The Protector Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "The Protector" under the Dragon Dynasty label arrives with a 1.85:1 1080p AVC encoded image that showcases a mix of high-quality technical aspects and some noticeable deficiencies. The colors are vibrant with a wealth of detail that makes the majority of the movie visually appealing. Specifically, scenes like the sprinkler fight sequence offer impressive clarity and vivid color reproduction, particularly in the greens. However, certain segments experience diminished contrast, such as the fiery battle sequence, which appears hazy and lacks definition.

While there are moments when the transfer excels, there are also periods marred by evident shortcomings. Sporadic grain and inconsistent noise levels can be intrusive, and skin tones often adopt an unnatural reddish tint. Additionally, a peculiar blurring effect, which seems to intentionally focus on certain portions, becomes increasingly distracting as the film progresses. Such issues are present in both the Thai and Weinstein cuts, suggesting that these flaws may stem from inherent characteristics of the original material.

Despite these mixed aspects, this Blu-ray transfer remains a significant improvement over Dragon Dynasty's previous releases like "36th Chamber of Shaolin" and "The Killer." While it is not without its flaws, "The Protector" presents enough high-definition fidelity to satisfy fans of Tony Jaa's martial arts epic, though discerning videophiles might find the inconsistencies frustrating.

The audio presentation for "The Protector" Blu-ray features a mix of both lossless and lossy formats, each offering distinct auditory experiences. The U.S. cut boasts a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix in both Thai and English, an exceptionally robust track that delivers an immersive sonic experience complete with the cracks, pops, thuds, and smashes that martial arts aficionados anticipate. This track significantly utilizes LFE, creating a bass-heavy environment without being overwhelming. Dialogue clarity is maintained, though ADR is occasionally noticeable. Note that the Blu-ray defaults to a Dolby Digital 5.1 mix, requiring manual toggling to access the superior DTS-HD MA track.

The Thai version, unfortunately, is limited to a Dolby Digital 5.1 mix, which while decent, lacks the depth and range of the lossless counterpart. Here, we experience clear channel separation and dynamic shifts in volume that respect the film's high-energy sequences. Directionality is pronounced, particularly during the quad and motorboat chase scenes, adding authenticity to the action. Bass rumbles are present but subdued compared to the DTS-HD MA track, and dialogue may occasionally sound flat, particularly during high-pitched or intense moments.

When contrasting the U.S. theatrical cut and the uncut Thai version, the difference in audio quality becomes starkly evident. The theatrical cut’s DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix, featuring a score by the RZA, immediately demonstrates elevated bass levels and a more modern, powerful soundscape. This added depth transforms familiar scenes into a heightened auditory experience, although at the cost of occasionally overpowering other sound elements. Conversely, the Thai cut maintains a more moderate audio profile, with less pronounced bass and more recycled sound effects during fight scenes. Both versions exhibit moments where dialogue can be shrill but remain overall impactful in delivering a classic martial arts audio experience.

The Blu-Ray extras for "The Protector" provide an enriching experience for martial arts enthusiasts and film buffs alike. The standout feature is the uncut original Thai version of the film, which offers enhanced context and character development, a crucial addition for those familiar only with the U.S. cut. Bey Logan’s audio commentary on the U.S. version is compelling and deeply informative, although some may find his enthusiasm overbearing. The disc also presents a series of SD featurettes, including Tony Jaa's demonstrations of Muay Thai techniques, insights into his stunt work without wires, and interviews that delve into the film's thematic elements and production challenges. Overall, while some extras can be slightly frustrating due to resolution changes and superficial coverage, they collectively offer a comprehensive look behind the scenes.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Bey Logan's detailed analysis on the theatrical cut.
• Tony Jaa Martial Arts Demonstration: A display of Muay Thai techniques.
• No Wires Attached: Details on performing stunts without artificial help.
• Making Tony Jaa: Interviews and insights into Jaa's martial arts training.
• Deleted Fight Scene: An omitted violent scene from the film.
• Theatrical Trailer: The American trailer in standard definition.

"The Protector," originally titled "Tom-Yum-Goong" and known in various international markets as "Warrior King" and "Revenge of the Warrior," is a quintessential high-energy martial arts film featuring Tony Jaa, a Muay Thai master. In this cinematic offering, Jaa partners with director Prachya Pinkaew, his collaborator from "Ong Bak." The plot follows Kham (Jaa), a royal guard and elephant trainer, whose beloved elephants are kidnapped to Sydney, instigating a relentless quest by Kham to bring them back, battling both Thai underworld criminals and crooked cops along the way. Though the U.S. release lacks logical coherence compared to the original Thai version, it compensates with astonishing, wire-free fight sequences that highlight Jaa's exceptional athleticism and martial arts prowess.

The standout aspect of "The Protector" lies in its intense action choreography, where Tony Jaa's raw physicality is on full display without relying on CGI or stunt doubles. The film features breathtaking scenes like the extended take through Tom yum goong restaurant, which seamlessly integrates relentless action with innovative camera work. Each fight scene is meticulously staged, from duels with fluorescent tube-wielding cyclists to massive brawls against towering musclemen. Director Pinkaew’s preference for long takes amplifies the visceral experience, avoiding clichés like slow motion or excessive editing. This approach lets viewers fully appreciate Jaa's fluid movements and complex stunts, making "The Protector" a parade of exhilarating martial arts spectacles.

While the American cut of the film truncates much of the character development and subplots found in the Thai release—resulting in a leaner, more action-dense narrative—the movie remains a compelling showcase for Tony Jaa. His iconic performance reaffirms his position as a successor to action legends like Jet Li and Jackie Chan, combining innocent charm with unparalleled fighting skills. This Blu-ray offers both versions, allowing audiences to choose between a more comprehensive storyline or non-stop martial arts action, catering to different viewing preferences.

The Protector (Tom yum goong) stands as a testament to Tony Jaa’s extraordinary martial arts prowess, albeit within a narrative framework that often sacrifices coherence and continuity, particularly in the U.S. theatrical version. The dichotomy between the self-indulgent Thai cut and the trimmed U.S. version presents a complex viewing experience where the former offers extended scenes at the price of pacing, while the latter struggles with narrative clarity. Despite these discrepancies, the bone-crunching action sequences are indisputably thrilling and remain the film's primary draw.

On the technical front, this Blu-ray release by Vivendi delivers an exemplary transfer that serves the film’s high-octane sequences well. Although some video concerns may trace back to the original source material, the overall visual presentation is solid and enhances the visceral impact of the combat scenes. Audio quality varies between versions, adding another layer of inconsistency; however, it generally provides a robust accompaniment to the on-screen action. The supplement package merits mention for its quality, making up for its somewhat limited scope with valuable insights and behind-the-scenes content.

In conclusion, The Protector, in its heavily edited U.S. theatrical version, leaves coherence and continuity on the cutting room floor. It's still a knock-your-socks-off entertainment, full to overflowing with the bone-crunching action that martial arts fans love. Vivendi has finally done one of their Dragon Dynasty releases service by providing an excellent transfer and some excellent supplements. Let's hope they've finally come to their senses and this is the beginning of a whole slew of great releases.