The Beguiled Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Sophia Coppola's The Beguiled gets mixed reviews, but its mood and quality shine on Blu-ray.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
The Beguiled's Blu-ray dazzles with its visually lush, period-accurate cinematography, despite inherent source material limits and a dream-like softness.
Audio: 69
The Beguiled's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack excels in clarity and atmosphere, adeptly enhancing its understated yet moody presentation with ambient effects and a minimalist score, maintaining authenticity and tension throughout.
Extra: 27
The Beguiled Blu-ray includes two featurettes exploring film's style, setting, and Coppola's direction, with insights on design, costumes, and cast perspectives.
Movie: 70
Sofia Coppola's The Beguiled, a beautifully crafted, slow-burning adaptation of Cullinan's novel, captures a feminist vibe and natural beauty, triumphing in its detailed storytelling despite debates on its necessity and innovation compared to the 1971 film.
Video: 73
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Beguiled," courtesy of Universal's Region Free UK release, showcases director Sofia Coppola's visually distinctive and atmospheric film with finesse, despite a few inherent limitations. Shot on film and meticulously finished in 4K, the 1080p/AVC-encoded video manages to preserve the integrity and beauty of Coppola's vision, although the choice not to issue a UHD version is noted. The release employs a somewhat unconventional 1.66:1 aspect ratio, true to Coppola's theatrical intentions, which, along with the adept handling of the film's low lighting and soft, hazy style, transports viewers directly into its 19th-century setting. The video straddles the line between clarity and atmospheric softness, confronting challenges such as slight haze and minor instances of ringing without detracting significantly from the overall viewing experience.
The visual presentation excels in detail and texture, particularly in well-lit scenes where the period attire, woodwork, and foliage come to life with impressively preserved textures and colors that, while restrained, effectively enhance the film's moody aesthetic. Indoor scenes, often lit by nothing more than candlelight, reveal an impressive depth of detail within the shadows, supported by robust black levels that maintain their depth without compromise. Skin tones are rendered naturally across varying lighting conditions, contributing to a consistently authentic look throughout the film.
Despite occasional dark scenes that test the limits of visual clarity and minor digital anomalies, the Blu-ray of "The Beguiled" presents a filmic experience that remains elegant and immersive. Cinematographer Philippe LeSourd's work is beautifully translated onto home video, with a color palette that uses muted tones and occasional vibrant splashes to great effect. The transfer is largely free from digital issues, presenting a clean, stable image that respects both the artistic intentions behind the movie and the period it seeks to recreate. Shadow detail is commendably handled, ensuring that even in its darkest moments, the film’s visual storytelling remains uncompromised, making this release a noteworthy achievement in home video presentation.
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of "The Beguiled" on Blu Ray, facilitated through a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, delivers an experience that’s both understated and exemplary in its execution. Dialogue, a pivotal element given the film’s narrative, is rendered with exceptional clarity, predominantly channeled through the frontal array, ensuring every word is comprehensible without overwhelming the subtle ambient effects that give life to the scenes. These effects, from the ambient outdoors filled with insect buzzes to the distant yet ominous sounds of battle, are meticulously placed across the soundscape, enhancing the film's atmosphere without becoming intrusive. The minimalist score, when present, is haunting and adds a nuanced layer to the drama, evident of a sound design that prioritizes mood and tone over spectacle.
Moreover, natural atmospherics are a standout in this presentation. The audio track expertly utilizes all speakers available to craft a tangible sense of location, whether it be through the immersive outdoor scenes buzzing with life or the echoing halls of the Civil War-era school. Subtleties in sound placement, such as the directionally appropriate thuds of distant battle or the crisp surround action distinguishing quieter moments, contribute significantly to the film’s immersive quality. The track maintains a wide dynamic scale, ensuring that from the softest whisper to the thud of cannon fire, fidelity is preserved without distortion.
While most dialogue is presented with clarity, there are moments where it becomes slightly muddled; however, these instances are few and far between, not detracting significantly from the overall auditory experience. The sonic environment crafted by the audio presentation goes beyond mere background; it's an integral part of "The Beguiled's" storytelling, enhancing the eerie mood and tension inherent throughout the film. This DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track may not be conventional demo material, but its robust yet nuanced delivery showcases how audio can subtly yet powerfully contribute to cinematic storytelling.
Extras: 27
The Blu-ray release of "The Beguiled" is moderately supplemented with extras, primarily featuring two concise featurettes that explore the depth and making of Sofia Coppola's visually captivating film. "A Shift in Perspective" delves into the unique storytelling and directorial approach by Coppola, highlighting the female-centric outlook, character dynamics, as well as offering insights from the cast including Kirsten Dunst, Colin Farrell, Elle Fanning, and sharing moments from life on set. "A Southern Style" complements by examining the meticulous attention to production design, costumes, and setting that altogether underline the film’s atmospheric tone. Despite the brevity of these extras, they provide a valuable glimpse into the creative processes behind this reimagined cinematic piece, featuring both technical discussions and personal reflections from the cast and crew. Furthermore, a DVD copy of the film and a digital copy voucher enhance the package, underscoring its appeal for collectors and fans.
Extras included in this disc:
- A Shift in Perspective: An exploration of the film's narrative approach, Coppola's directorial vision, and cast insights.
- A Southern Style: Focuses on the elaborate production design, costumes, and overall aesthetic that define the film's setting.
Movie: 70
Sofia Coppola's reimagining of "The Beguiled," grounded in the haunting depths of Thomas Cullinan's novel and inspired by Don Siegel's 1971 adaptation, shines with a freshness that interweaves gothic atmospherics with meticulously crafted character introspections. The setting, a secluded all-girl school in Virginia during the tumultuous times of the Civil War, becomes a crucible for complex emotions and darkened intentions when a wounded Union soldier, Corporal John McBurney (Colin Farrell), is discovered and taken into their care. The film unravels at a languid pace, rich in mood and thick with foreboding, building toward a conclusion that is both nightmarish and inevitable. Coppola's direction, alongside Philippe Le Sourd's cinematography, elevates the narrative with a blend of precise production design, haunting visual storytelling, and nuanced performances, particularly from Nicole Kidman, Kirsten Dunst, and Elle Fanning, whose portrayals breathe life into the starkly drawn characters.
Though comparisons to Siegel's earlier work are unavoidable, Coppola's "The Beguiled" distinguishes itself through a subtle shift in narrative focus, emphasizing the perspectives and inner turmoil of the women and girls more so than the charismatic corporal. This emphasis not only enriches the narrative with layers of feminist commentary but also situates the film within a broader discourse on power dynamics and gender relations in a confined, highly charged setting. However, while the film is visually sumptuous and anchored by strong performances, it occasionally falters under the weight of its own stylistic and thematic ambitions, not fully immersing into the darker or more psychologically complex waters that its predecessor navigated with more audacity.
Ultimately, "The Beguiled" stands out as an intimate and atmospheric exploration of repressed desires, shifting allegiances, and the fine line between caretaking and manipulation in a microcosm severed from a world engulfed in conflict. Its slow burn approach to storytelling may test some audiences, but for those attuned to Coppola's methodical pacing and visual poetry, the film offers a rich tapestry of interpersonal dynamics set against the backdrop of a gorgeously rendered historical milieu. While it may not surpass the raw edginess of the 1971 film in every respect, it brings new dimensions to the source material, proving that retellings can illuminate unseen facets of familiar stories.
Total: 62
The Beguiled," directed by Sofia Coppola, has received a Blu-ray release that showcases one of the director's most refined works since "Lost in Translation." Universally considered a significant entry in Coppola's oeuvre, this film seamlessly blends mood, performance, and narrative to create an immersive and emotionally varied experience. The Blu-ray, released by Universal in a region-free UK edition, offers viewers exceptional video and audio quality that enhances the film’s atmospheric tension and aesthetic. However, it's worth noting that the additional content is somewhat sparse, limited to a couple of brief featurettes that leave fans possibly wanting more.
Critics have praised "The Beguiled" for Coppola's fresh feminist reinterpretation of its story, despite the overshadowing influence of its predecessor starring Clint Eastwood. While the film excels in building a creeping sense of unease and presenting meticulously crafted characters, some argue that it falls short of capturing the intense passion and complexity that characterized the original. This reflection, however, does not detract from the overall excellence of the Blu-ray presentation. The high-quality video and audio transfers significantly contribute to the film's appeal, underscoring Coppola’s ability to convey a powerful narrative through visual and auditory finesse.
In conclusion, despite its few shortcomings in terms of supplemental material and comparisons with the original, Universal’s Blu-ray release of "The Beguiled" is a commendable addition to Sofia Coppola’s body of work and to any film enthusiast's collection. While the additional features may be minimal, the superb video and audio quality ensure that the film can be appreciated in its full glory. Whether you’re a dedicated fan of Coppola or new to her unique style, this Blu-ray offers a compelling reason to experience or re-experience "The Beguiled.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 80
It doesn't help that Coppola has (quite justifiably) attempted to shoot entire sequences to little more than candlelight, to reflect the era, bathing half the movie in deep, almost impenetrable shadows...
Audio: 80
The same can be said of the minimalist score, which is a haunting and evocative but simultaneously often almost unnoticed affair that gives the drama just the right nudge when necessary....
Extras: 50
There's little in the way of extras beyond a couple of short Featurettes: A Shift in Perspective and A Southern Style, both only a few minutes long, looking at the style and setting for Coppola's visually...
Movie: 80
Whilst he recuperates, he starts to bond with several women at the school - including the cold headmistress, the outsider teacher, and one of the more confident schoolgirls - although the relationships...
Total: 80
One of the director's most accomplished works since Lost in Translation Universal's Region Free UK Blu-ray release of The Beguiled provides very good video and audio as well as a couple of short extras...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Detail is very good, and even through the movie's many darkened and low-light interiors it's easy to see and enjoy good textural abundance on period attire, woods around the house, and trinkets throughout....
Audio: 80
Outdoor scenes are swarming with insect buzzes and hums; the sense of location immersion and authenticity is tangible, and the track makes fine use of all speakers at its disposal to create a rich environment....
Extras: 20
A Shift in Perspective (1080p, 6:53): A discussion of the movie's structure and story, Sofia Coppola's direction, the female-centric perspective, cast and characters, life on the set, and more....
Movie: 80
All of the characters undergo radical transformations throughout (with the arguable exception of the most steady of them, Miss Farnsworth), and he in particular as the realities of his wound, his place...
Total: 70
The film is sublime in its construction and the emotional reaction to it varied as it progresses....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Though a bit dark at times, details still shine through, and excellent clarity and vibrant contrast bolster the impact of the very film-like image....
Audio: 80
A wide dynamic scale keeps distortion at bay while seamlessly handling all of the track’s highs and lows, and superior fidelity and tonal depth bolster the impact of the music score....
Extras: 20
In addition, Kirsten Dunst, Colin Farrell, and Elle Fanning (but, interestingly, not Nicole Kidman) share their perspectives on the picture and its production, the film’s younger actresses talk about their...
Movie: 60
While I understand the desire to remake and update classic movies, the idea always seems better in theory than execution, and The Beguiled is a perfect example....
Total: 60
Coppola weaves a creepy mood, but keeps her characters too constricted, and the result - despite some gore - is a rather sterile, ponderous telling of what should be a passionate, tension-filled tale....
Director: Sofia Coppola
Actors: Nicole Kidman, Kirsten Dunst, Elle Fanning
PlotDuring the Civil War, at a remote all-girls boarding school in Virginia, the mundane rhythm of life is interrupted by the discovery of a wounded Union soldier. The young Amy, while foraging in the woods, finds the soldier and helps him back to the school. The presence of the soldier instantly disrupts the secluded existence of the women and girls at the academy. The headmistress, wary but compassionate, decides to shelter and nurse the enemy soldier back to health, invoking a sense of cautious curiosity among the students and teachers. As he gradually recovers, his presence ignites a flurry of excitement, jealousy, and taboo attractions within the walls of the school.
The soldier's stay brings to the surface the underlying tensions among the school's residents, as each individual, including the headmistress, a teacher, and a teenaged student, deals with their own burgeoning feelings and desires. The interactions between the soldier and the women evolve from cordial hospitality to complicated dynamics of power, seduction, and betrayal. As alliances form and rivalries fester, the once-calm atmosphere becomes charged with suspicion and competition, revealing the fragility of their secluded world. Without revealing the ensuing consequences, it's clear that the soldier’s arrival becomes a catalyst for unexpected revelations and transformations, challenging the residents' perceptions of themselves and each other, ultimately testing the limits of their isolation and the bonds of their makeshift family.
Writers: Sofia Coppola, Thomas Cullinan, Albert Maltz
Release Date: 30 Jun 2017
Runtime: 93 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, French