The Green Mile 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Green Mile shines on screen and 4K, capturing deep emotions and stunning visuals, despite some flaws.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 70
The Green Mile's 4K UHD presentation enhances detail and color, offering a natural, crisp image, though marred by over-processing that reduces film grain, with mixed feelings on the DNR application.
Audio: 74
The Green Mile's Dolby Atmos track delivers immersive, clear, and atmospheric sound with precise effects, dialogue, and score, enriching the movie's ambiance without feeling overdone.
Extra: 73
The re-release of The Green Mile includes familiar extras like Darabont's commentary, making-of documentaries, tests, and trailers but disappoints with no new additions and poor cover art.
Movie: 80
Adapting King's intricate tales to film is tough but Darabont's faithful 'The Green Mile' adaptation shines, blending character depth with cinematic grace, despite its home release critiques and the moral complexities of death row life it unveils.
Video: 70
The Green Mile's visual revival on the 4K UHD Blu-ray format showcases an impressive leap over its previous Blu-ray edition, benefiting from a meticulous new 4K scan of the original camera negative, complemented by a clean-up effort that enhances detail and color without overly compromising the film's authentic grain texture. Shot using Panavision Panaflex Platinum cameras on 35mm film, the transfer onto a native 3840 x 2160p resolution, paired with High Dynamic Range (HDR), Wide Colour Gamut (WCG), and encoded using the HEVC (H.265) codec, culminates in a presentation where the nuances of facial textures, clothing weaves, and environmental dilapidation are rendered with striking clarity and depth. The applied DNR (Digital Noise Reduction) has been a point of contention, attributed to smoothing out film grain to the verge of artifact emergence, potentially diminishing the organic feel of certain scenes by introducing smearing or waxy backgrounds which, despite these flaws, does not detract significantly from the overall rich visual experience.
Warner Bros.'s delicate handling of the film's natural aesthetic in this transfer is evident in improved color saturation and fidelity, shadow detail, and black levels, creating a more immersive atmosphere that is significantly less processed compared to its aged predecessor. Scenes once marred by brightness and contrast boosting or artificial color tints now reveal a warm, natural palette where light and darkness play more authentically across the characters' surroundings. Details previously lost or flattened due to older encoding methods are revitalized, from the subtle interplay of light in nighttime scenes to the vivid depiction of landscapes and interiors, all benefitting from an HDR enhancement that provides a balanced, yet striking representation of the film's composite moments.
The nuanced treatment of HDR and WCG in this transfer successfully brings out the intensity of The Green Mile's darker cinematography alongside a refreshed color palette dominated by dense amber hues and opposing blues during nightfall scenes. While Warner's decision to employ a mild filter has left some wide shots looking slightly softened, close-ups and medium shots remain unaffected, showcasing explosive detail that brings the characters and their environments to life with unprecedented vividness. Despite minimal grain, which may not appeal to purists seeking an unfiltered film experience, the overall effect is a compelling blend of warmth and clarity that utilizes 4K technology to emphasize the atmospheric depth of this cinematic masterpiece.
Audio: 74
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "The Green Mile" features an exemplary Dolby Atmos audio track that greatly enhances the viewing experience, bringing a level of immersion and spatial awareness that is both refined and atmospheric. The transition from the previous 5.1 mix to this Atmos remix has been handled with finesse, producing a soundstage that not only envelops the viewer with clear and natural dialogue from the frontal array but also utilizes the overhead channels and surround sound to create a vivid ambience. The well-integrated sound effects, from the rolling thunder to the echo of footsteps in the prison corridors, and the distinct separation within the mix, contribute to a convincing atmosphere that is both expansive and detailed. The score by Thomas Newman is dynamic and full-bodied across all channels, lending an additional layer of emotional depth to the film's most impactful moments.
In technical terms, this Atmos track is a showcase of auditory craftsmanship, meticulously balancing the clarity and volume of dialogue with the atmospheric sounds and background elements to produce a seamless auditory experience. The thunder rolls and electric chair deaths, in particular, demonstrate the effective use of bass and the depth of LF effects, creating rumbling scenes that leave a lasting impression. Whether it’s the eerie silence of an empty cell or the dramatic intensity of John Coffey's powers, each element is carefully placed within the mix to achieve an optimal sense of space and directionality.
Reviewers using advanced home theater setups, such as the Denon AVR-X4300H with MK Sound and Atmosphere ceiling-mounted speakers, have noted the track's energy and precision. Even though some may pine for the inclusion of theatrical audio mixes, the consensus appears to be that this Dolby Atmos remix not only honors but elevates the original audio design. Integration of discrete elements into the overall soundscape is smoother, and background sounds like jail cell doors or distant conversations are more immediately present, wrapping up an audio presentation that is as atmospheric as it is technically accomplished.
Extras: 73
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "The Green Mile" brings together a comprehensive collection of extras, albeit with no new exclusive content to this edition. Both discs contain director Frank Darabont's insightful audio commentary, offering a deep dive into the making and thematic complexities of the film. The Blu-ray disc holds the bulk of supplemental material, including a concise version of the making-of documentary, extensive featurettes exploring the creative process behind the movie, and an array of deleted scenes and tests that provide a unique look into the casting and visual choices. Despite the lack of brand-new features or the longer documentary found in previous deluxe editions, the collection remains a richly satisfying experience for fans, preserving the film's legacy through its detailed exploration of behind-the-scenes content.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by director Frank Darabont: Available on both 4K and Blu-ray discs.
- Walking the Mile: The Making of The Green Mile: A succinct documentary on the film's production.
- Miracles and Mystery: Creating The Green Mile: An in-depth featurette on the film's creative process.
- Deleted Scenes: Includes two clips shedding light on the editing decisions.
- Michael Clarke Duncan's Screen Test: A rare glimpse into the casting process.
- Tom Hanks' Makeup Tests: Reveals the transformation process for Hanks' character.
- Teaser and Trailer: Compilation of promotional materials, including interviews.
Movie: 80
Frank Darabont's adaptation of Stephen King's "The Green Mile" into a 4K UHD Blu-Ray presentation offers an exemplary case of how a filmmaker can securely translate the intricate narratives and deep character studies of a novel onto the silver screen without losing the essence that made the source material beloved. In this adaptation, Darabont elects to retain the fidelity to King's original story, foregrounding the nuanced interplay among four central characters: the inherently good Paul Edgecomb (Tom Hanks), the misunderstood John Coffey (Michael Clarke Duncan), the malevolently evil 'Wild Bill' Wharton (Sam Rockwell), and the odiously petty Percy Wetmore (Doug Hutchison). This choice ensures that the deep emotional and moral complexities of the tale are preserved, offering a movie that unfolds with the gravitas and detail of a novel, exploring themes of justice, mercy, and the human condition amidst the backdrop of death row's grim reality.
Despite some critiques regarding its lengthy runtime exceeding three hours, "The Green Mile" still stands as a towering achievement in cinematic storytelling, thanks primarily to Darabont's directorial sensitivity and the remarkable performances of its cast. The 4K UHD Blu-Ray rendition amplifies this experience with a markedly improved video quality that outshines previous editions. Warner Bros.' latest release elevates the visual presentation of Darabont’s film, ensuring that both its finely tuned emotional beats and the lush cinematography are rendered with striking clarity and depth. However, it's worth noting that enthusiasts expecting a revamped array of special features alongside this visual upgrade may find the offerings somewhat lacking, as focuses primarily on improving the foundational viewing experience rather than expanding the contextual framing provided by ancillary content.
Technical improvements aside, "The Green Mile" is ultimately an enduring tale of humanity’s dual capacities for empathy and cruelty, effectively conveyed through Darabont’s faithful adaptation amid the claustrophobic confines of death row. The 4K UHD version heightens the storytelling through enhanced visual detail, further immersing viewers in the emotional landscapes navigated by the memorable characters. Despite potential criticisms over its prolonged narrative, the film remains a poignant exploration into the moral dilemmas faced by those guarding society's condemned, inviting audiences to reflect on notions of justice and redemption in a manner that is both captivating and thought-provoking.
Total: 73
The Green Mile," skillfully adapted from Stephen King's novel by writer/director Frank Darabont, stands as a formidable narrative that seamlessly blends love, loathing, and a profound exploration of human emotions within the precincts of a prison ward. Darabont's direction ensures that the film transcends its lengthy runtime through impeccable pacing, allowing for substantial character development and a narrative that flows with ease, engaging the audience deeply. The richness of its storytelling, combined with stellar performances, cements the film's position as not only deserving of its numerous accolades but also as a piece worthy of its runtime for the emotional resonance it achieves.
Warner Bros.' 4K Ultra HD release of "The Green Mile" enhances this cinematic experience with a presentation that significantly improves upon previous home video formats. The 2160p, HDR-enhanced transfer brings out the finest details in the film's excellent cinematography, with richer colors, deeper blacks, and more pronounced highlights compared to its Blu-ray counterpart. This upgrade benefits greatly from a native 4K image, though it’s not without its drawbacks, such as digital noise reduction which, while erasing grain, introduces its own set of challenges. The Dolby Atmos audio track provides a clear, well-separated soundscape with robust bass, elevating the immersive experience. However, fans might note the absence of original theatrical audio and expanded extras, which slightly dampens the overall package.
In conclusion, while the 4K UHD release of "The Green Mile" is not without its minor quibbles, such as digital noise reduction effects and a lack of expanded documentary content, it undoubtedly presents an outstanding visual and auditory improvement over previous editions. This release is highly recommended for both long-time admirers of the film and newcomers alike, offering an enriched viewing experience that more closely honors the depth and nuance of Darabont's masterful adaptation.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 60
The WCG and HDR give a significant boost to the colouring, you can feel the heat of the Louisiana summer, greens are lush, red pops and blue is crisp....
Audio: 80
The Dolby Atmos surround track adds a real sense of immersion without any artificiality; the overhead channels are used to provide strong ambience and effects, with the rumble of thunder, exploding lights...
Extras: 60
Miracles and Mystery: Creating The Green Mile Deleted Scenes Michael Clarke Duncan's Screen Test Tom Hanks' Makeup Tests Teaser Trailer and Trailer...
Movie: 80
Whilst there are a number of others, all equally as fine in their roles, it is these four, and their interaction with the narrative around which the story unfolds....
Total: 70
The 4K UHD set from Warner is passable, the native 4K image is certainly a vast improvement from the old Blu-ray in terms of absolute detail, rich colouring, strong blacks and spectacular highlights, but...
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
Other moments, such as amber-lit afternoons and other "magic hour" moments, provide more of an overall blanket... yet this effect still feels much more natural than the old Blu-ray, which traded in natural...
Audio: 60
Other background elements -- jail cell doors, private conversations, occasional screams -- are likewise treated to a more immediate and involving presence that cements this as a strong and well-balanced...
Extras: 90
The included Blu-ray is identical to the 2009 release and retains all of those extras, while the 4K disc thankfully at least repeats the vintage audio commentary by director Frank Darabont....
Movie: 70
Warner Bros.' original 2009 Blu-ray was succeeded by a Diamond Luxe Edition five years later, which expanded the bonus features but retained its outdated, VC-1 encoded 1080p transfer, While Warner Bros.'...
Total: 70
Additionally, the new Atmos remix sounds a good deal more natural that the somewhat patchwork 5.1 mix... but the lack of theatrical audio, a remastered Blu-ray disc, and the expanded "Walking the Mile"...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
Darker cinematography allows the light sources to blossom, whether it’s interior electric bulbs or exterior sun bleeding in through windows....
Audio: 100
An effortlessly spacious Dolby Atmos track isn’t a mix full of bluster and bang, but it’s a sensational, moody, and atmospheric example....
Extras: 80
That includes deleted scenes, a making-of documentary, featurettes, make-up tests, Duncan’s screen test, and a unique look at how the teaser trailer came together....
Movie: 100
But, Green Mile isn’t exploitative with its magical realism, rather challenging the notion of innocence and whether modern society would kill a man capable of curing cancer purely for their own self-satisfaction....
Total: 90
Confined to a prison ward, The Green Mile brilliantly explores life, empathy, revenge, and religious beliefs through its genuine characters....
Director: Frank Darabont
Actors: Tom Hanks, Michael Clarke Duncan, David Morse
PlotIn a Louisiana penitentiary during the Great Depression, Paul Edgecomb is a death row corrections officer who oversees inmates awaiting their execution on "The Green Mile," so named because of the green linoleum that lines the floor. The routine of grim responsibilities weighs heavily on Paul and his team of guards, who are seasoned to the harsh realities of their work, which includes facilitating the final walk of condemned men. Their lives take an unexpected turn with the arrival of a gigantic black man named John Coffey, convicted of the violent rape and murder of two young white girls—a crime that his simple-minded demeanor and gentle nature seem to contradict.
Coffey displays extraordinary, supernatural abilities that defy explanation and deeply affect Paul and the other guards. As bizarre incidents unfold on the mile, Coffey forms a special bond with the empathetic Paul, who starts to question the morality of his occupation and whether justice is truly being served. While dealing with the daily dramas of life on the block, including the arrival of a dangerous and delinquent new inmate and the personal struggles of his colleagues, Paul is forced to confront his own moral compass as he learns more about Coffey's mysterious gift, and the profound impact it has on those around him.
Writers: Stephen King, Frank Darabont
Release Date: 10 Dec 1999
Runtime: 189 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, French