I Could Go on Singing Blu-ray Review

"I Could Go On Singing" receives a commendable presentation on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.40:1 aspect ratio, sourced from the MGM catalog. While the transfer showcases generally excellent detail and vibrant color saturation, it occasionally grapples with curious color anomalies, particularly noticeable in Judy Garland's skin tones during specific scenes. Despite some heavy grain, especially in second unit work like the helicopter sequence above London, the grain resolves naturally without compression issues. Close-ups are impressively detailed, and the saturated palette brings Judy's ensembles, such as her blue and green outfit or red dress in the "By Myself" sequence, to life.

The transfer from Twilight Time is a marked improvement over prior home video releases, with superior contrast and vivid color reproduction enhancing both the film's intimate moments and Garland's concert sequences. The black levels are deep, though not always forceful, and work cohesively with the detailed textures of costumes and backgrounds. Despite minor isolated print damage, notably during Garland's pivotal phone call scene, most blemishes are trivial and do not detract from the viewing experience. London and the English countryside exteriors are rendered beautifully, contributing significantly to the film's visual appeal. No digital artifacts such as banding, crush, or noise are present, and any digital enhancements have been applied discreetly.

Overall, the Blu-ray offers a visually vibrant and finely detailed presentation that does justice to Judy Garland's larger-than-life performances. Although a bit more restoration could elevate this transfer to perfection, fans of the film will undoubtedly appreciate this high-quality rendering, which successfully captures the essence and beauty of this underrated gem.

The audio presentation of "I Could Go On Singing" on Blu-ray delivers an exceptional experience through its DTS-HD Master Audio tracks. The primary DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track channels the film's extensive dialogue and musical sequences with impressive clarity and fidelity. Judy Garland's voice, although not at its peak, remains captivating, particularly in softer ballads like "It Never Was You," where her emotional delivery is profoundly moving. Her performance in more dynamic pieces like "By Myself" demonstrates her dramatic prowess, despite some occasional vocal wobbles. The overall sound quality is excellent, with no reported issues, ensuring a seamless auditory experience.

The isolated score track, presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 stereo, stands out as an extraordinary feature. This track allows listeners to immerse themselves entirely in Garland's musical numbers, supported by Mort Lindsey's distinguished arrangements. While the primary track predominantly uses the center channel, filling the room effortlessly with Garland's richly detailed and nuanced vocals, it occasionally exhibits faint hiss. The dynamic range is masterfully handled, faithfully reproducing both quiet nuances and more forceful sounds without distortion. Intricate sonic details, such as footsteps and finger snaps, are rendered distinctly. Dialogues are crystal clear, with Garland’s pristine diction making song lyrics easy to comprehend.

Overall, the audio presentation not only provides a mesmerizing auditory experience but also captures subtle atmospheric sounds that heighten the listening experience. Even minor off-camera noises during intimate performances only underscore the recording's authenticity and magic.

The Blu-ray release of "I Could Go on Singing" provides a treasure trove of valuable additions for film enthusiasts, particularly those with a fervent interest in Judy Garland. The extras include two compelling audio commentaries: the first featuring producer Lawrence Turman alongside film historians Lem Dobbs and Nick Redman, and the second by film historians David Del Valle and Steven Peros. Turman's commentary, filled with intimate insights into Garland's tumultuous personal life and career, lends a fascinating perspective complemented by anecdotes about the film's production challenges. The isolated score track in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 is a treat, highlighting Mort Lindsey's masterful compositions and Garland’s powerful vocals. Additionally, the disc includes two distinct theatrical trailers and a nostalgic TV spot.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentaries: In-depth perspectives from Lawrence Turman, Lem Dobbs, Nick Redman, as well as David Del Valle and Steven Peros.
• Isolated Score Track: Showcases Mort Lindsey’s musical genius in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0.
• Original Theatrical Trailer #1: Hypes Garland's cinematic return.
• Original Theatrical Trailer #2: Likely British, focusing more on Dirk Bogarde.
• TV Spot: A brief teaser celebrating Judy Garland's talents.
• MGM 90th Anniversary Trailer: Nostalgic addition marking MGM's milestone.

"I Could Go on Singing" leverages Judy Garland's unparalleled talents to craft a poignant, semi-autobiographical narrative. Directed by Ronald Neame, the film explores the tumultuous life of Jenny Bowman, a renowned singer revisiting the emotional complexities of her past while headlining in London. Garland, who had weathered significant personal and professional challenges by 1963, channels her own experiences into a raw, emotionally charged performance. Her portrayal of Jenny resonates deeply, drawing parallels to her real-life struggles and triumphs. The film features several of Garland’s live performances that are meticulously captured, highlighting her dramatic prowess and vibrant stage presence, most notably in a six-minute uninterrupted take that showcases her emotional depth.

The film's story, while straightforward, serves as a conduit for a character study, enhanced by a committed supporting cast including Dirk Bogarde as Jenny’s former lover and Gregory Phillips as their son. Jack Klugman and Aline MacMahon provide additional support as Jenny’s manager and assistant, respectively. The narrative shifts seamlessly between Jenny's attempts to reconnect with her son and her soul-baring concert performances, underscoring the duality of her public grandeur and private fragility. Noteworthy is the unvarnished depiction of Garland’s taxing rehearsals and intense emotional outpourings, delivering an immersive viewing experience enriched by Mort Lindsey's evocative music.

Neame’s direction shines in capturing the candid essence of Garland without superfluous embellishments. His choice to use extended takes without interruptions effectively underscores the authenticity of Garland’s performance. The film culminates with a series of concert sequences where Garland’s vocal prowess and artistic intensity illuminate the screen, affirming her legacy as one of the greatest performers of all time. Despite its modest dramatic ambitions, "I Could Go on Singing" stands as a powerful testament to Garland's enduring artistry and her ability to invoke profound emotional responses through her indomitable spirit and extraordinary talent.

"I Could Go on Singing" captures Judy Garland at a pivotal moment in her career, showcasing her ability to deliver intense dramatic performances despite her personal struggles. The narrative, while occasionally leaning toward melodrama, remains compelling, driven by Garland’s raw emotional depth. Dirk Bogarde and Jack Klugman deliver commendable performances, adding layers to the story. Technically, the Blu-ray boasts impressive visual and audio quality, preserving the unique film noir-esque lighting that enhances the moodiness of the musical sequences. Twilight Time's meticulous transfer ensures that every nuance is captured with precision, and the monaural sound mix is exceptional. The isolated music and effects track is a notable bonus that amplifies the film's emotional weight.

The Blu-ray offers two insightful commentary tracks that dive deep into the production's challenges and triumphs. Film scholars Nick Redman and Lem Dobbs, along with producer Lawrence Turman, provide a fascinating glimpse into the behind-the-scenes ordeals, particularly those related to Garland’s performance. Additionally, David Del Valle and Steven Peros offer a broader historical context about Garland’s career and the film's reception. These supplements are invaluable for any film enthusiast looking to understand the nuances of "I Could Go on Singing" beyond its surface-level narrative.

In conclusion, while "I Could Go on Singing" may not be Judy Garland's most celebrated film, it stands out as a deeply personal piece, showcasing her enduring talent. The technical merits of the Blu-ray are top-notch, capturing the film's mood and music flawlessly. Despite any narrative shortcomings, Garland’s magnetic performance is timeless, making this Blu-ray edition a must-have for fans and collectors. Highly recommended.