The Comancheros Blu-ray Review

20th Century Fox has delivered an impressive video presentation for "The Comancheros" on Blu-ray, maintaining the film’s original 2.35:1 aspect ratio in a restored and remastered 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer. The most commendable aspect of this transfer is the preservation of the film's grain, providing a genuine filmic texture reflective of its original visual intent. The print is immaculate with minimal specks or flecks, and virtually no larger print damage is evident. Colors throughout the movie are vivid, with reds and oranges particularly standing out, while skin tones remain consistently tanned, contributing to the film’s warm, sun-soaked aesthetic. Despite occasional source-related softness and minor color fluctuations, the overall clarity marks a significant improvement over previous DVD editions.

The detail is enhanced compared to older versions, revealing intricate textures in costume design, set decoration, and the epic landscapes that are central to the film’s visual narrative. The heightened depth and dimensionality afford viewers a more immersive cinematic experience, especially notable in wide shots of landscapes and bustling interior settings like saloons or paddle-steamers. Black levels are strong and contribute effectively to shadow details seen in various scenes, ensuring darker sequences, like the poker showdown, are richer and more atmospheric. Contrast remains well-balanced, though some highlights can appear overly bright at times.

Importantly, there are no significant issues with compression or unwanted digital enhancements—excess edge enhancement is absent, and there's no ringing or haloing beyond what’s naturally introduced by source lighting and photography. Even during panning shots and wide vistas, the image maintains smooth fluidity with minimal judder or aliasing, enhancing the overall viewing experience. This Blu-ray transfer stands as probably the finest visual representation of "The Comancheros" to date, highlighting the detailed effort that went into its restoration and remastering.

The audio presentation of "The Comancheros" on Blu-ray is delivered through a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix, which offers a significant upgrade over the original 4-channel Dolby Surround track. This lossless mix provides a wide dynamic range with enhanced clarity, notably improving dialogue delivery and overall sound balance. The original 4-track stereo mix is preserved and available in a DD 4.0 surround option, though the DTS-HD track stands out for its smoother and more evenly-distributed audio.

The film's audio landscape effectively utilizes the surround channels, subtly contributing to the immersive experience without overshadowing the central audio elements. Elmer Bernstein's evocative score particularly benefits from the dynamic range, filling the soundstage with its traditionally brassy and energetic orchestrations. There are moments of atmospheric utilization in the rear channels, such as rain effects and ambient noises, which add depth without seeming forced. Action sequences, although limited by the film’s age, bring life to the soundscape with notable uses of bass for explosions, hoofbeats, and gunfire, providing substantial but not overwhelming punctuations to the overall experience.

In summary, while the DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix does not revolutionize the audio experience, it provides an appreciable enhancement over the older Dolby Surround track. The sound mix does not rely on heavy-handed enhancements, maintaining the integrity of the original audio design while adding a touch of modern dynamic range and clarity that enriches the viewing experience. Dialogue is clean and well-centered, Bernstein's score shines brilliantly, and occasional use of surround effects ensures a well-rounded auditory presentation.

The 50th Anniversary Blu-ray release of "The Comancheros" surpasses expectations with a remarkable array of extras that both celebrate and delve deeply into the film's history. The presentation is housed in an attractive 24-page digibook with actor biographies, a plot synopsis, and numerous stills. The disc features a non-scene-specific commentary from Stuart Whitman, Nehemiah Persoff, Michael Ansara, and Patrick Wayne, offering a rich tapestry of behind-the-scenes anecdotes. Particularly noteworthy are the new documentaries: "The Comancheros and the Battle for the American Southwest," which explores historical context, and "The Duke at Fox," detailing John Wayne's career at 20th Century Fox with contributions from family members and historians. Additionally, a digitally restored 1961 comic adaptation, audio interview with Stuart Whitman, and vintage trailers solidify this as an essential acquisition for fans.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Reflections from actors on their experiences working on the film.
• The Comancheros and the Battle for the American Southwest: Documentary on historical context.
• The Duke at Fox: Retrospective on John Wayne’s career at Fox.
• Vintage Comancheros Comic Book: Full HD scans of the 1961 comic adaptation.
• A Conversation with Stuart Whitman: Audio interview with the actor.
• Fox Movietone News: Brief vintage newsreel.
• Theatrical Trailer
• Spanish Trailer

John Wayne's transition from stoic characters to a more charismatic figure is masterfully embodied in his role as Texas Ranger Jake Cutter in "The Comancheros." Supported adeptly by Stuart Whitman, Wayne reinvents the buddy film genre alongside director Michael Curtiz. The first half of the movie introduces characters and motives at a slower pace, but once the narrative picks up, it delivers a blend of humor, action, and entertainment set against the majestic backdrop of the American South. Elmer Bernstein's dynamic score and a memorable cameo by Lee Marvin as Tully Crow further elevate the film. "The Comancheros" is not among Wayne's top twenty films but stands out with its Cinemascope aesthetics and engaging performances.

Set in 1843 New Orleans, the story begins with Paul Regret (Whitman), a gambler who flees to Texas after killing a judge's son in a duel. He encounters the seductive Pilar Graile (Ina Balin) and soon finds himself captured by Texas Ranger Jake Cutter (Wayne). Their evolving dynamic, filled with mutual distrust and eventual camaraderie, forms the crux of the film. Though episodic and lacking in narrative cohesion, the movie excels in its staged action sequences and character interactions. The chemistry between Wayne and Marvin is especially noteworthy, providing some of the film's best moments. Despite its shortcomings, particularly an underwhelming script and forced plot coincidences, "The Comancheros" remains an enjoyable watch showcasing Wayne's legendary on-screen charisma.

"The Comancheros" might not rank as the top-tier John Wayne western, but it comfortably occupies a space among his reliably entertaining films. With stunning cinematography and a dynamic supporting cast, including a notably rugged performance from Lee Marvin, the film delivers on its promise of an engaging Western adventure. The chemistry between Wayne and Stuart Whitman further elevates the film, making it a memorable buddy story. The Blu-ray release by Fox is exceptional, featuring a near-perfect high-definition transfer that brings the scenic landscapes to life with vibrant colors and deep blacks. The audio quality, while not quite matching the visual fidelity, remains a commendable HD transfer for a film from the 1960s.

Additionally, Fox's Blu-ray package includes a plethora of special features that enhance the viewing experience. This includes a classy 24-page digibook that provides deeper insights into the world of "The Comancheros". The supplementary content is extensive and thoughtfully curated, adding significant value for fans and collectors alike. The supporting materials undoubtedly make this edition a standout, offering rich context and additional enjoyment beyond the film itself.

In conclusion, "The Comancheros" is a solid piece in John Wayne's filmography and benefits greatly from Fox's meticulous Blu-ray presentation. Though it may not be the pinnacle of his career, its strengths in storytelling, acting, and presentation make it a compelling watch. The high-quality picture, satisfactory audio, and abundant extras combine to deliver a package that both John Wayne enthusiasts and Blu-ray collectors will relish. Highly recommended.