Tomorrow We Live Blu-ray Review
Indicator Series | Limited Edition 4,000 copies
Score: 81
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Tomorrow We Live's Blu-ray release boasts a great 4K restoration, but lacks depth as a propaganda film despite strong performances and authentic attempts.
Disc Release Date
Video: 93
The Tomorrow We Live Blu-ray features an outstanding 4K restoration in its original 1.37:1 aspect ratio, offering vibrant and well-balanced visuals with impressive delineation, clarity, and depth. Minor fluctuations in some scenes are true to the original cinematography.
Audio: 83
"Tomorrow We Live" Blu-ray features a singular English LPCM 1.0 track, offering clear dialogue and distinct dynamic musical contrasts typical of the 1940s. Some background hiss is noticeable yet non-distracting, with no encoding anomalies noted.
Extra: 71
The Blu-Ray extras for 'Tomorrow We Live' offer enthusiasts a comprehensive experience with engaging audio commentary by critics, in-depth analysis of Greta Gynt's career, archival interviews with composer Roy Douglas, and an insightful illustrated booklet featuring essays and critical responses.
Movie: 54
George King's *Tomorrow We Live* (1942), restored in 4K by Indicator/Powerhouse Films, is a classic wartime propaganda film marked by its intentional caricatures and predictable narrative flaws. Despite engaging performances and significant historical context, its one-dimensional characters and clichéd plot limit its impact.
Video: 93
The Blu-ray release of "Tomorrow We Live" presents a visually impressive experience, thanks to a meticulous 4K restoration by Indicator/Powerhouse Films. The transfer, encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, maintains the film's original aspect ratio of 1.37:1 in 1080p resolution. This newly restored version showcases vibrant and healthy visuals that greatly enhance the film's original presentation. The clarity, depth, and delineation delivered through this transfer are consistently excellent, capturing the nuances intended by the original cinematographers.
Viewers will notice some minor variations in darker and well-lit scenes; these fluctuations are inherent to the initial cinematography rather than being artifacts of the restoration process. Moreover, the grayscale reproduction is remarkable, with blacks, whites, and grays appearing authentically balanced across all scenes. The precision in this restoration ensures that no distracting digital corrections are apparent, preserving the film's authentic cinematic texture.
Importantly, this Blu-ray release is Region-Free, ensuring accessibility on various players regardless of geographic location. The technical achievements captured in this release make "Tomorrow We Live" a superior visual experience for film enthusiasts and collectors alike.
Audio: 83
The audio presentation of the "Tomorrow We Live" Blu-ray features a single English LPCM 1.0 track. This track efficiently ensures clarity in all dialogues, allowing the audience to follow exchanges effortlessly. In true professional fashion, optional English SDH subtitles are also provided, catering to the needs of all viewers seeking enhanced accessibility.
While the sound presentation predominantly maintains coherence, there are instances where a subtle background hiss emerges, particularly during quieter scenes. Although this aspect becomes noticeable, it remains non-intrusive and does not detract from the viewing experience. These occurrences, typical of recordings from the 1940s, highlight the inherent limitations of historical soundtracks yet manage to preserve the film’s authenticity.
The musical score within this track showcases notable dynamic contrasts, especially commendable given the era of the film’s production. Overall, the audio transfer is free from encoding anomalies, suggesting a well-executed effort in preserving the original sound characteristics while providing a clean auditory experience for modern audiences. The technical fidelity and careful restoration reflect a quality dedicated to maintaining the auditory integrity of classic cinema.
Extras: 71
The Blu-ray extras for "Tomorrow We Live" offer an insightful and comprehensive exploration into the film's legacy. The disc features a rich audio commentary by critics Josephine Botting and Robert Murphy that unpacks the film's unique qualities with an informed perspective. Pamela Hutchinson's segment provides an engaging biographical look at Greta Gynt, illuminating her influence in cinema. Additionally, the BEHP archival interview with Roy Douglas is a highlight, offering firsthand recounts from the composer, enriching the viewer's understanding of the film's musical elements. An illustrated booklet adds depth with Philip Kemp's essay and a collection of archival interviews, articles, and technical credits, appealing to aficionados and newcomers alike. These extras create an immersive experience for anyone interested in the historical and contextual layers of "Tomorrow We Live."
Extras included in this disc:
- Image Gallery: A collection of original promotional materials for "The Whole Truth."
- Commentary: Exclusive new audio commentary by critics Josephine Botting and Robert Murphy.
- Pamela Hutchinson: Turning Heads: Critic Pamela Hutchinson discusses actress Greta Gynt's life and career.
- The BEHP Interview with Roy Douglas: Archival interview with composer Roy Douglas by critic Alex Gibson.
- Booklet: Illustrated booklet featuring Philip Kemp's essay, archival interviews, articles, critical responses, and technical credits.
Movie: 54
George King's "Tomorrow We Live" (1942), available on Blu-ray through Indicator/Powerhouse Films, encapsulates the archetypal traits of wartime propaganda cinema. Positioned in a German-occupied port town in Brittany, the narrative unfurls with Jean, a resistance fighter played by John Clements, seeking asylum and support from the local underground movement. The storyline develops around clichéd characters and predictable patriotism, a reflection of the film's nature and era. The film's main cast includes figures like Frisette and Marie, portraying resistance cooperation amidst the oppressive regime, albeit with simplistic character development. Despite efforts to craft an engaging drama, the execution feels lackluster, hampered by uninspired scripting and performances.
"Tomorrow We Live" stands out not just for its storytelling but also due to its visual pedigree, being shot by cinematographer Otto Heller. His work, renowned in prestigious titles like "The Ladykillers" and "Peeping Tom," adds a surprising layer of polish to the visuals of this otherwise modest production. However, despite the film’s technical merits, its handling of thematic elements and character portrayals veer into problematic territory. The Germans are depicted as almost caricature-like antagonists, overshadowing any semblance of nuanced conflict. This simplistic dichotomy between good and evil might have been avoided with more intricate narratives akin to other contemporary wartime films like "Commandos Strike at Dawn."
The Blu-ray edition introduces a pristine 4K restoration, enhancing visual clarity for modern audiences. Despite its lack of depth or memorability compared to other wartime narratives, the film's historical context and Indicator's thoughtful presentation make "Tomorrow We Live" a piece of cinematic history worth examining for its technical execution and role in the propaganda landscape of the 1940s.
Total: 81
The Blu-ray release of "Tomorrow We Live" from Indicator/Powerhouse Films offers a stunning 4K restoration, elevating the film's visual presentation significantly. Directed by German expatriate Otto Heller, known for his work on cinematic gems like "Peeping Tom" and "Alfie," this film is a straight-laced propaganda piece. Unfortunately, Heller’s contributions do not reach his usual high standards here, rendering the cinematography rather forgettable. Styled within the vein of a traditional propaganda film, "Tomorrow We Live" lacks the intricate quality of film noir's clandestine political thematics, diminishing its potential as a historical artifact or engaging narrative.
Yvonne Arnaud delivers the standout performance in the film as the single French actor amidst an otherwise English cast. Her poignant monologue about impending execution provides a striking emotional anchor, albeit in isolation. The staged defiance through the rendition of "La Marseillaise" is well-intentioned yet lacks the authenticity evident in classics like "Casablanca," where comparable scenes feature immigrant actors channeling genuine emotional weight into their performance. This comparison highlights a notable shortcoming in "Tomorrow We Live," where the predominantly English ensemble struggles to imbue their roles with the same visceral intensity.
While "Tomorrow We Live" may not captivate those seeking a compelling wartime narrative or a nuanced glimpse into era-specific sentiment, this Blu-ray release presents an opportunity to experience a highlighted example of period filmmaking, particularly with Arnaud's performance as its emotional core. Although it may falter in several cinematic respects, its restoration allows for preservation and reevaluation—qualities that situate it within the broader dialogue of wartime cinema. Ultimately, while lacking depth as a historical time capsule, it is worth a viewing for enthusiasts of restored classic cinema.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 100
In some areas, both darker and well-lit, minor fluctuations are noticeable, but they are introduced by the original cinematography....
Audio: 80
...
Extras: 60
Pamela Hutchinson: Turning Heads - in this exclusive new program, critic Pamela Hutchinson discusses the life and career of actress Greta Gynt....
Movie: 40
For example, while creating the conventional contrasts all propaganda films from the 1940s produced, the screenplay transforms all Germans into cartoonish characters, which is a major flaw that could have...
Total: 60
In America, for instance, a few of the big studios funded quite a few propaganda films that were disguised as film noirs, and many of them are great time capsules....
The Digital Bits review by Stuart Galbraith IVRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 95
Extras: 90
Movie: 75
Despite its misleading title, that likewise ensemble film operates from the same basic premise, though set in Nazi-occupied Norway....
Total: 89
Both films feature a defiant singing of La Marseillaise, the French national anthem; it’s infinitely more powerful in Casablanca even though in Tomorrow We Live the stakes are much higher....
Director: George King
Actors: John Clements, Godfrey Tearle, Hugh Sinclair
PlotIn a small French town during World War II, a band of brave resistance fighters tirelessly works to undermine the occupying Nazi forces. The group is led by the intrepid and determined Jean Baptiste Chauvin, a man whose cunning strategies keep the enemy on edge. Among his allies is an equally dedicated and stealthy priest, Father Robert Picard, who uses the façade of his religious duties to gather intelligence and pass critical information to the resistance. The bond between Chauvin and Picard fuels their commitment to liberating their country from the clutches of fascist rule.
Amidst mounting tension, the resistance fighters plan a daring mission to sabotage Nazi operations, aiming to cripple a strategic target critical for the enemy’s control. Risks intensify as their activities attract the scrutiny of Major Von Keller, a shrewd and relentless Nazi officer tasked with quelling the rebellion. As the cat-and-mouse game reaches a feverish pitch, allegiances are tested, and sacrifices are made in pursuit of freedom. The stakes become deadly as both sides gear up for a climactic confrontation that will determine the future of the town and its brave inhabitants. In this intense backdrop of war and resistance, individuals find themselves compelled to act decisively for their beliefs and country.
Writers: Anatole de Grunwald, Dorothy Hope, Katherine Strueby
Release Date: 20 Mar 1943
Runtime: 85 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United Kingdom
Language: German, French, English