Elles Blu-ray Review
Score: 49
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Elles features a compelling performance by Juliette Binoche, with strong audio and video quality, but is undermined by lack of special features, making it more suited for a rental.
Disc Release Date
Video: 54
The Blu-ray presentation of 'Elles' features a 1080p/AVC encode that delivers rich colors, deep black levels, and excellent shadow delineation, but is occasionally marred by slight compression artifacts and pixilation in darker scenes.
Audio: 69
The Blu-ray of 'Elles' features an immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround mix that employs subtle atmospherics, flawless panning effects, and clear dialogue, delivering a surprisingly rich and engaging soundfield, while the Linear PCM 2.0 track is acceptable for simpler setups.
Extra: 6
The Blu Ray extras for 'Elles' include high-definition theatrical trailers, an uncensored trailer, and a stills gallery. Additional trailers for 'The Fairy' and 'Whores' Glory' from Kino Lorber enhance the offering.
Movie: 51
"Elles," directed by Małgorzata Szumowska, is a complex, provocative film examining themes of sex work, empowerment, and societal constraints. It features an intense performance by Juliette Binoche as Anne, a journalist entangled in the lives of two student prostitutes. The film's minimalist compositions and jarring cut scenes, back-scored by baroque classical music, effectively convey its themes. While it struggles with pacing and depth, its visual storytelling and emotional undertones are compelling. The Blu-ray release offers a beautifully structured narrative reflecting the hypnotic yet sorrowful essence of the film.
Video: 54
"Elles" boasts a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode that impeccably captures the visual style conceived by cinematographer Michal Englert and director Małgorzata Szumowska. The transfer delivers a rich tapestry of colors; indoor scenes feature muted, neutral tones, while outdoor scenes are warmer and more vibrant. This creates a visually dynamic contrast that enhances the narrative's emotional landscape. Fine details such as skin textures and fabric patterns are rendered with remarkable clarity, though there's occasional softness in darker scenes. Notably, black levels are deep and plush, while highlights remain softened but consistent with clean whites, adding a significant sense of density and dimensionality to the image.
However, the presentation is not without its imperfections. Some darker scenes suffer from slight compression artifacts such as source noise and pixilation, with isolated instances of macroblocking—most notably in a scene featuring Juliette Binoche in the shower. These issues, while relatively minor and fleeting from a typical viewing distance, are worth noting for enthusiasts seeking a flawless visual experience. Despite these hiccups, "Elles" remains free from detrimental processing effects like DNR or edge enhancement. Ultimately, aside from these technical glitches, the Blu-ray edition of "Elles" delivers an evocative and visually sophisticated high-definition transfer that complements the film's atmospheric storytelling.
Audio: 69
Elles on Blu Ray offers an exceptionally well-crafted auditory experience through its dual audio options: the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround mix and the uncompressed Linear PCM 2.0 track. While the PCM track is adequate, the real standout is the immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix, which intelligently utilizes all six speakers to create an authentic soundscape. The surround sound is unexpectedly engaging, given the film's genre, effectively placing the listener in various environments from the bustling streets of Paris to serene parks filled with birdsong and traffic noises. This dynamic range is supplemented by intentional sound elements like rain, wind, and the bustle within a student admissions center, enriching the viewing experience.
Furthermore, the film's soundtrack incorporates classical pieces from Vivaldi and Beethoven, as well as modern tracks like a sultry number from The Knife, all of which are delivered with crystal-clear clarity and seamlessly integrated into the overall sound design. The classical music notably enhances the soundstage, extending beautifully into the rear channels. The dialogue consistently cuts through the mix cleanly, ensuring clear and fluid interactions among characters. Additionally, the inclusion of a deep and hearty low bass adds a satisfying weight to the audio, contributing to a first-rate lossless mix that balances ambient sounds with dialogue for a coherent and immersive auditory experience.
Extra: 6
The Extras section of the Blu-ray release of "Elles" presents a compact yet engaging assortment of additional content, contributing significantly to the overall viewing experience. The standout features include varied trailers—in both censored and uncensored formats—which provide insightful previews of the film’s delicate themes and tone. Additionally, the Still Gallery offers a deeper visual exploration into production and promotional aspects, enriching the viewer’s understanding of the film’s aesthetic and narrative intentions. The inclusion of trailers from other Kino Lorber titles like "The Fairy" and "Whores' Glory" serves as a curated glimpse into the studio's broader offerings. Each feature is presented in high definition, ensuring that the supplemental material is as meticulously rendered as the main feature.
Extras included in this disc:
- Theatrical Trailer: Censored preview of "Elles."
- Uncensored Theatrical Trailer: Uncensored preview of "Elles."
- Stills Gallery: Collection of production and promo photos.
- Also Available from Kino Lorber: Trailers for "The Fairy" and "Whores' Glory."
Movie: 51
"Elles" is a film that intertwines themes of sex work, marriage, and female autonomy. Director Małgorzata Szumowska, drawing from her rich cinematic heritage, employs a blend of minimalist compositions and jarring cuts, enhanced by baroque classical music cues. While Szumowska doesn't quite reach the subtlety of Polish legends like Roman Polanski and Krzysztof Kieślowski, her style is engaging and lends an intoxicating mix of intelligence and uncomfortable eroticism to the familiar subject matter. The narrative oscillates between interview sequences with self-employed call girls, flashbacks of their encounters with clients, and protagonist Anne’s internal struggles and fantasies.
Juliette Binoche delivers an unflinching performance as Anne, a middle-aged journalist balancing a chaotic family life with her career. The movie navigates through her interactions with two Parisian college students who turn to prostitution to support themselves—Charlotte (Anaïs Demoustier) and Alicja (Joanna Kulig). These women's stories reveal a complex world where their clients are not just depraved men but often lonely, bored husbands. Szumowska tailors the narrative to Anne’s perspective, showing how the tales of these young women influence and arouse her as she navigates her own unsatisfying domestic existence.
The film’s structure is poetically fractured, merging different narrative threads to create a hypnotizing rhythm. Cinematographer Michal Englert skillfully contrasts the dreary interior of Anne’s home with the warm, empowering exterior world, adding layers of visual symbolism. Although the thematic content is dense and Szumowska’s symbolic approach sometimes feels shallow, "Elles" manages to deliver a thought-provoking exploration of the complexities of sexuality, power dynamics, and personal fulfillment. The film is both provocative and contemplative, offering more than just another portrayal of sex work, while also highlighting Binoche's considerable acting prowess.
Total: 49
"Elles," despite limited critical acclaim during its U.S. theatrical release, stands out as a provocative exploration of adult sexuality and social class. Starring Juliette Binoche, who delivers an impressively nuanced performance as a middle-class journalist intrigued by the lives of the upwardly mobile prostitutes she interviews, the film delves into complex themes with maturity and depth. The narrative structure, composed of fractured memories and conversations, provides a fittingly uneasy yet sensual backdrop for this exploration.
The Blu-ray presentation by Kino Lorber is commendable, offering a strong but slightly imperfect picture quality and surprisingly immersive audio, which is particularly notable given the film’s dialogue-driven nature. The video fidelity captures the sophisticated visual symbolism well, though it may come across as overly ambitious to some viewers. Although the technical presentation is robust, the glaring absence of special features is a significant drawback, likely positioning this release more as a rental than a purchase for the general audience.
In conclusion, "Elles" is an unconventional and thought-provoking film that merits attention for its daring subject matter and Binoche’s stellar portrayal. However, the combined lack of supplemental materials in the Blu-ray package makes it less appealing for collection purposes, except for ardent fans of the lead actress. This Blu-ray is best appreciated as a rental, allowing viewers to experience a mature cinematic investigation into sexuality and societal dynamics without the commitment of a full purchase.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 60
Although there's some softness in darker scenes, the in-focus areas of the frame usually have a fine degree of clarity, with visible skin textures, individually discernible hairs, and plenty of detail...
Audio: 90
The latter is perfectly acceptable, but if you've got a multi-channel setup, you should definitely stick with the former, which is surprisingly immersive considering the nature of the film....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 70
The film does deal with some well-worn themes�flesh as a commodity, prostitution as a means for upward mobility, and the simultaneous empowerment and subjugation of women who sell their bodies for a living�but...
Total: 60
Kino Lorber's Blu-ray presentation is decent, with a flawed-but-strong picture and surprisingly immersive audio�for such a relatively quiet, dialogue-driven film�but the lack of special features will probably...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
This doesn't affect the rest of the palette, as primaries remain bold and full-bodied, but contrast does seem somewhat softened by the cinematography although consistent with clean, crisp whites throughout....
Audio: 80
Making terrific use of the surround speakers, the design employs a variety of discrete atmospherics with flawless panning effects, creating a very satisfying soundfield....
Extras: 0
Trailers (HD) — Along with two trailers of other films in the Kino Lorber catalog, two alternate theatrical previews for this film are included....
Movie: 40
The narrative has a poetic rhythm that's hypnotic and engrossing, as if every scene is designed with emotional weight while also venting a great deal of sorrow....
Total: 60
Told as fractured memories and conversations during a busy day, the film features a remarkable performance by Juliette Binoche, but it ultimately feels bloated and engulfed by the director's focus on sophisticated...
Director: Malgorzata Szumowska
Actors: Juliette Binoche, Anaïs Demoustier, Joanna Kulig
PlotA Parisian journalist, Anne, is assigned to write an investigative article about female university students who finance their studies through prostitution. As Anne delves into the world of two young women, Alicja and Charlotte, she is confronted with stories and realities that challenge her preconceptions about sex work. Their experiences reveal a complex mix of autonomy, vulnerability, and economic necessity, which force Anne to reflect on her own life and societal norms. Meetings with Alicja, who is from Poland and is dealing with her own set of challenges, and Charlotte, a native Parisian student, become eye-opening for Anne.
While balancing her own demanding career and chaotic family life, Anne gradually finds herself emotionally drawn into the lives of these young women. Their candid revelations about their clients and personal struggles blur the lines between professional detachment and personal involvement for Anne. As she juggles her role as a mother, wife, and journalist, Anne begins to question the choices and sacrifices she has made and the underlying truths of the world she thought she understood. The complexities and intimate nature of Anne’s interactions with Alicja and Charlotte bring about a profound self-examination, leading her to confront issues within her own life and relationships.
Writers: Tine Byrckel, Malgorzata Szumowska
Release Date: 01 Feb 2012
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: NC-17
Country: France, Poland, Germany
Language: French, English, Polish