District B13 Blu-ray Review
Banlieue 13
Score: 50
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
District B13 delivers thrilling athletic stunts and impressive Parkour, with a solid Blu-ray video and audio quality, despite a lackluster story and extras.
Disc Release Date
Video: 53
District B13 arrives on Blu-ray with a 1080p, 2.35:1 transfer using the MPEG-2 codec, boasting vibrant color and impressive contrast levels, despite minor issues like color banding and occasional noise in dark scenes. The overall picture quality is sharp, detailed, and invitingly natural.
Audio: 53
District B13's Blu Ray audio presentation boasts exceptional sound quality, featuring English and French DTS-HD 5.1 and Dolby Digital-EX 5.1 tracks. However, English dub sync issues and subpar subtitle translations detract from the experience. The French DTS-HD track stands out for its well-balanced, immersive sound effects and potent bass.
Extra: 41
The Blu-ray extras for 'District B13' feature a 49-minute making-of documentary with engaging stunt work by David Belle and Cyril Raffaelli, but extended scenes and outtakes add little value.
Movie: 51
District B13 is a high-octane action film showcasing David Belle's extraordinary Parkour skills, delivering breathtaking stunts and visceral chase scenes, though its simplistic plot and character development leave much to be desired—ultimately, a visual tour-de-force for action enthusiasts.
Video: 53
Presented in 1080p using the MPEG-2 codec, "District B13" arrives on Blu-ray with a 2.35:1 transfer that largely impresses within its context and technical constraints. The color palette, despite a predominantly washed-out aesthetic, manages to showcase vivid and bright hues, with blues and reds standing out spectacularly. The contrast levels, though occasionally varying due to the film's stylistic choices, often achieve a beautiful balance, particularly in daytime scenes where sunlight enhances rather than detracts from the image's detail and depth.
Black levels are commendable, delivering a satisfying depth, while shadow delineation is above average and fine object detail remains crisp. This results in textures that possess a natural dimension and inviting image quality, complemented by vibrant skin tones and sharp edges. However, there are some minor drawbacks such as occasional color banding in open areas and noise in darker scenes. Additionally, the stark contrast is at times artificially heightened, though these instances are relatively infrequent and don’t significantly detract from the overall viewing experience.
Ultimately, while "District B13" isn't a modern reference-quality release and some technical imperfections are present, the video presentation successfully captures the gritty essence of the film. Despite its early encoding codec and minor issues, the transfer achieves a lively visual richness and depth that should satisfy most high-definition enthusiasts.
Audio: 53
The audio presentation of the Blu Ray for "District B13" boasts an array of tracks including English DTS-HD 5.1 Surround, French DTS-HD 5.1 Surround, English Dolby Digital-EX 5.1 Surround, and French Dolby Digital-EX 5.1 Surround. The French DTS-HD track stands out for its compelling clarity and well-balanced distribution of sound across the channels. The dialogue is crisp and the action scenes within the industrial building are highlighted by impressive echo effects that enhance immersion. Additionally, the bass presence is substantial yet controlled, contributing to a dynamic listening experience.
However, notable issues arise with the English dub, which suffers from synchronicity problems and subpar voice acting. Furthermore, the English SDH subtitles can be disruptive, inundating viewers with unnecessary auditory descriptions such as "door opens" and "gun shots," which deviates from traditional translations. Therefore, this release immensely favors those fluent in French, who can fully appreciate the pristine audio quality without these distractions.
When evaluating the overall sound design, all tracks leverage the surround channels effectively to create a vibrant soundscape. Dialogue remains sharp and distinctive amidst the chaos of gunfire and environmental impacts, each fragment of shattered glass and splintered wood is meticulously rendered. The dynamic range is notably broad, with accurate prioritization of audio elements ensuring a natural auditory hierarchy; quieter sounds like reloading clips are appropriately subdued compared to louder effects such as gunfire. The primary issue lies in the handling of the baseline techno soundtrack, which tends to overshadow more significant elements within the soundfield, slightly detracting from the potential intricacies of the sound design.
Overall, while there are some flaws in translation and subtitling for non-French speakers, the technical execution of the audio presentation on this Blu Ray delivers a robust and engaging listening experience.
Extras: 41
The Blu-ray extras for "District B13" offer mixed engagement, primarily anchored by a 49-minute behind-the-scenes documentary divided into five sections—Preparation, The Casino, The Shoot, Parkour, and The Actors. This in-depth documentary includes interviews with the director, screenwriters, and stars, and provides a comprehensive look at the complex stunt work that defines the film. The dynamic stunts executed by David Belle and Cyril Raffaelli are particularly alluring, transforming otherwise standard scenes into visually captivating sequences. However, the extended fight scene and outtakes fail to add any significant value, with the former merely adding a few additional beats to an existing scene and the latter being largely ordinary and repetitive.
Extras included in this disc:
Behind-the-Scenes Documentary: A detailed look at the making of the film. Extended Fight Scene: Minor additions to the Casino fight scene. Outtakes: A collection of bloopers and unusable takes.
Movie: 51
"District B13," directed by Pierre Morel and produced by Luc Besson, epitomizes high-octane action cinema with a distinct French flair, driven by the spectacle of Parkour. The film centers around Leito (David Belle), who gets entangled with a drug lord after stealing a large batch of heroin, leading to a series of exhilarating chases and combat sequences. The plot thickens when undercover cop Damien (Cyril Raffaelli) partners with Leito to dismantle a lethal operation controlled by the local kingpin Taha (Larbi Naceri). Set in a 2010 dystopian Paris, "District B13" showcases a city marred by crime and delineated by quarantine walls, adding an authentic layer of grit to the narrative.
The core allure of "District B13" lies in its breathtaking stunts and acrobatic performances, making Parkour a visual feast. David Belle, the founder of Parkour, delivers jaw-dropping agility and precision that elevates the film into an action extravaganza. The stunning displays of movement, from wall-bounding to scaling buildings, are captured with meticulous camera work that keeps the audience enthralled. The film's minimal use of special effects underscores the authenticity and rawness of these sequences, making the stunts appear even more perilous and visceral.
However, the script and character development leave much to be desired. The dialogue and storyline are notably basic, and while this transparent simplicity might work for an action-focused viewing experience, it does little to engage those looking for substantive storytelling. Critics have pointed out the film's reliance on action clichés and implausible plot points. Despite these shortcomings, "District B13" succeeds in providing a thrill-a-minute ride for viewers seeking sheer kinetic energy and stylistic combat. Comparisons to early Jackie Chan films are apt, where physical prowess takes precedence over narrative depth, solidifying "District B13" as a must-watch for action aficionados.
Total: 50
"District B13," featuring David Belle and Cyril Raffaelli, is a captivating display of athletic prowess and jaw-dropping stunts that elevate the film's credibility. Despite the storyline's lackluster nature and mundane narrative execution, the film excels in providing high-octane entertainment that appeals to fans of action-packed martial arts sequences. The ability of the actors to perform the extreme Parkour stunts ensures viewers remain on the edge of their seats.
Regarding the Blu-ray release by Magnolia Pictures, the technical presentation, although not top-tier, meets essential standards. The video quality is quite impressive, providing a visually engaging experience. Complementing this, the audio packages deliver an immersive feel, ensuring that every punch and leap resonates effectively with the audience. However, it should be noted that the Blu-ray's supplemental offerings are rather underwhelming and may not satisfy those seeking extensive extra features.
In conclusion, "District B13" is a must-watch for action enthusiasts and Parkour aficionados who prioritize visual spectacle over narrative depth. While the Blu-ray presentation is solid and offers satisfactory sound and visuals, the limited extras might be a slight disappointment for collectors. Nonetheless, the film's core entertainment value remains intact, making this release a commendable choice.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 70
Some of the darker scenes within the industrial premise where Taha resides tend to look a bit too sharpened for my taste but overall the gritty look of the film more or less blends and masks them well...
Audio: 70
The producers of this disc have basically created a hybrid of HOH and traditional subs that more or less will irritate those of you that are not accustomed to such sort of translations (example: throughout...
Extras: 70
On this BD you will find a small section of outtakes that did not make it to the final version of the film, a rather long documentary divided into five subsections - "Preparation," "The Casino," "The Shoot,"...
Movie: 50
Top dog Sickening stunts and enough jumping to force anyone to seriously ponder why the cast of Banlieue 13 isn't at the Beijing Olympics Pierre Morel's directorial debut is as straightforward of a film...
Total: 60
The rest of this film is undoubtedly below average, neither the story nor the manner in which it is told would challenge your intelligence....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There are a few minor problems -- color banding occasionally appears in open expanses, darkness is sometimes sprinkled with noise, and the stark contrast is artificially pushed to the extreme in a handful...
Audio: 80
Unfortunately for English-speaking audiences, neither the dub nor the subtitles are an ideal option -- the dub suffers from sync issues and amateur voice work, while the English SDH subtitles annoyingly...
Extras: 20
Fans will definitely enjoy the footage of the actors working on the stunts and action sequences, and David Belle a& Cyril Raffaelli are great fun to watch as they up the ante, often making scenes far more...
Movie: 60
Known for his more challeging material, Besson's writing in 'B13' lacks the depth of his more serious fare, often sacrificing plot, logic, and consistency in order to move the story along....
Total: 60
As a Blu-ray release, the video quality on this one is quite impressive and the audio packages are also very nice -- the only thing spoiling the fun here is a weak set of supplemental offerings....
Director: Pierre Morel
Actors: Cyril Raffaelli, David Belle, Tony D'Amario
PlotIn a near-future Paris, the government has isolated the most dangerous neighborhoods with massive containment walls. Among these is B13, a lawless area ruled by criminal gangs. Leïto, a local vigilante, becomes a target after destroying a large quantity of drugs belonging to notorious gang leader Taha. Leïto's actions provoke Taha's wrath, leading to a chain of events that engulfs his sister Lola and places both of their lives in grave danger. Desperate to save her and escape the brutal regime of B13, Leïto confronts the overwhelming power of Taha's gang.
At the same time, an elite undercover cop named Damien is assigned a high-stakes mission to retrieve a stolen nuclear weapon, which is now somewhere within B13. Damien and Leïto reluctantly form an alliance, combining their unique skills—Damien's combat and tactical expertise with Leïto's intimate knowledge of the treacherous urban landscape. As they navigate through the perilous streets and countless dangers of B13, the two must overcome their differences and work together to save Lola and prevent a catastrophic disaster.
Writers: Luc Besson, Bibi Naceri
Release Date: 02 Jun 2006
Runtime: 84 min
Rating: R
Country: France
Language: French, Spanish