Elmer Gantry Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "Elmer Gantry" by Kino Lorber Studio Classics presents an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.66:1 aspect ratio. This release displays more vivid colors compared to some other recent Studio Classics titles, though slight but noticeable color fade is present. Despite fluctuations in color space, the overall presentation maintains a high level of accuracy. Flesh tones, albeit inconsistent, range from ruddy brown to pale, while other colors like greens and purples remain steady. The grain field is fairly heavy but presents naturally without digital interference. Although relatively soft throughout, midrange shots convey decent, if not impressive, detail, and close-ups exhibit generally above-average clarity.

The transfer's quality varies, with moments of exceptional clarity counteracted by noticeable print damage. Colors shift from vibrant and bright to dull and faded intermittently. Nevertheless, the 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer showcases a pleasing grain structure that preserves the celluloid aesthetic without overwhelming the image. Good contrast provides depth, and robust black levels enhance density. Fleshtones fluctuate within natural thresholds, though detail in close-ups diverges significantly—Lancaster's shots being highly detailed while Simmons' are notably softer. Fans should note that no digital issues like crush, noise, or banding are evident, and there are no signs of artificial enhancements.

This Blu-ray release may not fully do justice to the distinguished work of Oscar-winning cinematographer John Alton, who was responsible for the film’s distinct visual style. While this transfer certainly improves upon previous home video releases, it clearly shows its age with optical softness, grain, dirt, and minor skin blemishes typical for a film of its era. Therefore, while this Blu-ray edition offers a significant upgrade for fans, a complete restoration would likely better reflect the original cinematic experience.

The Blu-ray presentation of "Elmer Gantry" features a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono mix, delivering generally acceptable audio quality. While some instances of speed fluctuations and occasional mild distortion pose a slight issue, these anomalies are limited primarily to the opening credits and do not persist throughout the film. Dialogue remains clean and clear, ensuring comprehensibility at all times, and André Previn's Oscar-nominated score, despite moments of shrillness, is effectively integrated.

The overall audio experience is quite satisfactory for a mono mix. Dynamic range may be limited, resulting in a somewhat flat soundscape with negligible stereo separation, but essential elements such as dialogue consistency and sound effects clarity are well-maintained. Age-related imperfections are largely absent, enhancing the auditory experience. Subtitles in English are also available for further accessibility. This presentation, while not without minor issues, offers a competent representation of the film's original audio.

The Blu-ray disc of "Elmer Gantry" features a couple of notable extras that will delight fans of the film. The highlight is an engaging interview with Shirley Jones, where she fondly recounts her audition process, Richard Brooks' initial hesitation in casting her, and her revitalizing career post-Oscar win. Jones also shares personal anecdotes about working closely with Burt Lancaster and the miffed reaction of Brooks at not getting an Oscar nomination. Despite some candid revelations, Jones' reminiscences maintain a light-hearted charm. Additionally, the theatrical trailer provides a glimpse into the film's promotional aspects, although the print suffers from significant damage and fading colors, which somewhat detracts from its historical value.

Extras included in this disc:

• Interview with Shirley Jones: Jones discusses her role, career impact, and production experiences.
• Theatrical Trailer: Provides a fire-and-brimstone portrayal of the film despite noticeable print damage.

Richard Brooks' 1960 adaptation of Sinclair Lewis' novel "Elmer Gantry" is a profoundly engaging and incisive examination of revivalist evangelism, a subject that remains strikingly relevant. Burt Lancaster stars as Elmer Gantry, a loquacious, quick-witted traveling salesman whose chance encounter with evangelist Sister Sharon Falconer (Jean Simmons) catapults him into a lucrative career as a charismatic preacher. Brooks’ screenplay retains the biting cynicism of Lewis' original work, taking a critical look at grassroots religion and the syndicate that profits from it. Brooks adeptly balances this critique with nuanced empathy for Sister Sharon, modeled after real-life evangelist Aimee Semple McPherson, who genuinely believes in her mission while being unaware of Gantry's opportunistic machinations.

The film opens with a cautionary text crawl, hinting at the provocative exploration to follow. From Gantry's initial appearance in a bar on Christmas Eve to his dramatic entrance into the revivalist scene, Brooks wastes no time in showcasing Lancaster's character with all his flamboyant flair and rhetorical prowess. The narrative delves deep into Gantry's exploitative strategies and his complex relationship with Sister Sharon. The story takes a pivotal turn with the arrival of Lulu Baines (Shirley Jones), a former conquest of Gantry now seeking revenge. Jones’ portrayal of the scorned, vengeful prostitute is riveting and earned her an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress.

Despite a runtime of 146 minutes, the film maintains its momentum through Brooks' lively screenplay, replete with snappy dialogue and intense exchanges. Lancaster's performance is exuberantly over-the-top, yet mesmerizing, while Simmons provides a measured counterbalance. "Elmer Gantry" is both entertaining and thought-provoking, as it unpacks the dual nature of evangelism—both its capacity to offer hope and its potential for exploitation. The film's enduring relevance and critical acclaim underscore its status as a timeless cinematic achievement.

Richard Brooks’ "Elmer Gantry" is an electrifying adaptation of Sinclair Lewis' novel, capturing the hypocritical charisma of evangelists during the Prohibition era. Burt Lancaster’s riveting portrayal of the titular character is a tour de force, embodying the essence of Gantry with an energy that commands attention throughout the film's expansive runtime. Jean Simmons delivers a familiar but impactful performance, while Shirley Jones stuns with her role against type as a conniving prostitute. This Blu-ray release from Kino showcases these stellar performances alongside solid, albeit unspectacular, video and audio quality.

The technical execution of the Blu-ray is proficient, addressing some minor video and audio concerns but overall delivering a satisfying viewing experience. Despite its occasional imperfections, the transfer brings out the depth of Brooks’ cinematic vision, making every scene engaging. The extras on this release are minimal but worthwhile, featuring an insightful interview with Shirley Jones and the original theatrical trailer. These inclusions, though limited, add value and context to the main feature, providing audiences with a deeper appreciation of the film’s legacy and production nuances.

In conclusion, "Elmer Gantry," driven by Lancaster’s masterful performance and Brooks' dynamic direction, remains a compelling character study that resonates even today. The film's Blu-ray presentation is robust enough to merit a strong recommendation despite minor technical drawbacks. For those unfamiliar with this cinematic classic or looking to revisit its potent narrative, this release offers an enriching experience that holds its own against time.