The Molly Maguires Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "The Molly Maguires," released by Via Vision Entertainment, is encoded with MPEG-4 AVC and presented in an aspect ratio of 2.40:1, offering a 1080p transfer. The release stems from an older master provided by Paramount Pictures. The same master was previously used for Paramount's 2019 North American release. The transfer showcases a generally pleasing image, but it noticeably lacks the sharpness and depth that a modern restoration using 4K mastering could deliver.

Most close-ups manage to maintain decent quality under restricted lighting, but outdoor scenes falter with respect to delineation and clarity. Grain exposure is apparent but should be more refined for higher fidelity, while density levels are maintained adequately. Colors remain stable, though there is a need for better balance, particularly noticeable in daylight sequences where supporting nuances appear to struggle. The encode manages multi-layered grain well without compromising detail, although occurrences of print damage and frame instability are evident in several scenes.

Overall, the film has no major issues such as large cuts or severe frame warping but exhibits minor blemishes and white nicks. Despite these shortcomings, the Blu-ray offers the best home viewing experience available to date. However, substantial improvements could likely be achieved through a new 4K master, addressing the existing transfer limitations and enhancing visual fidelity across daylight footage and widescreen compositions. This is a Region-Free Blu-ray release, making it universally accessible across all regions.

The Blu-ray release of "The Molly Maguires" showcases an impressive array of audio tracks featuring English LPCM 2.0 and DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 options. The inclusion of both lossless audio and optional English subtitles, including SDH, provides a well-rounded viewing experience. The LPCM 2.0 track is noted for its enhanced clarity over the previously available lossy version, presenting clearer and more precise dialogue without any encoding issues. This track effectively handles the intricate sound details, such as the explosions at the beginning of the film, with a noticeable improvement in auditory fidelity.

The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track offers an immersive surround sound experience that expands the audio dimension notably. It manages to maintain clarity in dialogue, directing it towards the frontal soundstage while providing ambient enhancements through the surround channels. Notably, Henry Mancini’s dynamic score benefits from this surround format, enriching the overall presence and emotional depth of key scenes. This track maintains authenticity to the film's subtle soundscape, gracefully handling action sequences without overpowering the naturally reserved audio tone of the original production.

Collectively, these audio tracks provide a robust experience for viewers seeking both precision and immersion. Each track presents unique strengths, allowing for auditory appreciation either in focused clarity or an augmented dimensional soundscape, enhancing "The Molly Maguires" in a way previously unattainable with earlier formats.

The Blu-Ray disc of "The Molly Maguires" offers a thoughtfully curated collection of extras, enhancing the viewing experience with insightful retrospectives and engaging commentaries. The standout feature is the interview with actor Anthony Zerbe, titled "A Complicated Film," where he shares his invaluable experiences working with director Martin Ritt, highlighting the director’s nuanced approach with actors like Richard Harris. The audio commentaries, notably by Howard S. Berger, are detailed and rich in historical context, offering deeper understanding and appreciation of the film's themes and production. While the features are limited, they significantly contribute to understanding the film's complex narrative and production challenges.

Extras included in this disc:

• A Complicated Film: Actor Anthony Zerbe discusses his experiences working on the film and with Martin Ritt.
• Commentary One: Audio commentary by critic Howard S. Berger.
• Commentary Two: Audio commentary by author/producer Nat Segaloff.
• Trailer: Vintage U.S. trailer for "The Molly Maguires."

Martin Ritt's "The Molly Maguires" (1970) is a nuanced exploration set against the backdrop of 1876 Pennsylvania coal mines. The film intricately depicts the secretive Irish miner society, known as the Molly Maguires, who employ tactics such as sabotage and violence to challenge their perceived oppressors. Richard Harris stars as Detective James McParlan, sent to dismantle the society by infiltrating it. His involvement introduces him to the internal struggles of the miners led by Jack Kehoe, portrayed by Sean Connery. The evolving dynamics between McParlan and Kehoe underpin the film, presenting Harris with opportunities to develop a deeper understanding of his mission amidst growing personal connections.

Ritt's directorial approach blends Hollywood’s romanticism with a political narrative akin to John Ford's work on Irish themes. Despite solid performances, particularly from Connery, whose portrayal emphasizes controlled internal tension, the film wrestles with unclear storytelling focus. Editing shortfalls may contribute to its unfocused narrative shifts, moving from intimate character study to broader political discourse without cohesion. Additionally, the screenplay's inability to decide on a central figure creates an uneven balance of power between its leading roles. At times, Connery’s dominating presence overshadows Harris, misaligning viewer expectations with the film’s promotional framing.

Technically, "The Molly Maguires" benefits from James Wong Howe’s cinematography, capturing the expansive and arduous coal mining environment. The production design succeeds in immersing the audience in the narrative's intense socio-economic tensions. Despite initial critical lukewarm reception and misunderstood complexities in its original release, the Blu-ray edition presents a visually impactful restoration, encouraging contemporary viewers to reflect on its social themes resonant with modern issues. This underrated work emerges in high definition as a testament to Ritt's vision, bolstered by strong performances and crafted with a meticulous aesthetic.

Imprint Films presents "The Molly Maguires" on Blu-ray, offering a historical drama piece that feels both immersive and contemplative. Although the film lags at times, it manages to depict a story of social unrest with subtle performances and evocative cinematography by James Wong Howe. Despite mixed opinions on Martin Ritt's direction, the narrative attempts to navigate complex themes of loyalty and justice. This release revives a film that was underappreciated at the time of its initial release, providing an opportunity to re-evaluate its merits in a contemporary context.

The Blu-ray release includes a decent HD transfer stemming from an older master by Paramount, previously used for the 2019 North American release. Via Vision Entertainment enhances this edition with exclusive bonus features, such as an interview with actor Anthony Zerbe. These additions, alongside the quality of the transfer, make this version particularly appealing for collectors and film enthusiasts interested in classic cinema. Nevertheless, the film's pacing and narrative decisions, attributed primarily to Martin Ritt's approach, remain contentious points that may affect viewer engagement.

In conclusion, while "The Molly Maguires" may not resonate with everyone due to its pacing and directional choices, this release by Imprint Films offers a noteworthy package for archival collections. The inclusion of special features provides depth to the cinematic experience, even if the film is not fully memorable post-viewing. If maintaining a comprehensive Blu-ray collection is your aim, this release is certainly the one to acquire despite its narrative shortcomings.