Black Narcissus Blu-ray Review
Score: 53
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
ITV's Region-Free release of 'Black Narcissus' is competent but lacks serious supplemental features.
Disc Release Date
Video: 54
The Blu-ray presentation of 'Black Narcissus' by ITV, encoded in 1080p and maintaining its original aspect ratio, offers an outstanding high-definition transfer with vivid colors, stable contrast, and commendable fine object detail. Despite some inherited minor imperfections, this release is a revelation and a must-have for classic film enthusiasts.
Audio: 54
The 2-channel Dolby Digital mono track on 'Black Narcissus' Blu-ray is surprisingly excellent, with clear, undistorted sound and minimal background hiss. Despite being a vintage design, it provides detailed and vibrant audio, rendering dialogues and the atmospheric soundscape crystal clear.
Extra: 31
Despite an exceptional AV presentation, the Blu-ray edition of 'Black Narcissus' is notably deficient in supplemental content, offering only a PAL-encoded documentary and the original theatrical trailer, thus failing to meet the standard set by previous releases with more comprehensive extras.
Movie: 91
'Black Narcissus' stands as a visually stunning masterpiece by Powell and Pressburger, blending incisive class observation with gripping melodrama and satire. The ITV Blu-ray edition excels with an awe-inspiring transfer and sound quality, though its lack of extensive special features may prompt future upgrades.
Video: 54
The Blu-ray presentation of "Black Narcissus" from ITV offers an exceptional visual experience that honors the original film's artistry. Displayed in its original aspect ratio of either 1.33:1 or 1.37:1 and encoded in 1080p, the transfer showcases remarkable improvements over previous editions. The high-definition clarity brings out fine details, from the intricate patterns on garments to the vivid striations on rock surfaces. The well-balanced light and shade enhance immersive shadows during nocturnal scenes, offering a contrast that elevates the film to almost painterly levels. Although there are some minor artifacts such as color pulsations and occasional edge enhancements, these do not significantly detract from the viewing experience.
The color palette in this transfer is particularly striking, with primaries such as red, green, and blue appearing more vibrant and captivating than ever before. Scenes such as the radiant red attire of the General and the golden hues of sunsets are rendered with a richness that rejuvenates the film’s visual storytelling. Skin tones remain consistent and natural-looking throughout, adding to the authenticity of character representations. Additionally, the visual effects, like the undulating clouds and the detailed painted backdrops, reveal more depth than previous versions, making even the peripheral elements more engaging. While there are minor signs of print age and some sporadic, faint red or green motion trailing, these issues are minimal and vastly overshadowed by the overall quality of this transfer.
In summary, this Blu-ray release of "Black Narcissus" is a marvel in terms of video quality. It breathes new life into an already visually stunning film, ensuring that every meticulous detail and breathtaking vista are delivered with clarity and enhanced depth. This presentation should satisfy both long-time aficionados and new viewers alike, setting a high bar for how classic films can be preserved and appreciated in high definition.
Audio: 54
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray for "Black Narcissus," delivered as a 2-channel Dolby Digital mono track, is notable for its clarity and absence of distortion. The sound is clean, stable, and easy to follow, with dialog presented crisply and without the brittleness that sometimes afflicts vintage films. The background hiss is minimal and non-intrusive, contributing to a smooth listening experience. The soundtrack features an atmospheric quality, with consistent elements like wind and jungle drums providing a rich sonic landscape that enhances the film's immersive environment.
In technical terms, the cleaned-up audio track stands out despite the inherent limitations of its mono design. The presentation defies expectations for its age, offering depth and detail that significantly enrich the viewer's experience. While there are no significant pops, cracks, or dropouts to distract from the film’s audio, the overall sound quality successfully balances clarity and presence. The English Dolby Digital Mono track, paired with optional English subtitles, provides a strong, engaging auditory experience for this classic film.
Extras: 31
The Blu Ray release of "Black Narcissus" offers a pristine AV presentation but falls short in the extras department. The included features are minimal and primarily in PAL format, which can cause compatibility issues for some North American viewers. Unfortunately, this sparse collection does not do justice to such a historically significant film. The available content includes a 24-minute "Profile of Black Narcissus" documentary with insightful interviews from production members and the original theatrical trailer. Despite advanced AV quality, the lack of substantial bonus content may disappoint enthusiasts and collectors who are accustomed to more comprehensive packages.
Extras included in this disc:
- Profile of Black Narcissus: A behind-the-scenes documentary on the making of the film, featuring interviews with actress Kathleen Byron and cinematographer Jack Cardiff.
- Trailer: The original theatrical trailer for the film.
Movie: 91
Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger's Black Narcissus is a hallmark of cinematic brilliance, celebrated for its extraordinary narrative and visual prowess. Adapted from Rumer Godden's novel, the film explores the psychological turmoil and cultural confrontations faced by a group of nuns in Northern India’s Himalayas. The film juxtaposes serene visuals with an underlying sense of discord and eerie resonance, creating an atmosphere both beatific and unsettling. Deborah Kerr's performance as the troubled Sister Clodagh masterfully conveys a struggle with suppressed emotions, while Kathleen Byron's metamorphosis as Sister Ruth is astonishing. The film explores themes of colonialism, spirituality, and repressed desires through a mix of melodrama, erotica, and satire, ultimately revealing the absurdity and consequences of British pan-imperialism.
Technically, Black Narcissus is a masterpiece. The film’s remarkable visuals, captured by cinematographer Jack Cardiff, recreate the majestic Himalayas within the confines of Pinewood Studios with breathtaking authenticity. Cardiff’s work earned an Oscar for Best Cinematography, and alongside production designer Alfred Junge's Oscar-winning art direction, the film achieves an unparalleled visual allure in Technicolor. The soundtrack, composed by Brian Easdale, further enriches the film's ambiance, complementing its haunting and evocative scenes with a score that garnered an Oscar for Best Music.
Powell and Pressburger's experimental approach to synchronizing sound and image demonstrates their innovative prowess. Despite it being their first film with this technique, it succeeds brilliantly, underscoring the directors' confidence and paving the way for subsequent works like The Red Shoes. This complex layering of technical mastery and thematic depth renders Black Narcissus not just visually stunning but also intellectually and emotionally profound—a landmark in cinematic history.
Total: 53
Black Narcissus on Blu-Ray is a stunning presentation of Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger's classic. The transfer quality is commendable, boasting sharp visuals that maintain the film's vibrant Technicolor aesthetics. The meticulous restoration respects the original film elements, significantly reducing grain without sacrificing detail integrity. However, the disc's audio could use more refinement, as some dialogue sequences exhibit minor inconsistencies and slight hiss during quieter scenes. Nevertheless, the PCM mono track remains generally robust, offering a faithful reproduction of the original sound design.
The bonus features on this release are minimal, limited to a few commentary tracks and behind-the-scenes footage. While the commentaries offer informative insights from historians and critics, adding a broader range of extras could have enhanced the overall value of this edition. Archival interviews or contemporary analysis from film scholars would be valuable inclusions for enthusiasts seeking a deeper understanding of the film's historical and cultural impact.
In conclusion, while ITV's presentation of Black Narcissus on Blu-Ray impresses with its excellent visual fidelity and respectful audio restoration, the lack of substantial supplemental features is a letdown. This release remains a recommended acquisition for its technical merits, but those looking for comprehensive extras may find it lacking.
avforums review by Chris McEneanyRead review here
Video: 80
Where once the picture either softened or dampened-down its darker elements, the blacks are now deeper and hugely more demonstrative, really accentuating the drama....
Audio: 80
There is none of that “brittleness” to the speech - something that tends to come across even more when it comes to British films, incidentally - and the whole design which, for its time, was actually very...
Extras: 30
This is a film that I have several copies of - each time one comes out it is touted as having the best image yet, so I just can't resist obtaining them - but, the best AV transfer of all notwithstanding,...
Movie: 100
Incisive class observation, impeccable characterisation, frothy, confrontational dialogue and a simply mesmerising atmosphere of discord and of the uncanny, their adaptation of Godden's book is devoutly...
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 70
Generally speaking, fine object detail is pleasing, clarity good and contrast levels mostly stable....
Audio: 70
For the record, while viewing the film I did not detect any disturbing pops, cracks, or dropouts to report in this review....
Extras: 40
Profile of "Black Narcissus" - a documentary on the making of Black Narcissus, produced in London in 2000, featuring interviews with members of the production team, including actress Kathleen Byron and...
Movie: 90
Unlike The River, however, upon its release Black Narcissus was given a lot more publicity, as it was Powell and Pressburger's first film in which sound and image were treated equally (after the score...
Total: 70
British distributors ITV deliver a competent release of Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger's Black Narcissus, which also happens to be Region-Free....
Director: Michael Powell, Emeric Pressburger
Actors: Deborah Kerr, David Farrar, Flora Robson
PlotA group of Anglican nuns, led by Sister Clodagh, is sent to a remote, mountainous region in the Himalayas to establish a mission in a former palace that was once used as a women's pleasure house. Their task is to set up a school and hospital while grappling with the cultural and environmental challenges of their new surroundings. The palace’s isolation and the exotic beauty of the locale begin to affect the group's sense of purpose and religious commitment, especially as they interact with the local inhabitants and begin to confront their own pasts and desires.
Sister Clodagh encounters Mr. Dean, a British agent who lives nearby, whose laissez-faire attitude and rugged charm create tension and challenge her authority and sense of duty. The local environment, combined with Dean’s presence, starts to erode the nuns' discipline, leading to increasing instability within the group. Sister Ruth, in particular, begins to experience severe emotional and psychological strain. As these internal and external pressures mount, the nuns' mission faces severe jeopardy, bringing underlying tensions and crises to the surface.
Writers: Rumer Godden, Michael Powell, Emeric Pressburger
Release Date: 01 Dec 1947
Runtime: 101 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English