Journey to Bethlehem Blu-ray Review
Score: 63
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Journey to Bethlehem's Blu-ray offers solid AV quality, but with its grating production and mediocre songs, it's best sampled before buying.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 75
The Blu-ray's 1080p/AVC encode, maintaining a 2.39:1 aspect ratio, reveals oversaturated colors and inconsistent contrast, with stable but often cheap-looking details due to original cinematography choices. Despite some crushed blacks and blown highlights, there's no significant noise, keeping distractions minimal.
Audio: 75
Journey to Bethlehem's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track delivers clear dialogue and vibrant songs with strong LFE, but lacks ambition overall, presenting a front-heavy soundscape with minimal surround activity during non-musical sequences typical for budget holiday musicals.
Extra: 31
The supplemental content of the 'Journey to Bethlehem' Blu-ray is limited, featuring brief EPK-style featurettes and three short deleted scenes, all presented in HD, that total less than 20 minutes despite initially promising more extensive offerings.
Movie: 41
Journey to Bethlehem, a faith-based musical directed by Adam Anders, struggles with inconsistent tone and takes significant liberties with the Nativity story, leaving viewers unsure of its intended audience. While Fiona Palomo shines as Mary, the film's over-the-top performances, uncatchy musical numbers, and modern rom-com elements detract from its narrative integrity.
Video: 75
Sony’s Blu-ray release of "Journey to Bethlehem" offers a 1080p/AVC-encoded video transfer that is adequate, reflecting the original photography's constraints. The color palette predominantly features browns and yellows, often oversaturating, which causes skin tones to fluctuate between vivid oranges and muted yellows. Occasionally, the colors dim excessively, lending a washed-out appearance under the desert's intense glare. Black levels vary in quality, with some scenes exhibiting crushed blacks or blown-out highlights. The detail generally captures the film’s aesthetic but sometimes highlights the budget constraints, particularly in props and set design.
Despite these issues, edge definition remains precise, maintaining overall clarity with crisp lines. This presentation adheres to the original theatrical aspect ratio of 2.39:1, ensuring that technical purity aligns with the intended directorial vision. Fortunately, there are no significant occurrences of banding, blocking, or noise, ensuring an undistracted viewing experience. For audiences who appreciate the film, these visual aspects remain unobtrusive, allowing for immersion without technical distractions, even if they don’t elevate the film's production value significantly.
Audio: 75
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track for the Blu-ray presentation of "Journey to Bethlehem" offers a competent yet occasionally underwhelming audio experience. Dialogue remains consistently clear and well-centered, ensuring that vocal clarity is maintained throughout both musical and non-musical sequences. The singing performances notably shine through, with dynamics that stand out amidst the more simplistic soundscape. However, the non-musical parts tend to be overly reliant on front-channel output, presenting a sound field that lacks depth and immersive engagement.
Musical segments considerably enhance the mix, capitalizing on stronger surround activity and providing a more enveloping auditory experience. While LFE output maintains a solid presence, particularly during musical numbers, it sometimes crosses into overtly punchy territory. This heightened bass can inadvertently obscure vocals, detracting from the clarity essential to a musical soundtrack. The rear channels generally fail to fully utilize their potential, contributing to an overarching sense of two-dimensionality during quieter scenes.
Overall, while the audio track succeeds in certain areas, such as dynamic vocal clarity and robust LFE during musical pieces, it falls short in immersive sound distribution, particularly during dialogue-driven scenes. The resulting experience aligns with typical expectations for low-budget holiday musicals, where the energetic delivery of songs contrasts with less engaging dramatic and comedic elements. A more ambitious sound design could have elevated the overall auditory experience, creating a more thoroughly engaging mix for audiences.
Extras: 31
The Blu-Ray release of "Journey to Bethlehem" makes a promising suggestion of extensive supplementary content; however, it falls short of expectations. The extras presented are brief, totaling just under 20 minutes, and primarily consist of studio-promotional Electronic Press Kit (EPK) shorts. These segments include deleted scenes and concise character featurettes, each featuring a disclaimer noting that all cast interviews were completed before the SAG/AFTRA strike. While these may serve as modest introductions to the film's characters and behind-the-scenes elements, they lack depth and breadth. The content is at least delivered in HD, which lends some visual polish to the otherwise superficial features.
Extras included in this disc:
- Meet Mary & Joseph: A brief EPK with actors discussing their characters.
- Deleted and Extended Scenes: Three scenes providing minor additional context.
- The Heart of The Journey to Bethlehem: EPK-style behind-the-scenes insights.
- Meet Fig: Kid-focused EPK on working with the donkey.
- Meet Mary’s Sisters: Quick EPK with actresses discussing their roles.
- Meet Antipater: An EPK segment featuring Joel Smallbone discussing his role.
Movie: 41
"Journey to Bethlehem," directed by Adam Anders, is an ambitious attempt to bring a modern musical twist to the Nativity story. Unfortunately, Anders’ debut as a director reveals a clumsy execution that struggles to balance faith-based narrative with contemporary musical elements. The film’s rendition feels overtly contrived; from the awkward "meet cute" between Mary (Fiona Palomo) and Joseph (Milo Manheim) to the vibrant but jarring pop-infused score. Overshadowing the narrative, the musical stylings fail to resonate meaningfully, leaving many songs flat and lacking any memorable impact.
Despite some potential, "Journey to Bethlehem" suffers from inconsistent tone and structural liberties with the source material. Antonio Banderas’ portrayal of King Herod exemplifies this discord, as his over-the-top performance seems more suited for theatrical comedy than a serious retelling of biblical events. Besides Banderas, notable performances like that of Fiona Palomo are rare bright spots, yet they’re insufficient against the film's broad contextual shifts and questionable depictions, such as the outlandish inclusion of Antipater and the exaggerated presence of the heavenly host witnessed by Herod.
The film further falters due to a production design that seems to struggle with authenticity, leaning towards caricature rather than contextually accurate depictions of the Nativity setting. Coupled with uneven pacing and underwhelming dialogue, the audience is left questioning its target demographic. Overall, while Anders aims to create an inventive retelling of a timeless tale, the film misses the mark in delivering a compelling narrative that appeals coherently to both faith-based audiences and those seeking a refreshing take on a historic epic.
Total: 63
"Journey to Bethlehem" brings forth a modern retelling of the Nativity Story infused with musical elements. Although well-intentioned, the film delivers a mixed experience. While its narrative, designed to appeal to a broad audience, contains fundamental deviations from the traditional tale, it does so with a harmless intent. Notably, Antonio Banderas' performance is pointedly theatrical, at times overshadowing the film's essence, while the music largely remains unremarkable.
On a technical front, Sony's Blu-ray release of "Journey to Bethlehem" excels in the audiovisual department. The disc provides a solid and faithful representation of the video and audio, ensuring viewers can experience the vibrant colors and soundscapes intended by the creators. However, the lack of substantial special features is a notable shortcoming. It leaves audiences wanting in terms of exploring the film's production depth or behind-the-scenes insights often appreciated by true enthusiasts.
In conclusion, while "Journey to Bethlehem" may not resonate with everyone, especially those expecting a more traditional or refined storytelling approach, it could find favor among fans of Hallmark-style productions. Its innovative take on an age-old story, although flawed by some aspects of execution, is released with commendable technical quality that accentuates what strengths it possesses. It is advisable for potential viewers to watch it first before deciding on a purchase, as enjoyment can be subjective and reliant on personal taste preferences.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 80
It's all as it's intended, there aren't any significant instances of banding, blocking or noise to point to, and those who enjoy the film will find little of anything amounts to a distraction....
Audio: 80
It's all par for the course as low budget holiday musicals go, I suppose, but it would have been nice had the comedy and drama rose to the occasion as energetically as the songs....
Extras: 30
Included are three short deleted scenes -- "A Great Navigator", "Travel Montage" and "Joseph's Catapult" -- alongside a quick, studio-promo-style EPK called "The Heart of Journey to Bethlehem" and four...
Movie: 40
There are a handful of more somber selections that allow a bit of insight into the struggles of Mary and Joseph, but then it's right back to the yuk yuk, isn't the wiseman in red so funny!?...
Total: 60
Based on audience scores and a bizarre critical kindness shown to the film, I've been too tough....
Home Theater Forum review by Todd ErwinRead review here
Video: 80
IMDB.com says very little regarding the technical specifications for Journey to Bethlehem, but it is probably safe to assume that it was shot with digital cameras and completed as a 2K digital intermediate...
Audio: 80
Non-musical portions are very front-heavy with minimal surround activity, but when the songs kick in, the surrounds pick up, although I found that LFE levels were a bit too punchy, with deep bass often...
Extras: 40
Meet Fig (1080p; 2:10): This one is aimed at the kids, as Milo Manheim discusses working with the donkey who played Fig....
Movie: 50
First-time director Adam Anders, whose background is as a music producer for Glee, Rock of Ages, and Captain Underpants: The First Epic Movie, tries to bring a modern musical approach to the story, even...
Total: 60
This modernized musical retelling of the Nativity Story is harmless but also strays a bit from its source material with mostly forgettable songs and an over the top performance by Antonio Banderas....
Director: Adam Anders
Actors: Fiona Palomo, Milo Manheim, Antonio Banderas
PlotIn a serene village of Nazareth, Mary, a young woman chosen for an extraordinary destiny, begins to see her life change when an angel appears with divine news. Engaged to Joseph, a kind and humble carpenter, Mary grapples with the overwhelming revelation of her miraculous pregnancy and the enormous responsibility it entails. Despite initial doubts, Joseph stands by Mary as they navigate the challenges posed by their family's skepticism and societal expectations. In a world filled with hardship and uncertainty, their unwavering faith and devotion form the foundation of their journey—both spiritual and physical—as they prepare for an impending decree from the Roman Emperor that will send them on a path unlike any they could have imagined.
The couple embarks on a demanding journey to Bethlehem to comply with the emperor's census, setting the stage for a series of encounters that test their resolve. Along the way, they face numerous trials, including treacherous terrain and encounters with individuals both benevolent and sinister. Each challenge deepens their bond and furthers their understanding of the profound role they are destined to play. Amidst these trials, divine interventions offer guidance and protection. Their odyssey culminates in Bethlehem, where a humble stable becomes the backdrop for a momentous event that will alter history. As stars align and ancient prophecies inch toward fulfillment, their journey unfolds into an enduring tale of hope, love, and the extraordinary miracle at the heart of their travels.
Writers: Adam Anders, Peter Barsocchini
Release Date: 10 Nov 2023
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English, French