Banning Blu-ray Review
Score: 81
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Banning is a must-watch neo-noir gem with a 2K remaster and engaging extras, highlighting Quincy Jones' jazz score transformation.
Disc Release Date
Video: 78
Banning on Blu-ray impresses with a 2K master from Imprint Films that delivers a convincing, organic 1080p visual experience, despite minor specks and density fluctuations. The color balance and image stability shine, capturing an authentic period look without digital interference, scoring a solid 4.25/5.
Audio: 91
Featuring an English LPCM 2.0 audio track, Banning's Blu-ray release offers clear and stable dialogue, while Quincy Jones' original music and Gil Bernal's The Eyes of Love add significant atmosphere, though it's evident the sound design stems from an earlier era.
Extra: 71
Engaging insights abound in the Blu-Ray extras of 'Banning,' with Robert Wagner and Jill St. John reflecting on their careers and Jon Burlingame delving into Quincy Jones' unique score, complemented by a commentary from critics Berger and Mitchell, providing an immersive historical and technical context.
Movie: 74
Banning (1967) ingeniously merges TV production methods with cinematic flair, offering a stylish neo-noir experience filled with complex characters and captivating performances, enhanced by Quincy Jones' effective score. Its surprisingly high production value belies its rapid 21-day shoot, presenting a unique oddity of its era.
Video: 78
The Blu-ray release of "Banning" by Imprint Films presents a high-quality 1080p transfer, captured in an aspect ratio of 2.35:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC. Leveraging a newly commissioned 2K master from an interpositive, the film delivers a visually compelling experience. The presentation expertly balances organic textures with a clarity that ranges from very good to excellent, despite minor white specks and nicks that subtly remind viewers of its analog origins. The depth and delineation provide the content with a substantial visual allure, while minor density fluctuations remain present due to stylistic origins rather than post-production oversights.
Color reproduction in "Banning" stands out prominently with outstanding balance across all primary hues and supporting tones, offering a vivid yet authentic period look. While saturation could see slight enhancement in select instances, the overall palette remains convincingly natural, complementing the film's historical aesthetic. The image maintains excellent stability throughout, free from unwarranted digital tampering that often mars such restorations. This Region-Free Blu-ray guarantees compatibility across various geographical locations, reinforcing its accessibility and appeal.
In summary, "Banning" benefits significantly from Imprint Films’ thoughtful restoration efforts, achieving a compelling blend of nostalgic charm with modern technical assurance. Despite some negligible visual remnants of its interpositive roots, this edition of "Banning" is a visually satisfying addition for aficionados and casual viewers alike, nestling comfortably within any Blu-ray collection with a commendable score of 4.25/5.
Audio: 91
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray release of "Banning" is delivered through a standard English LPCM 2.0 track, complemented by optional English SDH subtitles to aid accessibility. The audio track succeeds in capturing the essence of the film's time period, where Gil Bernal's rendition of "The Eyes of Love" and Quincy Jones' original music compositions skillfully enhance the film's atmosphere. These musical elements contribute significantly to the stylish nature of the movie, adding depth and elegance to its presentation.
Despite the audio mix's age, the dynamic contrasts are commendable, allowing shifts in the auditory landscape to be appreciated. However, listeners will recognize it as a product of an era with less emphasis on surround sound technology. Nevertheless, the dialog track is exceptionally clear, sharp, and stable throughout, ensuring that viewers will have no trouble following the narrative. Importantly, the review found no significant age-related anomalies that might detract from the overall audio experience.
While this LPCM 2.0 mix may lack the immersive qualities associated with modern multi-channel formats such as DTS or Dolby Atmos, it effectively delivers a faithful reproduction of the film's sound design. The presentation maintains an authentic and nostalgic quality that aligns with the film's vintage aesthetics, making it a fitting accompaniment to "Banning."
Extras: 71
The Blu Ray extras for "Banning" offer a compelling glimpse into both the making of the film and its cultural milieu. The program "A Hole in the One" features Robert Wagner and Jill St. John engagingly discussing their acting careers, the film's unique historical context, and Universal's influence during that era. Insights on Gene Hackman's role and authentic golf hustlers enrich the narrative. "Members Only: Scoring Banning" provides an expert analysis by Jon Burlingame on Quincy Jones's distinctive score, highlighting notable studio trends of the time. The vintage trailer offers a nostalgic throwback, capturing the original promotion style, while the commentary by critics Howard S. Berger and Steve Mitchell lends depth with their extensive insights. The additional treat of an isolated score track offers audiophiles a pristine listening experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- A Hole in the One: Robert Wagner and Jill St. John discuss career evolution and film nuances.
- Members Only: Scoring Banning: Jon Burlingame analyzes Quincy Jones’s score.
- Trailer: Vintage trailer for "Banning."
- Commentary: Audio commentary by Howard S. Berger and Steve Mitchell.
- Isolated Score: Presented as a LPCM 2.0 track.
Movie: 74
The 1967 film "Banning," directed by Ron Winston and brought to Blu-ray by Imprint Films, is a quintessential example of Universal's late sixties strategy in film production, characterized by a blend of TV production efficiencies and B-movie aesthetics. Despite its theatrical release, "Banning" was produced within a constrained 21-day shooting schedule, typical of the era's quick-turnaround studio films utilizing the cost-effective Techniscope format. This method imbued the film with unique visual qualities, featuring plentiful light and vibrant colors that diverge from traditional noir shadows.
The narrative intricately weaves a story of hidden gamesmanship within an upscale country club in Arizona, where Robert Wagner's character, Mike Banning, disrupts the status quo. This film oscillates between suspense and intrigue as Banning navigates complex interpersonal dynamics, heightened by the performances of its leading ladies — Jill St. John, Susan Clark, and Anjanette Comer — each of whom adds layers of glamour and complexity. St. John's performance notably outshines her male counterpart with a contemporary sharpness that intensifies the film's appeal.
"Banning" is a deceptive oddity; although a small film by conception, it carries a grand presence due to its thematic richness and stylistic audacity. Its music score by Quincy Jones enhances the film's stylish edge, assisted by Gil Bernal's recurrent rendition of "The Eyes of Love." These audio elements, along with Winston's directorial choices, make "Banning" a remarkably stylish artifact of its time, reflecting an ambitious narrative ambition rarely associated with its modest production roots. This amalgam of style, substance, and ambition results in a film that is compelling, showcasing an unforeseen layered artistry born out of restrained circumstances.
Total: 81
Imprint Films has delivered an impressive new 2K remaster of "Banning," a lesser-known yet fascinating entry into the neo-noir genre. The film follows a trend seen in similar titles, such as "Warning Shot" and "P.J.," adopting film noir's thematic elements while eschewing its traditional stylistic aspects in favor of vibrant colors and light. This bold visual choice arguably laid the groundwork for the more recognizable neo-noir films that gained popularity in the 1980s and 1990s, making "Banning" an essential viewing experience for enthusiasts keen on exploring the genre's evolution.
One of the standout features of this Blu-Ray release is an insightful exclusive program that includes discussions with stars Robert Wagner and Jill St. John, adding depth and context to the film's production and historical significance. Additionally, the release includes the interview "Members Only: Scoring Banning," featuring film music historian Jon Burlingame. This feature dwells on the innovative contributions of Quincy Jones, spotlighting his role in the transition from grand orchestral scores to jazz-infused soundtracks, thus augmenting viewers' appreciation for Jones' impact on the film's auditory landscape.
Concluding, Imprint Films' release of "Banning" is a must-own for collectors and film aficionados alike. The impressive visual restoration, coupled with enriching supplemental content, significantly enhances the viewing experience. These additions not only bring out the fascinating historical context of "Banning" within the neo-noir canon but also highlight its contributions to cinematic innovation. Highly recommended for those looking to deepen their understanding of how such films influenced modern cinema's narrative and aesthetic transformations.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
In a few areas, small density fluctuations can be observed, but they are a byproduct of stylistic choices and minor weaknesses inherited from the interpositive....
Audio: 100
I think that a lot of what makes Banning a stylish film has something to do with the music and the manner in which it is used....
Extras: 70
"A Hole in the One" - in this exclusive new program, Robert Wagner and Jill St. John talk discuss the evolution of their acting careers, their collaboration on Banning, the era in which the film was shot...
Movie: 80
However, the three big female leads are to die for and the reason Banning quickly evolves into a strikingly stylish and very intriguing film....
Total: 80
These genre films tend to behave like film noirs, but reject their classic stylistic identity and always play with a lot of light and bright colors....
The Digital Bits review by Stuart Galbraith IVRead review here
Video: 85
Audio: 90
Extras: 80
Movie: 75
Many of these were shot in the less expensive Techniscope format, with budgets and schedules comparable to the company’s TV-movies....
Total: 83
Burlingame knows his stuff, and does an excellent job putting the late composer’s work—and the rise of jazz scores in place of big orchestral ones—into context....
Director: Ron Winston
Actors: Robert Wagner, Anjanette Comer, Jill St. John
PlotMike, a talented but troubled golf pro with a checkered past, arrives at an exclusive country club seeking employment. Attempting to rebuild his life, he's hired as an assistant to the club's head professional. Mike soon becomes entangled in the social dynamics and politics of the club, where members include affluent and influential individuals. His charm captivates various members, including Carol, the club president's daughter, and Angela, a spirited socialite. As Mike navigates his new environment, he discovers that his redemption is complicated by his unresolved issues and the temptations of the privileged world around him.
While trying to keep his past hidden, Mike faces growing pressures, both on and off the golf course. His involvement with the club's members draws him into a rivalry with fellow golfer Jonathan. Struggling to maintain his position at the club and his relationships with Carol and Angela, Mike finds himself making difficult choices. As tensions mount at a high-stakes golf tournament hosted by the club, Mike must confront not only his competitors but also the personal demons he has been running from. He must decide whether he will continue down a path of self-destruction or strive for personal redemption and integrity amidst the cutthroat environment of wealth and privilege.
Writers: James Lee, Hamilton Maule
Release Date: 13 Dec 1967
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English