Stardust 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Wal-Mart Exclusive SteelBook
Score: 71
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Stardust's 4K release delivers charm and warmth but falters in video consistency, while offering a nostalgic soundtrack with minimal extras.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
DTS-HD MA
Video: 66
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of 'Stardust' by Paramount offers a stunning 2160p/HDR10 transfer, showcasing a beautifully restored visual presentation in a two-disc steelbook edition, while including a region-free 1080p Blu-ray with the previous UK release's transfer.
Audio: 86
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of 'Stardust,' while visually inconsistent due to fluctuating detail and grain issues, benefits from superior color grading with HDR10 and Dolby Vision. The accompanying DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio mix elevates the experience, ensuring a richer, more engaging audio presentation compared to previous formats.
Extra: 51
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Stardust" features an exceptional audio track, rich in dynamic range and bass extension; however, dialogue occasionally gets overwhelmed by effects. The packaging slightly differs from the standard 4K Steelbook with minor design changes, but disc storage is noted as a drawback.
Movie: 76
"Stardust" on 4K UHD is an enchanting cinematic fairy tale with its charming old-school magic, a stellar cast, and visual flair that revives Neil Gaiman's fantasy world vividly. However, while the Walmart-exclusive Steelbook offers a nice collector's package, the film's CGI shows its age, and discerning fans may find it hard to justify upgrading from Paramount's slightly cheaper standard version.
Video: 66
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Stardust" by Paramount presents an impressive visual upgrade, highlighting the film’s enchanting fantasy elements. The 2160p resolution paired with HDR10 exemplifies a significant enhancement over its previous Blu-ray edition, offering a more vibrant palette that brings the whimsical world of the film to life. Details in costumes and set design are meticulously rendered, providing a tangible depth that was less pronounced in the original release. The enhanced luminosity and contrast significantly improve the viewing experience, capturing both the magical and darker tones of the narrative with impressive fidelity.
Complementing the vivid imagery, the use of HDR10 in this new transfer provides an expanded dynamic range that allows for deeper blacks and brighter highlights, essential for maintaining the film's atmospheric tone. The steel book edition exclusively contains this new 4K restoration, set apart from the accompanying 1080p Blu-ray, which retains the previous transfer. Colors are rich yet natural, adding texture to each scene while maintaining consistency across various lighting conditions throughout.
Overall, the 4K restoration of "Stardust" on UHD Blu-ray is a noteworthy upgrade for enthusiasts and collectors alike, offering a visually captivating experience that remains true to the film’s original intent while enhancing it with modern high-definition benefits.
Audio: 86
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Stardust" offers an engaging audio experience, predominantly anchored by a DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio mix that ensures a dynamic and immersive soundstage. This audio setup effectively harnesses the format's capabilities to deliver a robust and richly detailed auditory performance, accentuating the whimsical fantasy tones of the film. Notably, dialogue is crisp and well-defined, ensuring clarity even amidst complex scenes. It captures the atmospheric sounds intricately, from the whooshing wind overstormy skies to the quiet nuances of the enchanted forest, enhancing the fantasy realm's immersive quality.
The mix excels in its creative use of surround channels, enveloping listeners with spatial accuracy and a seamless 360-degree auditory panorama. Action sequences are particularly enhanced with precise directional effects, where every magical spark and sword clash are punctuated with distinct clarity and depth. Bass frequencies are assertively engaged during key moments, providing an impactful resonance that bolsters the dramatic weight of pivotal scenes without overwhelming the mid and high frequencies.
Overall, while the video quality may exhibit some inconsistencies, the audio presentation stands robust, providing an auditory experience that complements the fantastical narrative of "Stardust" compellingly. Audiophiles and casual viewers alike are likely to appreciate the depth, clarity, and richness that the DTS-HD 5.1 mix brings to this release, ultimately making it a reliable enhancement over previous editions in terms of sound design.
Extras: 51
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray extras for "Stardust" are a comprehensive addition for fans and collectors, packaged in a visually appealing Steelbook with minor design differences from the standard edition. While the inclusion of art cards featuring the main characters is a nice touch, the packaging could benefit from improved disc stability as both discs sit loosely on a stacked hub. Despite the lack of a 3D mix in the soundtrack, Ilan Eshkeri’s score is reproduced with impressive fidelity, offering a dynamic and captivating experience. The audio excels with superb surround usage, although some dialogue becomes submerged during intense sequences. Nevertheless, these features enhance the immersive quality of the home viewing experience, cementing this release as a valuable collector’s item.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making of Featurettes: Behind-the-scenes content exploring the film's production.
- Deleted Scenes: A collection of scenes not included in the final cut of the film.
- Commentary Tracks: Insightful discussions by the filmmakers and cast.
- Art Cards: Character profiles and artwork for easy storage within the case.
Movie: 76
Matthew Vaughn's adaptation of Neil Gaiman's "Stardust" reimagines the fairy tale genre with a refreshing old-school approach, blending elements of classical storytelling with engaging modern twists. The narrative, set in the quaint English village of Wall bordering the magical realm of Stormhold, follows Tristan (Charlie Cox) on a whimsical quest to retrieve a fallen star for his beloved. This star, transformed into a young woman named Yvaine (Clare Danes), intertwines with adventures involving royal heirs and sinister witches, climaxing in a captivating tapestry of princes, princesses, and magic. Maintaining the noble charm of traditional fairy tales, Stardust evokes nostalgia while delightfully enmeshing classic themes with mesmerizing new narratives.
The film’s ensemble cast, featuring talents like Michelle Pfeiffer, Robert De Niro, and Claire Danes, delivers captivating performances, adding gravitas and humor to Vaughn's direction. Often lauded for their impeccable portrayal of characters reminiscent of a high-stakes pantomime, these actors breathe life into Gaiman's whimsical world. While some CGI elements may appear dated against today's standards, the film’s enchanting visual style captures the fantastical essence that Gaiman's work embodies. Vaughn’s deliberate nods to fantasy classics ensure Stardust remains an enthralling piece of family-friendly entertainment, successfully bypassing the modern inclinations toward post-modern irony that often accompany fairy tale revisions.
As presented in its 4K UHD Blu-ray format, "Stardust" is both a visual and auditory delight, though the Walmart-exclusive Steelbook edition does little to distinguish itself significantly from its widely released counterpart. Though somewhat uneven in its pacing, "Stardust" offers charisma and creativity that compensates with pure entertaining value, solidifying its standing as a warm-hearted fantasy treasure. Fans of Vaughn’s approach will appreciate the film's adherence to traditional storytelling balanced with modern flair, while new viewers will find it a pleasing departure from typical genre entries.
Total: 71
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Stardust" presents a mixed bag of enhancements and disappointments. Visually, the 4K restoration offers an experience that, while charming, lacks the significant improvements fans anticipated. The video transfer suffers from inconsistency and a fluctuating encode, which may leave aficionados yearning for a more refined update. Despite these visual hiccups, the charm and warmth of the original 2007 release are still palpable. The soundtrack performance is robust, maintaining the quality experienced in prior formats.
In terms of packaging, the SteelBook edition stands out with its striking design, likely to appeal to collectors. However, the absence of new extras could be a deterrent for those who prioritize additional content at a £29.99 price point. This release comes in both standard and Walmart exclusive Steelbook editions, with differences primarily in cover design and collectible cards, offering negligible variation in terms of content.
In conclusion, "Stardust" on 4K is a fantastical journey that holds up as a nostalgic favorite but may underwhelm those seeking groundbreaking enhancements. While the SteelBook's aesthetic appeal is undeniable, prospective buyers should weigh the value against its price and lack of new supplementary material. The decision to invest in this edition will largely depend on personal attachment to the film and collector interest in the packaging.
avforums review by Mark CostelloRead review here
Video: 60
It includes a region-free 4K housing the film and its new restoration, while it also includes a region-free 1080p blu that is the same disc as the previous UK release – therefore this disc does NOT house...
Audio: 90
A quick check of the playback information also shows that in the scenes where detail drops to its lowest, so too does the encode – the scene as we zoom into the Sky Captain’s ship as it flies through the...
Extras: 50
Wonderfully dynamic, rising and falling in volume quickly and with absolute precision; ferocious in its bass extension (the magic creating the inn sees lightning crash with violent fury, while the storm...
Movie: 90
With its stacked cast (in no particular order…deep breath…Jason Flemying, Henry Cavill, Rupert Everett, Mark Williams, David Walliams, Dexter Fletcher, Ricky Gervais, Peter O’Toole and Robert De Bloody...
Total: 60
But the new 4K restoration is likely not what fans hoped for and secretly feared would arrive – a typically inconsistent video transfer, certainly not helped by a fluctuating encode; the soundtrack remains...
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 80
For details about the 4K disc's 2160p/HDR10 transfer, please see our review of the standard 4K Steelbook....
Audio: 90
Likewise, our review of the standard 4K Steelbook also details the included DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio mix....
Extras: 60
In fact, only the front cover is different here; it's more blue-dominant and less cluttered overall, trading in some of the smaller film-specific background and border elements for perhaps a more accessible...
Movie: 70
Available both in-stores and online, it's a relatively nice collector's package with admittedly similar design elements to Paramount's standard 4K Steelbook and includes bonus art cards that fit snugly...
Total: 70
If you feel differently and consider it to be a genre favorite, you'll surely want to pick up either Paramount's standard 4K Steelbook or Walmart's Steelbook variant, although the only real difference...
Director: Matthew Vaughn
Actors: Charlie Cox, Claire Danes, Sienna Miller
PlotIn a quaint English village called Wall, young Tristan Thorn is determined to win the heart of the beautiful but shallow Victoria. After witnessing a falling star, Tristan vows to retrieve it to prove his love, promising Victoria he will return with it. Crossing a forbidden wall, Tristan enters a mystical, magical realm where stars can take human form. He discovers the star is, in fact, a woman named Yvaine. Unbeknownst to Tristan, a trio of ancient witches, led by the sinister Lamia, also seek the star to harness her powers and rejuvenate their youth.
Meanwhile, the kingdom of Stormhold has its own intrigue, with princes vying for the throne left vacant by the deceased king. As Tristan and Yvaine journey through the magical land, encountering fantastical creatures and fearsome adversaries, they form an unexpected bond. Their adventure is a race against time, as malevolent forces close in, each with their own dark designs on Yvaine's celestial heart. The duo faces hurdles and dangers but also finds allies in the most unexpected places.
Writers: Jane Goldman, Matthew Vaughn, Neil Gaiman
Release Date: 10 Aug 2007
Runtime: 127 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English