10 Cloverfield Lane Blu-ray Review
Score: 71
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
10 Cloverfield Lane is a highly recommended Blu-ray with outstanding video, reference-caliber Atmos audio, and noteworthy bonus materials, despite minor plot predictability.
Disc Release Date
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 69
The 1080p Blu-ray of '10 Cloverfield Lane' effectively conveys the film's dark, earthy aesthetic with well-defined textures and depth, though it suffers from occasional noise, aliasing, and a notable judder during a panning shot. Black levels are strong but not inky, and colors are subdued yet accurate.
Audio: 82
The Dolby TrueHD 7.1 and Dolby Atmos soundtracks for '10 Cloverfield Lane' are lauded for their exceptional dynamic range, rich low-frequency effects, and immersive surround sound, especially during key action sequences like the car crash. Dialogue remains clear and centered, complemented by a notable musical score. Overall, these audio presentations balance tranquility with moments of intense, immersive activity.
Extra: 48
10 Cloverfield Lane's Blu Ray extras feature an insightful commentary by Dan Trachtenberg and J.J. Abrams, and seven featurettes totaling over 30 minutes that delve into set design, practical effects, costume creation, and music. The inclusion of a Digital HD copy and a unique slipcover add value, though some might find the details minimalist.
Movie: 81
"10 Cloverfield Lane," directed by Dan Trachtenberg, is a taut psychological thriller that excels in storytelling and performances, particularly by John Goodman and Mary Elizabeth Winstead. The film captivates with its confined setting and Hitchcockian tension, although its abrupt, Cloverfield-tying conclusion divides opinion.
Video: 69
The video presentation of "10 Cloverfield Lane" on Blu-ray is characterized by an earthy, organic aesthetic intended by the filmmakers and effectively captured in this 1080p transfer. Shot digitally on Red Epic Dragon cameras, the film exhibits a mostly accurate rendition of its theatrical look, albeit with a few technical quirks. The 2.40:1 aspect ratio and AVC MPEG-4 encoding ensure the cinematic feel is maintained through a thin veneer of grain. Detail levels are quite high, with textures such as facial pores and cinder block surfaces appearing brilliantly clear. Colors are neutrally balanced and exhibit lifelike natures, and black levels are deep yet sometimes murky in certain scenes.
Shadow delineation is particularly commendable, rendering subtle backgrounds in dark lighting conditions with impressive depth. This interplay of shadow and light is crucial for scenes within the confined bunker setting, lending the sequences enhanced visual intrigue. Although there are some observable noise spikes, particularly in low-light areas like Michelle's room, these instances do not detract significantly from the overall viewing experience.
Despite minor issues such as a detectable judder during a pivotal panning scene and occasional aliasing, "10 Cloverfield Lane" successfully maintains stable contrast and black levels throughout. The slight judder is noted by the director himself in the commentary, underscoring it's an artifact from the source rather than an issue with the Blu-ray transfer. Overall, this Blu-ray faithfully reproduces the film’s intended palette with crisp texture rendition and subtle color splashes, completing a competent and engaging visual presentation that aligns well with the filmmakers' vision.
Audio: 82
The audio presentation of "10 Cloverfield Lane" on Blu-ray is exceptional, highlighted by its Dolby Atmos (Dolby TrueHD 7.1 lossless core) track. With an 11.1 setup that integrates four height channels alongside a traditional 7.1 surround configuration, the mix delivers an immersive soundstage. The dynamic range is superb, with dialogue articulated clearly through the center channel, maintaining prominence within the front soundstage. Music and larger action effects deliver authenticity and balance, creating a seamless 360-degree auditory experience. While overhead channels are lightly applied in musical segments, they significantly enhance major sequences—especially the incredibly robust car accident scene. Crunching metal and rolling sensations are vividly rendered, utilizing low-frequency effects for added realism.
The film's score, composed by Bear McCreary, plays a significant role throughout, blending effortlessly with the rear channels to generate atmosphere and subtle ambient sounds. Although the track is relatively subdued for the majority of the movie due to its dialogue-centric nature, discrete effects and ambient noises are well-positioned, contributing to the tension-filled narrative. The smoke alarms, the car crash, and the finale are particularly noteworthy for their deep bass and heightened activity through all speakers, including well-defined overhead components.
Beyond the heightened moments, the audio presentation excels in creating an eerily compelling environment during quieter scenes. Low-frequency extensions are effectively employed to produce a palpable richness in impactful sounds while maintaining clarity in dialogue. Additional tracks include 5.1 Dolby Digital options in Spanish, French, and Portuguese, as well as an English Descriptive Video track. Subtitles are accessible in multiple languages, ensuring inclusivity. Overall, this Dolby Atmos track is a stellar example of blending tranquility and chaos to create a captivating auditory experience.
Extras: 48
The Blu-ray of "10 Cloverfield Lane" features a technically rich collection of extras that provide comprehensive insights into the filmmaking process. Anchored by an engaging audio commentary from director Dan Trachtenberg and producer J.J. Abrams, viewers gain behind-the-scenes access to the film’s creation, including structural analysis, key scene crafting, and actor performances. The set includes multiple featurettes collectively running over 30 minutes, each contributing unique perspectives. Key highlights encompass the film's connection to its predecessor, set and costume design, practical effects, visual and sound production, and musical composition. This content is indispensable for those intrigued by technical filmmaking marvels and narrative intricacies. Additionally, a Digital HD copy and bonus DVD offer portable viewing options with a cleverly designed slipcover.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insights from director Dan Trachtenberg and producer J.J. Abrams.
- Cloverfield Too: Discusses film's plot and relationship to its predecessor.
- Bunker Mentality: Explores the design and shooting of the main set piece.
- Duck and Cover: Designing a key late-movie costume.
- Spin-Off: Practical car effects construction.
- Kelvin Optical: Visual and sound effects at Bad Robot.
- Fine Tuned: Music's role in character and story development.
- End of Story: Crafting an original narrative within an existing universe.
Movie: 81
10 Cloverfield Lane offers a unique, tension-filled experience masterfully brought to life by director Dan Trachtenberg in his feature film debut. The film departs significantly from its predecessor, opting for a more confined and psychologically intense narrative. Michelle (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) finds herself in an underground bunker with Howard (John Goodman), who claims to have saved her from a disastrous event that has made the Earth's surface uninhabitable. The film effectively transitions between mind-bending suspense and moments of revelation as Michelle grapples with whether or not to believe Howard’s wild claims. The story is strategically constructed in three distinct acts, leading to an unpredictable and thought-provoking conclusion that challenges viewers' expectations.
On a technical level, the film excels in using its primary set, the bunker, to create a believable and immersive environment. The confined setting heightens the tension, making every interaction between the characters charged with uncertainty. Winstead delivers an impressive performance that portrays her character's evolution from vulnerable victim to resourceful skeptic. John Goodman stands out by balancing his role with a blend of unsettling intensity and inexplicable vulnerability that keeps audiences guessing about his true intentions throughout the film.
The ending, however, has been divisive among viewers. While the majority of the movie presents a focused and compelling psychological thriller, the final act shifts gears dramatically, aligning itself with the broader Cloverfield universe. This abrupt transition has garnered both criticism and praise: some argue it detracts from the standalone narrative's strength, while others appreciate the unexpected twist. Despite this controversy, the overall storytelling and performances make 10 Cloverfield Lane one of 2016's most engaging films.
Total: 71
"10 Cloverfield Lane" is a gripping motion picture that successfully interweaves a compelling human interest story with elements of survival and mystery. The film excels on multiple fronts including its writing, direction, and production design. The cast, spearheaded by John Goodman in one of his most remarkable performances, delivers a riveting experience that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. Paramount's Blu-ray release does justice to this cinematic gem with high-quality video, reference-grade Dolby Atmos audio, and a well-rounded selection of bonus materials, such as a top-notch commentary track.
Despite a slightly faltering conclusion, "10 Cloverfield Lane" firmly stands as a standout suspense film, earning accolades as one of the best movies of 2016. The Blu-ray edition’s minor shortfall in bonus content does not diminish its value as a worthy addition to any film aficionado’s collection. This release is a wonderful showcase of an outstanding first-time feature director and an immersive thriller that taps into the broader entertainment spectrum, including physiological chills and speculative survival scenarios.
In conclusion, "10 Cloverfield Lane" offers an exceptional cinematic experience, well-supported by Paramount's Blu-ray edition. Its solid presentation across video and audio components, combined with its thrilling narrative and potent performances, makes it an indispensable piece for your home media collection. Highly recommended without reservations.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Clothes are well textured, and the source's natural sharpness allows audiences to soak up all the little details around the shelter, particularly in the common area....
Audio: 100
Crunching metal, crashes onto the surface, and the sensation that the vehicle is indeed rolling over is amazing, and that top layer adds in plenty of clearly defined detail that creates a more realistic,...
Extras: 60
Audio Commentary: Director Dan Trachtenberg and Producer J.J. Abrams share some interesting anecdotal secrets behind the movie while discussing film and scene-specific structure, characters and development,...
Movie: 90
It's instead a more confined and intimate character film, one that asks a lot of good questions, answers some of them in due time, and yields an altogether captivating movie watching experience, structured...
Total: 80
10 Cloverfield Lane is a fantastic motion picture, a core human interest story of survival and the unknown, of mysterious intentions and circumstances....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
But despite the issues mentioned, which again I believe are almost exclusively from the master, the Blu-ray of '10 Cloverfield Lane' proves to be a pretty accurate rendition of how the movie looked on...
Audio: 80
While the audio here is just about perfectly rendered, aside from a car crash early in the movie and the quite active climax to the film (the last 10 to 15 minutes), there's not a whole lot to get excited...
Extras: 40
Paramount has divided this up so each segment can be watched individually (and give the impression that this disc has more bonus features than it really does), but this is really just a single featurette...
Movie: 80
Fortunately, everything up to this bizarre turn in events is so good, even it can't take away from the fact that '10 Cloverfield Lane' is one of the best films of the year....
Total: 80
It's a shame that '10 Cloverfield Lane' doesn't quite stick its landing, as otherwise it might be one of the best suspense movies ever made....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 90
Shadow delineation is quite good and revealing of subtle details within dark backgrounds and low lighting sequences which gave those scenes better visual depth....
Audio: 92
Front and rear channel imaging is spot on as details and spatial cues, such as those used for near field effect during the car accident sequence, mate perfectly with the events transpiring onscreen....
Extras: 50
Cloverfield Too – 9 minute featurette (HD) Bunker Mentality – 3 minute featurette (HD) Duck and Cover – 2 minute featurette (HD) Spin Off - 4 minute featurette (HD) Kelvin and Optical – 6 minute featurette...
Movie: 70
His theories are supported by a mysterious stranger who is in the bunker with them (John Gallagher, Jr.), but as his increasingly suspicious actions lead her to question his motives, she'll have to escape...
Total: 76
Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player Samsung UBD-K8500 Ultra HD Blu-ray Player Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo"...
Why So Blu? review by Brian WhiteRead review here
Video: 90
Obviously, there are expansive shots, but even in tight corners such as in the bunker, an apartment or even in the food cellar, the camera’s eye in this presentation perfectly captures the depth of the...
Audio: 100
The sub also comes alive during the many action moments when our protagonist is trying to escape and of course that surprise ending that will leave you wanting to revisit Cabin in the Woods....
Extras: 50
Then we continue on with a tour of the confined bunker in question here (most interesting to me), see how the costume designer was challenged to create a homemade Hazmat suit, follow the production team...
Movie: 90
It’s essential to know what all went down in that 2008 film and being armed with that knowledge fully prepares you for what might or what possibly might not be going down in the outside world....
Total: 80
It’s a solid presentation all around, but also more importantly it’s a bunker thriller yo....
Director: Dan Trachtenberg
Actors: John Goodman, Mary Elizabeth Winstead, John Gallagher Jr.
PlotAfter surviving a car crash, a young woman wakes up in an underground bunker, where she meets her rescuer, a mysterious man who claims to have saved her from an apocalyptic event. The man insists that the outside world has been rendered uninhabitable, contaminated by a massive chemical attack or some other disaster. The woman is understandably skeptical and terrified, finding herself trapped in a confined space with two men she doesn't know. The bunker is well-stocked and fortified, supposedly to protect them from the dangers that lurk outside.
As time passes, the woman faces the complexities of life in the bunker, including the dynamics between the inhabitants. Her rescuer's intentions and sanity come into question, while the presence of another man in the bunker, a fellow survivor, adds to the tension. She must weigh her desire for freedom against her fear of the unknown terrors that may await outside. The need to escape and find the truth about the outside world grows within her, yet she has to plot her moves carefully, constantly torn between doubt and fear. In this claustrophobic environment, alliances, trust, and the will to survive are tested to their limits.
Writers: Josh Campbell, Matt Stuecken, Damien Chazelle
Release Date: 11 Mar 2016
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English