Coma Blu-ray Review

Scream Factory's re-release of "Coma" on Blu-ray surpasses previous editions with an expertly executed 2K scan from the interpositive. Encoded using MPEG-4 AVC on a BD-50 disc, it maintains the original theatrical ratio of roughly 1.85:1, noted as a 1.89:1 in some sources—a minor discrepancy with negligible impact. Compared to Warner Bros.’ earlier BD-25 edition, Scream's transfer boasts significantly improved clarity and definition, further enhanced by an effective bitrate averaging 34,000 kbps, almost doubling the previous release's 18,972 kbps. The visual presentation reflects a deliberate and unmanipulated approach to color grading, offering richer delineation without sacrificing authenticity or veering towards saturation.

The sharpness is occasionally betrayed by excessive grain in initial sequences, notably during the main titles and particular scenes such as when Mark converses with Susan by the door frame. However, this graininess subsides thereafter to settle into a balanced texture throughout the film's remainder without becoming abrasive or distracting. The encoding captures the magenta hues skillfully, demonstrated in specific screenshots, confirming the commitment to visual fidelity despite the intrinsic challenges of dealing with late 1970s film stocks.

This version of "Coma" retains a nostalgic 1970s aesthetic characteristic of the period’s film stock while enhancing the overall softness into what can only be described as an aligned artistic choice rather than a technical limitation. With notable improvements over the previous Blu-ray, this release rectifies past color issues, which had rendered the film nearly monochromatic. Collectively, these enhancements make for a visually pleasing and authentic remaster true to the original cinematographic intent, encapsulating "Coma" in its rightful visual quality for both new audiences and longtime fans.

The Blu-ray release of "Coma" features an upgraded audio presentation with a DTS-HD Master Audio Dual Mono mix at 1899 kbps, 24-bit, significantly enhancing the auditory experience over the previously available DTS-HD Master Audio Single Mono mix at 1093 kbps. This superior encoding ensures that spoken dialogue is clear and precise in the 2.0 lossless mix, with no noticeable hiss or distortion. The dynamic range and fidelity faithfully capture the nuances of Jerry Goldsmith's score, allowing its intricacies to be fully appreciated. This preservation results from exemplary mastering from three-track stereo tapes, originally recorded by Aaron Rochin, preserving the vivid sound quality of the original compositions.

Goldsmith’s innovative score for "Coma," featuring a wide array of instruments including strings, bass, woodwinds, keyboards, guitar, harp, drums, and percussion, is both dynamic and atmospheric. The masterstroke of the score is the incorporation of the cimbalom, a string instrument whose dissonant chords function as a haunting leitmotif throughout the film. Additionally, ringing effects generated using an Echoplex add a unique sonic layer, cleverly echoing the film’s medical themes. These elements collectively form a contemporary sound landscape reminiscent of Goldsmith's other groundbreaking works, such as his score for "Planet of the Apes" (1968).

Optional English SDH subtitles are available to accompany the feature presentation, ensuring accessibility. This Blu-ray release makes the best possible use of its audio capabilities to elevate both dialogue delivery and musical accompaniment, making it an essential listen for audiophiles and film score enthusiasts alike.

The extras on the "Coma" Blu-ray offer both informative insights and nostalgic visuals. The standout feature is the newly recorded audio commentary by film critic Lee Gambin and novelist Aaron Dries, which dives deeply into both the film and its contexts. Gambin provides a cultural studies lens, discussing the sociopolitical climate and medical issues of the 1970s, while Dries focuses on author Michael Crichton’s contributions and his connections with Hollywood icons such as Steven Spielberg. Visual extras include a high-quality image gallery featuring posters and production images, presented with some variance in resolution. The original theatrical trailer is also included, maintaining decent audio-visual standards despite visible wear. Additionally, there are several TV spots, which, while offering a charming retro look at the film’s promotion, exhibit notably faded visuals.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: In-depth discussion by Lee Gambin and Aaron Dries.
• Image Gallery: Over 100 high-quality Coma-related images.
• Original Theatrical Trailer: Decent condition with visible film artifacts.
• TV Spots: Five faded commercials promoting the 1978 release.

Michael Crichton's "Coma," adapted from Robin Cook's novel, has generated a diversity of opinion over time concerning its effectiveness as a medical thriller. Critics have often pointed to what they see as a lackluster adaptation that fails to recapture the tense atmosphere of the book. Crichton, both the writer and director, faced scrutiny for not fully realising the potential of his source material, with some commentators criticizing the screenplay for its muddled plot and undefined characters. However, it's worth noting that these critiques have been challenged by others who regard "Coma" as a strong entry in the genre, particularly for its intriguing premise and the organic character development throughout the film.

Geneviève Bujold delivers a compelling performance as Dr. Susan Wheeler, a surgical resident at Boston Memorial Hospital who begins to suspect a sinister conspiracy behind patients mysteriously entering comas during routine procedures. Amidst societal constraints of the 1970s, her role stands out with notable strength and determination. Michael Douglas takes on a supporting position as Dr. Mark Bellows, capturing a nuanced shift from being self-centered to becoming more attentive and caring towards Wheeler—an evolution that enriches the film's character dynamics further. Notably, Elizabeth Ashley's chilling portrayal of Mrs. Emerson at the Jefferson Institute offers a memorable take akin to Crichton's past works like "Westworld," adding an eerie layer to the narrative.

Besides its intriguing narrative and notable performances, "Coma" is significant for showcasing early roles of now-famous actors like Tom Selleck and Ed Harris. Despite some surprising content that raises eyebrows about its PG rating, Crichton's film is a technically proficient thriller that continues to captivate audiences decades later. Whether or not it stands as an apex of Crichton’s filmography is debated, yet it undeniably serves as an engaging exploration of medical ethics intertwined with suspenseful storytelling.

Michael Crichton's "Coma" is elevated by a pristine Blu-ray release from Scream Factory, offering a robust combination of thrilling narrative and technical finesse. The film, reminiscent of Alan J. Pakula's conspiratorial tone in "The Parallax View," benefits substantially from Geneviève Bujold's emphatic portrayal of Susan. She confidently navigates the labyrinthine plot, supported by a formidable cast including Rip Torn and Richard Widmark, with memorable appearances by Tom Selleck and a subtle cameo from Christopher Reeve.

Scream Factory delivers a commendable transfer with refined picture quality, preserving the film's ominous atmospherics. While it might not be classified as a Special Edition, the Blu-ray's inclusion of an insightful commentary track enriches the viewing experience, providing depth to the film’s intricate themes. The uncompressed monaural mix excels in clarity, offering sound design that heightens the tension inherent in the story.

In conclusion, "Coma" on Blu-ray by Scream Factory is a noteworthy acquisition for thriller aficionados. Despite the absent upgrade to 4K UHD at present, the existing quality reaffirms its status as a paramount release. Its engaging presentation and technical execution justify a strong recommendation for both film enthusiasts and collectors alike.