Gray's Anatomy Blu-ray Review
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"Gray's Anatomy" on Blu-ray excels with Spalding Gray's compelling monologues and Soderbergh's dynamic visuals, complemented by a high-quality transfer and insightful supplements.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
Gray's Anatomy on Blu-ray, supervised by Steven Soderbergh and presented in 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 with a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, boasts impressive visuals, convincing color reproduction, stable contrast, and good detail with only moderate grain and minimal artifacts, meeting Criterion’s high standards.
Audio: 68
The Blu-ray's English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track offers a clean, stable experience with clear dialogue and subtle but effective surround elements, maintaining fidelity to the original sound design while enhancing Cliff Martinez's score and ambient effects.
Extra: 56
The Blu-ray extras for Gray's Anatomy are invaluable, featuring in-depth interviews with Steven Soderbergh and Renee Shafransky that reveal the film's unique genesis and Spalding Gray's creative process, raw surgery footage, a historic monologue with some video quality issues, and an insightful booklet by Amy Taubin.
Movie: 71
Gray’s Anatomy on Blu-ray is an intriguing experiment blending Spalding Gray's masterful storytelling with Steven Soderbergh's experimental cinematic techniques. The film's unique monologue structure and innovative visuals captivate, though occasional pacing issues and the absence of a live audience slightly hinder its impact.
Video: 68
The Blu-ray release of Steven Soderbergh's "Gray's Anatomy," presented in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, leverages a high-quality 1080p transfer supervised by the director himself. The high-definition digital transfer, created on a Spirit Datacine from a 35mm interpositive, ensures minimal dirt, debris, and grain thanks to Image Systems' Phoenix software. The supervision by Lee Kline and Soderbergh, combined with Chris Ryan’s adept color grading at Nice Shoes, New York, results in a polished presentation devoid of problematic sharpening corrections or serious stability issues.
Visually, the Blu-ray excels, especially given the film’s distinctive visual style. Close-ups are exceptionally detailed, capturing the intricacies of Spalding Gray's expressions with clarity. Colors such as red, blue, yellow, and brown are convincingly saturated, contributing to a well-balanced contrast across the board. The film’s black-and-white interview segments are marginally softer but still maintain a stable contrast and texture. Grain remains consistent throughout the movie, occasionally becoming heavy depending on the scene's original filming technique, adding to the film's natural look. The transfer maintains impressive sharpness and fine detail, avoiding major technical issues like banding or aliasing while preserving a rich visual depth.
Overall, the presentation on this Blu-ray is commendable and aligns with Criterion’s high standards. Whether through bold color choices in Soderbergh's moody lighting or the steady black levels providing solid dimension, the transfer allows the director’s unique visual approach to shine through effortlessly. Though a few specks are present and black levels are slightly elevated, they do not detract from the overall experience. This meticulous attention to detail guarantees that "Gray's Anatomy" looks fantastic in its Blu-ray release, delivering an engaging and visually impressive viewing experience.
Audio: 68
The Blu-ray presentation of "Gray's Anatomy" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, supplemented with optional English SDH subtitles. This audio configuration remains true to the original theatrical mix while enhancing certain aspects. The primary update, as mixed by Larry Blake from the 1997 stems, involves the upmixing of Cliff Martinez’s score to a 5.1 surround format. This update allows for a fuller auditory experience during musical sequences, making such improvements readily recognizable.
The dialogue, especially Gray’s monologues, stands at the forefront of this presentation, characterized by a clean, clear resonance that ensures every word is easily comprehensible. The surround sound elements are subtle yet effective, augmenting the narrative’s ambiance with carefully placed environmental sounds and specific music cues.While the 5.1 mix is somewhat subdued and front-loaded, it effectively maintains the authenticity of the original sound design. The audio track showcases a wide dynamic range free from distortion, though it does not emphasize deep bass frequencies except modestly through Martinez's score.
Overall, this sound mix handles the upgrade with precision, balancing respect for the original sound design with a subtle enhancement that complements the visuals. Despite limited surround use and directionality, the blend of effects and score enriches the audiovisual experience, and Gray’s voice remains impeccably clear and central to the narrative delivery.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "Gray's Anatomy" offer a rich and insightful collection that delve deep into the film’s creation, key personalities, and Spalding Gray's unique style. Steven Soderbergh's interview is particularly compelling as it details his collaboration with Gray and the innovative structuring of the film, while Renee Shafransky provides invaluable context on her working relationship with Gray and his notable blend of reality and fiction in monologues. "Swimming to the Macula" offers a raw and unfiltered look at Gray’s actual macular surgery, presenting high educational value. Additionally, "A Personal History of the American Theater" captures one of Gray’s essential monologues from a 1982 performance, though the presentation suffers from some visual artifacts. These inclusions, alongside the film's trailer and an insightful booklet, create a comprehensive package for fans and scholars alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Steven Soderbergh: Interview discussing collaboration, film structuring, and visual aesthetic.
- Renee Shafransky: Interview highlighting working relationship, creative process, and monologue structure.
- Swimming to the Macula: Raw footage of Gray's macular surgery.
- A Personal History of the American Theater: Performance of Gray’s monologue from 1982.
- Trailer: Original film trailer.
- Booklet: Illustrated booklet with essay by Amy Taubin.
Movie: 71
Steven Soderbergh's "Gray's Anatomy" (1996) is a striking and experimental adaptation of Spalding Gray's 1993 monologue, expertly brought to Blu-ray by Criterion. At its core, the film features Gray, known for his brilliant monologues, detailing his experiences with a rare eye condition and exploring various alternative treatments. These explorations include encounters with a Christian Science practitioner, a Native American healer, and a Philippine psychic surgeon, all of which provide more insight into Gray's personality than his medical condition. The narrative is punctuated with vivid, yet simple visual effects by Soderbergh that reflect Gray’s emotions and perceptions, alongside black and white interviews with individuals sharing their stories of eye injuries.
Soderbergh's direction features a dynamic yet minimalist approach, using long takes, simple sets, and inventive lighting to enhance the storytelling. Gray's monologue is delivered with his characteristic wit and neurotic charm, his delivery marked by meticulous timing and inflection. As the film progresses, the visual backgrounds grow more abstract, favoring bold hues and subtle sound effects to complement Gray's evolving narrative.
However, the absence of a live audience might impact the film's reception slightly, as Gray's performance thrives on audience interaction. Nevertheless, Soderbergh attempts to mitigate this by interspersing interview footage related to Gray's tale. While these segments don’t always enrich the main narrative, they do provide varying perspectives. Despite slight drawbacks like occasional lingering neurosis and some tedium in pacing, "Gray's Anatomy" remains an intriguing blend of monologue and cinema, showcasing Soderbergh's experimental flair and Gray's storytelling prowess.
Total: 66
Criterion's Blu-ray release of "Gray’s Anatomy" is an immaculate presentation that combines Spalding Gray's remarkable storytelling prowess with Steven Soderbergh's innovative directorial vision. Gray’s monologue is delivered with a sharp wit and incisive humor, making for a compelling viewing experience. The visual style that Soderbergh adds to this monologue elevates it from a mere recount to a visual and auditory experience that deeply engages the viewer.
The technical aspects of this Blu-ray release are commendable. The video transfer captures the intricacies of Soderbergh’s directional choices with high clarity and precision. The audio mix ensures that Gray’s narration is crisp and clear, adding to the immersive quality of the story. Additionally, the supplements included provide a deeper understanding of Gray's methodology and life, enhancing the overall appreciation of the film. While the synthesis of monologue and film as an art form may not appeal universally, it presents a rich, nuanced experimental approach worth exploring.
In conclusion, Gray's biting sarcasm and keen humor breathe life into "Gray’s Anatomy," making it stand out as an exceptional piece of narrative cinema. Fans of introspective and humorous storytelling akin to Woody Allen's work will find this Blu-ray release highly satisfying. Criterion’s dedication to delivering high-quality presentations is evident, making this release highly recommended for any collector or enthusiast of unique cinematic experiences.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
Color reproduction is very convincing - the variety of reds, blues, yellows, browns, and blacks are stable and well saturated....
Audio: 90
The following text appears inside the booklet provided with this Blu-ray disc: "The original theatrical audio mix was updated by re-recording mixer Larry Blake from the 1997 stems, the primary change being...
Extras: 80
In 1982, Spalding Gray performed the piece again as part of the Wooster, Group's eight-week series A Spalding Gray Retrospective....
Movie: 90
Remember, the monologue is essentially a series of descriptions and they could have felt remarkably dry if delivered by the wrong person....
Total: 90
This may not be the case with other viewers, but I thought that his monologues were superb....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Colors are the most impressive aspect of the transfer, and Soderbergh's bold and moody lighting design provides a feast for the eyes....
Audio: 80
Gray's monologue itself is of course the central focus here, and thankfully his speech comes through with a wonderfully clean, clear resonance....
Extras: 40
Swimming to the Macula (HD, 16 min) - Presented in upscaled 1080i, this is raw footage of Gray's actual macular surgery that is discussed in the monologue....
Movie: 60
While Gray's words are full of potent emotion, cynical humor, and insightful observations, the one-man conversation can get a little tedious, and though Soderbergh's style is striking, it never quite advances...
Total: 60
Gray's storytelling is heartfelt, humorous, and compelling, and Soderbergh's inventive visual style complements the oration nicely....
Director: Steven Soderbergh
Actors: Spalding Gray, Mike McLaughlin, Melissa Robertson
PlotA monologist recounts his experiences dealing with a rare ocular condition that threatens his vision. Told in a series of personal anecdotes and humorous observations, he delves into his initial bewilderment upon receiving the diagnosis. He navigates through various medical consultations and confronts the daunting prospect of surgery. Faced with uncertainty and fear, he starts exploring alternative treatments, trekking through a myriad of unconventional therapies, from faith healing to shamanistic rituals.
As he continues his journey, he wrestles with existential questions and personal insecurities, using humor and wit to cope with his mounting anxiety. Each episode reflects his inner turmoil and the lengths to which he will go to regain control over his health and life. Through the lens of his unique storytelling style, he offers a poignant, often comical, exploration of human vulnerability and resilience. The narrative culminates in his reflection on the nature of suffering and healing, leaving an indelible impression on the audience through its blend of candidness and levity.
Writers: Spalding Gray, Renée Shafransky
Release Date: 19 Mar 1997
Runtime: 80 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United States, United Kingdom
Language: English