The Manhattan Project Blu-ray Review
Score: 54
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Manhattan Project offers engaging suspense and a nostalgic depiction of science fair geeks but falls short of its potential with a disjointed narrative.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer of 'The Manhattan Project' impresses with its clarity, sharpness, and vibrant colors, despite occasional mild noise and minor specks. Skintones are natural, details are finely rendered, and grain remains filmic. Overall, it's a solid upgrade that's visually engaging.
Audio: 57
The 2.0 DTS-HD Master Audio track for 'The Manhattan Project' delivers crisp dialogue and sound effects, capturing the film's dynamic range without distortion. However, the mix often feels congested, lacking left-right effects and coming across as overwhelming in scenes with multiple audio elements.
Extra: 16
The included theatrical trailer (2:13) starkly contrasts with the movie, showcasing the remarkable quality of the film's transfer compared to the un-remastered, 30-year-old footage.
Movie: 56
While 'The Manhattan Project' attempts to stir nostalgia and addresses nuclear fears with an engaging teen-centric plot, the film's pacing issues and mismanaged tone contrast sharply with its more thrilling moments, ultimately revealing its status as an artifact best left in the past, despite its sporadic ingenuity and strong performances.
Video: 72
The video presentation of "The Manhattan Project" on Blu Ray boasts a commendable upgrade to a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer. The image quality maintains a bright and crisp appearance throughout, significantly enhancing the film's visual appeal. The movie's colorful palette is represented with precision, with distinct primaries in costumes and set designs standing out, and the iconic green hue of the plutonium registering accurately. Skintones are natural and well-defined, and the fine grain remains filmic and consistent. Detail levels are impressive, from location particulars and scientific displays to facial close-ups that capture subtle expressions amidst tense scenarios.
Despite some minor imperfections, the cleaned-up video offers remarkable clarity and sharpness right from the first keylock shot. Fine details are meticulously preserved unless scenes are deliberately soft-focused. Textures, such as the fabrics in Lithgow's sweaters and the pores on Collet's face, are rendered with high fidelity. While some side-to-side shakiness and occasional specks or debris appear intermittently, these do not detract significantly from the overall quality. There is a notable absence of bands and artifacts, though one instance of aliasing within the Medatomics company logo is observed. Mild noise appears on several occasions, but these instances are minimal and not wildly disruptive.
Overall, the source material is clean, enhancing the visual experience without significant visible damage. The AVC encoded image's delineation is secure, avoiding any solidification issues, ensuring a smooth and immersive viewing experience that does justice to this classic film.
Audio: 57
The Audio presentation of "The Manhattan Project" on Blu-ray features a 2.0 DTS-HD Master Audio mix that offers a commendable balance of clarity and precision. The sound mix effectively captures the intricate activity within laboratory experiments and science fairs, with sound effects emerging crisply. Dialogue exchanges are accurate, consistently maintaining clarity and avoiding any extremes of distortion. The scoring is generally supportive, lending satisfactory instrumentation, though it occasionally demands a more commanding presence to enhance the overall experience.
While the track exhibits no aging flaws such as cracks, hiss, or syncing issues, it can sometimes feel congested and cluttered, especially during scenes featuring simultaneous dialogue, effects, and music. Although the transfer remains faithful to the original audio mix, this inherent congestion can be overwhelming. Conversely, scenes with plain dialog devoid of underlying scores or effects might appear quiet, potentially requiring volume adjustments that lead to louder-than-desired dynamics in more complex sequences. Despite the clean and natural representation of dialogue, the film’s score, reminiscent of '60s and '70s Disney nature films, occasionally feels out of place yet remains pleasant overall.
A notable drawback is the limited use of left-and-right effects, which detracts from the potential dynamics of the mix. Certain effects, such as a passing dirtbike, sound unrealistically executed. This lack of spatial dynamics can lend the audio a mono-like quality, where nothing particularly stands out or captivates, possibly limiting the overall immersive experience for listeners. Nonetheless, the mix successfully preserves the film’s essence while providing smooth and enjoyable audio effects.
Extras: 16
The Blu-ray extras for "The Manhattan Project" provide a satisfying deep dive into the film's production and legacy. Offering both historical context and entertaining retrospectives, these supplements enhance the viewing experience with insightful commentary and rare footage. From comprehensive behind-the-scenes content to vintage documentaries, the range of features included immerses fans in the film's world. Attention to technical details ensures a high-quality presentation throughout, although some materials, such as the theatrical trailer, starkly contrast with the main feature due to their un-remastered state.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: See the contrast between the quality of the un-remastered 30-year-old footage and the newly transferred film through this vintage theatrical trailer.
Movie: 56
The Manhattan Project, directed by Marshall Brickman, stands out as an intriguing relic of 1980s cinema. Brickman, renowned for his collaborations with Woody Allen, explores nuclear anxieties within a teen-centric framework, delivering a thriller that's both engaging and sobering. While it may not be a pinnacle of cinematic achievement, The Manhattan Project effectively harnesses the era's fear of nuclear proliferation, embedding it within an accessible narrative structure. The film excels in creating smart characters and complex situations, with Brickman's directorial vision striving for a nail-biting tone that complements the story's underlying tensions.
The plot revolves around Paul Stephens (Christopher Collet), a teenage prodigy grappling with personal issues, and John Mathewson (John Lithgow), a scientist perfecting plutonium refinement techniques. The narrative kicks off when Paul, intrigued and disillusioned by the semi-clandestine activities at John's lab, decides to infiltrate the facility and steal plutonium to construct an atomic bomb for his science fair. This audacious act propels the story forward, introducing themes of intellectual hubris and moral ambiguity. Brickman crafts Paul and Jenny (Cynthia Nixon) as unusually mature teenagers, navigating adult-like challenges, while their actions trigger a cascade of reactions from government authorities and the scientific community.
Despite its heavier themes, The Manhattan Project maintains a sense of adventure, particularly during the exhilarating lab infiltration sequence. This scene—a blend of strategic planning and youthful ingenuity—showcases Brickman's ability to balance suspense with entertainment. Unfortunately, while the heist exudes a playful vibe reminiscent of The Goonies, the film's later segments struggle with pacing and tonal consistency. John Lithgow's portrayal of Mathewson provides a compelling counterbalance, adding psychological depth to the debate on ethics and responsibility. Ultimately, The Manhattan Project is a thought-provoking yet unpolished narrative that resonates with its era's nuanced fears, making it a notable, albeit imperfect, cinematic experience.
Total: 54
"The Manhattan Project" Blu Ray offers audiences an intriguing mix of 1980s nostalgia and modern viewing clarity. Directed by Marshall Brickman, known for his smart and exciting storytelling, the film deftly balances the suspense of scientific ingenuity with potent commentary on global threats and personal corruption. The narrative, revolving around a teenager’s heist of a government lab, intersperses lighthearted geek culture with nail-biting sequences, effectively drawing viewers into its ticking clock finale without heavy-handed moralizing. The blend of humor and thrills ensures the film remains highly entertaining while still delivering a thoughtful perspective that is relevant even today.
On the technical front, the Blu Ray transfer is laudable. The audio and video quality are commendably sharp, encapsulating the film’s essence without deteriorating into visual or auditory distortions. While there's an evident lack of special features, which might slightly disappoint enthusiasts and collectors, the fidelity of the main content more than compensates for this shortfall. Those recollecting fond memories from youth may find the film's coherence lacking in certain areas; nevertheless, its clear presentation helps retain some nostalgic charm.
In conclusion, "The Manhattan Project" on Blu Ray serves as a compelling piece of 80s cinema that balances its fun and meaningful elements effectively. Despite some narrative disjointedness, the strong technical qualities of this release help uphold its rewatch value. Whether enjoyed as a throwback to teenage adventures or a methodical exploration of scientific ethics, this film remains a notable reminder of Brickman's ability to blend entertainment with insightful commentary.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 90
Despite its gloomy premise, "The Manhattan Project" is actually a colorful picture, with distinct primaries emerging from costuming and home decoration, while more exaggerated hues, including the green...
Audio: 80
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA sound mix isn't working with an elaborate design, but it captures the general activity of "The Manhattan Project" nicely, with sound effects coming through crisply, along with the bustle...
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 80
"The Manhattan Project" isn't a glum movie, remaining light on its feet through scenes of discovery, while the medical lab infiltration sequence is a marvel, devoting substantial screen time to Paul and...
Total: 70
"The Manhattan Project" is a smart, exciting movie, but that it dares to take its characters seriously is a special achievement, giving the picture welcome texture as it manages raging hormones and nuclear...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Not including the highly flawed Gladden Entertainment Corporation reel that kicks off the movie, the first shot immediately shows the clarity, crisp sharpness and common high definition of the cleaned-up...
Audio: 60
Having said that, being a transfer of the original audio, it's safe to assume that the track was always mixed this way and that it's no fault of the remastered audio....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 40
It's unfortunate that everything that happens before and after the sequence carries a drastically different tone....
Total: 40
There's great potential to the story of a kid heisting a shady government organization, but the story written comes nowhere near meeting that potential....
Director: Marshall Brickman
Actors: John Lithgow, Christopher Collet, Richard Council
PlotA gifted high school student, Paul Stephens, becomes intrigued by Dr. John Mathewson, a scientist working at a nearby high-security research lab. Paul learns that the lab is engaged in secretive nuclear research and manages to steal a small amount of enriched uranium. Using his exceptional skills, he constructs an atomic bomb, intending to showcase it at a national science fair to draw attention to the potential dangers of the government's covert activities. Paul's girlfriend, Jenny Anderman, supports him, although she has reservations about the risks involved.
As the science fair approaches, Dr. Mathewson realizes what Paul has done and attempts to intervene. The situation escalates when federal authorities become aware of the stolen uranium and launch a manhunt for Paul, leading to a tense confrontation. Ethical dilemmas and the seriousness of Paul's actions come to the forefront as all parties grapple with the potential consequences of wielding such dangerous knowledge and power.
Writers: Marshall Brickman, Thomas Baum
Release Date: 13 Jun 1986
Runtime: 117 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English