Shaolin Mantis Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Shaolin Mantis," released under the 88 Asian Collection by 88 Films, utilizes an AVC encoded 1080p transfer framed at 2.35:1. While marketed as a new master from the original 35mm negatives, this release demonstrates certain technical limitations. Resolution issues are evident, with aliasing and jagged edges particularly noticeable in distant shots, such as those featuring the king’s throne. The resulting clarity is mediocre, with the minimized grain contributing to a somewhat waxy appearance and occasional smearing in close-ups.

Color rendition exhibits a mixed quality; while generally warm and inviting, certain hues like pinks, turquoise, and reds provide moments of visual excellence amidst overall flatness. However, a decline in the film's aesthetic integrity is seen towards its conclusion, with more muted browns presenting a less vibrant tableau that may derive from secondary sourcing elements. Although contrast holds up reasonably well and debris and scratches have been fully removed during the restoration process, shadow detail remains limited.

Additionally, the presentation experiences artifacts due to compression, notably on solid backgrounds such as gray concrete. Anamorphic anomalies occasionally lead to distortion through squeezing or stretching of the frame. Overall, while this transfer struggles to fully capture the filmic quality anticipated by enthusiasts, it succeeds in restoring the film to a watchable format with some commendable color points and an effective cleanup of physical imperfections.

The audio presentation of the "Shaolin Mantis" Blu-ray prominently features LPCM 2.0 Mono tracks, available in both English and Mandarin. While toggling between these options, noticeable similarities arise, particularly in music and effects. The English track exhibits a louder dialogue, albeit with a slightly out-of-phase quality, lending an overly reverberant tone. In comparison, the Mandarin track consistently delivers a more natural sound despite occasional lip-sync mismatches inherent due to language differences during filming. Notably, no significant damage is evident on either track, ensuring the overall audio remains intact. Optional English subtitles are also offered for viewers.

The sonic landscape presented reveals an expected decline in the upper registers of the score, manifesting as occasional wavering and instability. Contrasting this, the low-end frequencies offer a steadier presence; drum sequences produce a discernible rumble, demonstrating commendable depth from the mono track. Dialogue quality suffers from age-induced degradation, presenting as scratchy and worn but remaining perfectly intelligible on both language tracks. Despite these age-related imperfections, the audio tracks retain a level of clarity sufficient for clear comprehension, underscoring a faithful reproduction of the original auditory experience.

The Blu-ray extras for "Shaolin Mantis" offer a comprehensive and engaging exploration into the film's context and production, attracting both cinephiles and casual viewers alike. Notably, the disc features dual audio commentaries with esteemed Asian cinema experts Mike Leeder, Arne Venema, and Frank Djeng, providing in-depth insights and diverse perspectives on the film. Complementing these are a visual essay by David West, dissecting the cultural and thematic elements of the movie, and an exclusive interview with John Cheung, providing a firsthand account of his experiences during filming. The disc also includes U.S. and Hong Kong trailers, offering a nostalgic glimpse into the film's original marketing. This release is enhanced by its physical presentation, featuring a fold-out mini-poster, lobby card reproductions, a reversible sleeve with original artwork, and a durable slipcover.

Extras included in this disc:

• Complicated Families: David West's analysis of Shaolin Mantis.
• Uncle Tien Chung: Interview with John Cheung.
• The Deadly Mantis US Trailer
• Hong Kong Trailer
• Audio Commentary: Experts Mike Leeder and Arne Venema.
• Audio Commentary: Expert Frank Djeng.

Shaolin Mantis, a unique entry in the Shaw Brothers' martial arts canon, deftly merges political intrigue with a complex romantic subplot. David Chiang stars as Wei Fung, a scholarly figure subtly entwined in a web of allegiance and betrayal. Tasked by the Emperor to spy on Ming loyalists, Fung's mission takes a personal turn when romantic feelings burgeon for Tien Chi-Chi, played by Cecilia Wong. This emotional entanglement adds layers to the narrative, questioning themes of loyalty versus love. The cinematic journey through Fung's world is less about immediate combat and more about nuanced storytelling, crafting an engaging first half that prioritizes character development and thematic setup over action.

As the narrative progresses, Shaolin Mantis remains faithful to its martial roots while enriching the story with thematic elements. The film’s titular training sequence unfolds amid a series of dramatic events, where Fung draws inspiration from the movements of a praying mantis to refine his kung fu technique. This intriguing montage underpins the film’s third act, where pacing intensifies and strategy overtakes simple combat prowess. Every fight scene is meticulously framed against a backdrop of consequence and inevitability. The film skillfully balances the spectacle of martial arts with its cautionary undertones, reflecting a broader thematic narrative within Shaw Brothers' oeuvre.

The tonal evolution within Shaolin Mantis is both captivating and complex, transitioning from light-hearted exchanges to poignant tragedy. The romance between Fung and Tien Chi-Chi offers initial levity but gradually gives way to an intense, sobering conclusion. Highlighting themes of generational discord and revolt, the climax delivers a poignant message reflecting on the profound cost of revolution. This resolution, both treasured and debated amongst fans, enhances the narrative's gravity, leaving an enduring impact on its viewers through its compelling integration of personal and political struggles.

The Blu-ray release of "Shaolin Mantis" offers a distinctive cinematic experience that integrates whimsical elements like martial arts lessons inspired by a praying mantis with a narrative packed with political intrigue and examinations of personal loyalty. While not the most action-heavy entry in the kung fu genre, "Shaolin Mantis" possesses a unique energy, fueled by compelling performances that engage the viewer throughout its runtime. Its storytelling provides a refreshing blend of cleverness and martial art romance, setting the stage for a poignant conclusion that pays off the dramatic buildups portrayed earlier in the film.

In terms of technical presentation, this release stands out due to being a noted outlier in the recent spate of Shaw Brothers reissues. Compared to other releases by labels such as 88 Films, the video quality here does not quite reach the high standard set by its contemporaries. Nevertheless, the accompanying supplemental features enhance the overall package, offering enjoyable and informative content to potential buyers. These extras enrich viewers' understanding of the film's context and provide additional value that might entice collectors and fans.

In conclusion, "Shaolin Mantis" is characterized by its charming amalgamation of martial arts prowess and engaging storytelling. Though the movie may not top the action charts or showcase the pinnacle of video restoration, it remains a noteworthy release due to its narrative depth and supplementary offerings. For enthusiasts looking to explore beyond mainstream kung fu fare, this title presents an intriguing option in the expanding catalog of Shaw Brothers films on Blu-ray.