The Mortal Storm Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 69
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
A landmark WWII film, The Mortal Storm's new Blu-ray by Warner Archive features top-tier A/V from a 4K restoration, and essential extras, retaining its potent impact.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
The Mortal Storm Blu-ray features an exceptional 1080p transfer from a 4K scan, showcasing pristine black-and-white cinematography, rich black levels, and excellent contrast with minimal artifacts, making it a significant upgrade over previous editions.
Audio: 76
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track is clean, robust, and free from defects, offering clear dialogue, well-mixed dramatic score, and a wide dynamic range without distortion, making The Mortal Storm's audio a vibrant and engaging experience.
Extra: 33
Extras include an HD-remastered 'Peace on Earth' showcasing a poignant anti-war message, the Technicolor naval recruitment short 'Meet the Fleet' featuring young George Reeves, and a vintage trailer emphasizing the film’s literary roots, all enhancing the disc's archival appeal.
Movie: 80
The Mortal Storm is a profoundly effective anti-Nazi film by Frank Borzage, notable for its meticulous depiction of a nation’s rapid descent into fascism and the moral fortitude of those who resist. Featuring the final pairing of James Stewart and Margaret Sullavan, it leverages emotional storytelling amidst a backdrop of political terror, now beautifully restored on Blu-ray with optimized 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 video and DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono.
Video: 79
The Blu-Ray release of "The Mortal Storm" showcases an impressive 1080p transfer sourced from a meticulously executed 4K scan of the film's finest extant elements. This restoration ensures a visually striking representation of the movie's classic black-and-white cinematography. Details such as deep, rich black levels, well-defined whites, and nuanced grayscale variations capture the essence of the original nitrate prints. The transfer also maintains a natural film grain, enhancing the sense of authenticity and depth in the visuals. Fine details and textures are consistently realized, though a few interior scenes and rear-projection effects exhibit minor softness. Overall, the image presentation remains remarkably clean and stable, devoid of intrusive artifacts, edge enhancement, or banding.
Although some occasional nicks and the artificial nature of miniatures and painted backdrops are mildly accentuated by the enhanced sharpness, these issues are infrequent and do not detract significantly from the viewing experience. The high bit rate and skillful authoring of Warner Archive’s dual-layered Blu-ray further ensure that this presentation stands out, matching if not exceeding other top-tier vintage catalogue releases. With excellent contrast, clarity, and shadow delineation, this Blu-Ray edition represents a significant upgrade over the previous MOD DVD-R release. Enthusiastic praise is deserved for this transfer which brings "The Mortal Storm" to life with a fresh and vibrant visual quality that is a joy to behold.
Audio: 76
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track on the Blu-ray of "The Mortal Storm" is commendable for its clarity and robustness. This presentation is free of any distracting source defects, ensuring a smooth auditory experience from beginning to end. The dialogue is consistently clean and easy to follow, capturing the essence of the original one-channel roots without any feeling of narrowness or cramping. This holds true across varied acoustical settings within the film, like smaller dining rooms or crowded pubs. The dramatic score, credited to Bronislau Kaper, Eugene Zador, and Edward Kane, is well-balanced with strong dynamic range, effectively coexisting with the dialogue without fighting for attention. Additionally, the optional English SDH subtitles are in perfect sync with the audio, adding to the fluidity of the overall presentation.
Noteworthy is the absence of age-related hiss, pops, or crackles in the DTS-HD MA 2.0 mono track. The sound profile remains vibrant, with sonic accents and atmospherics delivered crisply. Highs and lows in the musical score are managed adeptly without distortion, although the audio does exhibit slight thinness compared to contemporary recordings. Nonetheless, the dialogue remains clear and consistently discernible throughout the film. Only minimal and momentary hints of hiss are present, primarily at the beginning of the film. Furthermore, any minor sync issues have been meticulously addressed, contributing to a coherent and engaging audio experience consistent throughout.
Extras: 33
The Blu-ray release of "The Mortal Storm" offers a compelling suite of extras that augment the main feature's thematic resonance. The vintage supplements include an Oscar-nominated animated short, "Peace on Earth," which presents an anti-war message through engaging storytelling and features the voice of Mel Blanc. Additionally, "Meet the Fleet" is a Technicolor propaganda short from 1940, designed to bolster U.S. Navy recruitment efforts, starring actors like Robert Armstrong and George Reeves. The original theatrical trailer is also included, providing historical context and emphasizing the film's literary foundations. Each supplement is presented in HD, with upgraded audio tracks enhancing the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Peace on Earth: Animated 1939 short with an anti-war message.
- Meet the Fleet: 1940 propaganda short featuring future stars.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original preview emphasizing the film's themes.
Movie: 80
"The Mortal Storm," directed by Frank Borzage, is a seminal anti-fascist narrative that chillingly portrays the rise of Nazi ideology through the lens of a German family. The movie opens on January 30, 1933, Hitler's appointment as Chancellor, shaking a tranquil small town and igniting a political turmoil that rips apart the family of Jewish professor Viktor Roth, played by Frank Morgan. His daughter Freya (Margaret Sullavan) finds herself caught between her love for Martin Breitner (James Stewart) and her fiancé Fritz Marburg (Robert Young), who succumbs to Nazi fervor. The film's impactful depiction of Roth's persecution underscores the ominous encroachment of anti-science, racist ideologies masquerading as nationalism.
Borzage’s direction juxtaposes intense family bonds against the backdrop of Nazi brutality, fostering a palpable sense of dread. The narrative avoids directly naming "Jews," instead using the term "non-Aryan," a strategic yet diluted effort to evade then-present German censorship. This linguistic vagueness may slightly undercut its protest value but does not diminish its historic and emotional resonance. Frank Morgan anchors the film with a nuanced performance, supported by Sullavan and Stewart's understated yet compelling portrayal of resistance and moral clarity amidst pervasive hate. The pub altercation scene where Martin defends a Jewish man epitomizes the film's moral courage, reflecting broader socio-political dynamics, paralleling contemporary issues of ideological extremism.
The Mortal Storm's poignant storytelling remains relevant today, mirroring modern socio-political fractures. Produced before the U.S. entered WWII, it boldly challenged American neutrality with its stark anti-Nazi message, despite potential market repercussions. The film's striking visual language and earnest emotionality have allowed it to age remarkably well, reaffirming its status as a critical piece of cinema history that unflinchingly confronts the perils of unchecked authoritarianism.
Total: 69
Frank Borzage's "The Mortal Storm" is a dramatically powerful portrait of the rise of Naziism in pre-World War II Germany, with an acute focus on the devastating impacts of radical ideology on family and friends. The stirring performances by Margaret Sullavan, James Stewart, and Robert Young anchor this historically significant WWII film. The film explores themes of bigotry, bullying, and authoritarianism with surprising brashness, providing an unflinching look at how opposing political viewpoints can sever personal ties.
Warner Archive's new Blu-ray edition represents a noteworthy upgrade from the previous MOD DVD, benefiting greatly from a brand-new 4K restoration. This restoration brings unparalleled clarity and depth to the visual presentation, preserving the film's stark cinematography. The audio quality is solid, complementing the compelling narrative with clear sound reproduction. Additionally, the Blu-ray includes a selection of vintage supplements that contextualize its historical relevance.
In conclusion, "The Mortal Storm" remains chillingly pertinent in today's socio-political climate. Warner Archive's Blu-ray release is characterized by top-tier audio/visual presentation and is enhanced with valuable extras. This package is an essential purchase for both historical and cinematic reasons, even as a blind buy.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
Although the image quality varies slightly at times for that reason, it's a remarkably stable and very clean picture that showcases The Mortal Storm's pristine black-and-white cinematography....
Audio: 90
Dialogue is very clean and easily understood; obviously the film's one-channel roots prevent any kind of separation, but crowded conversations are anything but narrow or cramped, whether the characters...
Extras: 40
Peace on Earth (8:30) - This Oscar-nominated 1939 MGM cartoon, directed by an uncredited Hugh Harman, tells a sobering account of war through the eyes of two baby squirrels and their grandfather....
Movie: 90
The spell is broken during his birthday dinner when it's announced that Hitler has been made chancellor of Germany, igniting a political debate between his pro-Nazi stepsons and pacifist Martin that ends...
Total: 90
Dramatically effective and well-acted, Frank Borzage's The Mortal Storm is a landmark WWII film of great historical importance that remains just as potent today, showcasing how opposing political viewpoints...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Excellent contrast and clarity bring the picture to life and a natural grain structure maintains the feel of celluloid....
Audio: 80
Any age-related hiss, pops, or crackle have been erased, dialogue is well prioritized and easy to understand, and a wide dynamic scale handles all the highs and lows of the music score without any distortion....
Extras: 20
This Oscar-nominated 1939 animated short features the voice talent of the legendary Mel Blanc and presents a surprisingly sober and effective anti-war message in - of all places - an apocalyptic setting....
Movie: 80
America may have been neutral in 1940, but Borzage's film takes a stand and undoubtedly opened the eyes of many U.S. citizens who up to that point didn't fully grasp the dire nature and complete breadth...
Total: 80
Director Frank Borzage's riveting film depicts bigotry, bullying, and cultish behavior with surprising brashness and examines the insidious nature and devastating effects of such radical ideology within...
Home Theater Forum review by Josh SteinbergRead review here
Video: 90
Make no mistake, this is a welcome and significant upgrade over the previous MOD DVD-R edition....
Audio: 80
Though the audio seems slightly thin in comparison to more modern recordings, dialogue is clear and easily discernible, and the quality is consistent throughout....
Extras: 50
This Warner/Vitaphone Technicolor fictional short about a day in the life in the U.S. Navy has also been upgraded to an HD presentation with lossless DTS-HD MA audio....
Movie: 80
Though the two have shown great chemistry in previous collaborations, this final pairing keeps them apart for most of the film’s running time; it is that familiarity and shorthand that helps to sell the...
Total: 90
Though the film was more of a critical than commercial success that has been overshadowed in film history by a certain satire released in the same year, the sincere performances from a noteworthy ensemble...
Director: Frank Borzage
Actors: Margaret Sullavan, James Stewart, Robert Young
PlotIn a small German town on the eve of World War II, Professor Viktor Roth is a beloved, well-respected teacher who lives a peaceful life with his family. The tranquil existence of the Roth family shatters as the rise of Adolf Hitler and Nazism grips the nation. This unexpected and swift change in political climate causes increasing tension and division among friends and neighbors. Professor Roth's step-sons, Erich and Otto, become ardent followers of the Nazi regime, while his daughter, Freya, remains resistant to the growing tide of intolerance and hatred. Freya's commitment to her ideals strains her relationship with her fiancé, Nazi supporter Fritz Marberg. Instead, she finds herself drawn to Martin Breitner, a compassionate local farmer who shares her values and revulsion toward Nazi ideology.
As the Nazi influence deepens its hold on the town, the Roth family faces relentless persecution due to the professor's Jewish heritage. This escalating oppression forces them into difficult and dangerous decisions, with their once happy family caught in a web of fear and betrayal. Freya and Martin's bond strengthens as they’re thrust into the resistance against the brutal oppression surrounding them. Despite facing grave dangers, they strive to uphold their dignity and humanity amidst growing turmoil. The story beautifully captures the devastating personal impacts of broader political upheaval and the courage required to stand against evil.
Writers: Claudine West, Hans Rameau, George Froeschel
Release Date: 14 Jun 1940
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English