Gotti Blu-ray Review
Score: 53
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Though technically solid, 'Gotti' struggles with disjointed storytelling, resembling a cable special more than a theatrical film; Travolta's performance is its redeeming feature.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 63
Gotti's 1080p/AVC-encoded Blu-ray presentation in 2.4:1/2.39:1 aspect ratio, shot digitally with Sony F55, features excellent detail, sharpness, and makeup effects, though it displays a drab, darkened color palette, inconsistent black levels, and some ragged stock footage moments.
Audio: 63
"Gotti's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track provides clear dialogue and punchy moments of gunfire, though its use of ambient sounds and directional effects is limited. The musical score sometimes feels out of place, and surround activity is sporadic, making it a solid but not exemplary audio presentation."
Extra: 26
Gotti arrives on Blu-ray completely bare-bones with no bonus features, front-loaded trailers, or supplements, aside from a brief featurette.
Movie: 40
Despite John Travolta's valiant performance, 'Gotti' is a disjointed and underwhelming biopic marred by a lack of coherent direction, inconsistent storytelling, and weak character development. While Travolta's commitment is evident, the film fails to capitalize on its intriguing subject matter, leaving it structurally hazardous and ultimately unsatisfying.
Video: 63
The Blu-ray release of "Gotti" presents the film with a strong AVC-encoded 1080p transfer framed in a 2.4:1 widescreen aspect ratio. Captured digitally using Sony F55 cameras, the high-definition video presentation generally maintains excellent detail levels and sharpness across various scenes. Even in the film’s more poorly lit environments, such as penitentiaries, the detail remains consistent. Despite a somewhat drab aesthetic, with a color palette dominated by yellows and browns, the makeup's extraordinary detail, particularly on Travolta, stands out impressively. No significant issues of image instability or compression anomalies are apparent, ensuring a stable and clean visual experience.
Although the overall presentation leans towards a darker and cooler tone, the occasional brightly lit outdoor scenes provide a welcomed warmth and pop. Blacks levels aren’t the film's strongest asset, though they remain adequate throughout. While the color scheme lacks vibrancy, the visual quality ensures that texture details—such as suits and environmental nuances—are well-rendered, contributing to a well-rounded viewing. Notably, the transfer handles stock footage reasonably, despite some ragged appearances, which aligns the Blu-ray experience closely with the film's intended visual style. In sum, "Gotti" on Blu-ray delivers a competent video presentation that remains faithful to its cinematic roots.
Audio: 63
Gotti's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track offers a solid, though not exemplary, auditory experience. The dialogue is consistently clear and well-prioritized across the frontal array, ensuring that the primary vocal interactions remain comprehensible throughout the film. While the track includes some effective gunfire and explosive sequences, these moments are sporadic and serve more as brief intervals of intensity rather than maintaining a consistently immersive atmosphere. The film’s musical score, though competently integrated, sometimes feels incongruous with its period setting, and its reliance on modern tracks, such as the Pitbull-inspired finale, can occasionally undermine the intended gravitas.
Surround activity is largely confined to enhancing the musical soundtrack, with limited use of ambient effects that might add depth to the viewing experience. There are certain settings, like the prison scenes between Gotti and his son, where environmental effects effectively dot the side and rear channels, adding to the immersion. However, these instances are relatively infrequent, and the overall surround usage feels minimal. Despite this, the audio elements are rendered cleanly and without noticeable issues. It’s also worth noting that some inconsistencies regarding audio options on the packaging may cause confusion; however, sticking to the 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track ensures the most reliable playback.
In summary, Gotti’s DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 presentation provides a competent but not particularly dynamic audio experience. It offers clear dialogue and occasional impactful scenes but generally lacks consistent use of environmental effects and surround sound activity. The musical score, while fitting in parts, sometimes disrupts the period ambiance. Overall, it’s a serviceable track that handles the essentials well but doesn't stand out as a demo-quality example.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray edition of "Gotti" is notably sparse in its offering, catering exclusively to those interested in the main feature without additional content. This release includes minimal, if any, supplemental material beyond the movie itself, leaving enthusiasts and collectors wanting for behind-the-scenes insights or additional contextual content.
Extras included in this disc: Just a brief Featurette: A minor inclusion that provides a quick overview, but lacks depth and substantial content to enrich the viewer’s experience.
Movie: 40
"Gotti" is a biographical drama hampered by its inconsistent direction and disjointed narrative structure. The film, which had been in development for over a decade, finally surfaced with Kevin Connolly at the helm, delivering a production that often felt more like a made-for-cable movie than a theatrical release. The film's non-linear timeline is a challenge, regularly bouncing between key moments in John Gotti's life without sufficient coherence. This fragmented storytelling fails to fully capture the complexities of Gotti’s character or the gravity of his rise and fall within the American crime landscape.
John Travolta’s committed portrayal of John Gotti is the film’s standout feature, bringing charisma and depth to a role that otherwise struggles under the weight of underdeveloped characters and patchy editing. Travolta’s dedication injects some life into an otherwise mediocre script, overshadowing a cast that grapples with limited material. The inclusion of real-life footage adds a touch of authenticity but only highlights the film’s inability to delve deeply into Gotti’s infamous reputation and the intricate dynamics of his criminal empire.
Despite its potential and Travolta’s engaging performance, "Gotti" ultimately falls short in its execution. The film attempts to emulate the style of successful mob dramas but lacks the substance and craft to stand on its own. The use of popular music feels forced, and the frequent voice-overs fail to provide the insightful commentary needed to elevate the narrative. In essence, "Gotti" is more a cinematic curiosity than a compelling biography, marred by its structural flaws and failure to capitalize on its intriguing subject matter.
Total: 53
"Gotti" offers a mixed viewing experience, characterized by standout performances and average technical qualities. The film, directed by Kevin Connolly, attempts to chronicle the life of infamous New York gangster John Gotti, played with dedication by John Travolta. Travolta delivers a committed portrayal that stands as one of the best in his later career. His performance, along with those of the supporting cast, elevates an otherwise uneven narrative. Despite its shortcomings, "Gotti" presents enough intriguing elements and moments to hold viewer interest, but it often feels more like a cable television feature than a major cinematic release.
The UK's Blu-ray release does justice to the film’s technical aspects, offering solid video and audio quality that fans would appreciate. The picture quality is clear and the sound design effectively captures the film's gritty urban atmosphere. However, the production's low-budget constraints are noticeable throughout, preventing it from reaching the heightened visual and auditory echelons achieved by higher-tier mob dramas. Nonetheless, for enthusiasts of Travolta or the genre, the Blu-ray edition provides a competent viewing platform.
Overall, "Gotti" is a serviceable watch that neither excels nor entirely disappoints. It is primarily buoyed by Travolta's magnetic performance and its faithful depiction of its subject’s life. While it may not have deserved the harshest critiques it received upon release, its modest production values and lack of cohesive storytelling prevent it from becoming anything more than a decent addition to the gangster film lexicon. The Blu-ray release is respectable, making it worthwhile primarily for fans or those intrigued by this chapter of American criminal history.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 80
It's a limited budget feature where, as aforementioned, the most impressive production element is the makeup, but the presentation does a decent enough job to elevate the film above straight-to-video fodder....
Audio: 80
The accompanying DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track has a little punch to it, but sometimes this can be a little incongruous given the material, with more punchy songs and beats designed to give it some vibrancy,...
Extras: 30
...
Movie: 50
The subject matter is there - the story of one of the most famous crime bosses in American history - but handling it is another matter entirely, and relatively inexperienced director Kevin Connolly (on...
Total: 60
Only really worth watching for John Travolta, giving a late career high performance and embracing what could have been a defining role in a poorly put-together biography of the colourful New York gangster,...
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
A lot of the film takes place in less than well lit environments, including several scenes inside various penitentiaries, but aside from passing deficits in shadow detail, general detail levels remain...
Audio: 80
Gotti's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 has moments of nice immersion courtesy of a glut of sometimes outr� source cues which are often used as a kind of bizarro world counterpoint to what's actually being displayed...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 40
It's a minor point, admittedly, but one which may indicate a certain lack of specificity that, ironically combined with picayune details about other elements of Gotti's life, makes Gotti both unclear and...
Total: 40
It's kind of interesting to note that there's some online data discussing the hard time Gotti had finding a distributor, but what's really interesting is that one of the production entities listed is "MoviePass...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
With the above in mind, and not having seen Gotti during its theatrical run (but hey, did any of us?), it's probably a good bet that the transfer here provides a proper interpretation of what the movie...
Audio: 60
In addition to the 5.1 DTS lossless track, a 2.0 track is also available, although your mileage may vary on how your receiver decodes it....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 40
Despite being often very watchable, the movie doesn't hold a candle to other mob movies, although Connolly definitely tries to use the same methods here that made Martin Scorsese's GoodFellas one of the...
Total: 40
While no one will ever accuse Gotti of being a great film, it certainly was not deserving of the critical thrashing it received during its brief theatrical run....
Director: Kevin Connolly
Actors: John Travolta, Spencer Rocco Lofranco, Kelly Preston
PlotThe film documents the rise of John Gotti, Sr., a mob boss known for his ruthlessness, charm, and strategic intelligence, which propels him to the top of New York City's Gambino crime family. The narrative is delivered through a series of flashbacks intertwined with scenes from Gotti's later years in prison, offering glimpses into his early underworld activities, including violent encounters, cunning maneuvers, and his unwavering ambition that secures his position as a formidable leader. Throughout the movie, we witness Gotti's complex relationships with his family members and fellow mobsters, particularly his mentor Aniello Dellacroce, which play crucial roles in shaping his journey.
The second half shifts focus to the increasing tensions between Gotti and law enforcement, as determined prosecutors tirelessly pursue his conviction. Simultaneously, the narrative presents the internal struggles within Gotti’s personal life and highlights his efforts to shield his family from his criminal undertakings. The story delves into the dramatic highs and lows of maintaining power within an unpredictable and perilous environment, showcasing the dangers faced by those who challenge Gotti's dominance. The culmination brings to light the enduring influence of Gotti's legacy within both the criminal world and his family's lasting bonds.
Writers: Leo Rossi, Lem Dobbs
Release Date: 14 Jun 2018
Runtime: 112 min
Rating: R
Country: Canada, United States
Language: English