A Place at the Table Blu-ray Review
Score: 50
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"A Place at the Table" is a highly recommended, powerful documentary that sensitively explores America's systemic hunger issues, with an educative and frustratingly enlightening tone.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 44
The Blu-ray of 'A Place at the Table' features a 1080p/AVC-encoded presentation with varying quality: interview segments are sharp, while handheld footage is softer, sometimes appearing upscaled. Viewers can expect typical low-budget quirks like aliasing, noise, and banding, but the transfer is adequate for its documentary content.
Audio: 54
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for 'A Place at the Table' delivers clean, clear dialogue and narration, essential for this front-heavy mix. While surround activity is minimal, music by T-Bone Burnett and The Civil Wars enhances the soundfield with solid stereo separation. Optional English SDH and Spanish subtitles included.
Extra: 46
"A Place at the Table" Blu-ray extras provide a comprehensive package, including insightful commentary from directors and producer, in-depth deleted scenes and interviews, and promotional content, all presented in 1080p with Dolby Digital sound, enhancing the documentary’s exploration of hunger.
Movie: 66
"A Place at the Table" vividly exposes America's hidden hunger crisis through compelling personal stories, crucial statistics, and interviews with experts, though its impact is slightly marred by underexplored narratives and a clear activist agenda. The Blu-ray presentation is technically solid, enhancing the film's informative and frustrating revelations.
Video: 44
The Blu-ray presentation of "A Place at the Table" offers a 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio. The visual quality accurately reflects the documentary's varied source material. Interview segments are decently sharp with commendable detail, while handheld footage following the families often appears softer and flatter, sometimes resembling upscaled material with fuzzy edges and muddled textures. There are instances of high-definition stock footage mixed with some noticeably standard definition shots, emphasizing the overall inconsistency in visual quality.
Although watchable, the film exhibits numerous low-budget quirks typical of shot-on-inexpensive-video productions. These include blown-out highlights, light banding, and macroblocking, which might distract discerning viewers. Additionally, artifacts such as aliasing, shimmering, noise, ringing, and stability issues are also present. Colors appear relatively drab and washed out, with little vibrance or pop. Contrast is generally solid but is occasionally marred by overexposed whites and light blacks, giving the image an overall flat and dim appearance.
Despite these shortcomings, the video presentation of "A Place at the Table" serves its purpose effectively. While it does not match the pristine and glossy visuals found in higher-budget documentaries, the transfer is adequate for conveying the film's powerful message. The modest video quality aligns well with the documentary's content, maintaining a respectful approach to the source elements.
Audio: 54
The Blu-ray edition of "A Place at the Table" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that accomplishes exactly what it needs to do for this documentary. The primary focus is on ensuring that the interviewees' voices are clear and crisp, which it manages with commendable precision. Dialogue and narration come through cleanly without any balance issues. While the audio is predominantly front-heavy, the rear speakers are occasionally utilized for ambient sounds, which enriches the soundscape subtly without overwhelming the viewer.
The musical segments, featuring original songs by The Civil Wars and T-Bone Burnett, add a layer of depth to the auditory experience with solid stereo separation and fidelity. Though the dynamic range leans toward the flat side, both high and low frequencies are handled cleanly, providing a consistently distortion-free experience. There is some minimal bass activity in the musical tracks, enhancing their impact without becoming intrusive. Optional English SDH and Spanish subtitles are available, displayed in easy-to-read white lettering. Overall, while the audio presentation is relatively basic, it is perfectly suited to complement the documentary's focus and keeps the viewer engaged through meticulous attention to detail in speech and music clarity.
Extras: 46
The Blu Ray of "A Place at the Table" offers a comprehensive collection of supplemental features, meticulously curated to enhance the understanding of the film’s core themes. The audio commentary with producer Tom Colicchio and directors Kristi Jacobson and Lori Silverbush is particularly insightful, blending behind-the-scenes trivia with a deeper dive into the critical issues of hunger and food insecurity. The inclusion of cast and crew interviews, alongside deleted scenes and interviews, adds significant value, providing viewers with broader contexts and personal stories that underscore the documentary’s mission. Presented in high-definition with Dolby Digital 2.0 sound, the features maintain high technical standards.
Extras included in this disc:
Audio Commentary: With producer Tom Colicchio and directors Kristi Jacobson and Lori Silverbush. Deleted Scenes: Four scenes offering additional insights into the subjects' lives. Deleted Interviews: Extended interviews with key figures like Jeff Bridges and Tom Colicchio. Cast and Crew Interviews: In-depth discussions with the filmmakers on their motivations. AXS TV: A Look at A Place at the Table: A brief promotional featurette. A Good Day: A stop-motion short promoting hunger awareness. The Full Effect: Plum Organics' Mission to Nourish Children Across America: A promotional video for Plum Organics. Theatrical Trailer: Official trailer in HD. Also from Magnolia Home Entertainment: Trailers for other releases.
Movie: 66
"A Place at the Table," directed by Kristi Jacobson and Lori Silverbush, is a thought-provoking documentary that puts a spotlight on the often-overlooked issue of hunger in the United States. The film sheds light on the alarming reality that 50 million Americans face food insecurity, defined as uncertainty about where their next meal will come from. Through its compelling narrative structure, the documentary juxtaposes personal stories of struggling families with expert interviews and animated statistics to provide a thorough examination of the intersection between hunger, poverty, and obesity.
One of the documentary's strongest aspects is its ability to present complex data in an accessible manner. Experts such as Dr. Mariana Chilton, Raj Patel, and Jeff Bridges contribute to the narrative alongside poignant case studies of families from Colorado, Mississippi, and Philadelphia. These elements collectively highlight the paradox where low-income individuals face both hunger and obesity due to the affordability of unhealthy food over nutritious options. The documentary effectively critiques governmental policies, particularly agricultural subsidies that favor large-scale agribusiness over small farmers, exacerbating the issue.
While "A Place at the Table" succeeds in generating awareness and empathy, some viewers might find it lacking in emotional depth. Certain segments feel underexplored or disconnected. Nonetheless, the documentary maintains a focused agenda without veering into overly preachy territory. It critically assesses societal trends and policy shortcomings while advocating for a reevaluation of national priorities, like allocating more funds toward public school lunches rather than military spending. By balancing personal anecdotes with factual rigor, the film offers an educational and impactful look at an urgent social dilemma, encouraging viewers to reconsider their views on hunger and poverty in America.
Total: 50
"A Place at the Table" is an enlightening documentary that dives deep into the pervasive issue of hunger in America. The film deftly exposes the paradox of food insecurity and obesity, particularly in states like Mississippi, where a Paula Dean billboard ironically reads, "Hungry Ya'll?" The juxtaposition highlights a systemic problem fueled by agricultural special interest groups that have made unhealthy processed foods readily affordable while rendering fresh produce prohibitively expensive. With a clear agenda to raise awareness and incite public action, the documentary is poignant and thought-provoking.
Technically, the Blu-ray presentation is competent though not exceptional. The video transfer is average but adequate for the material, letting the powerful visuals speak without any significant distractions. The audio mix, although basic, is solid and effectively conveys the narrative. Supplements included with the Blu-ray provide additional context and depth, expanding on the important topics the film covers and offering a rich, educational experience. However, those looking for a deeply artistic treatment might find the documentary more straightforward and journalistic in its approach.
In conclusion, "A Place at the Table" stands out as an important educational tool that effectively raises awareness about America's hunger crisis. While it might lack a strong artistic flair, its real-life stories are portrayed with sensitivity and respect, making it a powerful call to action. This film will likely leave viewers both enlightened and outraged, much like its predecessor, "Food, Inc." Highly recommended for those looking to understand and combat food insecurity in America.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 60
Overall, the documentary is very watchable, although you will spot lots of the usual low-budget, shot-on-inexpensive-video quirks�some blown-out highlights, some light banding, some macroblocking, etc....
Audio: 80
The rear speakers are used only sparsely for ambience, but the soundfield is filled every few minutes with songs by The Civil Wars and T-Bone Burnett....
Extras: 60
The Full Effect: Plum Organics' Mission to Nourish Children Across America (HD, 3:59): A promo for Plum Organics, a healthy baby food line....
Movie: 80
Though this "for the greater good" sentiment obviously doesn't sit well with certain groups�the agriculture industry, namely, as well as those who think it smacks of socialism�A Place at the Table wants...
Total: 80
The first step, of course, is realizing that there is a problem, and that's what A Place at the Table sets out to do�raise awareness....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Unlike many documentaries, the film is mostly comprised of new footage but there seems to have been a mixture of shooting equipment used and the overall image suffers from a comparatively low grade HD...
Audio: 60
Dynamic range is on the flat side, but highs and lows are both clean with no distortion and there is some marginal bass activity within some of the music tracks....
Extras: 40
Deleted Interviews (HD, 14 min) - Deleted interviews with Jeff Bridges, Tom Colicchio, and Adam Appelhanz are viewable separately or together, providing a few more details on the End Hunger Network, the...
Movie: 60
Throughout the runtime, the filmmakers cover all their bases, transitioning from emotional segments focused on the hardships of hunger on a one-on-one level, to larger discussions aimed at critiquing policies...
Total: 60
The movie might lack a true artistic voice, but the real life stories and dilemmas it examines are sensitively and respectfully explored, resulting in an educational and ultimately powerful documentary....
Director: Kristi Jacobson, Lori Silverbush
Actors: Jeff Bridges, Tom Colicchio, Ken Cook
PlotIn the United States, over 50 million people, including one in four children, suffer from food insecurity. The film explores the systemic issue of hunger through the eyes of three individuals struggling to provide enough food for their families. Barbie, a single mother from Philadelphia, relies on food banks to feed her two children; Rosie, a fifth-grader from Colorado, often goes to bed hungry despite her mother working long hours; and Tremonica, a second-grader from Mississippi, faces health issues due to a lack of nutritious food. Each story underscores the emotional and physical toll of hunger while highlighting the broader social and economic factors that contribute to this crisis.
The narrative weaves personal stories with expert analysis and facts to illustrate the depth and complexity of hunger in America. It examines the history and shortcomings of federal programs like the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and delves into the roles that policy, agricultural subsidies, and budget cuts play in exacerbating food insecurity. The film also showcases community efforts to combat hunger, such as food banks and nutrition education programs. Through these lenses, it becomes apparent that hunger is not merely an individual issue but a systemic problem requiring comprehensive policy changes and social action.
Writers: N/A
Release Date: 01 Mar 2013
Runtime: 84 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English