8 Mile Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
8 Mile delivers an engrossing experience with strong performances, excellent video and audio quality; regrettably, the supplemental features disappoint.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 67
8 Mile's Blu-ray presentation, via either VC-1 or AVC MPEG-4 encode in 1080p and 2.35:1, expertly retains the film's intentional grainy and gritty look with no blemishes or imperfections, offering excellent sharpness, fine detail, rich blacks, and realistic yet stable colors, despite occasional minor shimmer issues.
Audio: 69
8 Mile's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track excels in musical sequences with thumping bass and exceptional fidelity, although it's a mostly dialogue-driven film with limited surround activity. While club scenes use surrounds robustly, the mix focuses on clear, well-balanced dialogue and standout music performances.
Extra: 44
The Blu-ray of "8 Mile" offers three minimal extras: a puff piece Making of '8 Mile' featurette, an audition-focused Uncensored Rap Battles segment with some deleted footage, and the uncensored 'Superman' music video, reflecting Universal's disinterest in providing a full-featured special edition.
Movie: 62
8 Mile delivers a gritty, semi-autobiographical tale with Eminem's impressive starring debut, capturing the raw essence of Detroit's rap scene through Curtis Hanson's unvarnished direction. Despite its conventional storyline, the film's authentic portrayal of cultural and personal struggles provides a visceral and emotionally resonant experience.
Video: 67
“8 Mile” delivers a visually engaging experience on Blu-ray with a 1080p AVC MPEG-4 encode (2.35:1). The movie’s gritty aesthetic, intentionally maintained by Director Curtis Hanson and cinematographer Rodrigo Prieto, is faithfully reproduced on this high-definition format. Enhanced sharpness and fine detail replace the earlier SD-DVD release, enriching the film's texture and providing a significant visual upgrade. The pervasive graininess—particularly in scenes bathed in the film’s signature green fluorescent light—remains natural and authentic, avoiding any degradation into unwelcome noise.
Colors are consistently realistic, though there’s an occasional desaturation that suits the film's atmospheric context. The encode is spread across a BD-25 single-layer disc and maintains deep black levels, a major strength of this Blu-ray presentation. Contrasts are mostly superb, although mid-range scenes sometimes exhibit minor flatness. Nonetheless, the absence of edge enhancement found in earlier DVD versions means viewers are treated to smoother, more authentic visuals. Minor shimmer issues, particularly in hair-detail, are fleeting and do not detract from the overall viewing experience. This Blu-ray edition authentically captures '8 Mile' as intended by its creators.
Audio: 69
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track on the "8 Mile" Blu-ray offers a compelling audio experience, especially during the musical sequences. The sound mix captures the thumping bass lines and drum loops prominently, presenting exceptional fidelity across all frequencies. This ensures that the music, which is a significant aspect of the film, is delivered with a generous amount of oomph and clarity. Throughout the quieter, dialogue-driven scenes, the audio remains clear and well-balanced, with precision in the dialogue reproduction. Although these segments do not extensively utilize surround sound, they maintain an admirable level of detail.
In scenes set within clubs or during key musical moments, there is a noticeable shift to a more robust surround sound usage. These moments bring the mix to life, offering effective surround effects without the need for constant background scoring. The 48kHz/24-bit soundtrack shows its strengths primarily through the powerful and dynamic music tracks. The pre-recorded songs sound fantastic and are given ample room to shine, making them the star of the audio presentation. While the straightforward parts of the film may lack intense low bass or expansive dynamics, they suit the material perfectly, ensuring a natural and well-recorded listening experience.
Extra: 44
The Blu-ray release of "8 Mile" includes a modest selection of extras that replicate those from the DVD edition. The most notable feature is "The Making of '8 Mile'," which, unfortunately, falls short of delivering any substantial insights into Eminem's acting debut or the film's production process. It primarily serves as a promotional segment with brief interviews and behind-the-scenes footage. The "Uncensored Rap Battles" feature offers audition footage and extended, explicit rap battles, providing a glimpse into the film’s vibrant underground rap scene. Additionally, the uncensored music video for Eminem’s "Superman" is included. While these extras offer some entertainment value, they lack depth and a comprehensive look into the film’s creation.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of '8 Mile': Behind-the-scenes footage with brief interview segments.
- Exclusive Rap Battles Uncensored: Audition footage and extended rap battles.
- 'Superman' Music Video Uncensored: Explicit lyric version of the music video.
Movie: 62
"8 Mile," starring Eminem in his motion picture debut, is a compelling semi-autobiographical film that strikes a balance between raw emotional drama and gritty urban reality. Eminem's portrayal of Jimmy B-Rabbit Smith, a young rapper striving to escape his seemingly insurmountable circumstances, is captivating and imbued with visceral authenticity. Directed by Curtis Hanson and written by Scott Silver, the film deviates from the exaggerated glamour of traditional musicals, offering instead a poignant slice of life narrative. Instead of fantasy-laden scenarios, Hanson and Silver craft a harsh yet realistic depiction of Detroit’s bleak landscape and the relentless hustle of its inhabitants. Key performances by Kim Basinger as Jimmy's troubled mother and Brittany Murphy as his love interest bolster the film's grounded tone, bringing nuance to a plot that, while familiar, still resonates with emotional depth.
Technically proficient, "8 Mile" excels in its commitment to presenting an unvarnished view of hip hop culture and the socio-economic struggles of its protagonist. The film's climactic rap battles serve as both a release and a crescendo to Jimmy's journey, cleverly subverting audience expectations by infusing the predictable underdog tale with genuine suspense and tension. Eminem's rapid-fire lyrics and magnetic screen presence lend credibility to his character's ambitions, making the narrative's well-worn themes feel fresh and invigorating. Although the script occasionally leans on clichéd story beats, the energetic direction and strong character work ensure "8 Mile" transcends its formulaic structure.
The cultural subtext within "8 Mile," especially regarding white versus black dynamics in the rap world, is layered but not deeply explored, offering a tantalizing glimpse of complexities that could have been further examined. Nevertheless, the film's earnestness in portraying the hip hop scene with dignity and integrity is commendable. By focusing on Jimmy's personal and familial strife, "8 Mile" succeeds in weaving a gripping tale of perseverance, identity, and self-discovery, showcasing Eminem as a multidimensional performer capable of commanding the screen with an unexpected gravitas.
Total: 62
The Blu-ray release of "8 Mile" presents a commendable AV experience, showcasing impressive video and audio quality. The 1080p transfer delivers a sharp image with deep blacks and excellent contrast, providing a gritty and realistic portrayal of Detroit's lower-class neighborhoods. The color palette retains the cold atmosphere of the film, and the intricate details in the mise-en-scène are well preserved. Audio-wise, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is stellar, offering clear dialogue and immersive ambient sounds that enhance the film's intense climatic moments.
However, where this Blu-ray edition falters is in its limited supplemental content. The included extras are rather underwhelming, offering little beyond basic behind-the-scenes footage and interviews. For those seeking in-depth insights into the film’s production process or additional perspectives on its cultural impact, these extras will be disappointing. This lack of substantial bonus material does, unfortunately, diminish the overall package.
Even if you couldn't care less about rap culture and hip hop, you'll most likely find 8 Mile to be an involving and compelling film experience. Eminem delivers a blistering performance, and the supporting cast is uniformly excellent. The biggest surprise here may in fact be director Curtis Hanson, who really gives a palpable feel of what lower-class Detroit is like. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
This is inarguably a major upgrade from the SD-DVD release, with excellent sharpness and fine detail, and really appealing contrast and exceptional black levels....
Audio: 90
That means not a whale of a lot of surround activity, but still a fine and very nicely realized track, with clarity and precision....
Extras: 50
Three OK extras are included on this Blu-ray: The Making of '8 Mile' (SD; 10:02), features behind the scenes footage intercut with brief interview segments; Exclusive Rap Battles Uncensored (SD; 23:29),...
Movie: 80
Whatever qualms we older folk may have in lamenting more melodic times gone by, it can't be argued that Eminem's astounding starring debut in 8 Mile (after a cameo in The Wash) delivered a palpable emotional...
Total: 80
The biggest surprise here may in fact be director Curtis Hanson, who really gives a palpable feel of what lower class Detroit is like....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
This is a strong encode, and if not a fantastic high-def demo disc, it certainly presents the film as intended....
Audio: 80
The attraction here is the music, not explosions, and on that level this mix delivers the goods....
Extras: 20
Instead, this takes a look at the audition process for many of the up-and-coming rappers who will do battle with Eminem in the film -- it's like an 'American Idol' of rap....
Movie: 60
So watching the film for the first time on this Blu-ray was a strange experience -- I couldn't really separate Eminem as I view him now (fairly or unfairly), which is as a past-his-prime artist, from the...
Total: 60
But it's got a strong story and good performances, so it may appeal to even those who aren't fans of Eminem or rap music....
Director: Curtis Hanson
Actors: Eminem, Brittany Murphy, Kim Basinger
PlotIn the blighted urban landscape of Detroit, a young white rapper, Jimmy "B-Rabbit" Smith Jr., navigates the struggles of his daily life. Living in a rundown trailer with his alcoholic mother and her abusive boyfriend, he seeks solace and purpose in his music. By day, B-Rabbit works a dead-end job at a steel stamping factory, but by night, he pursues his passion for hip-hop, dreaming of escaping his dire circumstances through his lyrical talent. He is haunted by a recent humiliation at a local rap battle, which only compounds his sense of desperation and fuels his determination to redeem himself.
B-Rabbit finds friendship and support in a group of fellow rappers who share his aspirations. His best friend, Future, believes in his potential and encourages him to rebound and confront his fears. Amidst these trials, B-Rabbit begins a tumultuous relationship with Alex, an ambitious woman with dreams of her own who becomes both a muse and a distraction. As he grapples with his tumultuous home life, evolving romance, and the economic hardships that suffocate his community, B-Rabbit prepares for a rap battle that could change his life. The stage becomes a battleground where he must prove himself against fierce competitors, using his wit and raw authenticity to turn his life experiences into lyrical weapons.
Writers: Scott Silver
Release Date: 08 Nov 2002
Runtime: 110 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Germany
Language: English