Fu sing Blu-ray Review
Score: 52
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'Floating City' impresses visually, lacks emotional depth but has moments of brilliance.
Disc Release Date
Video: 59
'Floating City' Blu-ray offers a detailed presentation with intentional desaturation, vivid scenes, and minor artifacts in an impressive HD display, balancing nostalgic tones with sharp clarity.
Audio: 69
Floating City boasts a nuanced DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio with dynamic range, from subtle ambiance to vigorous storms, balancing crisp dialogue and a moving score, providing an immersive and detailed sonic experience.
Extra: 6
Film's trailer in 1080p (HD) and Dolby Digital 5.1 sound, duration 2:05 minutes, showcases immersive viewing and audio experience.
Movie: 56
'Floating City' explores identity and societal struggle with a visually striking yet emotionally disjointed narrative, rooted in a man's quest amidst Hong Kong's cultural shifts.
Video: 59
"Floating City" arrives on Blu-ray with a commendable presentation, courtesy of Well Go USA, featuring an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in both 2.39:1 and 2.35:1 aspect ratios. This digitally shot production showcases an impressive array of details, thanks to its refined usage of high-definition capabilities. Key examples include scenes where minor elements like old age makeup and dust mites become distinctly visible, highlighting the transfer’s ability to capture the minutiae of every scene. While the overall color palette leans towards desaturation, with predominant beiges and browns, strategic uses of color—such as the vibrant blue fish—offer visual respite, enhancing the film's aesthetic richness.
Despite the transfer’s strengths, there are some hurdles, including a light grain-like noise and occasional banding/false contouring visible during transition scenes or darker moments. These are minor but noteworthy distractions in an otherwise clear and detailed presentation. The cinematography’s deliberate choice of subdued and cool tones against golden glazes supports the narrative's emotional depth without excessively relying on visual vibrancy. Contrast levels are carefully managed, ensuring that even with slightly elevated black levels, details aren't lost to murkiness.
The presentation’s dedication to preserving the director’s vision is evident through its handling of various artistic choices, such as the aggressive color grading in certain sequences for thematic emphasis and the nuanced balance between clarity and artistic softness in dreamlike scenes. Despite some technical imperfections, "Floating City’s" Blu-ray video quality effectively complements its visual storytelling, making it a visually sumptuous experience that boasts meticulous attention to both grand vistas and intricate details.
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of "Fu sing" on its 4K UHD Blu-ray edition boasts a rich and nuanced soundscape that impressively complements the film's narrative. The lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track excels in delivering both the subtlety of quieter moments and the intensity of more vigorous sequences. Notable highlights include the storm sequence at the film's onset and a dream sequence predicting a character's demise, both of which demonstrate the track's dynamic range and its ability to render environmental sounds with striking clarity and realism. These scenes benefit immensely from deep low-end effects and a meticulous balance of ambient sounds, ensuring an immersive listening experience that extends well beyond the central action.
Dialogue within the film is uniformly clear and well-integrated with the surrounding audio elements, allowing for an effortless follow-through of the storyline amidst a myriad of auditory stimuli. The environmental ambience, particularly in scenes depicting natural elements like storms, is rendered with exceptional detail, leveraging both the front and rear channels to envelop the viewer in the film's atmospheric settings. This spatial audio execution is further enhanced by the sound design's seamless directionality, as exemplified by convincingly placed audio cues that reflect on-screen events, such as the precise imaging of a flying plane.
The Cantonese DTS-HD MA 5.1 track, along with an optional Dolby Digital 2.0 version, offers an authentic auditory experience that remains faithful to the source material. Equipped with optional English subtitles, the tracks maintain a harmonious balance among dialogue, effects, and the film's evocative score. The emotional depth of the score is particularly noteworthy, showcasing a broad dynamic range that adds a rich layer to the film's emotional beats. Together, these elements underscore the audio presentation's ability to deliver a compelling and atmospherically rich experience that significantly enhances the overall viewing experience of "Fu sing."
Extras: 6
The extra presentation of the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Fu sing" showcases a high-quality trailer that serves as a compelling preview of the film's cinematic experience. Presented in 1080p resolution and enriched with Dolby Digital 5.1 sound, the trailer provides viewers with a vivid and immersive auditory and visual experience, offering a tantalizing glimpse into the movie's storyline and its high-definition brilliance. The adherence to technical excellence ensures that enthusiasts and potential viewers receive a polished and enticing introduction to the film, signifying the care taken in every aspect of its home release.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: The film's trailer in 1080p with immersive Dolby Digital 5.1 sound.
Movie: 56
"Floating City," directed by Yim Ho, a stalwart of the Hong Kong New Wave movement, delves into the nuanced and tumultuous narrative of Bo Wah-Chun (Aaron Kwok), navigating through life's multifaceted layers as a multiracial individual in a predominantly homogeneous society. The film intricately encapsulates Bo's journey, commencing from his infancy, abandoned and subsequently nurtured by a tanka fishing family, grappling with poverty and societal estrangement, to his eventual ascent within the corporate echelons of the British East India Company. The portrayal of Bo's life showcases a poignant exploration of identity, belonging, and the ceaseless quest for personal and familial acceptance, against the backdrop of Hong Kong's complex colonial history and socio-cultural evolution.
The narrative structure, underpinned by Bo's personal odyssey, serves as a metaphorical canvas reflecting the broader themes of racial ambiguity, class disparity, and the inherent quest for identity amidst the whispered remnants of British colonial rule and Chinese traditionalism. Despite Aaron Kwok's earnest portrayal, the film intermittently succumbs to melodramatic excesses and a somewhat disjointed storyline, which occasionally detracts from its otherwise compelling thematic narrative. Yim Ho's direction oscillates between the visually stunning and the overtly didactic, navigating through Bo's emotionally charged life events with alternating finesse and heavy-handedness.
While "Floating City" ambitiously attempts to interweave Bo's individual struggles with the overarching narrative of Hong Kong's identity crisis, it sometimes falls short in cohesively connecting these parallel threads, leaving certain thematic explorations and character developments feeling underexplored or superficially addressed. Nonetheless, the film triumphs in moments that focus on intimate familial dynamics and Bo's relentless pursuit of self-discovery against the odds. Despite its flaws, "Floating City" emerges as a visually evocative and thematically rich cinematic endeavor that reflects on the enduring human spirit and the complex tapestry of life in a transitioning Hong Kong.
Total: 52
"Floating City," a film that intricately weaves together a narrative amidst the backdrop of Hong Kong's impending shift from British rule, showcases director Yim Ho's knack for creating visually compelling cinema. While the protagonist Bo's journey through personal and political upheavals forms the crux of the story, it's perhaps the depth of its kaleidoscopic ensemble—most notably Bo's mother—that leaves a lasting impression, anchoring the emotional depth the narrative aspires to achieve. Despite these strengths, there is a palpable sense of missed opportunities to delve deeper into the emotional and thematic potential laid out throughout Bo's saga. This slight misstep doesn’t completely distract from the film’s visual and auditory achievements on its 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation. The video quality is consistently solid, delivering a spectacular visual experience that complements Yim’s directorial vision, while the audio mix, though subtle, is impressively robust, enhancing the immersive experience of Hong Kong’s transition era.
On the technical front, this 4K UHD Blu-ray edition of "Floating City" does not disappoint, offering a stellar video transfer and a strong audio performance. However, the lack of substantive extras, save for a trailer, might leave enthusiasts wanting more insights into the film's creation and historical context. Despite these minor drawbacks, "Floating City" manages to engage with its earnest storytelling and the director’s heartfelt execution over a sprawling fifty-year narrative.
In conclusion, "Floating City" on 4K UHD Blu-ray is a commendable release that might not fully explore all its thematic ambitions but certainly delivers a visually stunning and audibly engaging experience. The film, with its rich portrayal of characters set against a dramatically changing Hong Kong, coupled with a high-quality technical presentation, makes it a recommended acquisition for fans of Yim Ho’s work and those fascinated by sweeping dramas that span decades. Yet, the absence of in-depth special features leaves a bit to be desired for those looking to dive deeper into the film's historical and cinematic context.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
The tanka docks are awash in beiges and browns, with only occasional pieces of fabric or the impressively blue fish that Bo is compared to offering any tonal relief....
Audio: 90
Even relatively quieter moments, like some of the charming scenes with Bo and his cousin as children, provide a wealth of ambient environmental noise spilling through the side channels....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 60
The eldest of these kids tries to quell the tears of her younger siblings upon this traumatic transition, mimicking her mother's frequent admonition that "we're not beggars", but Bo is obviously motivated...
Total: 70
While not a complete success, Floating City is far from a failure, and there's certainly a lot here to admire....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Detail is good throughout, however, and the picture retains a nice sense of dimension and sharp clarity....
Audio: 80
Though its auditory content is relatively modest, the track offers a convincing sense of atmosphere that complements the story well....
Extras: 0
Trailer (HD, 2 min) - The film's trailer is presented in 1080p with Dolby Digital 5.1 sound....
Movie: 60
Ho tackles many worthwhile themes dealing with family, love, class, self-worth, and Chinese history, but these various elements can sometimes seem a bit detached from one another, and ultimately lack that...
Total: 40
The film has some issues, but there is sincere heart in the director's execution, and several stretches of Chuen's journey are genuinely engaging....
Director: Ho Yim
Actors: Aaron Kwok, Josie Ho, Annie Liu
PlotIn the bustling world of Hong Kong, a successful middle-aged businessman finds his life in a downward spiral when he suddenly loses everything - his business, his money, and his reputation. Accustomed to a life of luxury and high social status, this catastrophic loss forces him to confront his values and the foundations of his identity. Struggling to cope with his new reality, he becomes entangled in the city's underbelly, a world far removed from the one he once dominated. As he navigates through his despair, he crosses paths with a variety of individuals from different walks of life, who play a pivotal role in his journey of self-discovery and redemption.
Among these individuals are a resilient street-smart woman and a young, ambitious dreamer, both of whom are facing their own personal crises. The interactions and relationships formed between them serve as a catalyst for transformation, challenging their perceptions of success, happiness, and the essence of true wealth. As they each confront their struggles, they learn valuable lessons about resilience, compassion, and the unbreakable human spirit. The narrative weaves a compelling tale of loss, recovery, and the quest for a meaningful life amidst the chaos of modern existence.
Writers: Marco Pong, Ho Yim
Release Date: 18 May 2012
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Cantonese