King of Hearts Blu-ray Review
Le roi de coeur
Score: 78
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
King of Hearts' allegorical charm and fantastic performances are complemented by stellar video and audio quality, with excellent supplements making it a recommended release.
Disc Release Date
Video: 88
King of Hearts on Blu-ray boasts an exceptional 1080p AVC transfer derived from a new 4K restoration, featuring natural grain, vivid colors with a pastel quality, excellent black levels, and impressive detail. A few minor tints in the palette aside, the transfer offers a thoroughly immersive and reference-quality viewing experience.
Audio: 78
"King of Hearts" features a high-resolution LPCM 2.0 mono soundtrack primarily in French with English subtitles, delivering clear and clean audio with precise dialogue, effects, and Georges Delerue's expressive score. Despite mainly using front speakers, it maintains exceptional clarity and balance without distortion.
Extra: 57
The Blu-ray's extras offer a compelling array of features, including insightful interviews with Genevieve Bujold and Pierre Lhomme, a feature-length commentary by Wade Major, and exclusive packaging elements such as an O-Card slipcase and a collector’s booklet, making it a well-rounded package for enthusiasts.
Movie: 82
King of Hearts is a whimsical, anti-war film featuring vivid characters and a poignant message, enhanced by strong performances and epic cinematography. Despite mixed initial reception, it garnered a cult status through its emotional depth and surreal narrative, often drawing comparisons to other absurdist and subversive films.
Video: 88
The Blu-ray release of "King of Hearts" by Cohen Film Collection presents an outstanding viewing experience, built around a 4K restoration that is portrayed through an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio. The restoration efforts are evident, as the resulting image is remarkably clean, devoid of any major distractions due to damage or age-related issues. The well-grained field adds an organic touch that maintains integrity without any visible compression artifacts. The film’s color palette, although presenting a subtle cool tint at times, generally maintains an appealing aesthetic with a pastel quality that strikes a balance between vivid and natural tones. Flesh tones particularly stand out with their natural portrayal, despite a slight purplish tint observed in some scenes.
The depth and clarity achieved by this 4K restoration deserve special mention. The consistent detail is impressive, particularly in close-ups where facial features are accentuated to high levels of precision. Outdoor scenes benefit from this restoration with a natural light portrayal and enhanced depth of field that remains steady throughout. Contrast and sharpness are well balanced, ensuring that the image never appears soft or blurry. Black levels are rich and offer excellent separation, even in dimly lit or night scenes, while color reproduction remains bright and vivid without over-saturation issues. Thanks to these technical achievements, the video presentation avoids noise, dirt, artifacts, or banding, making it a standout example of classic film restoration done right.
Audio: 78
The Blu-ray presentation of "King of Hearts" is anchored by an LPCM 2.0 mono audio track, predominantly in French with occasional passages in English, accompanied by forced English subtitles. As highlighted in the commentary by Wade Major, a significant portion of the film was dubbed, given the multilingual cast. However, meticulous post-production looping ensures that sync issues are minimal. The dialogue is delivered cleanly and effectively without distortion or damage, bolstered by Georges Delerue's evocative score, creating a seamless auditory experience.
The high-resolution LPCM 2.0 soundtrack (48 kHz/24-bit) is self-contained to the front speakers, effectively balancing dialogue, music, and both on-screen and off-screen sound effects. This clear and precise delivery is further underscored by the absence of clipping or distortion, ensuring a pristine listening experience. The track's dynamics are robust, offering a vibrant audio presentation that remains true to the film's original sound design.
Dialogue reproduction is notably crisp, making the various spoken languages intelligible without issue. While the film predominantly presents French dialogue, the incorporation of German and English adds to the multilingual texture without compromising clarity. Overall, this LPCM 2.0 track provides an impressive and immersive auditory experience for "King of Hearts", complementing the film's visual narrative with finesse.
Extras: 57
The Blu-ray release of "King of Hearts" boasts an impressive array of supplemental content, providing an insightful and comprehensive look into the film. The highlight is an engaging feature-length audio commentary by renowned film critic Wade Major, known for his work with KPCC and DigiGods. It offers in-depth analysis and behind-the-scenes information. New interviews with key figures such as Geneviève Bujold and cinematographer Pierre Lhomme provide valuable anecdotes and biographical details, although Lhomme's English can be a bit challenging to follow. Additionally, there is an interview with Michelle de Broca that is presented in voiceover, exclusive to this edition. Rounding out the extras are trailers for the 2018 UK theatrical release and re-releases.
Extras included in this disc:
- Feature Length Audio Commentary by Wade Major: In-depth analysis and behind-the-scenes insights by KPCC and DigiGods critic.
- New Conversation - Genevieve Bujold and Anne Thompson: Bujold discusses her experiences with Indiewire's Anne Thompson.
- New Interview with Cinematographer Pierre Lhomme: Lhomme shares production anecdotes and biographical information.
- Interview with Michelle de Broca: Producer and ex-wife of the director discusses her experiences, exclusive to this edition.
- 2018 Re-Release Trailer: Preview of the re-release.
- French Re-Release Trailer: Preview of the French re-release.
Movie: 82
"King of Hearts" (1966), directed by Philippe de Broca, provides a visually captivating yet whimsically poignant depiction of war's folly, set against the backdrop of a deserted French village during World War I. The protagonist, Scottish soldier Charles Plumpick (Alan Bates), is tasked with diffusing a German-planted bomb, only to find himself amidst the escaped inmates of a local insane asylum. These vibrant characters assume the roles of the evacuated villagers, presenting a surreal, allegorical examination of sanity and the absurdities of warfare. The character dynamics, particularly the sweet but understated romance between Plumpick and Poppy (Geneviève Bujold), add an emotive layer that complements the overarching anti-war sentiment.
The film's thematic exploration positions it within the absurdist film movement, drawing comparisons to titles like "One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest" and "The Ninth Configuration." Employing the “Macguffin” plot device, de Broca crafts a narrative that veils its deeper anti-war critique beneath a façade of steady whimsy and rich visual splendor. The absurdity and satirical moments echo the spirit of Dr. Strangelove, resonating with audiences in 1960s America during the Vietnam War era. This historical context undoubtedly contributed to its initial cult following in Art House theatres, despite its lackluster reception in France.
The film’s aesthetic and performative strengths are bolstered by stellar performances from Bates and Bujold, alongside an ensemble cast of international character actors. Its succinct runtime of 1 hour and 40 minutes ensures a tight, impactful narrative that never overstays its welcome. Despite some overt allegorical tendencies, "King of Hearts" weaves an engaging tapestry that juxtaposes whimsy with profound social commentary, making it both a memorable and thought-provoking cinematic experience.
Total: 78
The Blu-ray release of "King of Hearts" is a compelling package that blends charming performances, high-quality technical specifications, and substantial supplementary features. Under the direction of Philippe de Broca, the film oscillates between light-hearted absurdism and earnest allegory, ultimately presenting a narrative that showcases the nuanced performances of its talented cast. While some may argue that the film's message and chaotic presentation are at times too overt and less effective as a cohesive narrative, these same elements lend a unique charm to individual scenes.
The quality of the Blu-ray transfer deserves special mention. The video and audio specifications are outstanding, offering a viewing experience that truly immerses the audience in the film's whimsical world. meticulously handled, ensures that UK audiences get to experience the film in its full glory. Additionally, the supplementary materials enrich the viewing experience: an insightful audio commentary by Wade Major, a 14-minute interview with Geneviève Bujold reflecting on the film's lasting impact, and a 24-minute interview with cinematographer Pierre Lhomme, albeit occasionally hard to understand, offer depth and context. The inclusion of both English and French re-release trailers rounds out a robust set of extras.
In conclusion, while some aspects of "King of Hearts" may divide opinions as to its ultimate effectiveness as an allegory or narrative, the film’s inherent goodness and emotional appeal are undeniable. This Blu-ray release, bolstered by top-notch technical merits and enriching supplementary features, comes highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 100
Cohen is touting a new 4K restoration for this feature, and the results are expectedly excellent, with a viewing experience free of any distractions stemming from damage or age related wear and tear, and...
Audio: 80
As Wade Major mentions in his enjoyable commentary, a lot of the film was dubbed since many of the actors didn't speak French, but de Broca was evidently a stickler for good post-looping, and so sync is...
Extras: 40
Feature Length Audio Commentary by KPCC and DigiGods Critic Wade Major New Conversation - Genevieve Bujold and Indiewire's Anne Thompson (1080p; 14:25) is a fun sitdown with Bujold, who kind of looks like...
Movie: 80
The film's anti-war message might have been more at home during the era of Hair, in fact, rather than a decade or so later, but even given certain contextual issues, King of Hearts relies on a curious...
Total: 80
I may invite the umbrage of fans of this film, but I'm not quite sure King of Hearts is the unmitigated masterpiece some of its most ardent proponents insist it is....
The Digital Bits review by David SteigmanRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 95
Extras: 80
Movie: 95
Plumpick, having also escaped, continues his mission to find the bomb, but with the help of the escaped inmates, including his love interest Poppy (Geneviève Bujold), who crowns him and refers to him as...
Total: 91
There are also two interviews: a 14-minute conversational piece with actress Geneviève Bujold, who is interviewed by IndieWire’s Anne Thompson and reflects upon the film, what it means, and why it’s still...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
The picture never looks soft or blurry thanks to the fine grain structure ever present throughout the whole film....
Audio: 90
The subtitles are forced, but you are able to watch the feature without subtitles by selecting that option in the main menu....
Extras: 60
An awesome audio commentary is provided by Wade Major (KPCC & DigiGods) and the trailer for the UK 2018 theatrical release of the film rounds out the supplemental features....
Movie: 80
There are also many scenes within King of Hearts that clearly suggest it belongs to the absurdist film movement while conveying a pretty heavy message at the same time....
Total: 80
On the surface, King of Hearts plays like an absurdist film, which it does have elements of, but the message behind the entire film is anything but absurd....
Director: Philippe de Broca
Actors: Alan Bates, Geneviève Bujold, Pierre Brasseur
PlotDuring World War I, a Scottish soldier named Private Charles Plumpick is tasked with disabling a bomb planted by retreating German forces in a small French town. Upon his arrival, he finds the town deserted except for the inhabitants of the local insane asylum, who have all escaped. Mistaking him for a figure of authority, they crown him the "King of Hearts" and continue their delirious celebrations. Amidst this chaos, Charles navigates through their whimsical world, forming a bond with a beautiful but naive young woman and realizing the utter absurdity of the situation around him.
As Charles interacts with the asylum residents, he grapples with the profound difference between their seemingly innocent madness and the brutal reality of war. He faces moral dilemmas that compel him to reconsider his sense of duty and loyalty. Throughout his stay, the line between sanity and insanity fades, challenging his own preconceptions about what constitutes true madness. All the while, the ticking bomb remains a silent yet ominous backdrop to the unfolding drama, pushing Charles toward a moment of truth that will define his courage and humanity.
Writers: Daniel Boulanger, Maurice Bessy
Release Date: 19 Jun 1967
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: France, Italy
Language: French, English, German, Latin