Being John Malkovich Blu-ray Review

Spike Jonze's Being John Malkovich, presented in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, has undergone a meticulous 1080p transfer using MPEG-4 AVC encoding. Supervised by Jonze and cinematographer Lance Acord, the digital transfer achieves a 4K resolution from the original 35mm camera negative using a DFT SCANITY film scanner. Color correction was expertly handled by Stefan Sonnenfeld on a DaVinci Resolve system at Company 3.

The high-definition transfer exhibits commendable qualities, closely resembling the organic textures expected from an older film transitioning to Blu-ray. The majority of close-ups display strong detail and sharpness, free from problematic denoising corrections and oversharpening artifacts. Contrast levels are generally stable, although brief sequences with fast cuts and zooms occasionally introduce mild softness and fluctuating clarity. Prominent grays, browns, and blues appear stable, though color saturation may also fluctuate intermittently. Despite minor inconsistencies, there are no significant transfer-specific anomalies or stability issues, making this a respectable upgrade from previous DVD editions.

However, some reviewers noted areas where the transfer falls short, particularly concerning detail levels in specific scenes. Issues such as blurring facial hair, inconsistent textures, weak black levels, and visible dirt and debris were highlighted. Edge definition can be problematic, especially on the film's iconic 7-1/2 floor scenes. Instances of noise, though not overly disruptive, were also mentioned. Despite a thorough 4K scan and extensive cleaning efforts, some reviewers were disappointed by residual imperfections, suggesting that the final product could have benefited from more meticulous restoration processes. Nevertheless, fans of the film should find this Blu-ray release an improvement over earlier versions despite these shortcomings.

The audio presentation on the Blu-ray release of "Being John Malkovich" utilizes a single English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that demonstrates a significant improvement over the previous DVD and HD DVD editions. This lossless track is meticulously mixed, providing a nuanced auditory experience that complements the film's surreal narrative. Dialogues are crisp, clear, and well-positioned, ensuring that they remain intelligible throughout various scenes. Notably, the audio mixing leverages the surround channels intelligently, especially during the 'entry ride' into Malkovich’s head, where the intense yet controlled use of surround sound dramatically enhances the viewer's immersion.

The audio’s room dynamics effortlessly transition from the confined quarters of the 7-1/2 floor to wide open spaces, offering robustness and clarity that elevate the viewing experience. The track makes particularly good use of environmental sounds to create an enveloping atmosphere; ambient noises vary impressively in correlation with different environments, from muffled voices to subtle background sounds. The more aggressive portal sequences exhibit a rich use of sound design, incorporating subtle bass elements that enhance the sensory experience without becoming overpowering.

In conclusion, with its high-fidelity DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, Criterion's Blu-ray release of "Being John Malkovich" delivers an exemplary audio experience that preserves the original intent of the filmmakers while significantly enhancing auditory detail and clarity. This robust and intelligently mixed track ensures that viewers are thoroughly engaged, whether through the clarity of dialogue or through immersive environmental sounds that heighten the surreal experience of the film. English SDH subtitles are also available for those who need them.

The Blu-ray edition of "Being John Malkovich" offers an extensive and fascinating array of extras that enrich the viewing experience. Notable features include insightful interviews, hilarious commentary, and unique behind-the-scenes glimpses that highlight the film's intricate production. Each extra is presented with meticulous attention to quality and content, ensuring a comprehensive understanding of the film's creative process. The selection ranges from technical discussions about marionette manipulation to candid interviews with the cast and crew. The well-curated collection provides both entertainment and educational value, making it a must-watch for fans and film enthusiasts alike.

Extras included in this disc:

• Trailer: Original theatrical trailer.
• TV Spots: Four promotional TV spots.
• An Intimate Portrait of the Art of Puppeteering: A short piece on marionette manipulation.
• American Arts & Culture Presents John Horatio Malkovich: Dance of Despair and Disillusionment: Faux mini documentary from the film.
• 7 1/2 Floor Orientation: Hilarious segment on the strange floor.
• Spike's Photos: Director Spike Jonze recounts the making of the film with photos.
• John Malkovich and John Hodgman: In-depth interview about the film's themes and production.
• All Noncombatants Please Clear the Set: Documentary on the filming process.
• Selected-scene Commentary: Commentary by Michel Gondry and Jeff Buchanan.
• Booklet: Illustrated booklet featuring a conversation between Spike Jonze and Perkus Tooth.

Spike Jonze's "Being John Malkovich" remains a seminal work in contemporary cinema, blending enigmatic storytelling with profound themes of identity, free will, and the commodification of privacy. The plot follows disillusioned puppeteer Craig, played astutely by John Cusack, who stumbles upon a portal into the mind of actor John Malkovich. The film spirals into a surreal narrative exploring vicarious living, unrequited love, and existential crises. Cameron Diaz and Catherine Keener provide noteworthy performances, enhancing the film's depth with their complex character portrayals.

Jonze's direction masterfully balances absurdity and realism, creating a whimsical yet sobering depiction of humanity's baser instincts. The film's striking accuracy in pre-empting contemporary issues like privacy invasion is both unsettling and enlightening. Additionally, Kaufman's script shines with its intelligent humor and philosophical undertones, ensuring the film stays relevant even beyond its 1999 debut. Ebert's acclaim as the best film of 1999 underscores its cultural impact.

Technically, the Criterion Blu-ray release is impeccable. The transfer maintains the film's original visual grit, with near-flawless detail and color accuracy. Complementing the presentation, Criterion includes valuable supplemental features such as interviews with Jonze and Malkovich and a selected-scene commentary by Michel Gondry. These additions provide crucial insights into the film's creation and thematic depth. In English with optional English SDH subtitles, this Region-A locked disc is a must-have for cinephiles and scholars alike, offering an enhanced viewing experience that enriches its already profound narrative.

"Being John Malkovich" on Blu-ray is a compelling experience that transcends typical cinematic boundaries, offering a film that is both hilariously surreal and poignantly introspective. Directed by Spike Jonze and written by Charlie Kaufman, this modern classic features a stellar cast led by John Cusack, Catherine Keener, Cameron Diaz, and of course, John Malkovich himself. The film’s unique narrative—centered on a portal into Malkovich’s mind—brims with quick, sharp wit and profound observations about identity and consciousness, maintaining viewer engagement from start to finish. Kaufman and Jonze have crafted an unparalleled cinematic duo, making "Being John Malkovich" a timeless masterpiece.

The Blu-ray edition of "Being John Malkovich" does not disappoint in terms of both content and supplemental materials. The technical quality of the transfer is impressive, providing crisp visuals and clear audio that elevate the viewing experience. The extensive special features offer valuable insight into the film's creation and thematic undertones. Highlights include a scene-specific commentary by Michel Gondry, an insightful interview between John Hodgman and John Malkovich, and several short films directly tied to the movie’s narrative universe. Additionally, the included documentaries and exclusive behind-the-scenes content enrich the viewer's appreciation for the film's artistic complexity.

In conclusion, "Being John Malkovich" remains a hilarious yet deeply sorrowful exploration of human nature, capturing absurd realities that resonate even more than when it was first released. The Blu-ray edition further extends the film’s legacy with its detailed supplemental section. After watching this brilliantly crafted movie, make sure to delve into the exclusive interview with John Malkovich – a fascinating exploration of the film’s prophetic elements. "Being John Malkovich" on Blu-ray is an essential addition to any film enthusiast’s collection. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.