Philomena Blu-ray Review
Score: 64
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Philomena is a profound journey and well-acted drama with quality production, highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
Anchor Bay's 'Philomena' Blu-ray combines pristine digital and gritty 16mm footage with flawless clarity and natural colors, ensuring a visually cohesive, detailed presentation without noticeable flaws.
Audio: 70
Philomena's DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack delivers clear, dialogue-focused audio with rich music, subtle ambient effects, and authentic sounds, ensuring a deeply immersive experience without overpowering effects.
Extra: 36
Philomena's bonus features include a UV copy, engaging commentary from Coogan and Pope, insights from Judi Dench, a glimpse into the real Philomena Lee's story, and a detailed Q&A with Coogan.
Movie: 76
'Philomena' explores the emotional search for closure and identity, blending pain with hopeful resolution, underscored by powerful performances.
Video: 70
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Philomena" by Anchor Bay is an exemplary model of how to handle films that intertwine digital and film media, showcasing a seamless blend of contemporary digital clarity with nostalgic film textures. The Arri Alexa cameras deliver the modern-day sequences with impeccable detail, featuring deep blacks and consistent contrast throughout, which harmonize beautifully with the well-balanced skin tones. The majority of the movie benefits from this high level of clarity and detail, ensuring each frame from the modern narrative is delivered with a glossy finish that isn't overly done, preserving an impressive amount of detail without sacrificing the natural feel of the scenes.
Conversely, the integration of the 16mm and 8mm film for Philomena's flashback scenes and 'home movie' footage introduces a richer, grainier quality that evokes a sense of time passed without creating a visual disconnect from the digital sequences. These segments exhibit a heavy grain indicative of their respective mediums, yet are meticulously color-balanced to align with the digital footage, ensuring a cohesive visual experience across the entire film. The flashback scenes achieve a softer, almost dreamlike aesthetic, maintaining soft yet stable color schemes and a consistent level of definition that complements the contemporary footage well.
Throughout, the video presentation avoids common pitfalls like banding, aliasing, or other compression artifacts, presenting a clean and uninterrupted visual experience. The dual presentation styles – the clean, detailed digital photography for the contemporary story and the deliberately grainier, nostalgic film footage for the flashbacks – are both rendered with remarkable proficiency. Anchor Bay's Blu-ray enhances both aspects, with deep and true black levels, naturally consistent flesh tones barring some intentional warmth in lower-light scenes, and a color palette that stays true to life across varied lighting conditions. This Blu-ray incarnation admirably reflects the film's narrative dichotomy through its technical finesse, providing viewers with a visually rich and immersive experience.
Audio: 70
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack of "Philomena" provides an audio experience that is both subtle and complex, perfectly complementing this dialogue-driven narrative. The clarity and spaciousness of the music are standout features, offering a robust and smooth listening experience without stepping into aggressiveness. Ambient effects are seamlessly woven into the fabric of the film's soundscape, placing listeners directly within a variety of settings from a bustling 1960s carnival to a lively modern-day hotel restaurant. The authenticity of minor sound details, such as creaking floors, adds a layer of immersion that is both impressive and enhancing to the overall viewing experience.
Dialogue in "Philomena" is crisp and natural, emanating mainly from the center channel but enriched by a light reverberation that lends depth to specific scenes, like those within the Lincoln Memorial. This meticulous attention to vocal clarity ensures that every word is heard as intended, pivotal for a film where spoken words carry much of the narrative weight. Alexandre Desplat's Oscar-nominated score is another highlight, its emotional resonance given the breadth and depth it deserves through the careful audio mix, making its presence known without overwhelming the dialogue or ambient sounds.
In addition to the primary English DTS-HD Master Audio track, this Blu-ray release includes a French 5.1 Dolby Digital track and offers subtitles in English SDH and Spanish, catering to a broader audience. Though the film might seem like a straightforward conversation piece on the surface, the audio presentation here does an excellent job of subtly enhancing the storytelling without drawing undue attention to itself. It's a testament to the thoughtfulness put into this aspect of the film's Blu-ray presentation, ensuring a thoroughly enjoyable and immersive auditory experience.
Extras: 36
The "Philomena" Blu-ray extra features offer a multifaceted glimpse into the making of the film, its real-life inspiration, and the creative minds behind its success. Notable is the audio commentary by Steve Coogan and Jeff Pope, providing an in-depth look into the narrative choices, scene construction, and thematic underpinnings of the film. It stands out for its comprehensive exploration of both macro and micro elements of film-making. Additionally, the disc includes personal insights from Judi Dench about her illustrious career, though curiously omitting direct references to "Philomena." Moreover, a featurette on the real Philomena Lee adds a poignant, authentic touch to the extras, grounding the film's narrative in reality. A Q&A session with Coogan further enriches the disc, offering direct engagement with the film's co-writer and star. These components collectively enhance the viewing experience, providing meaningful context and background that fans of the film will surely appreciate.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insightful commentary by Steve Coogan and Jeff Pope detailing the filmmaking process.
- A Conversation with Judi Dench: An interview segment with Dench reflecting on her career.
- The Real Philomena Lee: A featurette including both a story recap and an interview with Philomena Lee.
- Q&A with Steve Coogan: A moderated session providing deeper insights into the film's development.
Movie: 76
'Philomena,' directed by the commendably skilled Stephen Frears, is a cinematic journey that intricately weaves together elements of mystery, friendship, and personal evolution against a backdrop of real-life events. This film, which has garnered notable admiration including four Academy Award nominations for Best Picture and Best Actress, showcases the talents of Judi Dench and Steve Coogan in roles that are both profound and heartfelt. Dench's portrayal of Philomena Lee captures the essence of a woman whose unwavering faith and innate kindness illuminate her decades-long search for her son, who was taken from her by the church's cruel decree. Steve Coogan, in a departure from his usual comedic persona, delivers a riveting performance as Martin Sixsmith, the journalist entangled in Philomena's story. Their quest, fuelled by hope and haunted by Church doctrines, takes them from Ireland to America, unraveling secrets that test their beliefs and the strength of their bond.
The narrative skillfully balances the heaviness of its themes with moments of lightness and humor, ensuring that the audience is engaged but not overwhelmed by the gravity of Philomena's plight. Frears masterfully directs the film with a visual subtlety that emphasizes the emotional depth of its characters, delving into their complex histories and motivations with finesse. This approach enriches the viewing experience, allowing for a deep connection to the characters' journey towards closure and redemption.
Central to 'Philomena' is its critique of organized religion and its effects on individuals like Philomena, juxtaposed with her unwavering faith. The film does not shy away from controversial topics, using Philomena's incredible story to explore broader themes of forgiveness, resilience, and the human spirit's capacity for renewal. Through its nuanced storytelling and sterling performances, 'Philomena' stands out as a compelling testament to the power of the human connection and the enduring strength of hope.
Total: 64
The Blu-ray release of "Philomena" encapsulates not just the technical elegance expected from a home cinema experience but also elevates the stirring narrative that the film unfolds. "Philomena" navigates through layers of mystery, emotional depth, and the intricate dynamics of human relationships to tell a compelling story of discovery, acceptance, and the indelible bond between a mother and her child. Anchored by sterling performances and buoyed by a direction that's both subtle and evocative, the film stands out as an exploration of personal journeys rather than a mere unraveling of a mystery. The Blu-ray edition compliments this narrative beautifully with its superior video and audio quality, ensuring that the film's nuanced storytelling and character portrayals are experienced in the best possible format.
Moreover, the package is enriched with several supplements that offer deeper insights into the crafting of this poignant tale. While "Philomena" might not have broken new ground in storytelling—its roots in true events notwithstanding—it's undeniably lifted by its heartfelt performances and the sincerity of its narrative exploration. The acknowledgment from critics and audiences alike suggests that while it might have sparked debates over its Best Picture nomination, it certainly deserves recognition for the emotional resonance and superb acting delivered.
In conclusion, Anchor Bay's Blu-ray presentation of "Philomena" is commendable not only for its technical merits but also for preserving and highlighting the emotional, rich tapestry that makes the film notable. Whether it's regarded as a deserving award contender or not, the release ensures that viewers can deeply engage with the film's powerful narrative and exceptional performances in the best viewing quality available. Highly recommended for those who appreciate cinema that marries profound storytelling with stellar acting, "Philomena" is a worthy addition to any collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Black levels are deep and true, while flesh tones are likewise consistently natural, save for some of the lower-light scenes in which they take on the room's warmth....
Audio: 90
Dialogue plays smoothly and naturally from the center and enjoys a realistically light reverberation within the Lincoln Memorial as heard in chapter eight....
Extras: 50
Audio Commentary: Writer/Actor/Producer Steve Coogan and Screenwriter Jeff Pope deliver an even, interesting commentary that deals in a wide range of subjects, discussing film generalities and details...
Movie: 80
The film not-so-subtly challenges and incorporates controversial story points, including stringent religious ideals and personal lifestyle choices, but the film's pleasure comes from witnessing the characters,...
Total: 70
It's about an unlikely bond between two people in the physical realm and a mother's search for a bond with the child she barely knew....
High-Def Digest review by Shannon T. NuttRead review here
Video: 80
The flashback sequences, as you can imagine with 16mm, show a pretty heavy amount of grain, but have been properly color balanced with the rest of the movie so those sequences aren't too jarringly different...
Audio: 80
Extras: 30
– This is one of those Q&A sessions where the question or subject appears on-screen in a still, and then we see the person talking about the topic....
Movie: 80
Like many films of this type, much of the enjoyment has less to do with Philomena's search for her son, as it does the friendship that develops between her and Martin along the way....
Total: 70
It's arguable whether 'Philomena' was deserving of its spot among the Best Picture nominees; however, it is a well-acted character drama that is certainly worth a viewing, and perhaps even a spot in one's...
Director: Stephen Frears
Actors: Judi Dench, Steve Coogan, Sophie Kennedy Clark
PlotA retired Irish nurse named Philomena Lee harbors a deep-seated secret she has kept for fifty years: as a teenager, she became pregnant and was sent to a convent. In the convent, her baby was taken from her and given up for adoption in America, as was the case with many unwed mothers in 1950s Ireland. Philomena has spent her life wondering about the fate of her son, Anthony, whose memory she cherishes in silence, unable to overcome the Catholic Church's strict policies on confidentiality.
Decades later, Philomena's resolve to find her son is renewed on his fiftieth birthday. Through a twist of fate, she meets Martin Sixsmith, a former BBC journalist and recently dismissed government advisor, feeling adrift in his own career and life. Despite his initial reluctance and skepticism about human interest stories, Martin is drawn to Philomena's unshakable commitment to finding her son. The unlikely pair embark on a journey together, leading them to the United States. As they follow the trail of Anthony's life, an odd-couple relationship develops between the worldly cynic Martin and the gentle, optimistic Philomena, driven by her love and longing. Their search uncovers a deeply personal and emotional story, challenging both of them in unexpected ways.
Writers: Steve Coogan, Jeff Pope, Martin Sixsmith
Release Date: 27 Nov 2013
Runtime: 98 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom, France, United States
Language: English