Ip Man 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Ip Man's 4K debut charms fans with stunning fights despite quality dips, a must for enthusiasts.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
DTS-HD MA
Video: 61
Ip Man's 4K UHD release exhibits mixed visual enhancements with a noticeable digital appearance, yet offers improved details and HDR highlights, retaining some original noise and coarse grain from its 35mm film origins.
Audio: 74
The Cantonese Dolby Atmos track on Ip Man offers immersive audio, enhancing action scenes and score, though vertical effects are sporadic. The 4K disc's mix improves dynamics, with more engaging surround activity and better bass, compared to the original's flatter DTS-HD Audio.
Extra: 66
The 4K UHD disc lacks extras, impacting its rating, while the 1080p disc includes a Making Of, insights from Ip Man's family, cast, and crew inputs, three deleted scenes with safeguards, and two trailers, enriching the package.
Movie: 84
Ip Man: The Complete Collection 4K continues the beloved martial arts saga in stunning clarity, although I'm less enamored than some. It includes all four films with Dolby Atmos, highlighting the legendary Wing Chun master's influence.
Video: 61
"Ip Man" makes its entry into the 4K UHD Blu-ray market courtesy of Well Go USA, featuring a 2160p transfer that brings both anticipation and a bit of disappointment. Presented in a 2.34:1 aspect ratio, this transfer appears to have been upsampled from its original 2K Digital Intermediate, intended for its theatrical release. Despite being shot on 35 mm photochemical film using high-quality Arricam and Arriflex cameras, the 4K rendition struggles to completely shake off a certain digital harshness—a characteristic not unlike what Marty hinted at regarding the 1080 version. This results in imagery that occasionally feels more reminiscent of video than film, peppered with instances of what seems like frozen grain and a noise that can become particularly distracting during more dynamically lit scenes.
Detail enhancement over its 1080p predecessor is evident, albeit subtly so. Textural specifics, such as fabric weaves, exhibit a higher degree of precision and clarity, benefitting from this upgraded resolution. Yet, the film's deliberate palette of browns and grays, alongside a sparsity of vividly colorful scenes, limits the opportunities for HDR to significantly amplify its visual appeal. Despite this, Dolby Vision does manage to inject some vibrant highlights into the mix—noticeable in domestic scenes with a cozy, peach-hued warmth which adds depth to the otherwise restrained color scheme.
The introduction of High Dynamic Range grading (both HDR10 and Dolby Vision) presents richer and more natural colors, especially apparent in scenes rich with cultural ambiance—like the one featuring Ip Man lunching with his businessman friend amidst a backdrop of lush reds and golds. Although the presence of grain and some residual noise from the original Blu-ray's enhancement techniques remind viewers of its source's limitations, these aspects are somewhat mitigated in this release. Shadows and highlights benefit from HDR's touch, making for an overall improvement despite its subtleties. While this may not be the most groundbreaking 4K upgrade, "Ip Man" certainly presents the best version of itself visually on home media to date, even if it leaves enthusiasts longing for just a bit more.
Audio: 74
The audio presentation of "Ip Man" on 4K UHD Blu-Ray, specifically the Cantonese Dolby Atmos track, marks a significant upgrade over its predecessor, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 options available on the original 1080p release. While the Atmos track does not consistently exploit the vertical sound envelope to its fullest, specifically in creating an ambient, overhead experience, it shines in its deployment during key action sequences and certain score elements. The blend of environmental sounds and spatially accurate dialogue enhances the viewing experience, creating a more engaging auditory landscape. English and Spanish subtitles are included, catering to a wider audience.
The sonic landscape of this release is further enriched by the Atmos mix's adept handling of directional audio cues and an expanded dynamic range. This enhances the realism of each fight scene, with every punch and kick landing with additional heft thanks to a more robust bass response. Surround channels are utilized more effectively, not just for action but also for enveloping ambient sounds, making the viewer feel genuinely immersed in the film's setting. The smooth and natural panning of audio between channels contributes to a more cohesive and immersive auditory experience.
Additionally, the disc offers alternative audio in English and Mandarin delivered through 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio tracks, alongside a Spanish 2.0 Dolby Digital option, ensuring that the release caters to various linguistic preferences while maintaining high-quality sound reproduction across all versions. Optional subtitles in English and Spanish provide accessibility to non-native speakers, ensuring that "Ip Man" can be enjoyed by a global audience in its visually and sonically remastered glory, making it a commendable addition to any 4K UHD Blu-Ray collection.
Extras: 66
The "Ip Man" 4K UHD Blu-ray provides a somewhat underwhelming experience for those seeking comprehensive extras directly on the UHD disc, as it houses no supplemental content, emphasizing the scarcity in its own right. However, the included 1080p Blu-ray compensates with a selection of extras that enrich the viewing experience, notably the making-of featurette which delves into the historical background of Ip Man, contributions from his family, and insights into Donnie Yen's dedication to embodying the character and mastering Wing Chun. Key cast and crew contributions round out this detailed look behind the scenes. Furthermore, three deleted scenes are presented with graphic overlays and timecode readings, a measure taken to dissuade re-editing into the main feature. Rounding off the extras are two engaging trailers that offer glimpses into the film's martial arts action and narrative intrigue.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making Of: Offers insights into the historical Ip Man, contributions from his family, and Donnie Yen's preparation for the role.
- Deleted Scenes: Features three scenes not included in the final cut, presented with graphic overlays and timecode.
- Trailers: Two trailers that showcase highlights of the film's action and story.
Movie: 84
The 4K UHD presentation of "Ip Man" in the Ip Man: The Complete Collection offers a renewal of the iconic martial arts saga with upgraded visual and audio quality that enhances the cinematic narrative. Well Go USA has embraced the continued interest in the story of Ip Man by releasing the first three films in this format, coupled with the previously available 4K version of the fourth installment. This release does not currently offer the option for standalone purchases of the first three films in 4K UHD, which may disappoint some collectors. However, the inclusion of Dolby Atmos audio across all four films significantly enhances the viewing experience, providing an immersive soundscape that complements the visual upgrade.
For viewers unfamiliar with the historical backdrop of Ip Man, this film series delves into the life of a revered Chinese Wing Chun grandmaster who lived through the tumultuous times of the Second Sino-Japanese War. Settling in Hong Kong post-war, Ip's legacy includes teaching future martial arts masters, among them the legendary Bruce Lee. The portrayal by Donnie Yen has been pivotal in bringing the intricacies of Wing Chun and the grandmaster’s ethos to the screen, cementing Ip Man's status not only as a martial arts legend but also as a cultural hero symbolizing the resilience and dignity of the Chinese people.
This collection, while primarily appealing to martial arts enthusiasts and fans of Donnie Yen, serves as a visually stunning homage to Ip Man's enduring legacy. The 4K UHD format, while not extending to individual releases for the initial trilogy, invites both newcomers and seasoned fans to experience the saga with enhanced clarity and audio depth. While some may seek more from this release besides the movie itself, its presentation is a testament to the enduring appeal and cinematic importance of Ip Man's story.
Total: 69
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray release of "Ip Man," the film that kickstarted a beloved martial arts franchise, offers a mixed bag in terms of visual presentation. While it stands as a pivotal figure in martial arts cinema, largely due to Donnie Yen's memorable portrayal of the titular character, this particular release does not reach the heights seen in subsequent entries of the series. Despite being part of the "Ip Man: The Complete Collection 4K," it exhibits some of the same video quality deficiencies highlighted in earlier assessments of its 1080p counterpart. This aspect might leave enthusiasts of the highest fidelity visuals a tad underwhelmed, given the anticipated leap in quality that 4K UHD usually suggests.
However, it's not all a step downwards. For those venturing into the "Ip Man" saga for the first time or fans looking to complete their collection, Well Go USA’s "Ip Man: The Complete Collection" offers an attractive package. The collection prides itself on delivering the best image quality seen across the series to date, alongside immersive Atmos surround sound that elevates the viewing experience significantly. What makes these films a must-have isn’t merely the narrative or character depth, but rather the exemplary martial arts displays choreographed by legends such as Sammo Hung and Yuen Woo-ping, brought to life through Donnie Yen's exceptional performance. While the collection may slightly fall short on special features, the core of its appeal lies in its breathtaking action sequences.
In conclusion, while the 4K UHD release of "Ip Man" may not completely satisfy videophiles seeking the zenith of visual remastering, it remains a commendable addition to one's collection, especially within the broader context of the "Complete Collection." Viewers drawn to unparalleled fight choreography and atmospheric soundscapes will find much to appreciate. This offering, despite its flaws, is still an essential purchase for fans and a significant entry point for newcomers into the dynamic world of Ip Man and the martial arts genre.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 60
This does in fact look a lot more like video than film quite a bit of the time, but there are curiously moments of kind of bizarre looking frozen grain, as in the opening mist strewn credits sequence....
Audio: 70
The most noticeable utilization of the Atmos tracks, as tends to be the case in all of the films in this set, is expectedly in some of the action sequences, as well as some of the score placement....
Extras: 80
The bundled 1080 disc repeats the supplements from the Blu-ray disc detailed in the above linked review by Marty....
Movie: 80
Note: This film is available as part of Ip Man: The Complete Collection 4K. As has been repeatedly documented by a number of reviewers at Blu-ray.com including yours truly, the story of Ip Man seems to...
Total: 0
This 4K UHD presentation is probably the least pleasing video of the four films in the new Ip Man: The Complete Collection 4K, reflecting some of the same deficits that Marty mentioned in his review of...
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 75
Colors are definitely richer and more natural looking thanks the HDR grade, with the palette starting off warmer and then shifting to a cooler look after the Japanese invasion....
Audio: 90
The Atmos audio is definitely more immersive; the surrounds are more active with ambience now and the panning is smooth and natural....
Extras: 60
The Making Of piece offers some nice background on the real historical Ip Man and his surviving family, who served as advisors on the film, as well as Yen’s efforts to understand the character and his...
Movie: 95
The important thing to know about Ip Man is that he’s a legend in China, a kind of godfather of the martial arts, and a symbol of the dignity of the Chinese people....
Total: 80
You buy them for spectacular fight choreography—and there’s plenty of that to be found here thanks to fine work by Donnie Yen and stunt masters Sammo Hung and Yuen Woo-ping....
Director: Wilson Yip
Actors: Donnie Yen, Simon Yam, Siu-Wong Fan
PlotIn the 1930s in Foshan, Guangdong, martial arts schools are in abundance, with the city known across China for its wealth of talent in the fighting arts. Amid this backdrop lives a quietly prosperous and unassuming Wing Chun master, widely regarded as the most skilled fighter in the city, though he chooses to live a low-profile life and avoids taking students. His peaceful existence is deeply rooted in his family life and his belief in practicing martial arts for its artistry and moral values, rather than for glory or financial gain.
However, the master's world is turned upside down when the Japanese invasion of 1937 reaches Foshan, drastically changing the fabric of life in the city. The occupation forces not only destroy the economy but also dismantle the societal structures that allowed martial arts to flourish. Facing a critical turning point, he must navigate the challenges of life under occupation while protecting his values and the people he cares about. This period of turmoil forces him into a position where he must make difficult decisions between staying true to his principles and adapting to the harsh realities of a war-torn land.
Writers: Edmond Wong, Tai-Lee Chan
Release Date: 12 Dec 2008
Runtime: 106 min
Rating: R
Country: Hong Kong, China
Language: Cantonese, Mandarin, Japanese, Chinese, English