Monk: Season Five Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Kino's Blu-ray of Monk: Season Five delivers standout episodes with excellent audio-visual quality and engaging extras, highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 84
Monk: Season Five Blu-ray offers a stellar 1080p presentation with a flawless 4K restoration, showcasing impeccable sharpness, rich colors, and deep black levels. Facial features, clothing, and location details are exceptionally clear, with a cinematic grain that enhances the visual fidelity. Each episode is clean, stable, and true to its source.
Audio: 82
Monk: Season Five's Blu-ray audio presentation, featuring a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, delivers surprising depth and engagement along the front channels. It offers excellent musical clarity, with dialogue prioritized cleanly. Though not legendary, it effectively handles both dialogue and rare action sequences.
Extra: 53
The Blu-ray extras for "Monk: Season Five" offer standard definition features from the DVD, including a unique black-and-white "Mr. Monk and the Leper" episode with commentary, and four entertaining webisodes, differing from previous releases by providing a mix of original and fun content. Highly recommended for fans.
Show: 85
Monk: Season Five on Blu-ray offers fans a high-quality experience with a 4K video restoration and dual audio versions, capturing the show's signature formula balanced by refreshing episodes like the noir-inspired 'Mr. Monk and the Leper.' While maintaining its charm, this season solidifies its peak with standout guest appearances and engaging character dynamics.
Video: 84
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Monk: Season Five" is exemplary, thanks to a meticulous 4K restoration process. The series, initially shot on Super 35mm with Panavision cameras, is now presented in a 1920 x 1080p resolution on dual-layered BD-50 discs. The episodes are framed at an aspect ratio of 1.78:1, offering a comprehensive visual clarity absent from prior DVD or streaming versions. Each episode maintains a bit rate between 25 and 35Mbps, ensuring robust detail and vibrant color fidelity. The film's aesthetic remains organic with impressive sharpness and depth, revealing every facet of character expressions and intricate costume textures.
The color palette is rendered with precision, exhibiting a range of hues that enhances the cinematic experience, notably with deep blacks and excellent contrast. Low-light scenes benefit from finely tuned shadows and minimal crush, ensuring details remain discernible in darker shots. Fans will appreciate the absence of any discernible print flaws or encoding faults, highlighting Kino Lorber Studio Classics' commitment to video quality.
With the technical prowess in color representation and white balance, skin tones appear consistently accurate and natural. The inclusion of grain provides a film-like texture without impairing the overall image quality. While some CGI elements occasionally seem less polished, these minor issues do not detract from the overall visual enjoyment. In summary, Monk's fifth season Blu-ray serves its audience with a visually rich and authentic experience, bringing out the best of the original material with superior restoration and presentation fidelity.
Audio: 82
The Blu-ray release of "Monk: Season Five" continues the series' tradition with a robust DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 lossless soundtrack. Despite its limitation to two channels, the audio presentation is impressively engaging, creating an immersive sound stage predominantly through the front left and right speakers. Musical elements, notably the iconic theme song, are delivered with exceptional clarity, extending to encompass the enriching scores and diegetic musical cues throughout the season. Episodes featuring varied musical settings, such as the rock concert, benefit from detailed and dynamically spaced soundscapes, capturing the lively atmosphere with distinct crowd noise and instrument separation.
Dialogue remains at the forefront of the audio mix, given the series' conversational nature, and is rendered with precision and clarity. Each episode maintains crisp audio fidelity without any noticeable dropouts. While the series rarely necessitates elaborate action sequences or sound effects, when such moments do arise, like the blowing hot air balloon in the Leper episode or bustling hospital scenes, the track handles these instances adeptly with a clear sense of directionality and energy. The track achieves a commendable balance of lifelike ambient effects and directional impact within its stereo limitations, ensuring a captivating auditory experience for viewers.
Extras: 53
The Blu-ray release of "Monk: Season Five" provides a commendable collection of extras that seamlessly contribute to the charm of this iconic series. Discs three and four host a variety of features, notably the dual versions (black and white, and color) of "Mr. Monk and the Leper," enhanced by distinct intros from Tony Shalhoub and Ted Levine with Jason Gray-Stanford. A detailed audio commentary accompanies the black-and-white version, featuring insights from key cast members and executive producers, offering depth to the viewing experience. Additionally, the collection includes four engaging webisodes capturing Monk’s quirky adventures, adding humor and character depth absent in past DVD releases. Although these extras are carried over from the original DVDs, they remain unique and noteworthy in today’s streaming era.
Extras included in this disc:
- Mr. Monk and the Leper Introduction: Intro for B&W by Tony Shalhoub; Intro for Color by Ted Levine and Jason Gray-Stanford.
- Mr. Monk and the Leper Audio Commentary: Commentary on the black-and-white episode by cast and crew.
- Mr. Monk and Dr. Kroger: Webisode: A short scene between Monk and Dr. Kroger.
- Mr. Monk and the Computer: Webisode: Monk rearranges a keyboard.
- Mr. Monk and the Blood Test: Webisode: Monk's prolonged wait at the doctor’s office.
- Mr. Monk Goes to the Gym: Webisode: Monk's challenges in a gym setting.
Show: 85
"Monk: Season Five" on Blu-ray offers a finely crafted continuation of the beloved detective series. This release, sourced from a new 4K video restoration, ensures the visual clarity and depth that meet fans' high expectations. The integration of 2.0 lossless audio furthers the atmosphere and highlights the show's excellent sound design. Notably, this edition features dual versions—color and black-and-white—of "Mr. Monk and the Leper," which engage viewers with its rich noir aesthetic. The season is heralded for its star-studded guest appearances, with Stanley Tucci's Emmy-winning performance as a method actor portraying Monk in the season premiere setting a high standard.
Despite maintaining its hallmark formula, Season Five rejuvenates interest with fresh situational humor and an exploration of Monk’s eccentricities, allowing for consistent viewer engagement. While characters themselves may show little development, the season's charm lies in the intricate plots and subtle psychological insights into Monk’s character, making his every phobia a delightful obstacle to navigate. The balance of humor and pathos is exemplified by episodes like "Mr. Monk Is at Your Service," where Adrian becomes a butler, or "Mr. Monk and the Garbage Strike," which showcases his obsessive-compulsive tendencies to comic effect amid a city crisis. Each episode brings its own unique flavor, anchored by top-tier performances from the returning cast.
Technically, the Blu-ray presentation of this season is robust, with each disc providing seamless access to all sixteen episodes, packed with plot synopses and notable guest appearances, such as Jennifer Lawrence and Sean Astin. The four-disc set promises an enriching experience for both dedicated followers and newcomers to the series, encapsulated within a thoughtfully designed package offering user-friendly accessibility to all its features.
Total: 77
Monk: Season Five might appear stagnant to some, but its consistency is a testament to its charm and reliability. This season continues to deliver captivating storytelling, anchored by Tony Shalhoub's brilliant portrayal of the titular detective whose unique quirks both impede and aid his investigations. The series maintains its delightful balance between light-hearted humor and intricate crime-solving that fans have come to cherish. The supporting cast remains strong, with memorable performances from guests enhancing the overall experience.
Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release effectively elevates the viewing experience, offering impressive picture and sound quality. The 16 episodes are carefully distributed across four discs, ensuring optimal performance. Notable extras include the much-appreciated black-and-white version of "Mr. Monk and the Leper," complete with cast and crew commentary, as well as the original color version. Additionally, four short webisodes add a refreshing dimension to this re-release, living up to Kino's reputation for high-quality home media offerings.
While it would have been preferable to see new bonus content introduced alongside this release, the inclusion of legacy materials from previous DVD editions adds significant value. Overall, Monk: Season Five on Blu-ray is a robust package that preserves the series' brilliance while enhancing its technical aspects. It remains a highly recommended set for both long-time fans and new viewers eager to experience this charming detective series with pristine audio-visual quality.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
It allows for a satisfying level of natural film sharpness to present on the screen, bringing exceptionally clear and accurate life to facial features, clothing lines and fabric elements, and of course...
Audio: 90
Additionally, there is suitably lifelike presentation elements in the rock concert episode to the music and lyrics, with aggressive spacing and good detail through the range of musical elements, not to...
Extras: 50
Disc Three: "Mr. Monk and the Leper" (B&W) Intro with Tony Shalhoub (480i, 4x3, 0:37): The actor introduces the reason why the episode is airing in black and white....
Movie: 80
As always, the season really thrives when the writers dig deep into the Monk psyche and work in situational humor that is the result of his various phobias, how Monk makes things infinitely more difficult...
Total: 80
Every episode is great and, as usual, it's not so much the mystery that sells the episode but rather...
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 95
Each disc features bitrates that range from 25 to 35Mbps, sometimes dipping to 20Mbps or lower on disc three due to the amount of content authored for that disc, but every episode is crisp with excellent...
Audio: 90
Extras: 60
The standard definition extras from the original DVD release have carried over, and they include some gems, including both the original black and white and syndicated color versions of the episode Mr....
Movie: 85
The show’s popularity was as high as ever as Monk (Tony Shaloub) and the rest of the show’s characters hit their creative stride, with Monk continuing to deal with his sometimes unbearable OCD, yet always...
Total: 83
The standard definition extras from the original DVD release have carried over, and they include some gems, including both the original black and white and syndicated color versions of the episode Mr....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Facial features, textures in clothing and costumes, and set design work are all on display with a naturally cinematic veneer of film grain....
Audio: 80
As the show has always been a pretty conversational affair, the mix supports our OCD detective and his musings....
Extras: 60
Since it’s something of a rarity - at least I haven’t seen it on streaming - I’m including the Black and White version of Episode 10 as a bonus feature since the different intros and commentary track is...
Movie: 100
Monk is one of the rare shows that was great from the start and managed to stay great through most of the run....
Total: 80
I do wish the extras were a little more extensive and recent, but all the same glad to see the legacy materials from the old DVDs are included....
Director: N/A
Actors: Tony Shalhoub, Jason Gray-Stanford, Ted Levine
PlotAdrian Monk, a brilliant detective formerly with the San Francisco Police Department, struggles with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and various phobias. These conditions emerged after his wife, Trudy, was tragically murdered in a car bombing, a case that remains unsolved and haunts him. Monk's acute attention to detail and ability to notice minor inconsistencies provide him with a unique investigative edge. Despite his talents, his mental health issues often make everyday tasks difficult for him. Nevertheless, he works as a private consultant for the police department, solving cases that baffle the regular force. Captain Leland Stottlemeyer, head of the homicide division, values Monk's insights and frequently enlists his help, although he sometimes finds Monk's quirks challenging.
Monk is accompanied by his dedicated assistant, initially Sharona Fleming and later Natalie Teeger, who help manage his daily life and serve as intermediaries between his idiosyncrasies and the world. These assistants not only aid Monk with his investigations but also provide personal support, often acting as surrogate family members. His journey through various intriguing cases serves as both a means of coping with his loss and a hope to find answers about Trudy's death. Over time, Monk faces new challenges, wrestles with his fears, and gradually steps closer to resolving his greatest personal mystery. Despite the heavy themes, moments of humor often emerge from Monk's interactions with those around him and the peculiar situations generated by his disorder.
Writers: Andy Breckman
Release Date: 12 Jul 2002
Runtime: 44 min
Rating: TV-PG
Country: United States
Language: English