Manhunter Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Manhunter" by Scream Factory maintains the film's original 2.35:1 aspect ratio, encoded in 1080p MPEG-4 AVC. The transfer retains a primarily cinematic look, capturing the essence of the film shot on Super 35mm film using Arriflex cameras. However, the video quality differs notably between the Theatrical and Director's Cuts. The Theatrical Cut, though not confirmed as a new master, offers a warmer palette and decent detail levels, particularly in bright outdoor scenes. Despite occasional softness and minor telecine wobble, colors appear natural, with brighter scenes displaying clearer sharpness and depth.

The Director's Cut suffers from noticeable inconsistencies, partly due to the integration of standard definition (SD) inserts with the high definition (HD) transfer. This results in apparent dips in picture quality within these segments, accompanied by increased noise and clumpy grain. Some scenes are nearly indistinguishable from the Theatrical Version, but others showcase distinct differences, leading to a less satisfactory visual experience overall. Issues such as minor telecine wobble and grain management persist, and black levels occasionally compromise finer details.

Regarding encoding, the film avoids major artifacts like aliasing or banding, aside from specific opening scenes designed to look grainy. Nonetheless, dirt and debris remain sporadically visible throughout the transfer. Colors exhibit richness without bleeding, and black levels are deep, though they can obscure some details. If viewed in high definition, elements like dust on projectors or sweat beads are sharply detailed. Establishing shots depict excellent depth, translating the spacing between actors and objects seamlessly. Skin tones skew cooler but are consistent throughout. Unfortunately, medium shots lose some detail compared to close-ups where facial features shine prominently.

In summary, this Blu-ray release showcases a respectable but mixed visual presentation of "Manhunter," with the Theatrical Cut faring better in terms of consistency and detail compared to the less polished Director's Cut.

"Manhunter" offers both DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and 2.0 tracks, each with distinct characteristics. The 5.1 mix notably enhances the film’s pulsating 80s soundtrack and offers robust low-frequency effects, though it occasionally overpowers the dialogue with music that feels a bit too prominent. Surround effects are applied to modest effect, particularly bringing life to dynamic sequences with flames, gunshots, and glass shattering, almost bursting into the viewer's space. Despite some dated elements, the 5.1 track successfully utilizes the full scope of surround channels, with heightened moments during key songs like "Strong As I Am" and "Heartbeat."

In contrast, the 2.0 DTS-HD track presents a more balanced auditory experience, where dialogue, effects, and score are more evenly prioritized. This track lacks the fulsome low-end punch of the 5.1 mix but compensates with clearer dialogue and a subtler, less crowded soundstage. Both tracks exhibit commendable fidelity and wide dynamic range, ensuring a clear and hiss-free presentation. Overall, while the 5.1 mix is ideal for those seeking a more immersive audio experience, the 2.0 mix may appeal more to purists and those preferring a straightforward audio mix. For accessibility, English SDH subtitles are included on both versions.

The "Manhunter" Blu-ray extras provide an extensive and immersive deep-dive into the film’s production aspects and behind-the-scenes insights. The set includes varied formats like HD and SD, offering both a seamless and detailed viewing experience. The inclusion of interviews with key cast members such as William Petersen, Joan Allen, Tom Noonan, and Brian Cox adds invaluable perspectives on the character development and the film's intricate production process. The technical commentary by cinematographer Dante Spinotti sheds light on visual storytelling techniques. For enthusiasts of film music, an in-depth exploration of the movie's score by composer Michel Rubini and others offers a comprehensive understanding of its creation. The range of content, from archival commentaries by Michael Mann to extensive galleries and trailers, ensures a thorough exploration of this iconic film.

Extras included in this disc:

• The Mind of Madness: Interview with actor William Petersen.
• Courting a Killer: Interview with actor Joan Allen.
• Francis is Gone Forever: Interview with actor Tom Noonan.
• The Eye of the Storm: Interview with Director of Photography Dante Spinotti.
• The Music of Manhunter: Interviews with composer Michel Rubini and others.
• The First Lecktor: Interview with Brian Cox.
• Theatrical Trailer: Original theatrical trailer.
• Still Gallery: Nearly 100 behind-the-scenes photos and production shots.
• Director's Cut: Available in HD & SD with commentary by Michael Mann.
• Audio Commentary: Commentary by Writer/Director Michael Mann.
• The Manhunter Look: Conversation with Cinematographer Dante Spinotti.
• Inside Manhunter: Featurette with stars William Petersen, Joan Allen, Brian Cox, and Tom Noonan.

Michael Mann’s Manhunter (1986) adapts Thomas Harris' novel "Red Dragon" with a distinctive visual flair, creating an inherently stylish but equally disturbing thriller. The film marks the screen debut of Hannibal Lecter—spelled Lecktor here—portrayed with chilling reserve by Brian Cox. While often compared unfavorably to the more celebrated The Silence of the Lambs, Manhunter remains a unique, finely executed piece of cinema with a very different approach. William Petersen stars as FBI profiler Will Graham, whose psychological scars from capturing Lecktor make him a multi-faceted character caught between his past and a new serial killer called the "Tooth Fairy," brought to life by Tom Noonan’s unnerving performance.

Manhunter stands out due to Mann’s meticulous attention to aesthetics, from the calculated cinematography and distinct visual style to the strategic use of music, including the memorable climax set to Iron Butterfly’s "In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida." The film’s clinical tone is contrasted with intense psychological undercurrents, mirroring Graham's struggle to maintain his sanity while delving into the minds of killers. The supporting cast—including Dennis Farina as Jack Crawford, Kim Greist as Molly Graham, and Joan Allen as a blind coworker unwittingly drawn into the dangerous game—bolsters the narrative, adding rich textures to the saga.

Despite its initial lukewarm reception, Manhunter has garnered a cult following over the years, appreciated for its groundbreaking portrayal of criminal profiling and its place in the Hannibal Lecter canon. Cox’s Lecter may not dominate the film like Hopkins' later portrayal, but his restrained, methodical menace is compelling in its own right. The restrained screen time of Lecktor aligns with Mann’s vision, focusing the narrative on Graham's journey rather than the iconic villain. This approach underscores the film’s strength in exploring the profiler’s psyche against a backdrop of stylized suspense.

"Manhunter," Michael Mann's 1986 adaptation of Thomas Harris' "Red Dragon," remains a fascinating and stylized thriller that stands the test of time. Notably distinct from other portrayals of Hannibal Lecter, the film emphasizes the psychological depth of profiler Will Graham over the notorious doctor. This approach contributes to its unique appeal and sets it apart from the subsequent, more mainstream interpretations. The moody yet scenic cinematography creates a palpable tension while maintaining a deliberate and reserved emotional tone, making "Manhunter" a captivating watch.

Scream Factory's Blu-ray release offers an admirable package, providing viewers with two cuts of the movie and an array of supplemental materials, both new and old. The transfer quality is excellent, delivering a crisp and visually satisfying experience that does justice to Mann's striking visuals. The audio quality is similarly impressive, ensuring an immersive viewing. This edition includes insightful interviews and bonus features that enhance the understanding and appreciation of this cult classic, despite its dated elements and numerous revisions over the years.

If you only know Hannibal Lecter via Anthony Hopkins or the television series, you're in for a treat (so to speak) with "Manhunter," though it should be understood that this film is less about the good (?) doctor than profiler Will Graham. Moody but unbelievably scenic, "Manhunter" develops incredible tension despite a hero who's loathe to show any emotion. Technical merits vary here, but as with most Scream releases, the supplemental package is excellent. Recommended.