Daddy's Little Girls Blu-ray Review
Tyler Perry's Daddy's Little Girls
Score: 53
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Daddy's Little Girls' Blu-ray offers excellent picture quality, an underused 7.1 uncompressed audio track, and valuable extras, but the film may not justify a purchase.
Disc Release Date
Video: 65
"Daddy's Little Girls" Blu-ray delivers a solid 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer with fine texture evident in close-ups and good overall clarity. While contrast can run a bit hot and colors aren't overly vivid, black levels are strong and detail is maintained well, making it a commendable presentation for a low-budget film.
Audio: 65
**Review Summary:** "Lionsgate excels with an unexpected top-tier 7.1 PCM uncompressed audio track for 'Daddy's Little Girls,' enriching its subtle ambient sounds and R 'n B tracks with clear bass and punchy clarity. Despite the film's dialogue-driven nature and limited discrete effects, the sound presentation is superbly dynamic and well-balanced."
Extra: 48
The Blu-ray of "Daddy's Little Girls" offers a robust set of extras, including an in-depth yet somewhat dry commentary by Tyler Perry, where he discusses production details and casting. The extras also feature insightful featurettes on character development, shooting challenges, and behind-the-scenes interviews, making it a comprehensive package for Perry enthusiasts.
Movie: 48
"Daddy’s Little Girls" demonstrates Tyler Perry's trademark sentimentalism and preachiness, offering predictable melodrama and mixed performances, but is somewhat redeemed by Idris Elba’s strong presence, despite its flat direction, heavy-handed moralizing, and lack of genuine emotional impact.
Video: 65
'Daddy's Little Girls' garners a polished presentation in its 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 Blu-ray transfer. The film’s visuals impress for a relatively low-budget production, exhibiting a pleasing sense of clarity and detail across foreground and background elements. Close-up shots reveal fine textures, such as the stubble on Idris Elba's face and the intricate threading of his clothing. While the film occasionally dips into softer focus, these instances appear to be related to camera work rather than the transfer itself. The image maintains a warm tone throughout, complemented by stable colors and deep hues, particularly noticeable in scenes like the purple-robed preacher against a red curtain backdrop or within the blues club interiors.
Contrast is notably high, infusing the picture with vibrancy but occasionally imparting a slightly artificial look to the overall presentation. Despite this, black levels are robust and preserve shadow details effectively. The print quality is in pristine condition, devoid of any blemishes or imperfections, which ensures a clean and smooth viewing experience. While colors are vibrant, especially blacks, the primary hues tend to be somewhat desaturated, and fleshtones can appear waxy due to the heightened contrast. Although the transfer doesn’t reach groundbreaking three-dimensionality, it certainly holds up with fine textures and solid detail, resulting in a commendable presentation for this genre.
In summary, this Blu-ray transfer of 'Daddy's Little Girls' showcases a solid four-star level presentation. It manages to balance warmth with clarity and detail while maintaining a thin but pleasing grain structure that adds depth and richness to the visual experience. Despite minor issues with high contrast and desaturated primaries, the overall quality is impressive for the film's budget, making it a visually satisfying release.
Audio: 65
Lionsgate consistently delivers an impressive audio experience, and their release of "Daddy's Little Girls" is no exception, boasting a superb 7.1 PCM uncompressed audio track at 48kHz/16-bit/9.6mbps. While the film's low-key drama, romance, and comedy elements might not immediately suggest the need for such an expansive surround capability, the audio design enriches the viewing experience with subtle and nuanced ambient effects. From the gentle rustling of wind through a cemetery to the vague chatter in a courthouse, the surround channels subtly enhance the setting, despite a general scarcity of discrete effects.
The track exhibits impressive dynamics, especially noticeable during the various R'n'B interludes that populate the film. The bass response is tight and clear, ensuring snare hits retain a punchy clarity while allowing the overall soundscape to remain rich and mellow. However, dialogue levels can initially seem subdued, particularly in quieter scenes such as those set in Willy's garage. Adjusting the overall volume slightly resolves this issue to ensure clarity throughout. Despite its understated sound design, one standout sequence underscores Perry’s effective use of audio: a slowly building scene transitioning from a car crash to a fistfight culminating in a riot, underscored beautifully by Sam Cooke's "A Change Is Gonna Come," showcases the power of multi-channel capability when all elements coalesce.
Despite its modest demands on the soundstage, "Daddy's Little Girls" benefits significantly from this high-fidelity audio presentation. While the track may not provide window-rattling bass or wall-shaking action, it surpasses expectations for similar genres, delivering a balanced, immersive experience that supports the film's narrative intentions with precision and subtlety. This Blu-ray audio makes the best of its format’s potential, offering a significant sonic upgrade to an otherwise restrained soundtrack.
Extra: 48
Lionsgate's Blu-ray release of "Daddy's Little Girls" boasts an extensive array of extras designed to satisfy fans and cinephiles alike. Tyler Perry's audio commentary is a thorough exploration of the film’s production, revealing behind-the-scenes nuances and Perry's filmmaking philosophy. Several featurettes, including "Tyler's Team: Cast and Characters" and "Introducing the McClain Sisters," delve into the casting and crew dynamics, highlighting Perry's collaboration with both seasoned actors and emerging talents. The unique challenges of shooting at the Georgia Aquarium are explained in "Atlanta Aquarium: Working Underwater," while "Conducting Chaos: The Riot Scene" breaks down the intricate staging of a key sequence. Additional content such as deleted scenes, gag reels, and an extended church scene provide further insight into the film's development and Perry’s creative process.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary by Tyler Perry: In-depth production details and filmmaking insights.
- Extended Church Scene: Full sermon footage.
- Atlanta Aquarium: Working Underwater: Details on filming at the Georgia Aquarium.
- Tyler's Team: Cast and Characters: Breakdown of characters and cast insights.
- Introducing the McClain Sisters: Interviews with the young actresses and cast members.
- Touring the Sets: Tour of the apartment sets with production designer Ina Mayhew.
- Conducting Chaos: The Riot Scene: Behind-the-scenes look at the riot scene.
- The Oakland Cemetery: Background on Atlanta's historic cemetery.
- Deleted Scenes
- Gag Reels: Compilation of humorous outtakes.
- Uncut: Craig Robinson's extended cameo scenes.
- More: Promotional content for Perry's sitcom "House of Payne."
Movie: 48
Tyler Perry's "Daddy's Little Girls" showcases his signature traits—heartfelt narrative laced with moral undertones and community-centric themes. Idris Elba stars as Monty James, a hard-working mechanic fighting to reclaim custody of his three daughters from his negligent ex-wife. While Elba’s performance is notable, the film suffers from Perry’s heavy-handed moralizing and predictability. Monty's relationship with Julia Rossmore (Gabrielle Union), a high-powered attorney, unfolds predictably amidst sentimentality, undercutting the emotional gravity with exaggerated melodrama. Despite genuine moments of emotion, the film’s didactic approach dilutes its impact.
Technically, Perry's direction lacks the finesse one would expect from a seasoned filmmaker. The film often feels like an elongated student project, marred by simplistic scene transitions and a visually uninspired aesthetic. The overtly sentimental score, lingering on scenes to manipulate audience emotions rather than letting them develop naturally, further hampers the narrative's authenticity. Monty's challenges are undermined by ill-timed humor, veering between dramatic gravity and trivial comedic moments, creating dissonance in tone and reducing the stakes of Monty's journey.
Performances are hit or miss; while the McClain sisters (Sierra, China, and Lauryn) bring a natural charm to their roles, and Union instills her character with conviction and presence, other performances—particularly Tasha Smith as the over-the-top ex-wife—seem misaligned. "Daddy's Little Girls" is emblematic of Perry's ambitions yet remains flawed in execution. It oscillates between inspirational drama and romantic comedy without finding a purposeful balance. However, Perry’s devotion to telling uplifting African-American stories is commendable, even if this installment falls short of fully realizing its potential.
Total: 53
"Daddy's Little Girls" on Blu-ray presents a mixed bag, both in terms of film quality and technical performance. Tyler Perry's attempt to navigate beyond his usual comedic personas towards more serious storytelling is commendable yet falls short of remarkable impact. Despite its well-meaning and occasionally insightful moments, the movie does not convincingly transcend into substantive filmmaking. However, fans of Perry's work may still find this Blu-ray release intriguing due to its superior audiovisual presentation.
Technically, the Blu-ray stands out with an unexpectedly superb video and audio quality. The visual presentation is sharp with vibrant colors, while the inclusion of a 7.1 PCM uncompressed audio track significantly enriches the sound experience. This rare audio feature, although underutilized within the context of the film, surpasses typical expectations for similar releases. Additionally, the Blu-ray offers a wealth of bonus features, proving to be valuable for fans and home theater enthusiasts alike.
In conclusion, "Daddy's Little Girls" on Blu-ray is an excellent purchase for established Tyler Perry fans due to its high-quality picture, superior sound, and abundant extras. For those new to Perry’s work or on the fence about his films, renting before committing could be a more prudent approach. As an audience, it's clear we might all benefit from lightening up and appreciating Perry's dedication to positive societal themes—even if his filmmaking remains a work in progress.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 80
The film has a nice warm tone, and while there are few truly vivid hues�see the purple-robed preacher standing in front of a red curtain or the interior of the blues club for exceptions�colors are fairly...
Audio: 80
There's a good bit of subtle ambience in the surrounds�street sounds, wind rustling though the cemetery, courthouse chatter�but there are very few discrete effects....
Extras: 50
In this commentary track, Perry discusses production details, the story's genesis, casting, and the freeing aspect of not having to simultaneously juggle being behind and in front of the camera....
Movie: 50
The film has heart, there's no doubt about that, but it trades genuine emotion for sentimental slush and goes all didactic on us in the process, spelling out its morals in oversized, too easy to read block...
Total: 50
If you're already a fan, Daddy's Little Girls is a no-brainer on Blu-ray, with excellent picture quality, a surprising (if underused) 7.1 uncompressed audio track, and a host of extra features....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Overall detail is about average for a new release, with the transfer exhibiting fine textures, although the sense of three-dimensionality is never breathtaking....
Audio: 80
In all honesty, the film's laid-back sound design and lack of action really doesn't require a soundtrack with such an expansive rear presence, but I certainly won't fault Lionsgate for going all-out on...
Extras: 40
It probably received such special placement on the standard-def set because it will appeal most directly to the core Perry fan-base that likes the more over-the-top, broad sense of comedy in his other...
Movie: 40
Daddy's Little Girls' feels at times almost like a full-length student film, present with little flourish, choppy scene transitions and performances that seem to succeed despite Perry, rather than because...
Total: 60
The results aren't particularly encouraging, but still 'Daddy's Little Girls' remains a well-meaning and occasionally perceptive comedy that's arguably at least a step in the right direction....
Director: Tyler Perry
Actors: Gabrielle Union, Idris Elba, Tracee Ellis Ross
PlotMonty, a hardworking mechanic and devoted father, dreams of providing a better life for his three daughters. Struggling to make ends meet, he faces constant challenges. One of his biggest battles is fighting for custody of his girls against his irresponsible ex-wife, Jennifer, who is in a relationship with a drug dealer. Monty desperately wants to shield his daughters from the negative influences surrounding them. He works tirelessly to prove he is the better parent and provide a stable home. His support system includes his loving mother and a loyal friend who offers wisdom and encouragement.
Monty's life takes a turn when he starts working as a driver for Julia, a high-powered, no-nonsense attorney. Initially, their worlds clash due to their vastly different backgrounds and personalities. However, as Julia witnesses Monty's dedication to his family, she becomes invested in his plight. Seeing an opportunity to make a difference, Julia agrees to help Monty in his legal battle for custody. As they spend more time together, they uncover mutual respect and understanding. Monty's determination to protect and nurture his daughters cements his resolve to overcome the obstacles in his path.
Writers: Tyler Perry
Release Date: 14 Feb 2007
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English