Shadows in an Empty Room Blu-ray Review
Blazing Magnum Una Magnum Special per Tony Saitta
Score: 38
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Shadows in an Empty Room offers relentless action and shocking stunts, overshadowing its messy plot and underwhelming mystery; recommended for fans of high-octane thrillers.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 52
The Blu-ray presentation of 'Shadows in an Empty Room' in 1080p HD (1.85:1) reveals wear and tear with brief scratches and differing print sources, yet preserves film grain and authentic colors, providing an acceptable, if flawed, transfer that respects its 1976 origins.
Audio: 32
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA mix on 'Shadows in an Empty Room' struggles with constant hiss and pops, muddled dialogue, periodic sync issues, and imbalanced volume levels, yet still manages to make performances and musical mood shifts understandable, delivering a passable, albeit imperfect audio experience.
Extra: 16
The Blu-ray includes a 3:33 SD theatrical trailer for 'Shadows in an Empty Room,' along with additional SD trailers for 'The Little Girl Who Lives Down the Lane,' 'Bobbie Jo and The Outlaw,' 'The Passage,' and 'Killer Force,' enhancing the viewing experience with classic previews.
Movie: 56
Shadows in an Empty Room, helmed by Alberto De Martino, delivers raw, unrelenting violence offset by a procedural mystery grounded in Quebec’s gritty streets. Although character development and plot coherence waver, the Blu-ray release from Kino Lorber retains the film's explosive charm and thrilling set-pieces, notably the iconic car chase and kung fu confrontations.
Video: 52
The Blu-ray presentation of "Shadows in an Empty Room" features a 1080p HD resolution with a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, effectively reviving this 1976 Canadian poliziotteschi film. The transfer reveals considerable wear and tear on the source material, with visible scratches and dirt, though they are generally brief and do not detract significantly from the viewing experience. The film grain is intact, providing an authentic, filmic texture, with no major evidence of color balance or black level manipulation. Certain more exploitative scenes appear to have been sourced from different prints, resulting in a minor discontinuity in image quality within the transfer.
While the print shows some extended damage, the overall detail is acceptable for a film of this era and genre. Close-ups reveal textures on actors' faces, costumes, and various locations. The colors are subdued but refreshed, offering a pleasing presentation of greenery and female costuming. The delineation maintains consistency within the limits of the original cinematography, ensuring that street scenes and other wide shots retain their intended atmosphere. Overall, it’s a commendable effort to preserve the film’s gritty essence on Blu-ray.
Audio: 32
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA sound mix for "Shadows in an Empty Room" offers a serviceable yet imperfect audio experience. The track suffers from aged elements resulting in persistent hiss, pops, and occasional surges in intensity. While dialogue generally remains intelligible, it is often muddled and challenging to discern, necessitating frequent volume adjustments. Music also exhibits a lack of precision; however, changes in mood are still appreciable.
Sound effects are blunt and unrefined, with loud gunshots and car crashes effectively amplifying the film's action scenes. Synchronization issues arise sporadically, affecting both dialogue and action audio tracks, which might stem from inherent limitations typical of B-movie productions. Despite these drawbacks, the audio presentation eventually gets the job done, making it possible for viewers to follow the performances and action.
Extras: 16
The extras of the Blu Ray for "Shadows in an Empty Room" are thoughtfully curated, although limited in scope. The highlight is the theatrical trailer, which captures the film's essence effectively in a succinct format. Additionally, the included trailers for other films offer a nostalgic glimpse into the era's cinematic landscape. While the special features may not be extensive, they provide valuable context and enhance the overall viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Theatrical Trailer (SD): A promotional clip encapsulating the film's key elements.
- The Little Girl Who Lives Down the Lane (SD): Trailer for another notable film.
- Bobbie Jo and The Outlaw (SD): Trailer for a classic release.
- The Passage (SD): Trailer highlighting an engaging drama.
- Killer Force (SD): Trailer for an action-packed feature.
Movie: 56
"Shadows in an Empty Room," directed by Alberto De Martino and released in 1976, offers a raw and compelling blend of Italian crime cinema within a Canadian procedural setting. The narrative follows Capt. Saitta (Stuart Whitman) as he approaches crime in Quebec with unrestrained violence. The screenplay keeps the audience engaged with an elaborate mystery and a colorful cast, including Saitta's partner Matthews (John Saxon) and the enigmatic Dr. Tracer (Martin Landau). Highlighting both Saitta’s relentless pursuit of his sister’s killer and the gritty atmosphere of Quebec, De Martino skillfully balances the unfolding detective narrative with extensive sequences of visceral action.
From the film's opening flyover shot of Ottawa, complemented by a curious jazz score, to intense foot and vehicular chases, "Shadows in an Empty Room" is rich with violent spectacle and dramatic tension. Scenes like the mid-film car chase are wrenchingly kinetic, featuring crashing, flipping cars that inject a burst of adrenaline into the story. Whitman's portrayal of the indomitable Saitta effectively channels a "Dirty Harry" bravado, though the movie’s occasional tonal dissonance between high-octane action and moments of oddball humor—such as Saitta's wild altercation with transgender characters—highlights its exploitation roots.
The evolving plot, punctuated by graphic violence and exceptional stunts, keeps the viewer on edge as Saitta tirelessly hunts for clues amongst a series of dubious characters. Key set pieces involve intricate stunt choreography within the constraining environs of Quebec, enhancing the film's appeal. Although at times the plot meanders with unnecessary complexities, the thrilling action sequences and De Martino's distinctive style hinge on a desirable balance between narrative intrigue and unflinching brutality. Despite some exploitation clichés, "Shadows in an Empty Room" captivates with its brutal charm and relentless pace, making it a memorable entry in the crime thriller oeuvre.
Total: 38
"Shadows in an Empty Room" presents itself as an intriguing yet unconventional melding of Italian poliziotteschi and Canadian thriller genres, striking a unique chord with its intense action sequences and raw confrontations. From the opening bank heist to its various pursuits, the film is relentless in its display of physicality and visceral engagement, ensuring a consistently high energy level that captivates viewers. The film frequently sacrifices narrative coherence for shock value and dynamic stuntwork, which can detract from its potential as a compelling mystery. These aspects, however, are overshadowed by De Martino's competent direction which expertly leverages the pure cinematic experience to maintain audience interest.
While "Shadows in an Empty Room" offers little in the way of a tightly woven plot, its incessant pace and riveting score provide sufficient compensation. The storyline is riddled with red herrings that complicate rather than clarify, thus it’s best appreciated by those who prioritize action over substance. The personal mission of the lead character, Saitta, adds another layer of urgency that attempts but does not entirely succeed, in grounding the chaotic narrative. Occasionally bogged down by weighty dialogue and unfocused drama, the film nevertheless manages to keep audiences engaged through its continuous momentum and nerve-wracking scenes.
In conclusion, Kino Lorber and Scorpion Releasing have delivered a basic yet satisfactory Blu-ray presentation of "Shadows in an Empty Room," but the real allure lies in the film’s preference for audacious stunts and unexpected turns over traditional storytelling. While it may not stand out as a dramatic tour de force, it is highly recommended for fans of gritty cop flicks and high-octane chase scenes. Casual viewers may prefer a rental before committing to a purchase, but its entertainment value suggests it's worth a watch for those seeking an adrenaline-driven cinematic experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 70
Detail is generally acceptable for the softly-shot effort, managing to find textures on thespian close-ups, costuming, and locations, and streetwise distances are preserved....
Audio: 50
Dialogue exchanges aren't completely disturbed, with basic intelligibility supplied, making it easy enough to track the performances....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 80
Yet, that's not nearly enough for "Shadows in an Empty Room," which expands to the whereabouts of a special necklace, adding another layer of questioning to the story, keeping Saitta busy with police work...
Total: 70
The working parts of the mystery never take hold (the ending is more of a shoulder-shrug than a stunner), but De Martino is careful to protect the shock value of his picture, filling it with aggressive...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
A few scenes appear to have been sourced from a different print as the transfer doesn’t allow a seamless transition between the sequences....
Audio: 40
Dialogue throughout the feature is muddled and difficult to understand with poorly recorded elements used....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 40
Unfortunately, I think the Euro-crime themes extend too far into the film’s plot and create an imbalance in the film’s tone....
Total: 40
Knowing that it’s a combination Italian poliziotteschi and Canadian thriller makes this frankenstein of a film easier to stomach....
Director: Alberto De Martino
Actors: Stuart Whitman, John Saxon, Martin Landau
PlotCaptain Tony Saitta, a tough and relentless police officer, becomes consumed with grief and vengeance after his sister, Louise, mysteriously dies from suspected poison. Determined to uncover the truth, Tony’s investigation leads him from sleazy nightclubs to precarious confrontations with dubious characters. Alongside Sergeant Ned Matthews and a dedicated pathologist, Tony relentlessly follows a tangled web of clues that hint at his sister's involvement with shady figures and criminal activities.
As Tony digs deeper, key suspects emerge, each with their own hidden secrets and motivations. Investigations take a dark turn as danger intensifies, revealing deep-seated corruption and a complex conspiracy entwining personal vendettas with professional deceit. In the midst of unraveling this labyrinthine mystery, Tony faces escalating threats and moral dilemmas that challenge his perception of justice. Each step he takes unravels more layers of deception but also propels him closer to a truth that could shatter everything he believed about his sister and himself.
Writers: Vincenzo Mannino, Gianfranco Clerici
Release Date: 09 Mar 1976
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: R
Country: Italy, Canada, Panama
Language: Italian, French, English