Golden Earrings Blu-ray Review
Score: 71
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Golden Earrings offers captivating performances from Marlene Dietrich and Ray Milland, despite far-fetched elements, making it an entertaining classic.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
The Blu-ray of 'Golden Earrings' offers a satisfying 1080p MPEG-4 AVC presentation in its original 1.37:1 aspect ratio. Despite minor scratches and fading at edges that affect black levels, sharpness and detail are commendable, highlighting the nuanced cinematography, even if back screen projections and makeup choices occasionally detract from realism.
Audio: 80
Presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono, the audio is clear and well-encoded, with dialogue consistently crisp and integrated ambient noises adding depth. Despite some echo in studio scenes, the track avoids hiss or pops, capturing the era's fidelity without age-related issues.
Extra: 60
David Del Valle's audio commentary, despite minor inaccuracies and mispronunciations, offers engaging insights into Mitchell Leisen's underrated directorial prowess, Ray Milland's ego post-Oscar win, and Marlene Dietrich's dynamic style, complementing the array of classic trailers from the Blu-ray extras.
Movie: 67
Golden Earrings blends adventure and comedy with captivating performances by Ray Milland and Marlene Dietrich, accentuated by notable production design, vivid cinematography, and a stirring score. Despite its lack of realism, the film's engaging plot, executed by Mitchell Leisen, offers charming escapism and showcases Dietrich's irresistible allure.
Video: 70
Kino Lorber's Blu-ray presentation of "Golden Earrings" is presented in 1080p high definition with an MPEG-4 AVC encode, adhering to the original 1.37:1 full-frame aspect ratio. Despite not utilizing a new restoration, the transfer remains commendable. While there are some light frame scratches during the opening credits, they vanish upon their conclusion. The video quality is respectable, characterized by a solid encode with minimal print damage or wear. The sharpness generally impresses, with details particularly striking in close-ups. However, there is some fading at the edges of the film which occasionally affects the black levels within the grayscale.
The film was photographed by Daniel L. Fapp using 35mm spherical lenses and exhibits standard yet effective cinematography. Notably, the presentation effectively captures a memorable tracking shot in the gypsy camp scene, emphasizing the active environment. Several outdoor scenes were clearly filmed on studio interior sets, assuredly conveyed in this Blu-ray format. Back screen projections are used for several vehicle and action sequences, integrating coherently without significant distraction.
Marlene Dietrich, despite heavy makeup and deglamorizing attire, continues to receive the glam treatment in her close-ups. Nonetheless, the makeup's darkness occasionally overshadows nuances in facial details. The image fidelity permits viewers to distinctly recognize Milland’s stunt double during certain sequences, evidencing the transfer's sharpness. While the Blu-ray is divided into 8 chapters, viewers will appreciate the attention to visual detail, though some fading along edges and unobtrusive scratches persist. Overall, this release offers a detailed and mostly clean viewing experience that preserves the film’s classic charm.
Audio: 80
The audio presentation of the "Golden Earrings" Blu-ray release is rendered in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono, delivering a noteworthy experience respecting the fidelity of its era. The audio is embraced by a lossless encoding which efficiently reproduces dialogue with clarity, maintaining an engaging quality throughout. This professional execution ensures that the soundtrack remains free from age-related disturbances such as hiss, crackle, or pops—an accomplishment that enhances the listening experience.
Although dialogue stands out for its clear reproduction, some studio-shot exterior scenes exhibit a slight echo, adding a particular texture to the audio but not detracting significantly from comprehension. Marlene Dietrich’s unique speaking style, which omits certain words, helps shape her character’s enigmatic presence. The vibrant ambient noise within the gypsy camp is skillfully interwoven with dialogue and lively dance music, fostering a rich audio atmosphere. This blend is further enriched with instrumental renditions of Golden Earrings and an exotic zither backdrop that anchors these scenes in an evocative soundscape.
Key musical elements include Murvyn Vye's performance of the eponymous song, which complements the film's narrative and setting. Dramatic sound effects, such as gunfire, resonate forcefully, underscoring the intensity of pivotal moments. Overall, Kino has delivered a robust and faithfully-tuned DTS-HD Master Audio track that serves to preserve and celebrate the original auditory artistry of "Golden Earrings."
Extras: 60
The Blu Ray of "Golden Earrings" offers a range of engaging extras that will appeal to cinephiles, particularly those interested in classic cinema. The standout feature is an audio commentary by film historian David Del Valle, who provides insightful, albeit at times disorganized, reflections on director Mitchell Leisen's contributions to the film and Hollywood at large. Del Valle praises Leisen's stylistic sensibilities and highlights the dynamics between stars Ray Milland, known for being headstrong post-Oscar win, and Marlene Dietrich, whose career and artistic evolution are discussed in depth. Despite occasional inaccuracies in Del Valle’s commentary, his passion is evident and enriches the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Film Historian David Del Valle: Offers insights into Mitchell Leisen's work and the dynamics of the cast.
- Golden Earrings – Trailer: Standard definition trailer.
- Desire – Trailer: High definition trailer.
- Seven Sinners – Trailer: Standard definition trailer.
- The Flame of New Orleans – Trailer: High definition trailer.
- Arise, My Love – Trailer: High definition trailer.
- The Lost Weekend – Trailer: Standard definition trailer.
- So Evil My Love – Trailer: Standard definition trailer.
- Death Takes a Holiday – Trailer: Standard definition trailer.
- No Time for Love – Trailer: Standard definition trailer.
Movie: 67
"Golden Earrings" is an unconventional film that successfully blends elements of adventure, comedy, and drama while managing to maintain an engaging narrative. Set in the tumultuous backdrop of pre-World War II Europe, it features outstanding performances, particularly from the charismatic Marlene Dietrich and the adept Ray Milland. Dietrich shines as Lydia, a gypsy whose fierce independence and captivating screen presence enhance the film's allure. The dynamic chemistry between Dietrich and Milland lends depth to their portrayal of an unlikely partnership set against the perilous journey through the Black Forest. Though the screenplay by Abraham Polonsky, Frank Butler, and Helen Deutsch might not offer groundbreaking twists, it provides a solid framework enriched by humor and intrigue.
Visually, "Golden Earrings" is an impressive production by director Mitchell Leisen, known for his storytelling prowess. Although the film relies on backlot simulations of German landscapes rather than authentic settings, the production design by Hans Dreier and John Meehan effectively conveys a sense of adventure with artistic flair. Noteworthy contributions from costume designer Mary Kay Dodson add a vivid sense of period authenticity. Additionally, Daniel L. Fapp's cinematography delivers compelling visuals that merge seamlessly with the film's narrative thrust, while Victor Young's musical score infuses charming, playful undertones that complement the visual storytelling.
The movie unfolds through flashbacks, providing anticipation yet revealing key facets of Colonel Ralph Denistoun’s escapades early on. The narrative choice might slightly diminish suspense but ultimately preserves audience engagement through skillful pacing by editor Alma Macrorie. Despite its occasional reliance on conventional techniques like rear projection, the film sustains a delightful sense of escapism enhanced by Dietrich's cultural performance interludes and powerful supporting roles. Overall, "Golden Earrings" stands as a vibrant cinematic relic marrying humor with espionage underpinned by thematic doses of romanticism and empowerment, ensuring its place among notable post-war cinematic curiosities.
Total: 71
"Golden Earrings" is a captivating blend of adventure and thrilling espionage with notable performances from its lead actors, Marlene Dietrich and Ray Milland. Despite occasional reliance on far-fetched storylines and stereotypical representations, the film's narrative remains engaging due to its energetic pacing and old-school charm. The chemistry between Dietrich and Milland sizzles throughout, making their performances a central highlight. Dietrich's portrayal, in particular, stands out as she pushes boundaries with her versatility and comedic flair.
The Blu-ray edition of "Golden Earrings" offers a commendable audiovisual presentation that maintains the integrity of the original cinematic experience. The video quality showcases the film's classic aesthetics, while the audio ensures clarity, despite the vintage source material. Presentation enthusiasts will appreciate the release’s classic artwork packaging, enhancing its appeal as a collector’s item. Fans of the film will certainly be satisfied with the quality offered in this edition.
In conclusion, "Golden Earrings" serves as an entertaining piece of 1940s cinema, underscored by standout performances and engaging storytelling. While some elements may feel outdated, the film’s allure persists, driven by its charismatic leads. The Blu-ray release is a valuable addition for enthusiasts seeking nostalgia and quality presentation, making it highly recommended for collectors and classic film aficionados alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 70
Though the release is not sourced from a brand- new restoration, this is a compelling and worthwhile scan of the film....
Audio: 70
The track doesn't suffer from any egregious hiss, crackle, pops, or clicks during the audio presentation....
Extras: 60
Audio Commentary by Film Historian David Del Valle Golden Earrings � Trailer (SD, 2:17) Desire � Trailer (HD, 2:50)...
Movie: 70
The screenplay by Abraham Polonsky (Body and Soul, Force of Evil), Frank Butler (Wake Island, Going My Way), and Helen Deutsch (The Unsinkable Molly Brown, The Glass Slipper) might not be the best of the...
Total: 60
...
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 80
Back screen projection is used for scenes of Denistoun and Byrd riding in the car, Byrd on a bicycle, and Lydia and Deniston on the horse-drawn gypsy wagon....
Audio: 90
Ambient noise in the gypsy camp is effectively blended with dialogue and enthusiastic dance music to create mood, and instrumental versions of Golden Earrings are heard throughout the film....
Extras: 80
Audio Commentary – Film historian and author David Del Valle provides a new commentary, speaking highly of director Mitchell Leisen, whom he refers to as a Renaissance Man, and believes he’s greatly underrated....
Movie: 70
A comedy-drama of the post-World War II era, it’s the tale of a military officer and his misadventures with a gypsy woman during the war....
Total: 80
But Marlene Dietrich’s uninhibited performance makes the film worth a look, as it reveals her ability to stretch herself in an unusual role and displays her comic talent....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 80
In most of the film, the sharpness is excellent (sharp enough to easily detect Milland’s stunt double in the long shots during the fight sequence) and details in the close-ups quite fetching (of course,...
Audio: 100
Dialogue has been professionally recorded and is never overpowered by the background score or the numerous sound effects....
Extras: 50
Along the way, there is some misinformation present (Bing Crosby did not win the Oscar for The Bells of St. Mary’s) and a number of mispronunciations of people’s names to contend with....
Movie: 70
Screenwriters Abraham Polonsky, Frank Butler, and Helen Deutsch have elected to tell the story in flashback spoiling any surprise about Denistoun’s survival but leaving some twists and turns to delight...
Total: 70
Though they may not have gotten along off camera, Ray Milland and Marlene Dietrich heat up the screen with excellent chemistry in Mitchell Leisen’s espionage romp Golden Earrings....
Director: Mitchell Leisen
Actors: Ray Milland, Marlene Dietrich, Murvyn Vye
PlotThe story begins in post-World War II London as Colonel Ralph Denistoun recalls a pre-war mission in Nazi Germany. While attending a dinner party, he notices a pair of gold earrings, which triggers memories of his past. The film transitions into Denistoun’s flashback, revealing how he and his fellow officer, Lt. Richard Byrd, were on a covert assignment to obtain crucial military secrets stored in a laboratory in Germany. During their mission, the duo encounters numerous challenges, eventually having to evade capture by fascist authorities. In their desperate bid to escape, the officers stumble into the camp of a Gypsy woman named Lydia.
Lydia is free-spirited and enigmatic, offering assistance to the fugitive Englishmen. She helps them disguise as Roma by altering their appearances, including convincing Denistoun to pierce his ears and wear gold earrings to complete his guise. Lydia’s knowledge of the land and local customs becomes invaluable as they navigate the perilous route back to safety while avoiding Nazi patrols. She and Denistoun develop a unique bond, affecting his worldview and inspiring him in unforeseen ways. As their journey unfolds, they face growing dangers and betrayals, creating tension between loyalty to their cause and personal desires. Denistoun's recount is a reflection of love and duty set against the dangerous backdrop of wartime espionage.
Writers: Abraham Polonsky, Frank Butler, Helen Deutsch
Release Date: 27 Aug 1947
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English, German