main cast and director.
- The 50s: Insight into creating the period look of the film.
- A Romantic and Sports Comedy: Exploring the real-life inspiration behind the film's typing competitions.
- Typists Rule: A feature on the various typewriters used in the movie.
Movie: 71
Regis Roinsard’s “Populaire,” presented on 4K UHD Blu-Ray by Entertainment One/Momentum Pictures, is a vibrantly executed period piece that immerses viewers in the visually delightful and emotionally engaging world of 1958 France. The film, especially noted for its exquisite direction and compelling narrative, tells the story of Rose Pamphyle (played by Deborah François), a young woman whose mundane life in a quiet French town takes a dramatic turn when she exhibits extraordinary typing speed, catching the eye of insurance agent Louis Echard (Romain Duris). The initial setup evolves into a tale of ambition, romance, and personal growth, set against the backdrop of a speed-typing competition that propels the story to its vibrant climax.
The visual presentation of "Populaire" on this Blu-Ray release is nothing short of spectacular, with cinematography by Guillaume Schiffman spotlighting lush landscapes, intricate period details, and fabulously designed costumes that effectively transport the viewer to mid-century France. The film benefits greatly from Schiffman’s skillful lens, capturing the essence of the era with the same finesse that earned him acclaim in "The Artist." Accompanied by a chic and carefully curated soundtrack featuring classics from Jaqueline Boyer, Leroy Anderson, and Les Baxter, the film excels in creating an atmospheric depth that enhances the viewing experience. The chemistry between François and Duris further amplifies the film’s allure, navigating through their characters’ complex relationship with grace and authenticity.
Despite its foray into clichéd territory towards its finale—an aspect that might overwhelm some with its overt sweetness—"Populaire" manages to maintain its charm and vibrancy throughout. Notably supported by performances from not just its leads but also from supporting actors like Bérénice Bejo, the film’s narrative momentum is retained through its engaging script and dynamic character arcs. The movie's received accolades, including five Cesar nominations for Best First Film, Best Cinematography, and Best Costume Designs, underscore its artistic achievements and contribution to French cinema. Enthusiasts of sumptuously designed period dramas will find "Populaire" a visually stunning and emotionally rewarding experience that stands as a testament to Roinsard's directorial prowess and the film’s exquisite production values.
Total: 61
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Populaire" presents an engaging viewing experience, which retains the charm and allure of its cinematic release, albeit with a noticeable alteration in its aspect ratio. Transitioning from its original cinematic aspect ratio of 2.39:1 to 1.85:1 for the home release might raise eyebrows among purists. However, this modification does not detract from the overall visual appeal of the film. The re-framing appears deliberate and is executed with a finesse that preserves the film's period aesthetic and dynamic composition. Comparisons to the French Blu-ray suggest an intentional choice for this UK edition, sparking curiosity about the rationale behind such a decision.
Technical aspects aside, "Populaire" itself is a delightfully crafted period comedy that shines in its 4K presentation. The enhanced resolution and color grading breathe new life into the vibrant 1950s setting, making every scene pop with an authenticity and vibrancy that's both engaging and visually sumptuous. This release underscores the film's strengths, offering a pristine audio-visual experience even if it strays from the original aspect ratio. The attention to detail in the transfer process is commendable, ensuring that the film's stylistic and narrative elements are conveyed with clarity and depth.
Conclusively, while some may find the alteration in aspect ratio a point of contention, the overall presentation of "Populaire" on 4K UHD Blu-ray is exceptional. The film's captivating story, combined with its delightful aesthetic and era-appropriate atmosphere, makes it a must-watch. This release receives our recommendation not just for its technical merits but also for preserving and enhancing the charm that made "Populaire" a beloved period comedy. Its beautiful presentation provides an ideal viewing experience for those special shared moments, making it an essential addition to any collection.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 70
Audio: 70
Extras: 50
Movie: 70
Total: 70
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
The film's original aspect ratio appears to be 2.39:1, but the high-definition transfer this release uses is framed in 1.85:1....
Audio: 100
Surround movement will not impress viewers who appreciate the type of movement Blu-ray releases of major blockbusters typically have, but there is more than enough that could surprise casual viewers....
Extras: 40
The Love Story - Regis Roinsard, Romain Duris, and Deborah Francois discuss the romantic overtones in Populaire and its main protagonists....
Movie: 80
The gorgeous period designs, outfits, hairstyles and of course the terrific soundtrack make this film look like a giant candy box in which there is something tasty for everyone....
Total: 80
Despite the fact that there is a French Blu-ray release which apparently has the film present in 2.39:1, I wonder if the new framing for the UK release is intentional....
Director: Régis Roinsard
Actors: Romain Duris, Féodor Atkine, Déborah François
PlotIn late 1950s France, a young and vibrant woman from a small village dreams of a life beyond her mundane existence and seizes an opportunity to work as a secretary for a charming but somewhat brusque insurance agency boss in Normandy. Despite her enthusiasm, her typing skills are abysmal. Her boss, noticing a unique talent beneath her initial ineptitude, decides to groom her for competitive speed typing, a popular sport at the time. Their professional relationship evolves as he becomes her strict coach, setting the stage for a journey that stretches beyond the confines of office walls and into the spirited arena of typewriting competitions.
As the young woman embarks on this unconventional path, she faces challenges that test her determination and spirit. The rigorous training sessions lead to moments of both conflict and camaraderie, gradually transforming her into a formidable contender in the speed typing world. Her journey through various competitions serves as a backdrop to an evolving dynamic with her boss, where personal and professional lines blur. Together, they navigate the highs and lows of competition, ambition, and the pursuit of dreams, within the colorful and competitive world of the late 1950s.
Writers: Régis Roinsard, Daniel Presley, Romain Compingt
Release Date: 06 Sep 2013
Runtime: 111 min
Rating: R
Country: France, Belgium
Language: French, English, German